Forums
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 717 comments are related to the topic:
Why can you still back May to leave at 1.15?

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 11 of 18  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | ... | 18 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 717
By:
LuckyAz
When: 28 May 19 00:48

May 28, 2019 -- 12:28AM, Lifter wrote:


No, there was a big discussion, with many of the opinion that May won't actually step down in June, that she would continue. I'm betting against that theory under the "When will Theresa May officially cease to be leader of the Conservative Party" market. Others are betting she will stay on as leader until a new one is chosen.


It's been widely reported she's agreed to stay in office until a replacement has been found.

I don't see a June departure unless all the new PM candidates agree to shake hands & step aside for Borris, the current market prices have that as a near 30% chance & so the craziness of this market continues. Crazy

By:
tobermory
When: 28 May 19 01:04

May 28, 2019 -- 12:48AM, LuckyAz wrote:


May 28, 2019 -- 12:28AM, Lifter wrote:No, there was a big discussion, with many of the opinion that May won't actually step down in June, that she would continue. I'm betting against that theory under the "When will Theresa May officially cease to be leader of the Conservative Party" market. Others are betting she will stay on as leader until a new one is chosen.It's been widely reported she's agreed to stay in office until a replacement has been found.I don't see a June departure unless all the new PM candidates agree to shake hands & step aside for Borris, the current market prices have that as a near 30% chance & so the craziness of this market continues.


She stays in office as prime minister until the leadership election is done, and steps down as party leader on June 7th.

By:
Lifter
When: 28 May 19 01:19

May 28, 2019 -- 12:48AM, LuckyAz wrote:


May 28, 2019 -- 12:28AM, Lifter wrote:No, there was a big discussion, with many of the opinion that May won't actually step down in June, that she would continue. I'm betting against that theory under the "When will Theresa May officially cease to be leader of the Conservative Party" market. Others are betting she will stay on as leader until a new one is chosen.It's been widely reported she's agreed to stay in office until a replacement has been found.I don't see a June departure unless all the new PM candidates agree to shake hands & step aside for Borris, the current market prices have that as a near 30% chance & so the craziness of this market continues.


Again, as tobermory says, she is continuing her duties as PM, not Tory leader.

BBC News - "Theresa May announced she would step down as Conservative Party leader on 7 June". "Mrs May will continue to serve as prime minister while a Conservative leadership contest takes place".

A senior minister tells Robert Peston - "We could have a weird few weeks of May as PM and @BorisJohnson as Tory leader". AKA they are different jobs.

Please note this market is for Tory Leadership, not PM.

By:
LuckyAz
When: 28 May 19 01:21

May 28, 2019 -- 1:19AM, Lifter wrote:


May 28, 2019 -- 12:48AM, LuckyAz wrote:May 28, 2019 -- 12:28AM, Lifter wrote:No, there was a big discussion, with many of the opinion that May won't actually step down in June, that she would continue. I'm betting against that theory under the "When will Theresa May officially cease to be leader of the Conservative Party" market. Others are betting she will stay on as leader until a new one is chosen.It's been widely reported she's agreed to stay in office until a replacement has been found.I don't see a June departure unless all the new PM candidates agree to shake hands & step aside for Borris, the current market prices have that as a near 30% chance & so the craziness of this market continues.Again, as tobermory says, she is continuing her duties as PM, not Tory leader.BBC News - "Theresa May announced she would step down as Conservative Party leader on 7 June". "Mrs May will continue to serve as prime minister while a Conservative leadership contest takes place".A senior minister tells Robert Peston - "We could have a weird few weeks of May as PM and @BorisJohnson as Tory leader". AKA they are different jobs.Please note this market is for Tory Leadership, not PM.


Tell Betfair CS that & then re adjust your position on this market while you still can is the best advice I can give you.

