Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Horse Antepost

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 309 comments are related to the topic:
Pinatubo

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 7 of 8  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 309
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 19 09:12
Good morning Figgis. Here is a question for you.

You own St Nicholas Abbey and you have chosen him to be trained by a British trainer of your choice, excluding Ballydoyle. Your horse has not won over anything short of 12 furlongs since he was a 2 year old. You have decided to run against Frankel at York, a flat, fast racecourse, over 10.5 furlongs. This is Frankel's first run over further than a mile and the main opposition comes from a horse who has never won over further than a mile. You are the only one of the main contenders who undoubtedly requires a minimum of 12f and you can run pacemakers if you wish.
What instructions do you give your jockey?
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 19 09:17
JOB must've also been under strict instructions not to pass Farhh for second, even though he was owned by their arch rivals. The plot thickens Confused. Could it be any more dense?! Grin
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 19 09:31
You really will do anything but have a sensible conversation Figgis. What is it with you? I asked you a perfectly sensible question and you are totally unable to give a perfectly sensible answer. If I asked you the same question but instead of St Nicholas Abbey and Frankel I included Enable and Magical I am sure you would give a perfectly sensible answer. Why are you trying so hard to defend the indefensible? This is the sport that I love and follow and for some strange reason I thought you were the same.
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 19 09:36
In fact it is the sort of question any poster on here would want to discuss about any race and in particular top Group 1 races. If you owned a two year old and you were planning to run it in the Dewhurst against Pinatubo. You would know your horses strengths and weaknesses and you know the chief oppositions strengths but there is a question mark about his weakness. Are you saying you wouldn't run your horse to it's strengths?
By:
impossible123
When: 20 Sep 19 09:47
Of course one would run one's horse to its maximum potential even if it finishes 2nd to Pinatubo; a credible performance to be 2nd to that equine machine. And, the prize money is valuable too if it's The Dewhurst. However, if the 2000G is the main event then I'd consider a race without Pinatubo to avoid bursting the "bubble" prematurely before Newmarket on 30th April.
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 19 09:55
JOB knew he was under strict orders not to threaten Frankel. There is a big difference beaten honesty and cheating. But as you know I have always thought Ballydoyle and Coolmore are crooks. But like most good things they just keep on giving.

Sensible? Yeah right. Maybe you should contact Greg Wood about your fantastic conspiracy theories regarding everyone from Coolmore to Timeform and the BHA? He's a journalist with integrity, willing to expose the corrupt. Oh no, hang on a minute, he also said he thought Frankel was the best he'd seen. Maybe you could try David Icke? Wink
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 19 10:11
You will do anything but answer the question Figgis. Cat got your tongue?
It is now abundantly clear in what you are saying that you are quite happy for a horse to be obviously and unquestionably ridden not to its best potential. Shame on you Figgis.
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 19 10:24
"Frankel tracking St Nicholas Abbey who is under a patient ride from Joseph O'Brien".
Under normal racing circumstances I would accept it as being just another inept ride from JOB but when I know there is an agreement between the owners of the first horse and the owners of the 2nd horse then, no matter how you dress it up, it stinks.!!!
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 19 10:38
you can run pacemakers if you wish

They did run pacemakers. Frankel had his own pacemaker, as was usually the case. Coolmore had a choice. They could have not run a pacemaker which would mean they either had to have JOB take on Bullet Train for the lead, which would be fine if he wasn't going that fast, but suicidal if he was, or have SNA just track BT in the hope that he would set it up for them. However, instead of leaving any of it to the mercy of what BT did and putting the onus on JOB to judge the pace was just right, they opted to run two pacemakers. This made more sense as their horse needed a good pace but wouldn't be vulnerable to the possibility of having to go too fast and be a sitting duck for Frankel to pick off. Also they could expose any possible stamina weakness in Frankel. Those two pacemakers took on Bullet Train for the lead and ensured the race was run at a true pace.

The fact it was a true pace has been unanimously agreed by everyone I've seen analyse ALL the times that day. The evidence is conclusive (although I'm sure you'll find some perverse way of disputing it). Coolmore had SNA tracking the three pacemakers. The race was set up perfectly for him to show his best. He got first run on Frankel and Farhh but wasn't even able to fend off Farhh inside the final furlong.

