|
By:
I remember trying to figure out how Long Run lost his crown in 2012, he won the King George and then ran a fine race in Gold Cup but was beaten by the previous seasons RSA Winner Bobs Worth. Always an improving horse coming along.
|
|
By:
I think a young Bobs Worth was different gravy to anything challenging Conti this year though to be fair.
He was a dual festival winner who'd won a Hennessey off 160 - 9lbs higher than what Many Clouds did. A young Bob's would be better than Conti imo. Re: Lord Windermere's RSA win, I think we'll have to agree to disagree. I know they've won the races you mention, but I just don't look down that list and see quality or consistency, although to be fair looking at the beaten horses in four or five of the most recent runnings doesn't scream that either. |
|
By:
I would be fearful of all three but the horse I cannot get away from is Silviniaco Conti - a proven Grade 1 performer at this level. He's been running in Grade 1 company for 5 years and to me is tougher and classier than all else that will oppose him. I think he's reliable too - he jumps, he stays and he quickens. I could not ask for anymore.
I'm coming at this from the same angle as you SYT. It's Conti's consistency and reliability that stands him apart for me. Every race he has had from November 2011 has been a Grade 1 or 2 chase, winning 9 out 16, and two of those defeats have been on his season reappearance when he has needed the run - he's a solid as they come. There are horses behind him in the betting like Lord Windermere, On His Own, Boston Bob, Giant Bolster, Sam Winner, Holywell etc and they are all extremely inconsistent, so I don't know how anyone could back one of them with any degree of confidence. It showed in last years race that any horse can be beaten on any given day, and even the most unlikeliest outcome can happen, but I'd rather side with the one where you know, barring accidents, will be in the mix jumping the last. Road to Riches and Many Clouds are serious threats, but the rest, they could run against each other ten times, and have a different winner each time. That's not being disrespectful to them, I just don't think they're as good as SC, RTR or MC. |
|
By:
IMO in last years race both SC and BW started racing a lot earlier than they did in any of the previous gold cups they have ever run in and just got tired late on and allowed 2 solid stayers with no gears but a relentless gallop to run past them on that last climb to the line.
SC fell on his first try at it and ok i admit a bit far out to know for sure, but he was travelling mightily well when coming down and had Ruby Walsh on board that day too, a true master at race riding pace etc. I am on the side of the fence that says SC would have won that race if staying on his feet and jumping well throughout so for me he is a better horse than BW, something that has been proven in each of the races they have met in since including last years gold cup. Fwiw thats how i see it anyways. I am not a fan of returning gold cup horses that have been beat in it before which is why I think the most likely winner is an improving horse, RTR perhaps but certainly would not right off any that have tried before. A complete U-Turn there from my early season thoughts but we now have a little more evidence to go on |
|
By:
You can look at the consistency/inconsistency issue at it from various ways to suit an individual argument, for instance you could say that conti consistently gets beat at Cheltenham through one reason or another...also you could argue that holywell is inconsistent as a whole but when it comes to the festivals in the spring on good ground he is consistent with 3 wins in the past two seasons.
I like him as you can guess and he's a proper stayer, he made a couple of mistakes at the festival last year but was immediately back in position and loved the hill, now, he is one that is sure to get home and does love the likely ground,I've no problem completely dismissing what happens through the winter as we've had evidence of what he can do in the spring on better ground....his Aintree win was even more impressive, whether those in behind ran their race, you'd have thought one or two did and he was coming off the back of a tough race himself remember but he still hammered them in a grade 1, If you consider what MC and DC have done this season it looks all the more impressive, you just can't dismiss the race as an end of season race and unreliable, it was a festival grade 1 and he was running loose on the run-in, incidently it provides a good example of the ground issue/time of year issue MC could face in March when you consider what he did to Holywell earlier this season compared to spring and better ground... obviously his jumping is an issue but you have to have a worry about something...as they all have in this race. |
|
By:
Well this consistency thing can be looked at with the price in mind.
