Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Horse Antepost

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 309 comments are related to the topic:
Pinatubo

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 6 of 8  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 309
By:
brigust1
When: 18 Sep 19 18:23
Hi AT. No-one will ever know. As you can see Triptych was plying her trade worldwide in a pool that was densely populated. Enable, on the other hand, was a very lucky girl. Both brilliant specimens of the breed.
By:
Sandown
When: 18 Sep 19 18:26
I consider Pinatubo to be capable of a rating of 133 making him a highly likely potential classic winner, probably the 2000 Gns and a worthy favourite for that race.
By:
brigust1
When: 18 Sep 19 18:33
Hi Sandown, how are you? Would you be backing him at the current price?
By:
Figgis
When: 18 Sep 19 19:20
That can only be described as a reduction in quality horses

It could also describe what you'd naturally expect. That many years ago a few blokes armed with just some Sporting Life results and a calculator (apparently Whitford was doing the form ratings all by himself early on) were less informed and equipped to do the job in hand. Windy City Happy.  I'm not knocking it. They did as well as they could be expected to. Bull's methods were pioneering and made him a lot of cash while he was ahead of the pack. He didn't do so well apparently though when the crowd caught up. Things advance.
By:
Sandown
When: 18 Sep 19 20:13
I'm fine brigust1 thank you, as I trust you are. I certainly would not be backing him in September for a race nearly 8 months away.
By:
Figgis
When: 18 Sep 19 20:22
Sandown, just out of curiosity, is that on the Timeform or official scale? Have you rated him using any sectional projections or just regular analysis?
By:
brigust1
When: 18 Sep 19 20:22
I thought not, nor me. I have just checked and I did have 4 bets on Cracksman for the Derby with b365, skybet twice and racebets on the 20th October the difference being I got 40/1,33/1, 33/1 and 40/1. I backed him on here the next day at 39/1. It would be nice for another one to come along. I keep looking but no luck.
By:
Sandown
When: 18 Sep 19 22:08
Figgis.The 133 is my projected rating.
By:
brigust1
When: 19 Sep 19 08:19
An easy question to answer S. When you do a rating do you put alongside that rating points like distance, going, racecourse etc or do you leave that until the day. Or do you not put down provisos?  The reason I asked is because over the years I have followed just about every rating source religiously to see if an edge can be obtained but found none, by a long way, were stand alone successes.
By:
Figgis
When: 19 Sep 19 08:38
Ratings are just a measure of the value of a performance in a given race. I've never understood why anyone would expect simply backing the horse who was deemed to have put up the best performance in the past to be an easy route to riches in the future. It would be just as stupid as automatically expecting a tennis player to win the US Open just because he put up a great performance to win Wimbledon. Or, before anyone points out the different surfaces, winning the Australian Open in the same season. Ratings are just a framework to work from.
By:
brigust1
When: 19 Sep 19 09:09
I don't think it is stupid looking to see how a tennis player who put up a great performance at Wimbledon then performed in the US Open. Just the same way I don't think it is stupid to see how a top rated horse performs in top class races against lower rated horses. I know full well there is a rush for everyone to rate horses on performances but it is something I have consistently found should be taken with a huge pinch of salt unless there are a number of provisos attached.
By asking S the question I did I just wondered whether or not he listed certain provisos against a performance that he may have felt were applicable to that particular performance for when considering how that particular horse may perform in the future. There is nothing stupid about that F.
By:
Figgis
When: 19 Sep 19 09:18
I don't think it is stupid looking to see how a tennis player who put up a great performance at Wimbledon then performed in the US Open

Neither do I, but that wasn't the point made. The comparison made was the stupidity of automatically expecting a horse to win a future race just because it recorded the best performance in a past race.

I have followed just about every rating source religiously

Maybe I misunderstood how you made your judgement. So when you say you have followed them all 'religiously', what exactly did that entail?
By:
brigust1
When: 19 Sep 19 09:30
It entailed every possible way from blindly to direct comparison. Ratings, in my opinion, are just a way someone interpret a certain piece of form. It should short cut the need for someone following form to go through form lines in other words save time. But it doesn't mainly because there are no provisos alongside the rating. The best thing to do is go through the form and then form your own opinion. If that particular horse ticks all of the boxes then you can compare it to the other runners.
I simply asked S if he added provisos to his rating for future reference.
By:
Figgis
When: 19 Sep 19 09:36
Sandown sounds an intelligent bloke to me, so anything but the kind of fool who would follow ratings blindly.
By:
brigust1
When: 19 Sep 19 09:52
You have a way of turning any concept into contempt F.
I do not follow anything blindly financially but I do like to research in detail so that a proper overview of the evidence can be determined.
I found from my research that neither following ratings blindly nor religiously was a good thing to do.
I have done the same detailed research on race 'timing', in it's various forms, and soon came to the conclusion that a number of self declared experts are pedalling unproven and distorted opinions about 'timing' mainly because the 'ratings' theory they espoused, which you have confirmed by saying following ratings blindly is for fools, has been blown from the water.
What you completely fail to grasp is that the majority of punters have not the time to study form in detail and loosely rely on the experts to guide them.
They are not fools as you put it. Although, from experience, you probably think they are.
By:
Figgis
When: 19 Sep 19 10:09
I have done the same detailed research on race 'timing'

