Forums

Cheltenham Festival

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 220 comments are related to the topic:
2017 gold cup you decide.

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 3 of 6  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 220
By:
wellchief
When: 31 Jan 17 17:44
Interesting Shockster.

I think there are a lot in there who are not likely to improve on their rating - like Cue Card, Djakadam, Road to Riches, Don Poli.  I think there are some who are probably not good enough, like Alary, Taquin, Irish Cavilier, T42, Minella Rocco, More of That, Zabana and Blacklion.

That narrows down my shortlist to Thistlecrack, Native River, Bristol de Mai, Champagne West and Outlander.  I couldn't back Thistlecrack after his last run and his odds, I think Native River will pay the price for his very hard season come March, which leaves Bristol de Mai, Champagne West and Outlander at the prices vs the field.

There's usually one that outruns their price, and it might well be that Djakadam or Cue Card only need to run to their mark to win, but I'll take those three improvers that I mentioned above.
By:
shockster
When: 31 Jan 17 19:57
If I had to back one to save my life then I'd definitely back Thistlecrack. I don't accept any argument that says he doesn't stay. However, at the prices I'm happy to leave him.  I have previously backed Zabana and think he will be better on good ground but his price is right.  I have added Minella Rocco 33/1 on the back of the Many Clouds form and unbelievably I took a chance on Champagne West after the entries came out and I'm on here at a big price which I will be cashing in to some extent, but do think he has an engine and is a live EW shout.  If it looks like going proper soft then I'll add Bristol to my list, but only on soft.
By:
dunlaying
When: 02 Feb 17 14:21
For betting purposes only , my shortlist is down to Cue Card , Djakadam and Champagne West.
The last named is fine if you are on at big prices. He still has a question mark over his jumping and could yet go for The Ryanair.
Imagine the roar if Cue Card and Thistlecrack were to meet the last fence together.
By:
impossible123
When: 09 Feb 17 15:08
Cue Card is weak: loads on offer at 11 here.
By:
impossible123
When: 09 Feb 17 15:55
False alarm - only bots at work.
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 09 Feb 17 19:27
Them rancid bots

Should be banned!!
By:
impossible123
When: 10 Feb 17 15:44
Could be a very contrasting weekend to several Gold Cup probables who are running in Britain and Ireland; one or two could increase their prominence in the betting, others possibly disappear all together.

Cue Card is a probable in the Ascot Chase next weekend over 2m 5f.
By:
Desmond Orchard
When: 10 Feb 17 15:53
Searing insight, as per.......
By:
buddeliea
When: 10 Feb 17 16:53
Hoping Bristol de mai will run another good race,got his ground so no excuses.
Should at least know if hes a player or not.
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 10 Feb 17 18:02
Having Native River majorly in my gold cup book i'm obviously hoping he dots up tomorrow and handsomely beats BDM however i am fairly wary of BDM tomorrow, if they finish hard pressing each other up the run i would definitely fancy BDM to win, it wouldn't make me think oh no i'm on the wrong horse in the CGC merely that the excuse that BDM had his optimum trip and NR is better over further would be in my head. Ok only 3 furlongs but that's like from half way down the hill with one fence and the uphill finish still to run/jump in the gold cup so would still fancy NR in a gold cup over BDM but who knows early days yet

Think tomorrows race is going to be a fascinating watch
By:
buddeliea
When: 10 Feb 17 18:08
Yes mate,intriguing race.
Can see your points re Gold Cup trip,NR could well be more suited to it than BDM.
I do think BDM could well be the classier of the two, but he has to stay well to win the Gold Cup....we know NR does.
By:
the bloob
When: 10 Feb 17 20:19
I can see Native River getting beaten tomorrow, I think Native River is overrated and conditions will really suit BdM tomorrow
By:
deepingfox
When: 10 Feb 17 21:32
EMPIRE OF DIRT to win Gold Cup 1 this weekend, and shrink to 8/1 for Chelters.
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 11 Feb 17 14:34
I think we have just seen the gold cup winner there just pray they all get there safe and sound now