How would you have ridden him with three pacemakers in the race? Should be interesting.
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 19 11:30
I will take it that you believe JOB rode St Nicholas Abbey to his full potential and leave it at that Figgis.
No matter how much evidence is shown to support the facts that Frankel's 2000 Guineas wasn't great. 
That Queen Anne as the fastest performance in Europe over any trip since I've followed racing since 1985.Is completely flawed.
That Frankel's so called TIME figures in the Queen Anne Stakes were highly questionable.
That the evidence clearly shows this was an astonishingly weak era.
That the quality of horses he beat were below general Group One standard.
That there was an agreement between the owner of Frankel and Coolmore.
That the races Ballydoyle always ran in were left alone for Frankel.
That the opposition from Ballydoyle, the most significant stable in Europe, was virtually non existent.
That the horses Baldoyle did run against Frankel ran surprisingly below form.
That the race the BHA rated the best race in their history was irreconcilably flawed.
That the race Timeform signalled as the greatest racecourse performance in their history was a farce.
That Frankel only beat TWO average times and they were on newly laid racecourses where evidence is sparse.
When I said Balldoyle never ran against him you defended them saying "it would be useless to" yet you bet against him twice.

I could go on but I have a life to live. You are living in denial Figgis.

There is nothing more I can do here.
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 19 11:48
You are living in denial Figgis

No. I just have a different opinion than you. An opinion many share (although it wouldn't matter a jot to me if they did or not), that Frankel was the best I've seen personally. An opinion you can't accept is just different without accusing anyone or any publication who shares it of being in denial, being downright corrupt and refusing to see that only YOUR view is the truth.

There is nothing more I can do here


Thank **** for that Wink
By:
dunlaying
When: 20 Sep 19 12:09
The way Frankel won the Guineas was great .
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 19 12:09
I humbly accept you opinion of me Figgis that is your right. What I have learned from this exercise is what your opinion is on other,different aspects of horse racing as well. This, after all, is a horse racing forum. The fact that you obviously agree with the BHA and Timeform and the decisions they have made is a decision for you. The fact that you refuse to accept that I do have a case to question these organisations on there actions whether it is the BHA or Timeform then I cannot do anything about that. You are clearly happy with everything then that is fine.
the one thing I have learned is that the TIME merchants think they can fool everyone into thinking they have found a new way of assessing racehorses but it is massively flawed and apart from them just saying it is my opinion it cannot be backed up by fact. 
Also, unlike you I provide copious and extensive evidence to support my opinion whereas you just state your views and cannot back any of them up with evidence or facts.
That is a pity but I do know what to accept from you.
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 19 12:33
the TIME merchants think they can fool everyone into thinking they have found a new way of assessing racehorses

I think you'll find horse racing time analysis is hardly a new concept, it was even written about over 100 years ago.

unlike you I provide copious and extensive evidence

Yes, copious is a word you could use, I'd use tedious Wink. As for it being evidence, well no, it's all just opinion. Like your opinion that a horse who beats Bering by 1.5 lengths deserves a 140+ rating, despite the fact Bering's best previous form was beating Altayan 1.5 lengths. My opinion is Altayan was a mug.