Can you give one or two details of this 'research'? I saw your research which showed us that a 5f race was run faster at the finishing post than the 5f mark in a mile race, but frankly I wasn't that impressed. Wink
By:
brigust1
When: 19 Sep 19 10:26
Absolutely not. You only have to look through this thread to see that I am meticulous in my research but I will save that for another day. If you don't mind. What I will say is if you give me a horse that from 'time' alone, not known form, is underrated then I can judge for myself where you may believe it works where I certainly do not.
Time is such a specific item to use as a judgement but you are dealing with a principle that is almost impossible to provide a direct comparison from, that makes 'time' irrelevant as a stand alone but may, and I only think may, be used as a back up to the major interpretations.
By:
brigust1
When: 19 Sep 19 10:29
However TIME is against me and I have to work. My publisher called me yesterday to ask how much I had written. I assured her everything was going well. I just omitted to say that the majority of my writing was on a betting forum. Happy days. Grin
By:
Figgis
When: 19 Sep 19 10:30
Brigust, ok, ought to be a simple question to answer. Entirely in your own opinion, which was the best middle distance (10-12f) performance this season?
By:
brigust1
When: 19 Sep 19 10:51
I really do have to go Figgis, I am not kidding.


I will not answer your question with reference to the best performance because that is history but I think the likely best future performance will come from Magical, hopefully in the Arc (I have backed her at big prices). And my reasoning is that I do not think to date she has been ridden to her best potential and I think she is closer to Enable that many think. So if she gets a good draw (and Enable isn't so lucky), good to fast ground and is ridden for a chance she could easily turn the tables on Enable.

I must go.
By:
Figgis
When: 19 Sep 19 10:55
I will not answer your question with reference to the best performance because that is history

But so are all the form ratings and time ratings you're dismissing. Bizarre.
By:
Figgis
When: 19 Sep 19 11:13
I do not think to date she has been ridden to her best potential

if she gets a good draw (and Enable isn't so lucky), good to fast ground and is ridden for a chance

In all recent starts Magical has tracked the leaders in races where the pace was very good or at least fair. She has had every chance. I would not back her at Sandown but had a few quid on her at York in the hope she was back to her best. I can't see how she had any excuse whatsoever in the way she was ridden. I know you think they should make the running with her but the chance of them doing that at Longchamp is very slim indeed I'd say (completely unnecessary too).
By:
Sandown
When: 19 Sep 19 11:52
When you do a rating do you put alongside that rating points like distance, going, racecourse etc

Brigust1. All those details are contained within a spreadsheet. It would be foolish, would it not, to ignore them? Mischief
By:
brigust1
When: 19 Sep 19 16:15
Hi S. Of course if you do a spreadsheet then what would be the point. Do you/have you included any question marks? Pinatubo has run enough times to have an opinion formed.
I remember when I saw Cracksman run for the first time on 19th October I immediately knew this was something different and I ran and reran his race several times. Frankie rode Stradivarius in the same race. What impressed me was his stride he took about 24 strides for the final furlong at Newmarket whereas Frankel took about 28 strides (which is normal) in the 2000 Guineas. By then end of the next day I had 5 bets on him with various bookies and by the end of the month that had doubled. Fortunately they interviewed John Gosden and he wasn't particularly excited but said he wouldn't run again until next season in a Group race at Newbury. That told me a whole lot meaning he would be missing the Guineas and with his stride Newbury would be brilliant. Epsom, on the other hand would be a risk but if he ran at Newbury and won I could lay him off or back him to cover my stake. It was all very exciting and as suspected Epsom didn't really suit him but his long stride, especially on the requisite soft ground, was all the difference.

