|
By:
And if these shenannigans continue we have plenty more of this nonsense to look forward.
|
|
By:
Hmm average race rating still doesnt help imo.
If the RPRs are approaching grade 1 then this is diluting the championship races. If the RPRs are not approaching grade 1 then the race simply shouldnt be a G1! What would make me sit up and listen is some of these 2.5m specialists who can only post a G1 mark at 2.5m but not 2 or 3 miles. Who are they? Riverside Theatre maybe? Albertas possibly? Id look it all up myself but cant find them! Without the benefit of ratings I can think of far more horses who raced it because they werent good enough over 3 miles. Cue Card, Dynaste, Al Ferof. Alan King said yesterday that he might be able to win a Ryanair with Smad place but has no chance in the Gold Cup. Smad place is a hennessy winner who's 2.5m form amounts to beating fingal bay! This doesnt look like a race for 2.5m specialists but I would genuinely re-evaluate it with some good examples. |
|
By:
and i can think of many examples of horses that didnt run in the ryanair because they werent quick or good enough at that trip- the quality of the ryanair is going up and if it continues too it will soon be on a par with the cc and gc if it doesnt continue to it wont how difficult is this to undrstand omg
|
|
By:
and it is not diluting the other races if the horse cannot replicate this rating over 2m or 3m2. for fans of vautour on your behalf i truly hope that 2 1/2 does not turn out to be its best trip because if it does then irrespective of what rating it posts in these races it appears there are many that wont take it seriously.
|
|
By:
Genuinely can't believe this subject has sparked so many strong feelings either way.
And that so many people have an issue with a top class race at the Festival. Pretty sure if any of the people anti the race owned a Grade 1 horse who excelled at this distance they would be very, very excited to be running in this race. For me, I can't see a counter argument to The Headmasters post. The gap between Championship races at the Festival at 2m and 3m2f would just be too much. just because it used to be that way isn't an argument to me. |
|
By:
how difficult is this to undrstand omg
![]() I thought you wanted to use RPRs to prove a point? So far youve only given one example and it was a fictional Vautour one you made up. And the pointless one about the race improving over time. Who are all these specialists who can only post a G1 rating in a 2 1/2 mile race? Ive tried to help with two possibles. |
|
By:
i used rprs to show how the ryanair is improving and to state that the gap between the ryanair and the cc and gc is closing - and that this could suggest that if this improvement continues then the ryanair will be a serious race in its own right and not a mish mash hybrid or whatever the phrase was - not to prove any other point - i never once implied that a horse can only post a g1 rating in a 2 1/2 race i have consistently talked about the possibility of a horse posting its HIGHEST rating at 2 1/2 mile and if there are a few top class horses like this then i for one will be grateful that the ryanair exists - now either you are too lazy to read all my posts or you are just trying to wind me up - either way fair play to you
|
|
By:
Not trying to wind anyone up and you can have the last word after this if you want.
I would like to be convinced that the ryanair is a specialist race but there just arent enough examples of specialist runners to me. If you dont think its necessary to identify these types and that the race gaining grade 1 status is itself proof of its grade 1 worthiness then fair play to you. GL |
|
By:
they dont have to be 2 1/2 specialists just better at 2 1/2 miles than 2 or 3m 2 - for me the recent winners of the ryanair are good/very good/excellent horses (uxizandre, cue card, dynaste and riverside) and at the time they won it were imo better at 2 1/2 than 2 or 3 m 2 and if this trend continues then the ryanair will establish itself as much more than a mish mash hybrid - i am happy to see a horse post a rating of more than 170 which 3 of the 4 i mentioned did while also knowing they did not stay 3m2 or have speed for 2m (though think uxi would have been a massive runner in cc with that performance) - so i am not sure (again with exception of uxi - what harm these horses running in ryanair did to cc or gc
|
|
By:
Well you're saying it yourself miltons. The Ryanair is a mish mash. Some of us think that the owners of the very best horses should be aiming for the stars. That's the romance of the game. Would One Man have farmed the Chump Change Championship? Almost certainly. He didn't though did he? They aimed for the stars and came away with a Champion Chase.
Again there are many of us that think that Vautour is just too good. Especially seeing as he hasn't run in either of the big ones. It would just be a case of farming. No guts no glory. He had the speed to spread eagle the Supreme field. If for some strange reason they go yellow and bottle a shot at Gold then the sporting thing would be to see him race head to head with UDS and god willing the existing champ to create a race for the ages instead of a lap of honour in the Easyjet. Let him take his chance in the Game Spirit. |
|
By:
The Chump Change Championship?