I've heard many people say a horse wasn't able to challenge another horse because it was poorly ridden. I've said it myself. Sometimes I agree with them, sometimes I don't. I would excuse anyone some irrational pocket talk immediately after a race, been guilty of it myself. However, apart from the odd occasion when a horse is ridden much too fast too early, giving it no chance to last out, I've never heard anyone after careful consideration moan about a ride a horse was given when it did no more than plod on 7 lengths behind the winner. For me, anyone who does so is making a bell-end of themselves. And if they're still wittering on about it 8 years later that makes them look a complete c0ck Wink
By:
Akak
When: 20 Sep 19 12:39
Time to agree to disagree guys?
By:
impossible123
When: 20 Sep 19 12:43
Well said 'Akak', but i think it will be wasted on 'Figgis' - a one dimensional poster who I've on 'ignore' since Anno Domini.
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 19 12:49
That's such a pity. I would never ignore impossible123, I find his constant observations about two horses being value but only if the other doesn't show up invaluable.
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 19 12:58
You may find the 'evidence' tedious Figgis but I do hope some on here have found it interesting, if nothing else. This is not, and never has been, a rallying call just a response to other poster's points. I never brought Frankel onto this thread you did, I never defended Bering I just pointed out that your point about ratings obviously getting out of sync was, like everything else. wrong. There is no evidence of that.
You can twist my words any way you wish but I will stick to the facts. That is something you are palpably incapable of doing. 
Continually trying to discredit posters that do not agree with your opinion has no place on a forum. If you want to back up your opinion with facts, like I do, then at least that gives other posters the opportunity to assess the facts and form their opinion then you can. That is what a forum is all about.
I don't know if you follow Andrew from Sweden in the lower house but he puts up his opinion and it is backed up by facts. They can then form their own opinion as to whether they act on it or not. You, on the other hand, post your opinion and it is backed up by your ratings and your speed figures which no-one knows anything about so they cannot form any sort of opinion.

I agree Akak it is time to agree to disagree.
By:
FOYLESWAR
When: 20 Sep 19 13:07
yes lets sweep this under the carpet and get back onto pinatubo
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 19 13:09
What I do disagree with Akak is when high staking bookmaking owners are forming agreements with other owners about what horses they are going to run against their horse and those they do run run suspiciously. Plus the races concerned are likely to have an ante post element that can be hugely exploited. And the Racing Post know all about it. That cannot be right.
By:
Akak
When: 20 Sep 19 13:20
As a mere bystander, I have always enjoyed reading both you guys opinions. Your both correct because thats all it is (your opinions). Figgis, sarcasm is quite acceptable amongst a group of friends, as its just a bit of banter, but on a forum such as this, you do come across as a very argumentative individual. That aside I do respect your opinion as I do brigust1.
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 19 13:42
backed up by facts

The only facts in racing are the bare results. Everything else is opinion, even the state of the going. All races are open to interpretation, otherwise there would be no betting. If horse A beats horse B one person could think that's the end of the matter, another person can think there is a reason why it might be reversed in future. None of this is facts, whatever you say. Punters don't have to use ratings, they can just think horse A is better than horse B. However it can't just end there. They must have in mind a certain amount in hand that one horse has over another. Putting a number on it just makes it easier to quantify.

Dealing with only this season's form, Crystal Ocean beat Magical, then Enable beats Magical, then Enable beats CO. The obvious conclusion is that they all ran to form each time therefore an in form Enable will always beat Magical. Often I would come to the same conclusion. Luckily I don't always on these occasions, as there would be no point in betting, and in this instance I believe Magical is capable of reversing the form. My reasons are that the POW was a better race than the KG and Magical put up a better performance that day than she did at Sandown or York. There are no facts, just as there are no facts if someone believes Frankel winning at York was a brilliant performance and someone else thinks it wasn't.

My reasoning is based on how I have interpreted the times of the races in question. The times are facts. The interpretation is not. I could go into why I believe the difference between the times CO clocked in the POW and KG equates to him running 7lbs lower in the latter, but there would be absolutely no point. Just as ratings firms have stated why they believe Frankel's performance at Ascot was great. It's never going to be to the satisfaction of everyone. People will be using different standard times for comparison, they will have different interpretations of the exact going allowance. They will have different ideas of which horses ran to form. For most people Waldgeist improved in the KG, whereas I believe he ran almost the same race. They could be right, I could be wrong.

None of this stuff is about 'facts' and I'm surprised any experienced punter would try to pass off interpretations as facts, but then I never see you as much interested in punting matters. More concerned with pointlessly trying to prove to others that your own opinions are some divine truth, or 'facts'.
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 19 13:55
What tosh. You stated the facts first about previous meetings then added your opinion.
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 19 13:57
What tosh. You stated the facts first about previous meetings then added your opinion

What facts about previous meetings?
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 19 14:12
More concerned with pointlessly trying to prove to others that your own opinions are some divine truth, or 'facts'. Any evidence of this please?
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 19 14:33
Any evidence of this please?

