Forums

Bloodstock & Breeding

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
Slick'N'Smooth
10 Dec 08 16:48
Joined:
Date Joined: 08 Dec 08
| Topic/replies: 167 | Blogger: Slick'N'Smooth's blog
I would be interested to hear peoples opinions on this horse. I did ask on my other topic but we got a bit sidetracked!

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 1 of 10  •  Previous 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 10 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 370
By:
Docofthebay
When: 10 Dec 08 18:27
Lol, yes!

Well he was a very hard-knocking and very good racehorse. He also was a tremendous specimen, who deserved better than the patronage he's had at stud, his books have lacked quantity, and severely lacked quality.
By:
Slick'N'Smooth
When: 10 Dec 08 19:49
This is something we agree on Doc!

He is a horse that I feel has had to do everything the hard way. He was a good 2yo but had the misfortune to be born in the same years as Rock of Gibraltar, Landseer and most of all Johanesburg. Any one of those in a year would be something but to come up against all 3......! He would have won the Coventry but for jumping the road, Dettori got him disq from 4th in the French 2000 and Godolphin repeatdley ran him over the wrong distances and avoided their other horses. And all because he is by the 'wrong' stallion and out of an old mare.

And still, now he is at stud (which Darley took so long to decied where he was going he missed all the stallion books) but again he is overlooked. He is exactky the type of horse people need to use, tough, sound and totallly genuine. Not only that but he represents an outcross with Sadlers Wells (and therefore ND) only appearing as Charnwood Forest's broodmare sire. Some breeders are rapidly painting themselves into a corner with their Danzig/Danehill/Sadlers Wells/Galileo and Darshaan horses.

As you may have guessed this horse was something of a favourite! I haven't seen him in the flesh since once in his 2yo days, but I have heard many comments about how nice he is.Fopr me I feel he is a 'forgotten' horse. I hope he is Champion First Season sire, though I wouldn't take a bet on it...........but he has done everything the hard way so far
By:
Young Broodmare Filly Wanted
When: 10 Dec 08 19:59
Evening

I had Firebreak on my list this year, but i have back heeled due to inbreeding with Warning as i have a mare by Fraam out of a Piccolo mare and feel this is to close.

I have viewed him at stud and is a lovely horse but on the small side, so would not send a small mare to him.
By:
Slick'N'Smooth
When: 10 Dec 08 20:15
For me personally the fact that Warning already appears in the pedigree would be a PLUS not a negitive! Esp as it is not in the first 3 gens of the foal. You would have to take into account the mares conformation (and that of any previous foals) as Warning is known for dodgy front limbs, but if she were mine and straight in front then I would go for it.

A case in point this year, I was very keen on a mare ( and prob would have bought her had she been OK physically) but she was withdrawn. Lot 2614 at Tatts Dec would have been bought for the sole reason to send to Firebreak. She was by Bishop Of Cashel (not wildly commercial, but bred on the same Warning/Sadlers Wells mare, cross as Charnwood Forest) and out of a mare by Song (as is Firebreak's dam) The resulting foal would represent a very interesting 4x4 Warning, 4x4 Song and 5x5 Sadlers Wells all three good racehorses i'm sure you would agree!

I have added this hypothetical mating to Pedigree Query under the name of Embers11 if you want to see the linebreeding. I will delete it tomorrow.
By:
Young Broodmare Filly Wanted
When: 10 Dec 08 20:42
I was thinking it would be too close in the generations. I like the idea of inbreeding to Warning and the cross works well with my fraam mare.

My mare is fine and retired sound at 5, winning 8 races. Her confirmation is fine.

I do not know how to use the hypathetical mating website you mentioned.
By:
Slick'N'Smooth
When: 10 Dec 08 20:45
What is your mare's name? I can do the pedigree and post a link for you to copy and paste.
By:
Young Broodmare Filly Wanted
When: 10 Dec 08 20:49
magical music

I have never used these methods for research.

Have you enquired about Firebreak?
By:
Slick'N'Smooth
When: 10 Dec 08 21:05
http://www.pedigreequery.com/fire+magic4

this is the link to the fictional pedigree. The linebreeding is shown by the blocks of colour, you can see that it is not excessive or close linebreeding.

This is the fictional pedigree of the Bishop of Cashel mare I mentioned above

http://www.pedigreequery.com/embers11
By:
Young Broodmare Filly Wanted
When: 10 Dec 08 21:12
Cheers, sounds like he is back in on my list. Especially with free return with filly foal.

PS one of my other mares is in foal to Misu Bond. Nice looking horse and like you have a decent mare i do not want to spend big bucks with stallion fees.
By:
Young Broodmare Filly Wanted
When: 10 Dec 08 21:15
just a glimmer is by far more inbred than my possible foal.

