Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 563 comments are related to the topic:
did jesus of the new testament exist??

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 10 of 15  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | ... | 15 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 563
By:
Foinavon
When: 24 Jan 17 15:54
Judgement is man's invention. To many, you are an apostate. There is no judgement after death, there is nothing. We who are still living may judge the dead but it serves no purpose.
By:
dustybin
When: 24 Jan 17 16:07
You suggest zorro I shouldnt ask questions, yet it says in Genesis that the nature of sin is the knowledge of good and evil.
That we are cast into this sin by default as the sin of the father.
So if the manifestation of my natural sin is to know the difference between good and evil....isnt it prudent to determine the meaning of sin itself? (otherwise how do I determine what is good and what is evil?)
Besides, or are you saying only the pious may question science?
By:
zorrostrikes
When: 24 Jan 17 16:13
I'm saying only men called Jeff should examine science...

How does your mind work dusty?

infer away -
By:
Breedingmad
When: 24 Jan 17 16:14
If you look back at the census back then you find it's all true.
By:
dustybin
When: 24 Jan 17 16:22
Im astounded at what Im reading, to such an extent i find it difficult to comprehend that there is a supposed someway rational debate going on where the religious dont have to explain the nuances like this next one......

The average age of those living around the time of Cain....was 900 years old Plain
By:
zorrostrikes
When: 24 Jan 17 16:25
i'm suggesting this - look first at a blue letter bible.

It's online.

If you read the bible it's not a literal book. it uses imagery.

He shone as bright as the sun. (what 5000 degrees kelvin?)

it was read by Paul, it was read by people in the year 600 AD.
it was read by the victorians. and now by the evolved people of the 21st century.

Should God have re wrote it for each generation? given you equations for creation, sent a special note to Richard Feynman - with the details.

It's not a literal book. It's more like a puzzle book.

see the cartoon - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3BGO9Mmd_cU
By:
dustybin
When: 24 Jan 17 16:27
imagery or imaginary?
By:
zorrostrikes
When: 24 Jan 17 16:29
At first people lived to a 1000 on average then some pratt spoiled it.

god made it around a 120.

You said eve bore a son and called his name Seth, for she said, “God has appointed"

now read out what the first ten in the lineage - what their names mean?

Adam is man. the hebrew words have meaning. every letter has a meaning.

so look up the meanings of their names.
By:
dustybin
When: 24 Jan 17 16:31
There seems to me to be a far simpler explanation than the elaborate one you profess.
That being that somebody tried their hardest to edit a story to be vaguely consistent.

Like a drunk man telling some exceptional story in the pub sitting the next day to try and explain a lie?
By:
dustybin
When: 24 Jan 17 16:33
He shone as bright as the sun. (what 5000 degrees kelvin?) That is called an idiom
By:
zorrostrikes
When: 24 Jan 17 16:33
The Composite List of the first people in genesis -

Hebrew     English
Adam     Man
Seth     Appointed
Enosh     Mortal
Kenan     Sorrow;
Mahalalel - The Blessed God
Jared     Shall come down
Enoch     Teaching
Methuselah - His death shall bring
Lamech     The Despairing
Noah     Rest, or comfort.

That's rather remarkable: that the Jews should hide an integrated message at the start.
By:
dustybin
When: 24 Jan 17 16:34
Ive got the book 'the bible code'....should I infer the code in that also?
By:
zorrostrikes
When: 24 Jan 17 16:36
different authors making one integrated message through history - just to fk with Dusty bin?

those twisted FKs - devious plan eh?
By:
dustybin
When: 24 Jan 17 16:39
Im about to have my tea, I shall return zorro but I wish you to know this before the time out.
Im not here to discourage you or anyone else, Im here to discuss elements which the religious deem of vital importance and that knowledge is for myself alone.
Whether people read our discussions is of no significance to me.
You are also blasé when you dismiss the realities of life.
Im bound to question, and I need to make money.
These two are constants that I cant effect....unless i close off my brain and rely on charity.
By:
zorrostrikes
When: 24 Jan 17 16:43
whit - am i in a mansion sipping champagne from a divas purse? (is that an idiom?)

i'm looking for scratch too. I like to bet for bonus cash.

wasting time till the lord picks me up.
By:
zorrostrikes
When: 24 Jan 17 17:15
google exists? if it's knowledge to fight god you want?

i'm not a minister, I studied art and graphic design.

my school mate ended up in seminary college, met him on a job.
I wonder if he's an atheist now?