Those you mentioned Chief,aside from holywell,are all decent prices and can all be backed in case they run their race.And imo they are all e/w chances. Yes,as you say Conti should be in the mix,hes ultra consistent,fair enough,but at his price right now you would want at least that,and to me given all the evidence thus far I really think there are at least 2,maybe more,that are more likely to win a Gold Cup. So I simply cannot back him. Of course he may prove me wrong,hes certainly got some class. |
|
By:
You're all wrong, he's gonna win, I guarantee it.....only joking. I can understand both sides of the argument to be honest. Maybe my heart is ruling my head and he shouldn't be such a short price, but I'd love to see him win, thinks he deserves a Gold Cup.
|
|
By:
Silvi is the best horse in the race but we are having to factor in 2 unlucky runs in the race and no wins at the track so at the price he is to be avoided.
|
|
By:
So much for HOUBLON DES OBEAUX going straight to the Gold Cup?
Houblon Des Obeaux is on target for the Denman Chase at Newbury next weekend. Second in the Hennessy to Many Clouds when trying to give the subsequent Cheltenham winner 6lb, he then chased home the rapid improver The Young Master at Ascot, giving him 17lb. Trainer Venetia Williams will now give him a chance up in grade before another possible crack at the Cheltenham Gold Cup. "He's very well and goes to Newbury for the Denman Chase," said Williams. "He's won some good races but has paid for it in the handicap. "We'll see how he gets on. It will obviously be very competitive with everyone heading to Cheltenham after it and all being well, so will we." |
|
By:
Sam Winner will head straight for the Betfred Cheltenham Gold Cup without the aid of another run.
Paul Nicholls' eight-year-old has come alive over fences this term, with big-race victories at Cheltenham and Aintree backed up by a pleasing third in the Lexus Chase at Leopardstown. And with four Cheltenham victories already in safe-keeping, owner Angela Yeoman hopes Sam Winner's prowess at the track will again serve him well in the big one on March 13. She said: "He's really very well and we're very happy with him. "He's had a little rest during the winter and is ready to go again. "He seems to have grown up, which has been really pleasing to watch this season. "He will not run before Cheltenham but I've absolutely no idea who will ride him in the Gold Cup - that's for Paul to work out. "It has surprised me how good he has been in the wet, but I really think the deciding point (in the Gold Cup) will be the Cheltenham hill." |
|
By:
The finish to last year's race was surreal at the time and looks no different now.
Won by a horse unable to keep tabs for most of the race . Should have lost the race for interference , but they are never ever going to disqualify a Derby , Gold Cup or Grand National winner. On His Own was in the form of his life approaching the race , counts for a lot. As for the superstars Silviano Conti & Bobs Worth , only the jocks could have any idea what on earth happened to these two after the fence. Poorest Gold Cup since Cool Dawn in my opinion , and that is why I think some new kid on the block will win . Ridiculed for my view , but Djakadam was awesome last time out & with a prep run would have won the Hennessey , he goes there in form , and will do for me. |
|
By:
shutthefrontdoor alarming drift ,layed off most of my stake earlier thank fook !
|
|
By:
35 left in at the moment ..I guess we will end up with about 14/15 on the day? .Anybody heard of any of the likely non runners at this stage?
|
|
By:
1913 derby 6/4 fav craganour disqualified fact
lord windermere won fact reality |
|
By:
Rather liked On His Own's run at Leopardstown in the Lexus. Bowled along with his ears pricked and stuck on pretty well.
Has form in this race. Not a lot can put me off him except that he hangs a bit. Fit and conditions suit and form is good enough. Fave in this is not appealing imo. |
|
By:
Hi gart, OHO does jump a bit right which is a shame he'd have won the Gold Cup but for that you'd imagine. Tough ask for an 11yo too. But it's such an open year.
|
|
By:
Maybe I'm a bit daft but couldn't resist another few quid on First Lieutenant at 100+ on here. Ground drying in Ireland and backed him for todays Hennessy as well.
|
|
By:
Shock,
Not sure if hes on the list,but Whill have a market for winning today and any race at Cheltenham. Worth a look mate. Actually I shall start a topic in case others are interested. |
|
By:
I'll be happy enough if FL wins today, but had a look at special doubles on WHills and a couple stand out.
|
|
By:
Well that firmly puts Carlingford Lough in the frame. Foxrock not entered and his handicap mark completely blown, could they supplement him??? Boston Bob was staying on in behind but doesn't look good enough and as I have him and First Lieutenant partly NRNB my pocket would be happy for them to skip the Gold cup.
|
|
By:
I'd say that's it now for the Fingal Bay dream. Needs to go back to hurdles.
|
|
By:
Now the vast majority have had their prep runs, the Stats can be applied comparing recent year winners, to predict the outcome.