Have you had a similar epiphany and have you yet seen anything that might be this horses downfall?
By:
Figgis
When: 19 Sep 19 17:26
Stride pattern at the end of a race will obviously be affected by what happened earlier in the race. No surprise that Frankel's stride was shortening at the end of a strongly run (for the conditions) Guineas. Whereas Craksman's maiden was run more slow early/fast late. Not my territory but interesting nonetheless. I know that people who specialise in such matters recorded Frankel with a longer peak stride than his colt, also a faster peak stride frequency.
By:
brigust1
When: 19 Sep 19 18:18
If I remember correctly Frankel won the Guineas in 223 strides and Sea the Stars in 208 strides. And, lets face it, Frankel was in full stride almost throughout unlike STS.
By:
Figgis
When: 19 Sep 19 19:47
Not too surprising that Sea The Stars took fewer strides as apparently he had an extraordinarily long stride, it's notable that Frankel's were measured as quicker though.
By:
brigust1
When: 19 Sep 19 19:54
My Swallow did it in 222, Brigadier Gerard 223 and Dancing Brave 227.
In the Juddmonte STS did the last 2f in 54 and Frankel in 60. BG in 55.
By:
Figgis
When: 19 Sep 19 20:00
Surprises me about My Swallow. Seen the video of that Guineas many times and take BG out of the race, MS and MR look absolutely shagged even before the final furlong.
By:
brigust1
When: 19 Sep 19 20:06
In the Queen Anne over a mile Frankel ran the last 2 furlongs in 25 seconds in the 1972 King George over 12 furlongs Brigadier Gerard ran the last 2 furlongs in 25 seconds carrying 7lbs more.
By:
brigust1
When: 19 Sep 19 20:20
In the 2000 Guineas Frankie Durr on My Swallow never picked his stick up until BG had passed him and then only it him 5 or 6 times. I am pretty sure Geoff Lewis never actually hit Mill Reef BG went past them both so quickly.
By:
Figgis
When: 19 Sep 19 20:40
only it him 5 or 6 times

You think whipping a slowing horse more than that would make it run any faster?

You recall it differently than what I remember from watching the race a few times. Lewis had to make sure of second and wasn't giving MR an easy. I remember thinking how BG looked fresh at the finish, but then looking over at the other two and thinking they both looked bolloxed well before the finish. They were treading water, Mill Reef even beginning hanging out towards the centre. Even ignoring BG from the race MR didn't finish the race like others of his I watched.
By:
brigust1
When: 19 Sep 19 20:50
You can easily see that Lewis was just waving his whip. Durr tried to use My Swallow's stride to ensure a good pace and BG just sprinted past them and BG was always about a length behind them throughout. The form book shows that Mill Reef should finish less than a length in front of My Swallow and that is what happened. The fact that My Swallow strode along throughout shows they went a good pace which should have suited Mill Reef. If BG had not run the result would have been exactly as predicted.
By:
Figgis
When: 19 Sep 19 21:03
You can easily see that Lewis was just waving his whip

Right, if that's what you saw. So it's ok for Lewis to do that but if JOB does similar against a horse that passes him like his horse is running on the spot, it stinks. I see.
By:
brigust1
When: 19 Sep 19 21:09
If you cannot see the difference Figgis then I am not going to waste any more of my time. Isn't it odd a minute or so ago you said you thought they were out on their feet. You would cause an argument in an empty room Figgis. I wonder how much of what you have learned on this thread shows just what a fantasy life you fave been living. Let us hope Pinatubo is the real deal.
By:
Figgis
When: 19 Sep 19 21:16
Isn't it odd a minute or so ago you said you thought they were out on their feet.

Not odd at all, I said I thought they were and still do. I said if that's what you saw, you find it acceptable for Lewis to be beaten 3 and do that but not when JOB is beaten 7. Now that's odd Wink
By:
Figgis
When: 19 Sep 19 21:17
Let us hope Pinatubo is the real deal.

You'll be praying for it. I'll take it or leave it Wink
By:
brigust1
When: 19 Sep 19 21:48
That position is silly and untenable. Lewis knew Mill Reef would beat My Swallow but JOB knew he was under strict orders not to threaten Frankel. There is a big difference beaten honesty and cheating. But as you know I have always thought Ballydoyle and Coolmore are crooks. But like most good things they just keep on giving. Laugh
By:
impossible123
When: 19 Sep 19 22:16
Pinatubo looks like the 2nd coming (so far). Let's hope he's looked after and get to all the gigs next season. After the many false dawns with Too Darn Hot Flat Racing needs a genuine superstar who could take all before him with aplomb, I believe.
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 19 06:47
like most good things they just keep on giving

They're not the only ones

JOB knew he was under strict orders not to threaten Frankel Happy
Page 6 of 8  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com