My only drawback as mentioned on another post is that he has not had the best mares
By:
Slick'N'Smooth
When: 10 Dec 08 21:24
Although Firebreak has not had great mares, no stallion in the low fee category would have. However his foals and yearlings have sold well and Bearstone will probably race some by him. He has as good a chance as any to make it.

I thought Misu Bond was a good looking horse, a typical Danehill Dancer.Andrew Spalding is a decent guy to deal with as well.I did enquire about Firebreak but I got a better deal with Misu Bond and the Danehill Dancer/Kahyasi cross works well and is current. Head over heart!
By:
Young Broodmare Filly Wanted
When: 10 Dec 08 21:43
I have used Andrews stallions a number of times.

My heart is saying Firebreak for my Fraam mare. I will use Misu Bond again with the same mare i have in foal now as long as decent foal
By:
Slick'N'Smooth
When: 11 Dec 08 07:14
I wish you the best of luck.
By:
dominion
When: 12 Dec 08 16:58
Dear Mr Slick - I have a colt foal by Firebreak and he is a cracker.Close coupled,good limbs and a lovelly temperament.He looks a sprinter in the making.Would not hesitate to go back to Firebreak,especially if his first crop f two year olds run well next year.Was concerned about the stamina influence of Charnwood Forest so close up,but so far doesn't appear to becoming through.Pedigreequery informs me that I have multiple influences of Lady Juror in my colts genetic profile,based on the mares breeding-so I am doubly delighted.You seem to know more about this horse than Bearstone- I would be keen to hear more on your opinion of Firebreak.
By:
Slick'N'Smooth
When: 12 Dec 08 19:18
I do have an interest in Firebreak, he is a horse I have followed closely from the beginning. I am vaguely familar with the family and in actual fact looked at Firebreak as a yearling ( and was in the ring when he made 525,000 at HIT). Speaking to Emma Balding, she said that the syndicate that owned him, Kennet Valley, were sorry to lose him but it was thier policy to sell 2yos. Some of them tried to form a seperate syndicate to buy him but they couldn't compete with the Maktoum buying power. There is a theory that says that Godolphin bought him so as not to be against him in his races as a 3yo. How true this is I don't know.Another point that isn't generally known is that he was the yardstick at Goldolphin for their top horses. He had (in Sam Bullards own words) a 'race every week at home. If the horse could beat or match Firebreak, it was in with a good chance.' All this and still competing at Gr 1 level on the track. But for Darley he had no end value as a stallion,(being by Charnwood Forrest) so he was easily pushed aside to make way for more 'commercial' horses even if he was better.

As far as I am aware the family is a straight correct family.I looked a a Librettist colt this year at the foal sale out of Firebreak's Fantastic Light half sister and he was a nice, if a bit small, strong and correct colt. I was not keen on the sire though so he had to be a no. But this is another horse I shall follow with interest. I have heard time and again what a lovely temprement Firebreak has. The Stud Groom who had him as a yearling told me the horse had never put a foot wrong and was the easiest to deal with.

I really do feel this horse has been so wrongly overlooked for all his good qualities, and hope he can prove people wrong with his 2yos next year. Bearstone seem to be a bit lax on promoting him, with no updated pictures of his progeny on thier site from his first foals last year. And in fact they have not updated the poor picture they use of him.There has been very little in the Racing Post sales features about him having a foal and yearling average more than 3x his advertised fee, and in fact last year his foal average was 4x his fee. (sales stats courtesy of RP website so any errors are theirs!) There was no mention of him in the Horse and Hound stallion issue. Even when he was racing and after his many Group wins, there was never a Tony Morris pedigree analysis despite him having a more unusual pedigree.Not even his breeder won the Small Breeder of the month award from the TBA despite , I believe, only having a few mares at the time. He is almost an invisble horse.Sometimes I almost feel like taking out a full page ad in the Racing Post myself for him. Though I must stress I have absoultley NO financial interest in this horse at all, just a bit of a fan. I wish I had a mare for him myself,but sadly none of mine are suitable for him. As I have said above I would have purchased the Bishop of Cashel mare just to send to him.

I really do wish you all the best of luck with your Firebreak progeny, if they are anything at all like their sire they will be tough, genuine, sound and fast!
By:
Slick'N'Smooth
When: 12 Dec 08 19:23
BTW it's Mrs Slick'N'Smooth!
By:
dominion
When: 13 Dec 08 09:06
Dear Mrs Slick,an incredibly detailed answer -brilliant.Mismanagement of their breeding stock is a common criticism levelled at Godolphin,so I am not surprised to hear you express it again.His career might have been better served had he stayed at Andrew Baldings.All that aside,I am delighted with our fellow,even more now after your hearing your comments.Lets hope he can get a nice two year old next year.PS I dont suppose you would know where I could see some of his races ?
By:
Slick'N'Smooth
When: 13 Dec 08 10:17
Again Firebreak is overlooked! I can't find any video clips of him on You Tube. There used to be a rather low quality clip of him winning at Beverly early in his 2yo seaon, but I can't find it now. Do Bearstone not have a promotional DVD?