ROAD TO RICHES is a standout on statistical match, so I have just taken the 10/1 on Betfair. ROAD TO RICHES 93.8% CARLINGFORD LOUGH 85.6% MANY CLOUDS 81.0% The rest under 80%. |
|
By:
Carlingford Lough nice run today.
Thought he would come on for the Lexus run, hes a big player. |
|
By:
Agree Budd, thrust himself right into the picture with that win, and McCoy winning would bring the house down on Friday 13th March.
|
|
By:
Wouldn't surprise me if there's a right plunge on this horse come the day due to the McCoy factor.
|
|
By:
Lord Windermere surely the one, even culloty said before race he would be better at Cheltenham and on better ground. Coming nicely to the boil again at right time
|
|
By:
^^^ AMAZED WHEN HE HIT THE FRONT THEY CAUGHT HIM MIND. SO WAS THE MARKET, HIT 1.25
|
|
By:
Dilemma for McCoy because sentiment will lean him toward the Mcmanus horse for his last Gold Cup, but I think hand on heart, he'd sooner be riding Holywell.
|
|
By:
Bizarre ride on Lord Windermere - needs to be produced at the last.
But if he improves for Cheltenham in March like he has the last 2 years then he still looks cracking value. Will top up if the ground looks like being OK. |
|
By:
They didn't just catch Lord Windermere they sprinted 9L past him. Will be surprised if anything behind Carlingford Lough today will beat him at Cheltenham as this was only his 2nd run of the season. Take Foxrock out of this and CL beat the rest easier than Road To Riches. Clear 2nd Fav in my book.
|
|
By:
Really Duffy? If AP looks at the respective races they have had this season, I think he will be well happy to ride CL.
Shock, Don't forget RTR is a better horse on decent ground mate. |
|
By:
CL beay Morning Assembly easier on good last season than on soft, so ground is no concern for CL. His achilles may be his jumping as didn't jump well at Cheltenham in the RSA, but i will put that down to a blip.
|
|
By:
I was glad to see the two younger ones fight it out at the end, and leave the others behind.
Foxrock is a real strange one though. Strong fav in the four miler last year and ran no sort of race, beaten by 130 rated horses, and couldn't win a handicap at Christmas off 142, but then ran that race today. Proper head scratcher. |
|
By:
Still think The Lord will prevail again at Cheltenham , just the final prep today. Won't be produced till the last at festival, only teasing them today
|
|
By:
Aye, Lord Windermere has to be the value call imo.
|
|
By:
I think Foxy is a stronger horse this year Chief - and needed the run at Christmas. I think he was being prepared for a crack at a National. Still not convinced he is a Cheltenham horse and couldn't have him for a Gold Cup under Heskin. Lord Windermere is progressing nicely and is still a way off full fitness I gather.
|
|
By:
Think Boston bob was given a very nice prep race today came from last to fourth
with no great urgency. Will be better on good ground and he looks like a horse which is only getting into gear. 25/1 currently with ladbrokes think Ruby will ride him so he will do for me |
|
By:
budd
Who cares about this season's form to date...hell if that were the case, no-one on the planet would be backing Josses's hill, but as we know, despite what we see this season, some still see positives, eh?...to use a cliché, but in this case one with solid foundation, Holywell IS a spring horse and IS at his best on good ground rendering what goes on through the Winter as more or less meaningless, with the current GC picture as it is, is very much as good as the rest of the bunch. |
|
By:
![]() |
|
By:
Would be amazed if AP choose Holywell over Carlingford Lough. Point to piece of form that would lead him to pick Holywell? Id prefer to go with G1 winning form over seasonal form eveyday.
|