|
By:
right guys, i haven't seen pitch so hard to say, listened on tms, seems slow and low, this is probably harder to back than it is to bat on, my book england win
india win draw![]() ![]() now all 3 still a possibility, Eng bat tomorrow and get 300 by mid afternoon lot of pressure on india, personally think Eng rolled over for 250ish game on,india bat well get a lead only 2 outcomes india or draw, india rolled over for 180-200 probably Eng or draw, question is will cracks widen and bounce get uneven if so should be a result or will pitch flatten out, draw be fav then , also mindset Eng will bat and bat whatever happens, no declaration in this game from Eng either inns, india will need to take a chance when batting to force a result,i'm more confused now then before ![]() guess by this time tomorrow we will know more, personally fearing the draw really if pitch flattens out and cracks don't open up |
|
By:
Having laid the draw the last session was not good for me . Eng obv content to bat time - tactically this is correct as they are up in the series . My concern as a draw layer is Indias inability to take wickets - Eng will bat as long as they can 3rd innings - will India chase at all costs 4th innings ? They should do but not sure they will .
Bres next in who can stick about then Swann will attack and 10 11 are walking wickets . I am still a draw layer based on Eng having 2 good spinners - I expect India 4 down by end of day 2 - and this wicket looks a result wicket to me due to pace and bounce I also think the only way India can win is if sehweg plays a whirlwind of a knock - and if they make rapid progress tomoz - the rest of the batters are plodders - think I am talking myself in to laying them ! |
|
By:
will have to see both teams bat before i enter this market.
not often you see KP bat like he did. Doesn't look like a wicket where you can just force it so will be interesting to see how India go. |
|
By:
What a nightmare pitch / match to call!
I've half a mind to green out! People complaining over the slow run rate I suggest are thinking with their wallet rather than their heads. This is a 5 day Test match on a dry pitch with cracks and uneven bounce from ball 1. As for India batting 4th I think they will make better use of the wicket and bat only once. They should be use to slow low turners. Anyone with half a brain will nudge and nurdle bring the field in then hit through and over. The low bounce suits their batsmen. If they can bat for 2 days and score over 450 they should win as the pitch I think will start to disintegrate although nothing has gone through the surface. This is a tough one to call. England have dropped the ball. |
|
By:
What a nightmare pitch / match to call!
I've half a mind to green out! People complaining over the slow run rate I suggest are thinking with their wallet rather than their heads. This is a 5 day Test match on a dry pitch with cracks and uneven bounce from ball 1. As for India batting 4th I think they will make better use of the wicket and bat only once. They should be use to slow low turners. Anyone with half a brain will nudge and nurdle bring the field in then hit through and over. The low bounce suits their batsmen. If they can bat for 2 days and score over 450 they should win as the pitch I think will start to disintegrate although nothing has gone through the surface. This is a tough one to call. England have dropped the ball. |
|
By:
I can not see India batting 2 days but you never know !
|
|
By:
neither can I! It should be like net practice. Stay at the crease and defend the straight one. **** anything overpitched or offline. push cheeky singles and be patient. Apart from low bounce the pitch is not difficult to bat on. Scoring runs quickly is a different matter but there is no hurry.
I think Fletcher has finally had some influence as Dhoni realises he needs all the help he can get. I am not convinced the line of attack and field placing were thought out by Dhoni alone. If Fletcher is able to get across to his men how to bat on a pitch like this then England could be in trouble but at the moment both sides seem bent on playing after you Claude. I am over exposed on India btw. Hoping to buy them tomorrow if these two continue to bat with a brain. Green on England and draw. |
|
By:
ditto i have just made india a big red, this partnership and then swann is key, if england can reach 300, they will do so slowly and it should be game over for india ..300 is of course a massive if
|
|
By:
I don't think India will get over 350 runs in their first innings, let alone 450!
|
|
By:
I hope you boys are right but I am not so sure. There is no devil in the pitch yet. England undid themselves. Trott and KP showed the right apptitude then got themselves out as did Bell.
I am looking to close India out as soon as possible or at least reduce exposure. there is a long way to go and I also lacked the patience to stay out. there were some big odds available. If England do start well I will lay the draw and back india for a three way green as God only knows what happens next! |
|
By:
I hope you boys are right but I am not so sure. There is no devil in the pitch yet. England undid themselves. Trott and KP showed the right apptitude then got themselves out as did Bell.
I am looking to close India out as soon as possible or at least reduce exposure. there is a long way to go and I also lacked the patience to stay out. there were some big odds available. If England do start well I will lay the draw and back india for a three way green as God only knows what happens next! |
|
By:
I hope you boys are right but I am not so sure. There is no devil in the pitch yet. England undid themselves. Trott and KP showed the right apptitude then got themselves out as did Bell.
