We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
Ignore 135 in the link
|
|
By:
That Celtic Swing 138 needs some serious revision. I can understand them taking a punt on a literal interpretation of that form at the time, even though many people questioned how much it was exaggerated by the softish ground, but really CS never got close to that mark. Pinatubo puts up one of the best 2yo performances seen, backed up by the clock, but still remains 4lbs short of that over inflated rating. Celtic Swing's RPT win was about 9lbs behind Pinatubo in my view.
|
|
By:
Timeform cannot handle ratings and soft ground. Look at Cracksman.
|
|
By:
I thought Xaar was overrated but either way it's clear he didn't train on, went backwards, so fair enough you could argue his rating shouldn't be altered just because he didn't go on. As for Armiger though, that rating should've been seriously downgraded. I fancied him for the Derby myself, even backed him ante post, but even though he didn't train on there's no way that was one of the all time 2yo performances, no matter how impressive it might've looked on the day.
|
|
By:
Cecil had a horse called Armiger who
trounced the field,backed him 12s for the Derby,turned out no good. What was his 2yrold rating? |
|
By:
Incidentally Xaar was another horse who, while always well regarded, didn't look exceptional until making big improvement later in his 2yo year.
|
|
By:
I also thought that Frankel was 133 with Timeform as a 2yo? What happened to Air Force Blue? He was rated higher than Too Darn Hot by them as a 2yo.
|
|
By:
Xaar beat Tamarisk by 7 lengths in the Dewhurst which resulted in his short price and then beat the same horse by 15 lengths in the Guineas. Just over rated that's all.
The Guineas itself won by King of Kings wasn't a great race either. The list I saw Frankel was 128. |
|
By:
https://www.timeform.com/horse-racing/features/ratings-update/air-force-blue-timeform-rating-12102015
Not sure what's gone on there. |
|
By:
Frankel 129p
|
|
By:
I mean I don't know what happened with the Frankel 133. I can understand they went out on a limb with Air Force Blue as a 2yo but then maybe downgraded him later. Nothing wrong with that, rating lightly raced horses is often a best fit/guess at the time until further evidence. If they did revise his rating though it beats me why they would allow those Celtic Swing and Armiger ratings to stand. My guess it was so long ago and allowed to stand for so long that they don't feel they can interfere with ratings compiled by people no longer there. Makes a bit of a mockery of any historical comparisons though.
|
|
By:
they changed Dancing Braves rating
|
|
By:
That was the BHA
|
|
By:
yeh your right,I always thought that was timeform aswell.
|
|
By:
Timeform never. The clowns at the BHA did.
|
|
By:
Their DB Arc rating never added up. A very good horse and a very exciting race to watch but the numbers didn't correlate with the race. The BHA knew a change needed to be made if they were going to continue to try to make historical comparisons. Well done them I say.
|
|
By:
he was more than a very good horse.
|
|
By:
It's all a matter of opinion how good he was. His actual career was one of the most exciting I've followed. There was a lot of media speculation about him. Whether he was just a hyped 2yo or not before the Guineas. Whether he'd stay the Derby trip, as a Guineas winner hadn't won the Derby since Nijinsky. The Alex Bird bet. The poor ride from Starkey. Whether Shahrastani had improved past him at The Curragh. Then the climax of the Arc and the visually impressive style of victory. His style of running and great turn of foot also made him very exciting to watch. Personally I've seen better pound for pound performances in the Guineas, The King George and the Arc, but that's just my opinion. No arguments if some people think he was the best. Ratings aren't supposed to be about overall opinions or impressions though. They're supposed to be a measure of an actual performance in a race. The BHA just corrected what had previously been wrong.
|
|
By:
The problem with the BHA was the reason. Anyone could see they wanted to put Frankel above Dancing Brave but he wasn't able to achieve it on the Track. It stinks to high heaven. The race they rated Frankel 140 was a farce. The Gardner- Hill said they rated the race through the 4th horse and Phil Smith said they rated it through the 2nd horse. You don't have to look very hard to see they were two chancers who wanted to say they rated the top rated BHA horse. The same for Timeform. Phil Smith ent me a letter saying it was difficult separating the two because Dancing Brave beat better horses narrowly while Frankel beat lesser horses easily. They were his very words. Anyone in sport knows it is a greater achievement to beat better opponents narrowly than to beat lesser opponents easily.
|
|
By:
Gardner Hill rated the race through a horse who was having his first run in the UK and never won a Group race in his life. No-one knows to this day which horse ran to form. Half the field ran stones below their rating. And Phil Smith rated through a horse who ran 21lb below form.