It's a Grade 1 race at the greatest meeting in the world. Clearly it doesn't have the prestige of the CC or the GC as they have been around forever. A bit of a ridiculous comment. |
|
By:
eternal - i was mimicing what a poster called it many many posts ago - my god one man was b****y years ago - my posts have all been about the steady rise in quality of ryanair winners since it started and the possibility of the ryanair being a top quality race in the future if (and only if) the recent upward trend continues and that way we will have three prestigious chase races at the festival not two and that is ok imo and the other two wouldnt have to become less prestigious or be threatened by it - like i have said repeatedly this is not about vautour as we dont yet know what his best trip is so if he runs in either cc or gc then thats cool but for the horses sake i hope vautour doesnt prove to be best at 2 1/2 miles (and not the best at 2 or 3m2) because it seems now that even his own fans will be thoroughly disappointed in him
|
|
By:
tbh i am angry with myself for bothering when it doesnt really matter - i am just trying to be positive and optimistic about a race that i feel is showing signs of life and real promise when clearly some are so firm on their view. good luck to all those that dont like the race maybe time will prove you right, maybe not and if not maybe some of you will change your mind - i cant believe i have wasted so much of my time - note to self - stop being a moron
|
|
By:
With Djakadam in the same ownership as Vautour I'd be extremely surprised if Vautour runs in the CGC as he clearly was running out of puff in the King George despite its non perfect jump at the last fence; I reckon the Ryanair or the Champion Chase beckons.
|
|
By:
I just can't have the CC as a viable alternative. They clearly think the horse stays... They've just run him in the KG and talk of him as a future GC horse. They have a crack two miler in the yard (albeit in a different ownership), they refused to take him on last year to win the more prestigious novice race. So while they have a Grade 1 race tailor made for the horse over 2m5f, why would they choose to take on speed merchants when the horse hasn't run over 2m for ages?
Seems inconceivable to me tbh. |
|
By:
CCM
Only ridiculous if you park up your sense of humour but the serious point is that great horses don't target the Ryanair. |
|
By:
Of course Vautour taking in the Champion isn't inconceivable. There's an old and very true adage that it often takes a horse which gets two and a half to emerge the best over two miles at that course in championship races. It's been proven so many times as to be incontrovertible to those of us who have followed the game for many years. Just trawl through the list of the winners of the top 2 mile races. Don't let Mullins the farmer muddy the water.
|
|
By:
miltons
I think you're confusing people questioning whether the cream should target the race and people not liking it. It's a fine race for horses in the low to mid 160's and can provide a very useful consolation prize for those not quite good enough to win the true championship races. |
|
By:
wow!! Can't believe this is still going on
![]() Next season will be worse You ain't seen nothing yet! What happens if UDS, Vautour, Djakadam somehow all win? Does Douvan, Shaneshill, Killultagh Vic all need to go to Aintree? Perhaps Willie Mullins wakes up one morning trying to figure just who exactly is the best, goes bonkers and they all go Ryanair or campaign for 2m2f, 2m6f, 3m ![]() |
|
By:
This is but the hors d'oeuvres which makes the main event all the greater. Where else do you get the back and forth of intelligent conversation about events still months away with none of us right until the actual event? It's almost as good as the event itself.
|
|
By:
sorry cause i get this is tedious - i am actually boring myself so forgive me - eternal - so in the ideal world you put a condition on the race so that horses rated say 165/170 or over could not enter. that way you keep a race you like but force the horses you want either to the cc or gc or out of cheltenham. Cant remember who it was that talked about people in racings less than favourable attitude to the ryanair - so if you and they are right racing would welcome such a move with open arms.
the thing is without a condition like that it becomes a free market and if the ryanair starts attracting better horses which imo it is starting to do it is because people in racing (I am not talking about mullins and vautour) are entering their horses whether you like it or not - i posted stuff about rr not running his horses together in the vain hope it might influence him - why dont you campaign for a rating ceiling on the ryanair in the vain hope it will influence somebody |
|
By:
I was joking in the latter but actually loving the passion on display here. As EO said, it's very rare to read a good debate anywhere especially on Cheltenham. MS, EO
![]() ![]() |
|
By:
In a parallel universe 10 trillion light years away there is a National Hunt Festival, the feature of which is the Universal Chase over 2.5 miles. It decides the Inter-Galactic Chaser of the year. All the best 2 mile chasers and 3 mile chasers converge at this classic, championship distance to fight for top honours. It is difficult to get form books, being as they're so far away..but think Arkle v Flyingbolt v Dunkirk v Mill House....Badsworth Boy against Burrough Hill Lad, Pearlyman and Dawn Run. How about Remittance Man and Viking Flagship versus Jodami and The Fellow? Kauto Star, Denman, Master Minded and Moscow Flyer? Or maybe Un De Sceaux, Sprinter Sacre, Cue Card and Vautour. Still think 2.5m is an Intermediate trip lads? Bit of a mish-mash hybrid? Sounds pretty tasty to me.