By:
Lifter
When: 28 May 19 01:26
The rules of the market are very clear, there is no need to ask Betfair anything. It's like asking whether I need Liverpool to score if I bet on Liverpool to score. With that said, I have had confirmation today that the market will be settled upon Theresa May ceasing to be leader, whether that is June 7th, or after.
By:
Lifter
When: 28 May 19 01:29
Just need to wait for an official announcement from the Conservatives.
By:
LuckyAz
When: 28 May 19 01:33
If Befair CS have advised you there's a chance of May still being leader after the 7th June then her resignation date in this political context is meaningless.
By:
tobermory
When: 28 May 19 01:33
Betfair's market is clearly Tory leader, with no mention of prime minister. The CS are not going to decide the market, anymore than someone behind the counter in William Hill decides how the company settles. Any report you look at states she is resigning as leader on June 7th and continuing as caretaker prime minister. If people who lay June Exit have screenshots with CS telling them that May is leader until the election is over I still can't see how Betfair will pay out when May has given a speech saying she has quit as leader and the position  is vacant.
By:
LuckyAz
When: 28 May 19 01:36
To the best of my knowledge She's never said her position is vacant.
By:
tobermory
When: 28 May 19 01:41
What is gonna happen on June 7th ? Is May really going to say 'I resign the leadership of the Conservative party but will continue as leader until the election is over' ? It makes no sense at all. She would just have said last week I resign as leader effective at end of election. I mean June 24 2016 Cameron said 'I am resigning as leader effective on the election of my successor' He didn't say 'I am resigning on July 1st' and the on July 1st announce he had resigned but would stay in til the election was complete!
By:
tobermory
When: 28 May 19 01:42
It will be vacant when she resigns on June 7th.
By:
LuckyAz
When: 28 May 19 01:46
Guess we'll have to wait until 7th June to find out when some will be scratching their heads wondering why the market is still open, best of luck with your bet.
By:
Lifter
When: 28 May 19 01:48

May 28, 2019 -- 1:46AM, LuckyAz wrote:


Guess we'll have to wait until 7th June to find out when some will be scratching their heads wondering why the market is still open, best of luck with your bet.


And this is why we can get such great odds. Some of the market confusing leader and PM.

By:
LuckyAz
When: 28 May 19 01:52
The only confusion is over what Betfair deems to be an official leader in this political context.
By:
unitedbiscuits
When: 28 May 19 08:33
Until Theresa May leaves No10, she has no duties as leader of the party. Nor would any nominal replacement party leader. The ‘22 committee (not her) said she was standing down on 7th June as a technical formality demanded by their constitution to initiate the leadership contest. David Cameron did the same in June ‘16, leaving in July ‘16. There was a similar gap w/ Tim Farron.
By:
dave1357
When: 28 May 19 08:46
There was a similar gap w/ Tim Farron.

Why do you repeat nonsense?  This has already been shown to be irrelevant.

The LD constitution specifically states that the leader continues until the election concludes.  There is no such stipulation in the Labour or Tory constitution.
By:
unitedbiscuits
When: 28 May 19 08:51
That could have a bearing, dave.  What about Cameron?
By:
dave1357
When: 28 May 19 09:55
As stated above as well Cameron specifically didn't resign. 

I held nothing back, I was absolutely clear about my belief that Britain is stronger, safer and better off inside the European Union and I made clear the referendum was about this and this alone – not the future of any single politician including myself.

But the British people have made a very clear decision to take a different path and as such I think the country requires fresh leadership to take it in this direction.

I will do everything I can as Prime Minister to steady the ship over the coming weeks and months but I do not think it would be right for me to try to be the captain that steers our country to its next destination.

This is not a decision I’ve taken lightly but I do believe it’s in the national interest to have a period of stability and then the new leadership required.

There is no need for a precise timetable today but in my view we should aim to have a new prime minister in place by the start of the Conservative Party conference in October.

Delivering stability will be important and I will continue in post as Prime Minister with my Cabinet for the next three months.
By:
unitedbiscuits
When: 28 May 19 10:28
Dave is quoting Cameron's resignation speech. May's resignation speech makes no mention either, because standing down as party leader is simply a necessary mechanism to enable the leadership race. According to Wiki, Cameron was party leader until July '16. Again, according to Wiki, Cameron resigned from being party leader directly after the referendum, in June. Indeed, he would have to have done so, to conform with the constitution of the '22 committee, according to dave's link.
Whether Betfair had a Cameron Exit mkt I don't know but, if they did, commonsense suggests it would have been settled in July. If the May Exit mkt is settled in June but she leaves in July, Betfair would have to defy public perception and settle subsequent mkts on such a precedent, and maybe revisit mkts already settled in line with public expectation.
By:
Celeric
When: 28 May 19 10:32
What happened with Cameron is irrelelevant. It is totally clear she is resigning on june 7th. This is the exit date for party leader. nobody has provided any quotes or evidence to the contrary. All other comments are guess work.
By:
Lifter
When: 28 May 19 10:39

May 28, 2019 -- 10:32AM, Celeric wrote:


What happened with Cameron is irrelelevant. It is totally clear she is resigning on june 7th. This is the exit date for party leader. nobody has provided any quotes or evidence to the contrary. All other comments are guess work.


Spot on.

