Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Cheltenham Festival

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 227 comments are related to the topic:
Champion Chase 2013

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 2 of 6  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 227
By:
CVByrne
When: 01 May 12 16:06
Sorry stront but I laughed out loud at this piece Sanctuaire's style could put SS's jumping under pressure I've never ever seen a horse jump a fence as well or make as much ground at a fence as Sprinter Sacre. He is better than perfection, he is sensational in his jumping. So it's he who puts pressure on others with his jumping, not the other way round and Sanctuare has made mistakes in his jumping this season before the foot perfect Celebration Chase round.

Don't forget sanctuaire has not won anything resembling a decent race until he went fresh and raced a bunch of horses as far away from winning a champ chase as they come at Sandown on Sat in a Grade 2. Don't get carried away with one performance from Sanctuaire, wait and see what he does when he meets real horses.

I remember people getting carried away with Woolcombe Folly winning under top weight at Cheltenham in a faster time than Master Minded on the same card back in 2010. That was an exceptional performance and then going off 7/1 in Champ Chase where he was hammered.

Lets see what the Tingle Creek tells us, but personal belief is Sprinter is on a different planet to Sanctuaire.
By:
strontium
When: 01 May 12 16:21
You're probably right, but not necessarily. SS has not yet faced a fast, front running fluid jumper - who knows what it will do to him? Sure he's a super jumper when he's in control. But if Sanct hares off in front and Gerahghty nudges SS to keep up and he then belts one, who knows what will happen? (It's a similar scenario to what SS did to Peddlers Cross). SS has to get upsides Sanct to put his jumping under pressure, he can't do it if Sanct gets a soft lead. Just as Sanct has only had 3 chases, SS hasn't had a hard test yet (impressive though the Arkle was).

I'm not getting carried away with Sanctuaire - please don't put words in my mouth. I've said in this thread I think he's about a 10/1 shot for the QMCC. I've also said a (visually) impressive end of season win on very soft ground does not prove he's the real deal. Funnily enough I had exactly the same thoughts about Woolcome Folly as you - there are several similarities.
By:
CVByrne
When: 01 May 12 16:35
I'm just saying, sprinter is running scary good times on the bridle this season, Geraghty struggles to hold him back in the early part of the race as he wants to go quicker. So he will not be nudged to keep up with Sanctuare, of that I'm very sure, he'll be cantering along and jumping like magic in the early part of the race when they meet.

What's unknown is what he'll do off the bridle when the chips are down. That's the one thing we don't know. Will Sanctuare keep finding more and keep Sprinter behind him all the way? That's where the questions to be answered are.

We both agree, we need to see them square off in the Tingle Creek to see where everyone stands. But with sizing Europe and Finians Rainbow in there, the amount of pace is frightening. It could actually see the perfect conditions for Sprinter to really "arrive" or it could see the Sprinter bubble burst.

Fascinating isn't it.
By:
shockster
When: 01 May 12 16:38
Whilst I agree that SS is probably the better of the 2 horses, I think it's a bit rich to compare Sanctuaire with Woolcombe Folly.  This was a grade 2 that had probably Grade 2 horses in it not a Handicap. Do You both believe every horse in the race ran below par with the exception of Sanctuaire and Dan Breen.  I can't have that.  Maybe this will be Sanctuaires peak, it was Mastermindeds at Chelt. But i'll be amazed if he doesn't win a grade 1.
By:
strontium
When: 01 May 12 16:38
Yes it is. Sprinter is hugely impressive and exciting - it will be great to see him against top class horses. There's only so much we can learn from him humping small fields of inferior animals.
By:
CVByrne
When: 01 May 12 16:45
Shockster, what we meant by Woolcombe Folly was the Folly in overrating a horse based on one race. What happened at Sandown was a horse getting an early lead and the field expecting him to come back to them. Tactically it was a great ride and the horse won't be allowed such a soft lead in future. People know about him now, know he can go and keep going. Also he went there fresh, with the race as his aim, while it was the end of a very busy season for Somersby and Wishfull Thinking, 2 horses who certainly are not 2 milers. The rest of the field are rubbish horses.