Unfortunately, back on Planet Earth, our forefathers missed this golden opportunity and we rarely, if it all, get to see these epic battles take place. But fear not! There is a new race in the programme that is steadily bedding in and might, one day, come close to giving us those stellar shootouts our alien friends have been enjoying for years. Unfortunately though...some clown decided to call it the Ryanair Chase ![]() |
|
By:
Sounds amazing as long as they dont upgrade the 3m budget-rocket chase to tempt good horses out of it ![]() |
|
By:
It's a shame the race in space has as daft a name as it has down here on earth......why don't they split those horses up in the inter-galactic cup to see which ones are the quickies and which ones are the stayers , they could call it the Gold Cup and Champion Chase.
|
|
By:
You don't like the sound of the Universal Chase and now you want horses being split up duffy?
Tough crowd ![]() |
|
By:
Not at all miltons. I respect the right of greedy trainers and owners to deprive racing enthusiasts, whose money keeps the sport going, of they want to watch in order to farm as many races as they can. That's their prerogative. As one of those enthusiasts I'm just pointing out that depriving people of what they want isn't really a recipe for growing a sport. In fact there are examples from other sports where the best don't take on the best thus depriving the sport of the oxygen of publicity and consequently the sport diminishes.
If you want to see the sport diminish and the top races farmed by super trawlers again that is your prerogative. Count me out. |
|
By:
Hi MS, it wouldnt need conditions, it would just need to be downgraded.
I understand if you think that unfairly penalises horses who 'fall between 2 and 3' or wastes their talent. fwiw i dont think any of this is tedious (but maybe that just means im tedious!) |
|
By:
EO. You really think 'racing enthusiasts' keep racing going?!
|
|
By:
I don't understand this downgrading business. Both the Mares Hurdle and Ryanair were Grade 2s that were promoted to G1s having passed the rigorous testing laid down and policed by the Jump Pattern Panel. It hasn't happened on a whim.
|
|
By:
I always assumed they were upgraded for money reasons but happy to be educated otherwise
|
|
By:
I'm just pointing out that depriving people of what they want
You're speaking for everyone again EO. It's not what I want. I think the Ryanair is an excellent addition and adds a lot to the Festival. |
|
By:
I always assumed they were upgraded for money reasons but happy to be educated otherwise
Nope. The only race I can recall being parachuted in to the Pattern cos of £££s was the Betfair Chase - and even then Haydock had to give up two Grade 2s to get there. If it was down to cash that abomination of a 100K Hurdle on the same card as the Betfair would be a Grade 2 rather than a lowly Class 2. If anyone's interested I can post how it works? It might take tedium to a new level though ![]() |
|
By:
Sounds like the Christmas ive always dreamed of!
Seriously I actually would be interested but it boils down to...'Could 'horseracing'/BHA/Clare Balding/someone get a race downgraded if they thought it was in the interests of the sport?'. Not that anyone here has remotely proved it is. |
|
By:
No CCM I'm definitely giving my own opinion. I appreciate, the force, eloquence and wit can sometimes carry all before me but I can assure you that is as much curse as it is blessing.
![]() Of course I respect your right to choose not to see the best take on the best. That's your prerogative. However, for those with a sense of the romance of sport I ask, rhetorically of course, what would sport have been without Ali/Frazier, Borg/Supermac, Botham/Lillie, Moore/Pele, and all the rest? There's a simple recipe. Find ot what the fans crave and give it to them. Great horses farming big prizes against three runner fields doesn't set anybody's pulse racing. We saw it today. The Challow hurdle. A fixture in the Christmas programme with four runners. The four runner novice in Ireland with three of the runners owned by the same owner. It's simply not good enough and it isn't even that big a problem. I could fix it tomorrow. However, I digress. I want to see the best face off against the best I appreciate 2 miles to gold cup is a leap. 2 miles 5 isn't and what else will get people enthused ore than the question which would be on many racing enthusiasts lips more than will Vautour get home? |
|
By:
On the issue of the Ryanair adding to the festival I'm ambivalent about that. Thursday is for the course's and bookies benefit and the meeting has been diminished by that added day in my opinion. Of course if your idea of a championship is a load of additional handicaps then I'd imagine you do enjoy it.
|
|
By:
Whats wrong with handicaps?? gets the brain working and nice price winners are a regular thing.
Seems fine to me. |
|
By:
Ryanair gives us another Grade 1 to watch, and normally serves up a thrilling finish.
That seems fine to me as well. Sure connections of horses that appreciate a championship race at the "middle distance" think it fine also. |
|
By:
EO. You really think 'racing enthusiasts' keep racing going?!
For sure CCM. I'm no elitist. The ten bob or ten pound flutterer is as much an enthusiast in my opinion as the super rich Ricci's and collectively the punter has put billions more into the game over the years than even the most keen owner. Without the punter you've got little more than the old days of toffs racing for match bets away from the pblic gaze. No huge prize money. No fancy courses. No bookies. Probably a tenth of the stables. No TV. Somewhere along the line they forgot to crown the true kings of the sport and also forgot what it is they want. |
|
By:
I'm not saying there is anything wrong with handicaps Budd. We have them every day of the year. I for one don't want a championship event diluted by too many of them. This is a curse which I feel Punchestown suffers from which could easily be an event in itself to rival at least Aintree if they got rid of the amount of poor quality races.
|