By:
unitedbiscuits
When: 28 May 19 10:39
Irrelevant to you, Celeric, but obviously not irrelevant to Betfair, since how they settle one market determines how they settle other markets of the same ilk.
By:
Lifter
When: 28 May 19 10:41

May 28, 2019 -- 10:28AM, unitedbiscuits wrote:


Dave is quoting Cameron's resignation speech. May's resignation speech makes no mention either, because standing down as party leader is simply a necessary mechanism to enable the leadership race. According to Wiki, Cameron was party leader until July '16. Again, according to Wiki, Cameron resigned from being party leader directly after the referendum, in June. Indeed, he would have to have done so, to conform with the constitution of the '22 committee, according to dave's link.  Whether Betfair had a Cameron Exit mkt I don't know but, if they did, commonsense suggests it would have been settled in July. If the May Exit mkt is settled in June but she leaves in July, Betfair would have to defy public perception and settle subsequent mkts on such a precedent, and maybe revisit mkts already settled in line with public expectation.


If the May Exit mkt is settled in June but she leaves in July

Why would they do that? They'll settle when she is officially no longer leader of the Conservatives. Pretty simple stuff.

By:
unitedbiscuits
When: 28 May 19 10:43
Uh huh.
By:
Lifter
When: 28 May 19 10:45
As Robert Peston says, "we could have weird few weeks of May as PM and @BorisJohnson (eg) as Tory leader". They are two different jobs, they don't have to be handed over on the same day.
By:
donny osmond
When: 28 May 19 10:50
camerons speech, like mays,  makes no indication of intent to be party leader, or not,
after resignation.



once again some folk are confusing resignation with leaving post

they may be simultaneous and they may not
By:
dave1357
When: 28 May 19 10:55
UB this is what May said

So I am today announcing that I will resign as leader of the Conservative and Unionist Party on Friday 7 June so that a successor can be chosen.

I have agreed with the Party Chairman and with the Chairman of the 1922 Committee that the process for electing a new leader should begin in the following week. I have kept Her Majesty the Queen fully informed of my intentions, and I will continue to serve as her Prime Minister until the process has concluded.

So she said: I will resign as leader of the Conservative and Unionist Party on Friday 7 June

Cameron said: There is no need for a precise timetable today

There couldn't be more of a contrast.
By:
unitedbiscuits
When: 28 May 19 11:07
But Cameron did resign as leader of the Conservative party directly after the ref. , according to Wiki; and for the same reason as May, as a mechanism to set a timetable for the election of his successor. Yet in any meaningful sense, Cameron's exit was July.
By:
dave1357
When: 28 May 19 11:13
wiki isn't a credible source.  The word and letters of people involved in the process and procedural documents are the only credible sources.
By:
unitedbiscuits
When: 28 May 19 11:19
What you're saying, dave, is that you weren't there when Cameron resigned as leader of the party, so maybe it didn't happen.
But the '16 leadership contest could not have happened until Cameron resigned leadership of the Conservative party, according to you link.
By:
dave1357
When: 28 May 19 11:24
No I'm saying that there was a distinct contrast between Cameron and May.
By:
tobermory
When: 28 May 19 11:27
If people think the Cameron and May resignations are the same, and that they will both be leader until the successor is elected, why did Cameron not give a precise date that he would step down.
By:
Lifter
When: 28 May 19 11:28
Cameron said he is resigning, but gave no date. May said she is resigning, but gave a date.
By:
unitedbiscuits
When: 28 May 19 11:57
Nevertheless, Cameron had to resign leadership of the party before the '16 leadership contest could be framed.
By:
tobermory
When: 28 May 19 12:24
Cameron effectively 'gave his notice' that he would be leader til his successor was elected.

May gave notice that she will be leader until June 7th.
By:
unitedbiscuits
When: 28 May 19 12:31
No, the constitution of the '22 committee requires that the leader resigns before a leadership contest can be triggered. They were preparing to change that constitution to force a second vote of no-confidence in May, which is why May agreed to the timeframe of her departure which begins, as it did in '16, with resigning the party leadership.
By:
Lifter
When: 28 May 19 12:47

May 28, 2019 -- 12:31PM, unitedbiscuits wrote:


No, the constitution of the '22 committee requires that the leader resigns before a leadership contest can be triggered. They were preparing to change that constitution to force a second vote of no-confidence in May, which is why May agreed to the timeframe of her departure which begins, as it did in '16, with resigning the party leadership.


May spoke with the 1922 committee and party chairman to get the election process underway in the following week.

By:
unitedbiscuits
When: 28 May 19 12:54
But the election process is predicated on May or Cameron resigning the leadership of the party, according to their constitution. That is the first step.
By:
Lifter
When: 28 May 19 12:56
So, you're saying that May will no longer be leader of the party in June, to get the election process going?
By:
unitedbiscuits
When: 28 May 19 13:08
Arguably, but in any meaningful sense, her exit date is her exit date. Officially, Cameron was leader of the party until he left No10 and May succeeded him.
Page 11 of 18  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | ... | 18 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com