Native River Love
By:
duffy
When: 11 Feb 17 14:42
Certainly liked the way he powered up the run in.
By:
jasey
When: 11 Feb 17 14:48
Native should be clear fav for the Gold Cup.I can't see how Thistlecrack can beat him.
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 11 Feb 17 14:51
I'm in balls deep at 8s was raving about him even after Thistlecrack won the KG, korals are a stand out 11/2 can't say am not tempted to go in again Crazy
By:
impossible123
When: 11 Feb 17 14:55
I think up the Cheltenham hill finish Native River would be the one to be on should Thistlecrack come upside or infront after the last; the former would be the last horse in the race Thistlecrack would like to be fighting against up the hill.
By:
jasey
When: 11 Feb 17 14:56
I think BDM just showed he is a tad overrated and that there are hcaps that we should take notice of and ones that we shouldn't.
By:
jasey
When: 11 Feb 17 14:59
I think NR Rocco and maybe Outlander winner comes from one of those and I could see the Polinator placing again.
By:
duffy
When: 11 Feb 17 15:22
Thistlecrack connections are going to have to commit to their horse staying and be positive, they will have to attempt to take NR out of his comfort zone earlier in the race and get him going a stride or two quicker than he likes, this will hurt him at the end.

If they allow him to set his own pace it will be bad news. Smad Place in the Hennessy compared to what SP had to do in the KG last year are good examples.

If Thistlecrack is the real classy horse that many think then he has to kill the opposition during the race like proper Grade 1 performers do.
By:
impossible123
When: 11 Feb 17 15:25
I do not rate the Irish ones given Ruby's injudicious ride on Djakadam in the Lexus; I think the finish will be fought between the English ones with Djakadam (best of the Irish) filling a place once again.

BDM did not seem to jump as well here as he did in the Peter Marsh Chase. Maybe with hindsight, he'd have been better ridden from the front - he just did not seem to be as interested when behind the other two runners for some reason.
By:
wellchief
When: 11 Feb 17 16:39
I don't think that was BDM's running, but hard to see him reversing with NR if they meet again anyway.

NR was impressive - Le Mercurey would have been a little too close for my liking if I had backed him big for the Gold Cup, but in these small runner fields with muddling tactics, sometimes distances don't matter too much.

The way he powered clear after the last was impressive though.
By:
impossible123
When: 11 Feb 17 17:07
Maybe it was a little too soon post the Betfair Chase for BDM.
By:
maelduin
When: 11 Feb 17 17:36
I think BDM will be heading for the Ryanair. Not a bad e/w bet @ 12/1 NRNB with PP.
By:
the bloob
When: 11 Feb 17 20:14
it appears that Bristol de Mai's win at Haydock was a one-off, it seems that both his best runs have been at that track and he is nothing more than a respectable horse elsewhere.

on that basis I wouldn't read too much into Native River's win today, just look at the proximity to Le Mercurey. The one thing in Native River's favour is the fact that he's a proper stayer, I just don't think he's good enough to beat the other main contenders
By:
buddeliea
When: 11 Feb 17 21:55
Well I won't be tearing up my BDM slip just yet as I still think that he repeats his jumping at Haydock in the Gold cup he's a big player.however jps like he did today he has no chance.
By:
ReaseHeath
When: 11 Feb 17 22:06
just an idle thought: Le Mercurey is n't in the Gold Cup but was beaten 3.25 lengths today by Native River receiving 1lb and 3.5 lengths at Aintree in December by Many Clouds getting 5lbs.

I can see a typical Nicholls plan forming to try and mug opponents still feeling the effects of their Gold Cup exertions in the Betfair Bowl at Aintree.
By:
cyclops
When: 12 Feb 17 00:03
Not sure NR did anything today other than confirm he's still in good form. Le Mercurey, guys?????
Lacks the class to win a good Gold Cup, but this year's may well be highly moderate. Wouldn't have the class of a Djakadam (on all form so far) though Djakadam seems to have been under par since last year's Gold Cup.
By:
buddeliea
When: 12 Feb 17 06:04
So is Thistlecrack gonna be done by his stable mate?
Seemed to me that Thistle was much happier bowling along at Kempton than he was in behind at Cheltenham.
So can Thistle be in front of his mate in the Gold Cup?
I cant see it myself, and if that is the case, are his chances of winning the Gold Cup scuppered by his mate?

