|
By:
I'd be much more fearful of Seventh Heaven (or even Found) than Minding.
Minding should be aimed at the QEII. |
|
By:
You could be right about Minding despite her heroic win in the Epsom Oaks as I'm still not fully convinced her best trip is 12f solely because Architecture is not a filly I rate highly - certainly not Gp1; Harzand - at least good ground a must - ought to be able to 'murder' Found in the 'Arc' but the unknown is the progressive French filly whose trainer seems to be winning most Gp1 races at will ie La Cressonniere; I'm still not a fan of Postponed despite everything he's done so far.
The 'Arc' is only about 6 weeks away,...how time flies! |
|
By:
in my mind i thought sinndar was a good price cos nobody thought anything could touch montjeu .a very similar scenario to whats shaping up for this arc , ive bet la cress , zarak , almanzour now i think i must bet harzand as well having a identical profile to sinndar
|
|
By:
La Cressonniere is no Zarkava
|
|
By:
La Cressonniere and Harzand - both have a strong constitution - settle and can quicken off a strong pace; Harzand will definitely appreciate the strong pace associated with the 'Arc' and stays the trip very well - the same cannot be said for La Cressonniere - but Harzand requires at least good ground to show his best and has been trained with this race in mind since the Irish derby.
I hope the best British and French 3yr olds make it to the 'Arc' to give Postponed proper competition. |
|
By:
I don't think the Arc is necessarily associated with a strong pace, just the opposite in many recent runnings.
|
|
By:
One would imagine Weld/Aga Khan will run a pacemaker or two - worked for Sinndar.
|
|
By:
And that was a proper way to run a pacemaker, uncle. None of this ridiculous haring off and being ignored by the pack and the stable companion held up in rear that we see too often. Sinndar's pacemaker just set a good sensible pace for him to track closely, a far better tactic in my view.
|
|
By:
You wont see another Zarkava for 30 years, wont stop plenty of 3yo fillies winning the Arc tho.
|
|
By:
O'Brien had said before the race that USAR would come on for the run and we know that he often uses these lower Group races to get his runners ready for the races that really matter to Coolmore. However, it seems very unusual for him to step his best middle distance 3yo down from a Gp1 to a Gp3. Maybe he's done this before but I can't recall it. It seems the Derby took a lot out of USAR and there's no guarantee he will recapture that form in the near future. As someone who backed him in the Derby and had hopes he could improve as the season progressed I now have major doubts.
|
|
By:
Think they new this one would disappoint which is why they skipped York for this low-profile race. Stick a fork in it IMO.
|
|
By:
I'll give him the benefit of the doubt but he needs 12f and should surely go for the Prix Niel rather than the Irish Champion.
|
|
By:
Agreed A_T, he's obviously not been showing them what he showed before the Derby. They can ready them at home when needed and I'm sure he'd have been aimed at a big race instead of here if possible. Today seemed a run more in hope that it would bring him on, but we'll see.
|
|
By:
La Cressonniere runs her trial on tuesday, only 365 left at 14/1
|
|
By:
couple of interesting things from La Cressonniere 2yo form, the horse she beats 3 1/2L here went on to run 3rd in the G1 CRITERIUM DE SAINT-CLOUD, finishing a neck in front of Idaho!
https://youtu.be/k6Qs0V6d80E?t=220 on her last start at 2yo she also comfortably accounted for Jet Setting on heavy ground, the only horse to beat Minding this season. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h05vrTNsYB4 the 14s gone now |
|
By:
only 2 bookmakers betting a 1/4 odds the place i see in a race where normally its a maximum field, deplorable stuff
|
|
By:
That was the most impressive ive seen her, she is improving, no way Postponed can give her the weight and live with that acceleration.
|
|
By:
As expected La Cressonneire won as she liked after quickening away from her pursuers at the 2f marker; I think she's force to be reckoned with in the 'Arc' if she stays 12f receiving 11lbs from Postponed and 3lbs from Harzand.
|
|
By:
Yeah you would have to say 8/1 is quite big. One firm stayed at 12. Pitty i've no account with them. She did that well, and well i wouldn't be a layer, put it that way.
|
|
By:
https://youtu.be/4n04XA1kIRI?t=582
|
|
By:
La Cressonniere’s win in G2 Prix de la Nonette, part of a one-two-three for the Jean-Claude Rouget stable, was just a good ‘stable’ workout and she was obviously not trained hard for this as her main target is in October.