It is probably on top shelf at the back of a cupboard covered in dust if they have!
By:
hOOd
When: 13 Dec 08 11:05
I think a lot of GB races were deleted from Youtube over rights issue

Firebreaks HK Mile win is still on the HKJC website.....

http://www.hkjc.com/english/racing/results.asp?racedate=12/12/2004&raceno=7&venue=ST
By:
dominion
When: 13 Dec 08 12:17
Many thanks H.If Bearstone have a DVD featuring him , I have not seen it.As you alluded to earlier on Mrs S,they have been very weak in the promoting of him.Shame.Maybe we should form a syndicate and promote him ourselves.Neither Darley nor Bearstone seem over enthusiastic.
By:
Young Broodmare Filly Wanted
When: 13 Dec 08 16:08
I was given a DVD of his performances when i first viewed him. I agree though Bearstone have not promoted him well.

Does anyone know which trainers have them for next year?
By:
Slick'N'Smooth
When: 13 Dec 08 18:27
Yes thanks for that link.

Andrew Balding has at least two and so does Ann Duffield.Emma Balding told me that Andrew was very pleased with theirs and they are nice sorts with the right attitude.
By:
Slick'N'Smooth
When: 23 Mar 09 22:36
Some early entries now appearing for Firebreak inc two in the Brocklesby. Pat Eddery has a very nice colt, and one each for Kevin Ryan and Bryan Smart
By:
antoine doinel
When: 23 Mar 09 23:13
For colt read**
By:
antoine doinel
When: 23 Mar 09 23:14
Perverts
By:
ben10
When: 23 Mar 09 23:19
I noticed that Slick, quite like the Eddery one for the weekend, providing it survives the ballot.
By:
jbarnes (no not him)
When: 24 Mar 09 08:31
how are you dom?


atb
By:
Young Broodmare Filly Wanted
When: 25 Mar 09 19:55
I noticed them too, i have my fingers for good season as my mare travels down to him in the next week or so.
By:
Benkers
When: 25 Mar 09 23:29
Shame you chose Firebreak YBFW.....doesnt suit your mare on any level...too many sons of stallions in the mating to be successful...and your mare already returns the strains that Firebreak has....just not going to be effective...hopefully produce a runner for you, but certainly nothing of note...but good luck
By:
Young Broodmare Filly Wanted
When: 25 Mar 09 23:55
I do not understand your comment sons of stallions, can you explain.
By:
Slick'N'Smooth
When: 26 Mar 09 06:30
Benkers,
Firebreak was a fast,early,tough, sound and geniune racehorse. He is the best son of his well bred sire, who was by a useful influence of precosity and speed and out of a mare form a top producing family by a very good broodmare sire. Firebreak's dam was also early and a minor black type mare who has produced other minor black type horses from deciedely moderate coverrings.

He is a smallish,neat and correct good looking horse, who, from the stock I've seen gets nice correct,racy sorts.

YBFW's mare is I think by Fraam out of a Piccolo mare. With another cross to Warning, I **uld hope to increase my chance of an early fast 2yo. I can't believe that anyone would think that Fraam is such a high class broodmare sire that you are likely to breed a champion from a covering in the mares price bracket. I would think that some good wins and perhaps a black type placing would not be unexpected though.

All stallions are the sons of the same number of stallions, whether those are multiple champions or selling platers, so I don't really see your point, I will assume you have omitted some words in that sentance.

After all this I suppose YBFW could send his mare to the wildly commercial stallion you suggested in another thread Benkers. Perhaps First Trump is the son of the right number of stallions for you...................
By:
Benkers
When: 26 Mar 09 08:05
I like Firebreak, one of my favourite horse on the track when he was around...but he doesnt suit Magical Music on any level. You cant breed good horses like this mating will produce.

Id like to know why you think breeding back strains that the mare already has, Warning included, will produce a black type placed animal, especially through sons...

ill remind you of Domino....and if you know your breeding, you'll know why and how this horse is important in breeding.

Each to there own and racing and breeding is after all about opinions...to a degree.
By:
Benkers
When: 26 Mar 09 08:18
To explain.....Magical Musics 2nd dam is by a SON of Warning in Piccolo...through the Firebreak mating, you are breeding back in a son of Warning in Charnwood Forest.