Virtually every post you've made regarding Frankel. One example, if anyone says Frankel's time performance was high (and lots of people have, not just me) you don't just say yo disagree, you say it is absolute twaddle, despite boasting about how you don't concern yourself with time analysis as it's a load of rubbish.

I saw a lot of people saying Visinari put up an exceptional debut time performance. It baffled me as, although it wasn't bad, I really couldn't see it myself. However I didn't start writing to the press that they were "being led by the nose", that they were all wrong and I was right, or that they were involved in some kind of corrupt Mark Johnston scandal. As frankly, that would be a bit weird, if not a lot unhinged. No, I accepted that other people are using different methods and have different interpretations of the results. As it happened, Visinari didn't turn out to be that fast, so I was probably right this time (although it isn't beyond possibility for a 2yo to go well backwards after a debut). I'm hoping to be right about Magical, but this time it could be my interpretation that is up the spout.
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 19 14:48
Figgis 'time performance' is not a fact it is your opinion. I was in the same mind about Visinari but the reason you disagreed was because there were no facts. Had they said Visinari tan over 7f, or whatever, that is a fact. Or that he won by 6 lengths, or whatever, they are facts. Time performance is opinion.
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 19 14:48
*ran
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 19 14:52
I thought JOB rode an injudicious race on St Nicholas Abbey in the Juddmonte, that is opinion.
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 19 15:13
Figgis 'time performance' is not a fact it is your opinion

I have never said time performance is fact. Time performance is just another form of handicapping, but with some extra pointers and parameters. Handicapping is based on the facts of the race results, but the ratings are only an opinion of the facts. Even if the previous opinion of a horse was correct nobody can say 100% which horses ran to form in the following race. Even if some firms try to pass their computerised handicaps as gospel, somebody had to program it based on what they thought was most relevant. Some are obviously better than others. If more handicappers are in agreement then usually there's more chance that they're right, but certainly not always.

If a horse is estimated to given a fast performance only once then there is of course more margin for error. There is more chance of it being correct if the race is run a strong card, such as Royal Ascot, as the supporting evidence is more reliable. As Frankel was estimated to have run very fast performances numerous times, usually on strong cards and by many different analysts, both public and private, then does that make it a 100% fact? No it doesn't, but there's a strong likelihood that there's some truth in it.
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 19 15:27
Just to redress the balance of me blowing my own trumpet about Visinari, I thought people who put up Japan after Ascot for the Arc were being extremely optimistic. At Ascot, from time analysis, I had him beating trees and doing nothing he hadn't done before. He couldn't do much more than win how he did though so there was a chance he could be better than that, but given his connections and the prospects of him being overbet I preferred to remain doubtful. His backers were right, he was better than I thought and he has to be included in the mix as a possible Arc winner, although I still think he's not the most likely and the value has gone.
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 19 15:33
Anyway, back to Pinatubo, whether he goes on next year can only be guessed at, some think he will but I'm more inclined to think he won't, but I've been surprised that so far that I haven't seen any dissenting voices as to how good he is at this moment. Last year a few of us thought TDH was being overrated but this year everyone seems to agree about the showing last Sunday. Maybe I've just not seen the doubters.
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 19 15:37
I saw Willo extolling the virtues of Visinari from a time point of view, and I saw the interview with Johnson afterwards where he appeared to suggest he was being misled by the 'time' idea and should not have run him in that race where he was beaten.
My opinion is that no-one knows where the fastest part of a racecourse is and many racecourses are over 20 horses wide. The going description is far from being scientific as is the water distribution. The weather can play a part but winds can be variable. You then have pace, position and potential interference to contend with. Rail positions are moved often daily and nowadays the grass is cut during meetings or not at all as opposed to just the day before.
Added to this there is the distinct possibility that a horse can bounce after a particularly fast run. Minefield of the highest order in my opinion.
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 19 15:53
Figgis I thought you would be shouting the times for Pinatubo from the rooftops. He ran 1m 21.82 in the Gr1 at the Curragh compared with 1m 24.28 by Love in the Fillies Gr1. And at Goodwood he ran 1m 27.03 compared with Sir Dancealot in the Lennox in 1m 28.10.
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 19 16:09
Minefield of the highest order in my opinion