If you are not playing games and are sincere (i'm not that gullible am I? )

then Chuck missler on Youtube has learn the bible in 24 hours on video.

please be aware playing games with God's words is not a good idea. I've taken some liberty with some of my own interpretations, every man reads his own story in the book. He either sees the crimes and the rapes - the dark side only or he sees only the loving side of God. The book is independent of the reader. it's not PC for the 21st century Hipster class.

Do not take the lords name in vain.


CS lewis also has lectures on Youtube about the bible.

Adam means man, one word into the book and it's going wrong. You need to know what it's trying to say. the fig tree is the nation of Israel. So don't think he's talking about
figs.

movie makers call this SUBTEXT. something else is being discussed under the table.
By:
dustybin
When: 25 Jan 17 13:01
Im investigating a few possibilities that have arisen, strangely from observation and argument from atheism.

I dont think Ive said anything deemed blasphemy, flippant perhaps.

I have zero spiritual stock, Im actually trying to locate the logic that substantiates the belief required to grow faith and strangely I might have found it.
If it follows that obedience was the message Jesus was making when he implied he showed the way through his actions then it could be theoretically possible that we build faith through a constant supply of decision making each day, between vice and virtue.
Virtue always meant to me the living accordance to nature....the 'right' rather than the 'good'.

It could be that choosing vice has a result in not being able to see the wood for the trees, in the sense the allegory is meaningless, even if you attempt to look you wont find it.
Ive often wondered that science is only discovered through investigation, things dont appear then why would faith>
I rather had hoped the clouds would part or something that is unquestionable would occur....but perhaps that would effect the outcome, an interference.
If we set up an experiment with a rat for it to press a pedal to release a treat, then effectively we have written the code that determines the reward. The rat can learn and chose whether to press the pedal, and we as observers dont interfere either way.
The code could be written in nature and science the manifestation of the physical observable world, like the cage and the feeder for the rat.
When you chose virtue over vice the reward is pleasure that derives from the chemical release in the brain that stimulates the synapses, which is the code for the reward.
The picking of virtue being what the creator determined was what it wanted you to do, since virtue creates harmony.


It might all be bulls hit, but this morning I made the effort.
Instead of calling a c unt a cu nt as I always always normally would, I actually refrained and said nothing.

We shall seeCool
By:
zorrostrikes
When: 25 Jan 17 15:44
Science is only discovered by investigation.
It's the same with anything. God introduces himself to you at a party, starts a conversation, but some people turn away before he can give them his contact details. Therefore they never get to know him. He's not a stalker that pushes his love. So he won't chase them up. They have to seek him out. They are aware he exists?

God gave us laws - ten. We disobeyed them. he gave us more - we broke them all(over 600). If there was a law not to take smarties up into the space station? don't you think one astronaut would smuggle a few up there. It's the nature of man to be rebellious.
the lesson is simple - sin leads to death and corruption. Those that get it? will not repeat the mistake again, when we are reunited with god on his plane of existence. It'll be like looking at a cooker ring at full blast and wanting to put your hand on it?
God could have said nothing to Adam and eve about the tree of Knowledge of good and Evil. he could have sat an angel beside it and told him to shoo them away... But he's revealing he knows the nature of temptation. Temptations come with consequences. If you like cream cakes, satan doesn't tempt you with sausages.