Magical Music herself is actually well bred in terms of structure, she has full brothers Alycidon and Acropolis....one through a son in Alcibiades and the other through a daughter...Fab, her 3rd dam. There are 3 daughter strains of Big Game.

Breeding daughter strains is not a bad thing, since they only carry the x chromosome, only passed on through daughters....something that cant be passed on by sons. But it doesnt tell the whole story.

There are lines in every pedigree that when reintroduced via other siblings enhance the pedigree. This mating to Firebreak doesnt do this.

But good luck with her anyway
By:
turnturtle
When: 26 Mar 09 11:16
Did I understand you correctly? You think that sires cannot pass on the X chromosome????? Why do people find basc Mendelian genetics so hard to grasp?
By:
dominion
When: 26 Mar 09 11:20
Mr Barnes.It has been a long time.Agg. seems to have disappeared.Shame liked that horse.My own horse has been running well,despite several high profile jockeys not riding like high profile jockeys.Mrs Slick - glad to see you are still flying the flag for Firebreak.Our one has improved again over the winter.Absolutely nothing wrong with him.Like a lot of people on this thread,I am praying his two year olds perform well.Watched his win in HK - what a gutsey horse.
By:
Benkers
When: 26 Mar 09 12:22
Yeah sorry, it was early for me...i meant that dams carry an extra x chromosome and that a stallion can only pass his x chromosome to his daughters. So the chances of a dam passing her dominant gene is always 50/50..

and before slick gets on her donkey, when i said you cant mate sons of stallions in the pedigree, there are obviously good horses that have this, Northern Dancer appears everywhere through sons, but there has to be other factors that override this and where as i am happy to breed to sons of stallions, i have to have other strains to reintroduce...look at Youmzain, Sir Percy...and even Danzig.
By:
Slick'N'Smooth
When: 26 Mar 09 19:39
Benkers, There are no donkeys on my stud; so whilst I may at times get on my high horse, I will never get on my donkey, high or otherwise!

YBFW is breeding to sell, therefore his main consideration IMHO should be how commercial a mating is, not how many 'strains' or 'sons of stallions' there are. As with some adivice you gave on another thread, it may have been correct to the Nth degree re strains etc (I couldn't tell you as I did no research) the choice of First Trump was laughable form a commercial point of view.

The belief in, or doubts, over linebreeding/inbreeding/strains etc are largely personal and tend to be affected by past personal experience. Remember the old adage, 'if it works it's linebreeding, if it doesn't it's inbreeding' But your reasoning above is IMO slightly confused, either sons of stallions cannot be relied upon to pass on genes to a greater or lesser extent when appearing multiple times, in which case then it will have little effect on the progeny so wheres the harm; or it can be a benefit, and so where is the problem in trying? Breeding is a massive gamble anyway (even with a professors expertise in genetics) so why not try and create a nick? You mentioned on your previous post that 'if I knew anything about breeding, I would know about Domino and his impact' well I hold my hands up and confess I have no idea what you are talking about, but I like to think I know a little about breeding racehorses as I have bred many listed horses, several Group horses , a Classic placed horse, and a Group 1 winner. If you enlighten me about Domino then maybe I could breed a few more! BTW all of these were commercially bred with fashion first and foremost in my mind.

YBFW original point to me was that he wanted to use Firebreak but was put off by Warning already appearing on his mares page. I merely said that IMO this would be a benefit NOT a negative. I did not suggest Firebreak as the ideal stallion for his mare, but if he is looking for a cheap, fast precocious sire then he can't go too far wrong. Also unusually for a Warning line horse he is 100% straight and correct.

It would be a shame if this thread about a very tough and worthy horse got sidetracked by nit-picking and name calling.
By:
jbarnes (no not him)
When: 26 Mar 09 21:34
nice to see u post dom

which is your horse now?

atb
By:
Young Broodmare Filly Wanted
When: 26 Mar 09 22:33
well a few differing opinions. Me, i'm happy with my selection using my own methods and ideas.

Like the idea of the inbreeding to Warning as nick with Fraam works well so why not repeat?

Firebreak - 2 year group winner that continued winning at group level until retirement.

Form on differing surfaces, as my mares best results are all weather.

Firebreak won up to a mile again suiting my mares wining distances.

Fee value and market sales

I really liked the stallion when initially viewed for another mare.

Fraam as a broodmare seems to get gritty runners 13% winners to runner in 2008 with 57% wins to runners and good start to 2009. No big winner but only 54 runners last year according to RP. Lucky Leigh (Piccolo) 4th in Group 2, top performer.
Page 1 of 10  •  Previous 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 10 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com