However, I can’t remember an Arc winner who had not previously won or at least been placed (and at Group 1) over 12f. Zarkava (first filly in 15 years to win the race(13/8))) and the other recent 3yo fillies that won (Treve (9/2), Danedream (20/1)) were multiple group 1 winners that had all won over 12f previously that year. Avenir Certain had a similar path to the 2014 Arc, was an unknown stayer on decent ground, had a good draw and was 8/1 on the day, so I don’t see any value in La Cressonniere at 8/1 after today’s win as this told us nothing about her prospects of staying the Arc trip and who knows what draw she will get and what the ground will be at Chantilly on October 2. She will be back out soon to a more reasonable price for those who fancy her chances for sure. |
|
By:
nice performance by the winner, she shows plenty of speed and today was a typical french race... she at least showed her well being and the first 2 pulled clear...this should put her spot on for the big race, much to ponder with her
|
|
By:
after listening to the trainer it looks like she will go straight there, looking at the timing it is quite surprising she wouldn't take in the prix vermeille on route, it would certainly answer questions in regards distance and she hardly flicked a hair today
|
|
By:
8/1 still a very fair price imo, filly has been underrated all along, and unlike Avenir Certain, she has a good chance of staying on breeding.
The race does not look deep this year, a Gold Cup horse 5th in the betting tells you that, so she doesnt have much to beat. Unless the trials throw something up she will be close to fav in the French betting, and probably about 6/1 here. |
|
By:
I like La Cressonniere as she's impressed me in every race she's won. I understand her ability to stay 12f is unproven but she's won the Diane over 10.5f impressively which gives me sufficient hope she'll stay the 'Arc' trip. If she goes to the Vermeille next month she'd most likely be 'fav', and the present price of 8/1, still a longer price than Minding (5/1) whose participation is yet to be confirmed, is fair I think. Should she win the Vermeille no doubt she'll be compared to Treve when Treve as she can travel and quicken - only time will tell.
Postponed is the rightful 'fav' at 4/1 but the best he's beaten this year was Found and the latter is no 'Arc' winner; Harzand, Minding, La Cressonniere and Order Of St George are the major unknowns and apart from the last mentioned will be receiving lumps of weight from Postponed too. |
|
By:
There will be no Vermeille for La Cressonniere but head straight to the 'Arc', according to connections; she'll be a major player, and her win in the Prix de Diane on dead ground gives me hope she'll stay the trip too.
|
|
By:
Missing the Vermeille? Sounds like they have big doubts about 12f but don't want those doubts tested before Arc day.
|
|
By:
Perhaps she might be easy to train and get ready. Might not want to test her stamina close to the arc. Probably not ideal, but hey ho.
|
|
By:
I think connections are right to skip the Vermeille after today with the Vermeille only about two weeks to the 'Arc'; I'd like to think they are pretty hopeful La Cressonniere would stay 12f because she came from a long way back to win cosily in the 'Diane' over 10.5f on dead ground.
|
|
By:
a-t if you thought you owned a top class filly but had stamina reservations and the arc was your sole goal you wouldnt run either . if she doesnt stay in the arc shes fresher .maybe shes the new banks hill! fillies and mares turf on a tight track
|
|
By:
the Vermeille is 3 weeks before the Arc.