I am looking to close India out as soon as possible or at least reduce exposure. there is a long way to go and I also lacked the patience to stay out. there were some big odds available. If England do start well I will lay the draw and back india for a three way green as God only knows what happens next! |
|
By:
If Eng start well I would be more nervous about the draw - takes more time out of the game - I think Root and Prior could bat long even with the new ball
|
|
By:
just listened to bbc podcast aggers and boycott
now geoff talks sense, he says you have to graft and runs will come nothing fancy after all he was made to bat here kp was interviewed he didnt know what wicket will do from here on, said he just couldnt score so there we are, just a point it was kp's 2nd slowest score of over fifty in his career says it all, india 25 yrs ago would bat 450 plus on here but this one day game has changed them,, have they the temperament too graft, if they try and force they may come unstuck, Eng may well have a good score who knows, fascinating stuff unless your exposed on the draw like me |
|
By:
collingwood reckons its over in 3 days..i think hes being a tad exhuberant tbh
|
|
By:
I'm fecked here. I'm red the draw and India and don't think that England can win this.
![]() |
|
By:
25 wickets in next 2 days sorry i cant have that
|
|
By:
35 sorry
|
|
By:
To be fair to Colly this was something he said before play started.
|
|
By:
Cunningplan - Exposed on the draw - u mean ur on the draw ?
I am green eng / ind for now Eng can win this - two good spinners on a poor wicket |
|
By:
ok fair point,
thing is if india fall apart in 1st inns we will all think different |
|
By:
paul england can win, imagine if they score say 260, india bat better than expected and score 300, that still gives england the edge with india batting last
|
|
By:
tbh i think anderson will do thhe most damage in indias first innings
|
|
By:
sno2 no sorry laid draw heavy and backed england
india win not a disaster financially but draw is a big hit Eng win would do just nice ![]() |
|
By:
Two long tails - poor wicket - no poor weather about - ind have to go for the win - monty all over them - jimmy one of the best in the world -
My concern is eng third innings - if they wanted to I think our top 4 could block it for 5 sessions vs this lot and they won't be that ambitious going for the win 50pc of my bankroll is on laying the draw - I hope to wake up to ind 2 down at about 630am ! Doubt it though prior can bat long and root looked assured Gl cp I'm after the same result |
|
By:
Think anything around 280-300 be ok for england here. Looks tough to score on and also keeps draw in picture too. Think you can survive outthere but tough to score quickly. Will indian batsman have patience to bat 5 sessions for 400 and a good lead ?, doubtful.
|
|
By:
Finn may well have caused big problems. Great shame he's missing
His extra height and reverse swing.. The low bounce..250 and we're competitive. Flower et al have to take some heat re Bell's role on this tour. Jonny must be livid. It's a pitch you can bat for ever on, if you keep your concentration. |
|
By:
It's a pitch you can bat for ever on, if you keep your concentration.
for now. Would imagine the pitch gets a lot worse as we go on. India havent prepared a road for us to take this series 2-1 and havent picked 4 spinners for nothing either. |
|
By:
Yes gentlemen, agreed. I took an opening posi on England but switched to draw early doors. I've ummed and ahhed about it but on balance I'm going to stay with the draw here.
|
|
By:
I may be wrong but it looks like it will get lower and slower.
If the spinners don't get bounce, you get on the front dog and bat all day. Soft hands please Belly... |
|
By:
yeah, agreeing with that Injera. Sorry Lix, it's marginal I agree. We're all trying to figure this one out!!!
![]() |
|
By:
well i hope so, I'm on the draw for now
![]() |
|
By:
Oh sh*t Lix - unlike you to be on the draw!
Wouldn't say it'll be a draw but it should trade at 2s or less ![]() |
|
By:
Both - totally agree. Sub 2's and I'm out :)
|
|
By:
i'm confused
i agree with inj that around 250 to 260 is competitive. but the spread is 324-332 for england, i'm baffled to explain the prices. that's plenty on this deck, where there's an excellent chance that 1st innings crease occupation is just as important as runs with the majority agreeing that this is a awful wicket deliberately underwatered to force a result. there's a slim chance the grass may hold it together, but once there are signs that it won't the draw should really be 100-1. |
|
By:
the pitch was very placid today england arguably threw a few wkts away very slow spin and bounce maybe pitch gets tougher later in game i do not normally agree with lix but think the draw could get some downward movement if root and prior can stick around a few overs they never really looked in trouble looked very easy in the afternoon would be nice to see them both there at lunch
![]() |
|
By:
the deck is fine no real movement no real turn or bounce on the 1st day
![]() |
|
By:
100/1 draw root and prior bat 15 / 20 overs draw will be sub 3.0 given the way the draw moved on the 3rd wkt partnership 5.0 to 2.8 for 80 odd runs ![]() |
|
By:
We won't know for sure until India bat. My problem in being an England backer is that I need them to stick around to post a competitive total. However, not long enough so it brings the draw in to play. I think India are rightly favourites but a bit short for me.
|
|
By:
i cant see Eng batting past lunch think they will succumb in 1st session
|