the crux is this - everyone is a sinner. in thought or deed. nobody can keep the law. the law is Satan's favourite thing.(he's a lawyer in JOB) he convicts you of a crime. he owns you. until you call up the defence lawyer(jesus) jesus shows the cops the Habeas corpus.
gets you free forever. Those that don't have a good lawyer on their side gets to go to trial.
a good christian knows he can't avoid temptation, he'll back slide somewhere but he tries to live up to jesus expections. But no action will save you from hell. only Christ has paid the full price. no man can buy heaven with good deeds.
some Christians don't understand this concept. called grace. they think deeds will get them into heaven, but they see themselves back slide and it's like a busted diet? becomes a scales of justice scenario.  ten good things and one bad thing? No.
By:
dustybin
When: 25 Jan 17 16:02
But equally any man's conscience will tell them if they have an ounce of integrity that simply saying you have faith based on fear is like throwing seed on stony ground and pretty shameless.
Ive read i can appeal to god/jesus and apologise.
Thats not difficult, Im not a nice person the idea that Im sinless is a joke.
So I could get on my knees every night but that would be like driving the nail into him myself and until faith itself is affirmed then its fruitless.

The notion that god prefers those that take the pi ss out of him over those that acknowledge themselves to be bad and potentially seek atonement but only when they feel sincerity is absurd and cant be right imo.
By:
zorrostrikes
When: 25 Jan 17 16:15
It's not based on fear? it's love.

the bible is a love story - between Mankind/womankind and God.

God made us SPIRIT/SOUL and BODY. God is Spirit(jesus says this).

Yes be fearful of God, it's said that is the start of wisdom but it's the same as a child's fear of his father. You steal from the shops as a kid, you get caught, you know your father is going to give you a tanning. If you don't learn from that lesson and continue it, you are letting your father down again?

In the book of revelation there are three groups.. the bride of christ, the body of christ and the beast.

Those that have faith, those with a little faith and those with no faith (they oppose christ).

an army of non believers, who oppose christ, anti christs, one army - called the beast. the beast system. Man believing Man is self justification. being self righteous. This is the cardinal sin against God. The refusal of the holy spirit.
You ask for the holy spirit and it will be given to you if you are faithful.
By:
zorrostrikes
When: 25 Jan 17 16:33
When Jesus left to prepare a place for his followers, he faithful. he left the comforter behind, the helper. An aid in writing the Gospels. A way of accessing Jesus. He restrains the full power of Satan. Jesus left in place the Grace covenant - this is the seed that grows the crop. the crop must be harvested. the time for the harvest is the 6000th year. it's passed, Jesus is delayed - he said he'd be delayed, it's intentional to throw off Satan. For Satan to fulfill his part, he needs the holy spirit to go away. Let him flex his spiritual muscles. The holy spirit exists in god's faithful. So they have to go away. This is described as the rapture. Some weird films have tried to simulate what this would look like? empty clothes? or complete vanishing? it might be that all the faithful drop dead in one stroke. But it will be explained away.
Jonathan Edwards, founder of Princeton in the USA - gave sermons about it. he talked about the tribulation too. in a sermon in 1739 he says the tribulation would begin in 2016. based on bible scripture. If he was the usual date setting nut, he would have said 1755? some number close to his day. it's a common way to influence your peers. if you are a manipulator. It's kind of a coincidence that Israel has reinstalled the San Hedrin last year after 1,947 years, they have a high priest - (the new ciaphas?) the USA withdrew their support of Israel for the first time ever? it's getting interesting.
By:
dustybin
When: 25 Jan 17 17:34
it's passed, Jesus is delayed - he said he'd be delayed
He's waiting for me.
Cool

Well I dont know about all that, maybe Ill come across it in time. Setting a date far off means you cant be proven wrong, what are they going to do next year if it doesnt come to pass?
Dance on his grave?

This isnt mocking but every horror film I seem to recall makes the good guys look like ****.