And this is the greatest racecourse performance in the history of the BHA. You have to laugh at the clowns. |
|
By:
Anyone in sport knows it is a greater achievement to beat better opponents narrowly than to beat lesser opponents easily
Is this a serious statement? How good a miler would you say Green Desert was? |
|
By:
These are Phil Smith's words and he repeated them in the national press and I am not going to discuss them with you. If you don't like it take it up with Phil Smith. Oh, I forgot you won't hear anything against Frankel. Silly me.
|
|
By:
Well if horse A beats horse B (a typical Gp1 winner) by a head but horse C beats horse D ( a typical Gp2 winner) by 7 lengths then I'd say the performance of horse C was the better, and I imagine any handicapper like Phil Smith would agree. I doubt he said anything to contradict that, but if he did he's an idiot.
|
|
By:
"Even though I rode Shergar, I would say Dancing Brave is the one that has been really hard done by. To my mind Dancing Brave was a really exceptional horse. They could have left them together," said Swinburn.
Swinburn was supported in his criticism by leading National Hunt jockey Ruby Walsh, who felt the press were to blame. "I think it's ridiculous," said the 33-year-old Irishman. "Frankel was hyped by the press and the handicappers have simply fallen in line." Phil Smith, England's senior handicapper, defended the changes by saying it had been on the cards ever since Irish great Sea The Stars carried all before him in 2009 from the 2000 Guineas to the Epsom Derby to the Arc. "To fiddle it just to get Frankel on a higher mark would be wrong. This wasn't an exercise to make him the best horse," said Smith. |
|
By:
It was clearly a fiddle. They should be ashamed. I hope Pinatubo matches his mark because then there will be more scrutiny of the ludicrous way Frankel was rated.
|
|
By:
I liked Swinburn as a jockey but to say "To my mind Dancing Brave was a really exceptional horse", suggests he doesn't understand what they're supposed to be rating. They're not rating whether they think a horse was exceptional or not (for the ****g umpteenth time), they're putting a measure on one actual performance.
|
|
By:
Dancing Brave's trainer Guy Harwood told Sky Sports News Radio: "It sounds to be an extraordinary thing to do, to downgrade a horse. I don't know you can do that, having used experts to give you an opinion. At the end of the day, trying to compare one great horse to another is not a clever thing to do. I think it's absurd."
|
|
By:
why only Dancing Brave?
|
|
By:
why only Dancing Brave?
Because the numbers didn't add up and it had been pointed out to them repeatedly. The rating was given at the time like some kind of Dancing On Ice overall opinion on the horse's career put into a number, rather than a measure of any single performance. |
|
By:
Celtic Swing put up a single performance
at Doncaster,yet you think it should be revised,contradiction there it seems. |
|
By:
What contradiction? I said they were right to revise DB and I think they should revise Celtic Swing. Celtic Swing was rated on a single performance that many people said was too high at the time and nothing he did before or afterwards suggested it was ever right.
|
|
By:
Actually I remember Big Mac, before CS's 3yo season saying to Jim McGrath that his company had lost the plot when rating the horse.
|
|
By:
I would have believed what the BHA said about the ratings if they hadn't chosen the Queen Anne as the greatest racecourse performance in their history.
According to Gardner Hill and Timeform the race was rated through Indomito if that is the case then : Excelebration ran 21lb below form Side Glance ran 2lb below form Windsor Palace 9lb below form Bullett Train 14lb below form Helmet 23lb below form Premio Loco 21lb below form Red Jazz 23lb below form Strong Suit 35lb below form Worthadd 34lb below form And this supposedly the greatest racecourse performance in history. |
|
By:
I don't do performance ratings and I often disagree with Timeform and the official handicappers but I have that Queen Anne as the fastest performance in Europe over any trip since I've followed racing since 1985. They both did a great job, in my view
![]() |
|
By:
You can paint that any way you like if is effing scandalous for ratings organisations. And saying that was the 'fastest' performance just shows how clueless and misguided you are. This will all come out in the wash when they start comparing him with Pinatubo.
And when you say the fastest performance in Europe you do know that if the Kings Stand and the Queen Anne had started off level Frankel would have been 15 lengths behind Little Bridge when he passed the winning post. ![]() |
|
By:
And that is with Frankel running on the easiest part of the track and Little Bridge running on the stiffest.
|
|
By:
And saying that was the 'fastest' performance just shows how clueless and misguided you are.
From the man who repeatedly states times are worthless. And when you say the fastest performance in Europe you do know that if the Kings Stand and the Queen Anne had started off level Frankel would have been 15 lengths behind Little Bridge when he passed the winning post You do know that fastest performance means accounting for various distances? Apparently not. Hilarious ![]() |
|
By:
And when you say the fastest performance in Europe you do know that if the Kings Stand and the Queen Anne had started off level Frankel would have been 15 lengths behind Little Bridge when he passed the winning post
Have to repeat that. That's just incredible anyone would literally compare the time of a 5f race with a mile. One of your best yet. Unreal ![]() |
|
By:
No I do know you time 'flyboys' select the odd sectional and base their whole theory on that.
Frankel ran 14 times odten with a pacemaker and he was a free running animal yet he never broke a single course record. In fact he only beat average time TWICE and both of those times were on newly laid surfaces at Ascot and York. You can fool yourself as long as you like Figgis. |
|
By:
You stated it was the fastest performance in Europe yet 5 of the 8 furlongs were nowhere near (15 lengths) the other race on the same course that day. Completely clueless.
|