Le C is at least a course winner which is no bad thing. The second yesterday finished about the same distance behind Minding at Goodwood, in what was the Coolmore filly's least impressive performance for me. Minding is a proven 12f horse but Le C looks like having an ideal Arc prep. Take your pick... |
|
By:
I never put much emphasis on the draw in the Arc, but this year it really shouldnt matter at all, they go middle from the 1m4 start at Chantilly for nearly 2f on to the more familiar part of the course we see in the French Oaks/Derby, so plenty of time to be where you want to be before position matters.
|
|
By:
ive got a bit of almanzour that doesnt look promising , a bit of zarak in case he really comes to himself and la cress , also a bit of profit with harzand , err is there anything else in the race ! at mo i put it between harzand and la cress
|
|
By:
One could do worse than a token bet on Order Of St George who is running in the Irish Leger on 11th Sept - he is a stonking 20/1 here, a lot more just last week.
|
|
By:
Order of St George
The Melbourne Cup entry date is Sept 1st with the weights published 2 weeks later. In all likelihood with his OR 124 he will be given an impossible weight to carry by the Australian handicappers and AOB has stated in that eventuality he could then be pointed to the Arc with the proviso of soft ground conditions. Levmoss won both the Ascot Gold Cup and Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe (1969) and dual Ascot Gold Cup (1981, 1982) winner Ardross ran well in the race on two occasions- as 5yo he was the best of the British challengers, finishing fifth behind Gold River and was then beaten a head by the French filly Akiyda a year later. The 2005 Ascot Gold Cup winner Westerner finished second to Hurricane Run in the same year. Order of St George ran the final 2f of the Gold Cup in less than 25 seconds, so he certainly has shown enough pace given soft ground conditions and if he is set alight a fair way out he may well be a hard horse to catch. Interestingly, Galileo has yet to sire a winner Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe. I had egg on my face last year over the participation of Order of St George but I might have the last laugh this October if everything falls into place. |
|
By:
There are a few intriguing questions to be addressed this year, not least how will AOB shuffle his pack? Next to the English and Irish derbies, there is no more important race for Coolmore to target than the Arc, and as yet it is not clear how their team will pan out.
The money in the BF A/P market is pathetic with just a few quid here and there, so for me a better guide at present is the BM market prices. MINDING is shortest in (best priced 8/1) and has the potential to win the Arc but the doubt here is whether there is a colt that could do it as that would be much better business by a factor of N. FOUND looks an alternative (BP 16/1) and perhaps a more likely possibility this year. She looks up to a place but is exposed and may not be the most likely Coolmore winner but a place would do them nicely. ORDER OF ST GEORGE (BP 16/1 with WH but 14/1 best elsewhere) looks an intriguing possibility. He may be Coolmore's best chance with a colt this year. He has stamina in abundance and a turn of foot which given soft ground, as Madhu suggests, would give him a major chance. The Irish St Leger would be a reasonable prep race as nothing entered will give him a hard race and the interval between races is just right. The MC is an obvious alternative but a run in the Arc would preclude that given quarantine requirements. SEVENTH HEAVEN (BP 16/1) is only quoted by 4 main BM's but she is a serious prospect as she is thriving at present and providing she gets fast ground could improve enough to go close. But, another filly/mare running would just add to Coolmore's predicament of an embarassment of riches in their female options. HIGHLAND REEL (BP 20/1 but generally shorter) has the form to win an average Arc and to my mind this years renewal looks just that (POSTPONED notwithstanding) . He could turn up being a great traveller. IDAHO (20/1 generally) could easily take in the St Leger (for which he is a short fav) as its been done a few times before. Another colt which brings their colt team to 3. US ARMY RANGER (BP 25/1) must be something of a disappointment to AOP & Coolmore. 12f and soft ground would be his ideal conditions and he could still prove to be as good as they think he is and could show the necessary improvement to win an average Arc. Not one to be ruled out just yet. BALLYDOYLE (50/1) COOLMORE (50/1) DEAUVILLE (50/1) are all still quoted but it is hard to see any of these running let alone winning. The chosen runners from Coolmore will seriously shake up the market all by themselves without taking any other variables into account so I see this years market as one to be very cautious about. What yet hasn't been factored in to the debate is the change of venue from Longchamp to Chantilly. Although a RH course like Longchamp, Chantilly is flatter and doesn't rise as does Longchamp, but does seem on the turn for quite a way. I think that the draw may well be more significant even than at Longchamp. especially if there is a large field (20+) as there might be with no outstanding horse likely to frighten off runners.We don't have much in the way of stats for 12f at Chantilly and the ground there at that time of the year is also a bit less known. Taken altogether, the race has an open feel to it, more so than the betting implies. |
|
By:
Minding's chance is difficult for me to weigh up. I still think her Guineas win was up with the best winning performances of that race and on my ratings with the fillies allowance she'd have dead heated with Galileo Gold if she'd faced the colts in what admittedly was a weaker than usual 2000. I had her Irish Guineas form almost a stone behind that and the winner Jet Setting did nothing at Ascot to make me change my mind. Minding ran to a similar mark when winning a weak Oaks. I'd also argue that her wins since have been more in keeping with her Irish Guineas and Oaks form than her Guineas form. We know she stays 12f against a moderate standard of opposition but don't know if she could put up a similar level of form over the longer trip to the form she showed at Newmarket. It's also difficult to say for sure if she's even the same filly she was in the spring. Maybe she's just been doing enough since then but her very best form was five runs ago.