There is a constant though, which maybe the origin of people's insecurities and that is the enduring lack of answers to anything of substance coupled with an implied sense of security based on things they observe nearly always being how they learned them to be through experience.
Even science at quantum level states that however wild the prediction if theres a 1/x in front then its a certainty however seemingly unlikely, so at some point something completely left field will occur and shock everyone.
I remember reading Michio Kaku refer to something similar as waking up on mars (due to the wavelength of some of the human cells), its not that its impossible its just no single individual lives long enough for it to have ever happened.
By:
zorrostrikes
When: 25 Jan 17 19:37
I watched a lecture last night on Youtube - called: The Dawkins Delusion: Debunking the Conflict Between Science & Religion | Denis Alexander, PhD

It's a Cambridge Scholar who isn't critical of Dawkin's science only his 'trolling behaviours' He lays out the case that religion and science split in the 19th century because of economic factors. That it's not a conflict of truths, but economics.
The clergy were the keepers of science and up and coming lay people needed to wrestle the facilities off them. Making it a business?

it's worth a watch. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8QMnd4aii8o

I used to believe in Darwin up until a couple of years ago  - but i have trouble with Macro evolution. The lecturer doesn't. So he's pro evolution. But he's also a christian. It's okay to be both. But I have my own world view like everyone else.
my stance is that it's nearing the end. Evolution will be a moot concept.
A lot that is deemed important today might be heading for the bin.
(i base this on fifty variables at least, not one thing, some not even bible related)

the lecture will send you to sleep if you start to watch it.
By:
dustybin
When: 26 Jan 17 11:04
Ive not seen it but Im sure he doesn't have the monopoly on uninspirational discourse.

The junior schools (Including Middle) I went to were CoE, we would be handed hymn books on entry and we'd be forced to knock out at least two songs per assembly, twice a day.
On occasion the twee Head Master would toddle down from his tower and witter on about some story from the bible.
No other religion was ever mentioned and what is now called RE (as a subject) was basically colouring in outlines of shepherds and camels.
It was all forced arm up back, much like the message itself in many respects.

The only images I remember were of Robert Powell as Jesus cutting a rather pathetic figure even then, but it wasnt until I saw him again in 'The Detectives' with Jasper Carrot that I thought it all seemed something of a symbolic hero rather than actual. Grin (that was flippant again)
By:
zorrostrikes
When: 26 Jan 17 12:19
It all sounds half hearted...

The protestants fought hard to wrestle the real spirit of Christ free from the old church. Tyndale died to get the bible published in english. The world tries to insulate Jesus from mankind. Jesus isn't a friend to the world, some happy clappy hippy. Hymns and one parable in schools is a  scratch on a marble block. It doesn't describe the integrated message of the bible.
He's here to separate us out from the world. You accept that you are up there on the cross with him. Dead to the world. He says the world will hate you. Our death is the death of sin. They are pinned to the cross. We accept payment has been made.
yes you will sin, that cannot be avoided but your soul will say it is wrong, and each time your spirit confronts the sin it will dwindle. Sin is boring. It's repetitive and tiring.

I think about the film with Kenneth Brannagh - Conspiracy (2001), it's the nazis deciding about how to eliminate the Jews/gypsies /slavs. They have a meeting with all the top men in the party and discuss killing in terms of economics and logistics. It's a pedantic, lifeless exercise. They mention instead of killing them, can they just sterilize them to stop breeding. It shows that real evil at it's apex is about number crunching. they talk about the cost of a bullet being too much?

I even thought - if they had sterilized the Jews they probably would not have been so vilified by the allies after the war? yet it's just as evil? they treat other people as lesser creatures. 

HOLY WOOD films are not very good,  the little animations on youtube which takes two minutes are better, as they reveal scripture a little.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3BGO9Mmd_cU
By:
dustybin
When: 26 Jan 17 12:47
You know the 'message' in all forms would hold more gravitas if it were humans that had created themselves in the first place.
To talk in a framed language of 'good', 'evil. 'choice' 'love' and 'freewill' all comes under scrutiny when in terms of choice it comes down to a creator forcing a creation into being, then willfully abandoning them when they choose the wrong option of two.
The term 'faith' means something which you can justifiably believe strongly enough in to back with conviction.
I couldnt faithfully say that image of creation to be of love of goodness.