It is no more of a minefield than any other form of handicapping or forming an opinion on any race, as most of those variables play some part when dissecting the outcome of any race. Sure, on occasions time analysis can lead you up the garden path, but most people who have done it for any length of time should be aware of that. Especially if they're going to back a once raced 2yo on that one piece of evidence. That said, I have seen far more instances where a piece of form has been overrated, or an inferior animal finishing close to a much superior one has been overrated, due to a failure to take into account the time performance of the race.

I think what many detractors fail to realise, which is possibly the fault of the way time analysis has sometimes been presented, is that any going allowance/s (which is the all important factor in arriving at the numbers) has to be calculated through form analysis. The ratings aren't produced by some magic going formula separate from the form. So the time analysis is actually an extension of the form analysis. Despite any occasional erroneous conclusions that inevitably come with the territory, just as they do with other forms of race analysis, it works out often enough to be worth doing.
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 19 16:33
Figgis I thought you would be shouting the times for Pinatubo from the rooftops

I thought I did when I said on Sunday's effort, transferred to a mile, I'd have him beating every recent 2000 Guineas winner bar Frankel. That's without any improvement whatsoever, as I don't add for wfa. He improves another 5lbs and he'd even beat Frankel as a 3yo. I am not saying I am 100% sure I'm spot on in this case, as I often find the Curragh one of the most tricky courses to rate, due to the varied nature of the track and the fact there are often only 1 or 2 decent races on a card with the rest crap. I'd say this card was easier than most though so I'm pretty confident. I thought his Epsom win would mean O'Brien's would have to be reasonably good to beat him at Ascot but he improved there and I have him improving quite big with every run. So given that profile, Sunday's figure is very believable and I certainly wasn't expecting him to improve again, so it's not like I'm rating him on some preconceived notion.

Whether he will remain in this form next year is another matter though and I have doubts. I think their best shot is going for the Guineas first time out if he's ready as I'm not sure about him going on throughout the season, I could see him going backwards, but we'll see.
By:
impossible123
When: 20 Sep 19 16:33
Thank goodness, a cease fire for 24 mins (so far). Long may it continue.
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 19 16:49
Ok well pick the bones from Frankel's Queen Anne. It has had tomes written about it. But not this.

First lets look at how the race was run.
From the stalls the head on shows Bullet train immediately cross over in front of Frankel nearly knocking him off course.
The race was run down the centre of the course. Bullet Train led with Frankel, Side Glance, Windsor Place and Indomito in single file behind. On the near side ran Helmet and Premio Loco. On the far side ran Excelebration, Worthadd, Red Jazz and Strong Suit. That was the position until 3f from home.

They finished in this order
Frankel
Excelebration  (-14)
Side Glance   (-2)
Indomito    level
Windsor Palace   (-9)
Bullet Train     (-14)
Helmet             (-23)
Premio Loco     (-21)
Red Jazz       (-23)
Strong Suit     (-35)
Worthadd.       (-34)

There were only two horses in front and they were Bullet Train and Frankel. The five horses that ran down the centre of the formation of which 4 were the lowest rated in the race the other was Frankel, ran a total of 25lbs over their ratings assuming Frankel ran to his rating. Of the six horses who ran on the flanks, Frankel apart they were the next six highest rated in the race, they ran a total of 164lbs over their ratings.
That would normally be completely inexplicable. However on closer inspection there is a distinct possibility that the spine of the formation led by Bullet Train ran down a track created by the Queens Coaches just before the first race. If you look closely you can see a track going straight through Frankel's stall.

How do you explain that?
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 19 16:58
Don't forget this was the greatest racecourse performance in the history of BHA and Timeform.
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 19 16:58
they ran a total of 164lbs over their ratings

I don't understand what this is supposed to mean. You've already acknowledged that, in the handicapper's opinion, everything ran below form bar Frankel and Indomito?
Page 7 of 8  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com