One thing for sure, I wish I had spotted NR at the start of the season,never had him in mind at all.
He looks the likeliest winner for me,not cos of yesterday so much,but cos he is more suited to the extra distance than a lot of these,and obviously has more class and speed than I thought.
In fact to me he has everything a Gold Cup winner needs.
By:
maelduin
When: 12 Feb 17 11:43
Native River typifies everything you need to win a GC - he jumps for fun, bowls along in front and stays all day. In fact you really couldn't find a better horse to expose Thistlecracks weaknesses. I've thrown sentiment (+ a few Ante-post Thistlecrack vouchers) out the window and lumped on NR @ 9/2. GL
By:
impossible123
When: 12 Feb 17 14:17
I think Native River at 9/2 (nrnb) is good value given all his attributes. And since the Cotswold the Gold Cup race will not be run at a crawl and Native River must be the horse connections of Thistlecrack most feared even on good ground.
By:
FOYLESWAR
When: 12 Feb 17 14:24
if they feared native river then what about minella rocco who thrashed native river last season over 4 miles last season at the festival ? he may not line up but 20/1 non runner no bet looks attractive to me and you have the insurance .
By:
impossible123
When: 12 Feb 17 14:30
The GC is over 3.25m; if 4m Minella Rocco is a good bet (nrnb) or ground very soft/heavy.
By:
The Sawyer
When: 12 Feb 17 19:53
Imposs123

"And since the Cotswold the Gold Cup race will not be run at a crawl"

Not sure I understand - are you saying the Cotswold was run at a crawl?
By:
impossible123
When: 12 Feb 17 20:43
Sorry, what I meant was the pace in the impending Gold Cup would ensure Thistlecrack's stamina be stretched to the limit ie they could be going like the clappers from the start - very fast.
By:
ZenMaster
When: 13 Feb 17 09:45
I don't see any form that justifies Native River being the one to beat in the Gold Cup and i think that he is a false price.

He was off the bridle a long way out in the Hennessy against 150 types and was all out to hold on from Carole's Destrier with only 5lb more in his back.
In the Welsh National he was giving 17lb to a 139 rated 11 year old.
Then he beats Le Mercurey 151 in a 3 runner race. Bristol De Mai is obviously a one trick(Haydock) horse and is only a 150 rated animal anywhere else.

Native River is the horse that was outpaced in the 4 miler at the festival last year on good/soft. So given the chances of it being good/soft again on Gold Cup day what are the chances of him being outpaced again. The Hennessy was on good/soft ground and he was struggling to get away from 150 rated animals.

If it comes up soft he has less chance of getting outpaced but surely on good/soft even a less than fluent jumping Thistlecrack will be dancing all over him, and those suggesting Native River will set a searching gallop on good to soft are living in la la land, Native River will be scrubbed along from 3 miles as Tom Scu takes a tug.

People seem hung up on the Cotswald race on sticky ground due to the covers being on, not easy to jump out of and not easy to accelerate through. The Gold Cup will be on much better ground.
By:
impossible123
When: 13 Feb 17 13:45
Native River has improved with every run certainly from last season thus unwise to rate him on that. Also of the main protagonists eg Cue Card and Djakadam, the former whose stamina Gold Cup distance could be in question too despite his going well before tipping-up, and the latter has had two attempts already but ran out of it on both occasions, again, his stamina could be suspect too.

I must admit I was one of those not impressed with Native River in the Hennessy but one cannot be but impressed at the weekend where not only did he make the running he was able to quicken when it mattered; Le Mercurey was going well too but just could not pick-up when it mattered.

As for the Irish contingent I'm not impressed and I do not anticipate the winner of the Gold Cup coming from them. If Cue Card stays 3.25m he'll give a very good account of himself and show his King George run was below par due to his early exertions trying to match Thistlecrack.

It would be an irony if Mullins/Ricci/Ruby win the race with Djakadam given their recent high profile absentees ie in racing, one minute down, the next up!
By:
ZenMaster
When: 13 Feb 17 14:42
Le Mercurey has not finished a race off all season, i doubt very much Native River quickened at all but was the only one who actually finished the race and stayed on well.

He dictated the race against a horse that can't finish a race and another that was never put into the race, made a mistake 2 out and found zilch.

The ground for the Gold Cup will be similar to what Nativer River ran on in the Hennessy when he was struggling to get away from those 150 rated plodders.
Yes he is on an upward curve but he will still get badly outpaced on good to soft ground in the Gold Cup.
By:
duffy
When: 13 Feb 17 14:44
Zen ...we get it, you're a Thistlecrack fanWink
Page 3 of 6  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com