For a 'father' to create some form of offspring and then shed responsibility is bad enough, but at least the spawn grows into something that equates to the father.
But for a superior to create an inferior and then punish them into an existence they cant leave with torture doesnt nurture a belief in 'love' to me.

The act of giving life and rearing them promotes Love and thats enough, to then punish them for not being what the father desires is vindictive imo.

With that in mind I have no problem if the spiritual mind can be shaped by good deed to such an extent that they are drawn to the goodness of godly intent, but to put faith in anything from the mouth of man alone is like handing a knife to a fellows hand and simply hoping they dont choose to cut your throat....the armour with which we treat suspicion is the armour that keeps us alive.
By:
dustybin
When: 26 Jan 17 12:52
Incidentally, I read a little about this tribulation and other prophecies and apparently the devil will return in the guise of Christ before Christ's second coming.
How the f uck you even stand a chance?
Even the return that you believe will occur could be the devil himself.
By:
zorrostrikes
When: 26 Jan 17 14:29
Man - that's a thick pea soup of misunderstanding of God there.

God is refining us. He is making us perfect spiritual creatures. We are going to be on God's level with him on his plane of existence. To get there, we have to shed our sins voluntarily. we have to surrender. To God's authority.
Pride is the problem. The angel's rebelled because of pride. man refuses God because of pride.

You just described it yourself 'if man created himself...'- Johnny cash said it too - we want heaven but we don't want God in it.

Everyone here on earth is under some authority, they pick their own Gods, Rock gods, Sports or science heroes. They pick some belief system. They are false religions and satan makes one a year. David Bowie openly tells you he worships Satan. We laugh it off. Many celebs do this. Is it all shine-ola? the universe works with rules and these people are declaring themselves to be Satanists because it's the rules. You worship them and that worship gets passed on. 

the bible says that Satan isn't against Christ, he'll replace him. He'll oppose him. the people with him are the same they oppose christ. Little baby anti christs with axes to grind. Petty judgements on God. They refused the holy spirit and don't know God they look at the bible and mis read it as you are doing. you are still reading the surface meanings.

the bible says there will be some that say - over here - jesus is here? False prophets. He's in the desert. etc. Jesus says as I leave so I shall return - every eye will see me at once - he's going to descend from the sky and there will be no doubt who he is.
if a guy changes lead to gold and says he's jesus - he's not jesus.

eat of the tree - you will be like God, knowing Good and evil.

You think you will one day evolve into a God. ? pride and self righteousness.
By:
dustybin
When: 26 Jan 17 15:00
I remember the particularly pious teachers in the schools mentioned would say something like; 'you worship those that can not save you on the belief they can'
Thats a common misconception of the majority of people.
I and others dont worship anything in the place of a god almighty since I acknowledge nothing is great enough to compare with the image of which they paint of a creator.
I say we might admire people or actions, but I doubt many pray to anything believing them to be greater than what they are.
They certainly arnt likely to believe them deities.

Its correct to assume we are all slaves of something, the fact we are trapped in nature attests to that fact, so we were never free from influence from the start so that isnt freewill, thats manipulation.

If a man has a child and does his best to defend and nurture them the child grows to love the father.
If a man has a child and molests it as well as feeds it then the child grows up with conflicting feelings.

We are the products of our surroundings and have little to no call on the things that shape us....much like pavlovs dog didnt set up the test.
By:
dustybin
When: 26 Jan 17 15:16
I fail to see even those who believe and expect Jesus to return wont be tricked by satan acting as him, even if they knew it was to happen, since how do you know what satan will do?
By:
howard
When: 26 Jan 17 15:22
They don't think Dusty. They just hope. They don't want their existence to end. Best to listen to nobody in this life...use your own eyes and brain.
By:
zorrostrikes
When: 26 Jan 17 15:29
You want a legal answer. like a lawyer in a court room.