|
|
By:
they will only run Minding or Found if they think none of their colts is a possible winner - for one of their colts to come second to a stablemate filly would be too much to bear!
|
|
By:
I think Found is a definite for this race - she ran last year, but USAR is highly unlikely now after the disappointing run in the Royal Whip - he'll never beat Harzand on softish ground.
If Minding goes to the Irish Champion (10th Sept) and wins then unlikely she'll run here as I firmly believe (her connections too, I think) her best distance and lesser competition is 10f. Seventh Heaven is still improving and her main objective is the Fillies and Mile race at Newmarket on Oct 15th - important to gain another Gp1 - and there is always next year. I'd back her against Minding over 12f but not 10f because she needed every yard in the Yorkshire Oak before winning convincingly against Found, but she's very ground dependent ie good/firm. Order Of St George is a near certainty to run if the ground is soft but will rule out Seventh Heaven and as he's the best 'Coolmore' chance to win the race, in my opinion. Postponed and Order Of St George are very good horses but I think the 3yr old have the upper hand this year with the likes of La Cressonniere, Harzand, Seventh Heaven (if good/firm) and Minding; I'm unsure about the Japanese runners as I've little or no knowledge of their potentials. If the going is good/fast, there will be no Order Of St George and/or Harzand, but Seventh Heaven is a possible especially if Minding wins the Irish Champion Stakes, but only one of these two fillies will run, not both, I'm nearly certain. I hope La Cressonniere, Minding, Harzand, Postponed and Order Of St George all run to ascertain how good the 3yr olds are compare to their seniors. |
|
By:
Order Of St George- Idaho
The weight Order Of St George is given in the Melbourne Cup will surely dictate whether he becomes a possible runner in the Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe. Lloyd Williams, the majority shareholder of Order Of St George and four-time Melbourne Cup winner, stated after the Gold Cup that if receives 57kg or more the exercise of taking in the 17,000km trip would be a waste of time and money as horses carrying that weight rarely win the Melbourne Cup. Whether that was a ploy to get a reasonable weight is unknown. In the media today Racing Victoria general manager Greg Carpenter concerning Order Of St George, and 2014 Melbourne Cup hero Protectionist, is quoted stating "The topweight has to have at least 58kg. Without giving too much away those two horses are going to be up near the head of the weights." Therefore, we will not know until 2 days after the Irish St Leger is run and the release of Cup weights on September 15 whether Order Of St George comes into the Arc equation. Respectfully for that reason, the notion that Order Of St George is a near certainty to run if the ground is soft is a fallacy. To be honest, if Idaho were to win (or run well) the St Leger and then run in the Arc 22 days later, given a better draw than Kingston Hill (20 of 20) he would be a serious player. Since Sandown let the cat out of the bag about his potential I nabbed some more of the 100+ about him for a punt to have alongside my shining Knight. |