God offers a free gift. a pardon for all sins. But pride of your own experience of life is making you turn it down.
You'll hang on to your sins like John Wayne. Sucking it up... i'm okay.

God cannot allow sin to exist. It's a free choice to pick sin. Your still asking to hang on to it. Not surrendering it. You blame God for mankind's choices. Should god be looking over your shoulder and if you try to do something evil stop you? That makes you a puppet.

Evil exists and God is letting us deal with it. It's a lesson.
the whole of the old testament is about men trying to deal with their sins... every time failing. So God gave us the perfect sacrifice, one that cleanses us of all sins. We have the sheepskin of Jacob draped over our shoulders and can now go into the tent to ask for the father's blessing. God does not see us - only Jesus. Jesus is our covering.
no more prophets. it is finished. the seed is planted and the crop is ready.

If you read about Jacob and Esau, on the surface you'd miss this? the bible is metaphor and subtext, not about slaughters and murders,it's got hidden messages. All descriptions that lead to one solution. the blood on the cross. the tree of life is the cross.

Sounds to me that your faith is in science. You'll argue God is bad, Blaspheming the spirit of the Lord. You see man as the injured party. It's self righteousness all the way.

God has every right to deal with us how he wishes, he made us. He made Satan and he'll deal with him as he wishes. He'll roll up creation and make a new heaven and a new earth.
The pot telling the potter what he is? That's just arrogant.
You say he is a manipulator by stepping aside? you say he is controlling if he steps in?
It's clear that you made your choice long ago. You'll voluntarily jump into a pit. When there are a 100 ways to avoid it.

The year is 5777 on the jewish calendar the year of completion of grace. the covenant will end and the lord's return is sure to follow. you had the warning shoved in your face and choose to call God the sinner. Smart move.
By:
dustybin
When: 26 Jan 17 15:37
Just briefly for now in response...
You are correct to say I see man as the injured party, since I pity even the condemned man who acted due to whatever the reward was that lead him there, since as you suggest the story of his choice is so contrived within a story within a story.

I just cant get my head around the concept zorro that the sin created by god, then to be wholesale forgiven by the actions of his son get absolved simply by us saying we believe it.
What kind of hocus is this?
By:
dustybin
When: 26 Jan 17 15:39
If a marker were placed that was irrefutable then there would be a choice
By:
dustybin
When: 26 Jan 17 15:41
metaphor by its definition is vague and opaque, to suggest man needs to rely on this and have faith in it to save him doesnt give much hope for them imo
By:
dustybin
When: 26 Jan 17 15:49
Its almost a testimony of insanity to accept some of the unverified notions within the bible, thats what i struggle with zorro, since we have to live within the boundaries of what we witness and experience, not on what we are told has or hasnt happened.

We agree on a number of areas but disagree on others, Im trying to bridge the gap with logic but i admire the fact you attempt to do what you believe is right whether i believe it to be correct or not,
By:
zorrostrikes
When: 26 Jan 17 15:51
I guess someone has to choose to be in the losing side. Free will. You chose the one side that is preordained to lose. The book says it? yet you still choose it? total free choice.

I just see it as super dumb.

they had a thing in English classes in my day called 'interpretation' - they'd hand out a poem and we would examine one page for an hour. The teacher would reveal hidden meanings in Ted Hughes' work or some other poet? A panther in a cage? Ted Hughes' Jaguar

you treat the bible as if it was Raymond Chandler novel - it's a book by the greatest poet outside of this world and you think you know it? rather sad.
By:
dustybin
When: 26 Jan 17 16:03
You cannot call something 'super dumb' for baseing an evaluation on logic.

For every interpretation there is going to be misinterpretation too.
Countless times Ive heard reference to things as 'its what you want it to mean' so as to appeal to anyone for whatever reason.
By:
dustybin
When: 26 Jan 17 16:03
basing
By:
dustybin
When: 26 Jan 17 16:07
For such an honest misinterpretation to cost so much is why i would pity humanity, by your reckoning.
Page 10 of 15  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | ... | 15 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com