So in that sense, we need to see what happens next season. When all the horses will be spot on to win the Tingle Creek.
By:
strontium
When: 01 May 12 16:48
Shock, I just think there are possible similarities with the Woolcombe Folly race. That was a Class 2 handicap (so not some hack race). WF put in a very impressive performance on the clock under a big weight but has never come close to it again - indeed he's back down to the mark he won off that day now. It's possible Sanctuaire's peformance will be similar - same trainer, same trip, specially prepared for the race. I'm not saying it will be, just that it might be and I'd like to see Sanctuaire back up his run.

I do take the point about all the other horses on Saturday running below par. The simple answer is I don't know if they did. As I said above, if Somersby ran to form, Sanct is the best chaser in training, which seems unlikely after 3 chases. Most of the rest (French O, Wishfull Thinking, Cornas, Woolcombe) have had poor seasons, so who knows what "form" is? I'm prefectly happy to believe the Timeform rating of 169+ for Sanctuaire at this stage.
By:
shockster
When: 01 May 12 16:54
CVB Somersby does seem to be tripless although he did beat Finians Rainbow in the VC Chase over 2 miles and believe me I do understand about overrating a horse.  Let me put one last scenario to the test.  If SS had delivered that performance at Sandown on Saturday would you believe that Somersby had had an off day?
By:
strontium
When: 01 May 12 17:01
I think so Shock, otherwise you're rating the horse at 183+ which seems implausible for a novice. It would also mean Dan Breen improved his career high mark by 12 lbs to around 160. Which horses do you think ran to their marks in that race?


This is what the BHA handicapper says:
With its proximity to the Cheltenham, Aintree and Punchestown festivals, Sandown’s Celebration Chase has tended to suffer from a touch of ‘After the Lord Mayor’s Show’ syndrome. Not this year! Writes John de Moraville.

Saturday’s Grade 2 showdown, inaugurated in 2001 after Cheltenham’s Queen Mother Champion Chase was a victim of the foot-and-mouth crisis, produced a star of its own in Sanctuaire, a six-year-old novice having only his third start over fences.
He was a talented but temperamental 150-rated hurdler whose victories included the Scottish Champion and the Fred Winter.

Sanctuaire, who had pulled hard in the past and given trouble at the start, seemingly relishes his new front-running chase tactics. Unchallenged winner of his two previous outings, he again blasted off in front and, jumping from fence to fence, had his far more experienced rivals on the rack by half-way.

Never in danger of defeat, Sanctuaire hammered Victor Chandler Chase winner Somersby (166) by 17 lengths with Dan Breen (148) finishing a creditable third. While Somersby and the majority of Saturday’s field failed to give their true running, a line through Dan Breen, who had also run to 148 in winning a course and distance novice chase (subsequently disqualified) on similar going last season, gives Sanctuaire a chase rating of 167.

That mark - just 2lb below brilliant Arkle hero Sprinter Sacre - may well flatter him and is sure to provoke a heated debate at next week’s Anglo-Irish Classifications meeting. But one thing is certain, on a front-runner’s track like Sandown, Sanctuaire is an extremely potent force. Unsurprisingly, he is due to return to the Surrey circuit in December for the Tingle Creek.
By:
CVByrne
When: 01 May 12 17:03
It would just be one more in a string of awesome performances from a horse who won the Arkle at a canter.

See Sprinter won 5 races this season at a common canter, including 2 grade 1s and 2 grade 2s. Sanctuaire won one grade 2, at the end when he was fresh against horses who were at the end of a long season. You see the difference?

As for Somersby, we all know he's a different horse at Ascot, the previous year he nearly beat Master Minded there. Horses for Courses.

I personally think Sprinter is on a different level entirely to Sanctuare. But we'll see if I'm right next season.
By:
thieveslikeus
When: 01 May 12 18:07
Problem is CVB, that the most reliable speed figures, as produced by Raceform, indicate that SS has run very ordinary times not fast times at all!  Even the Arkle which was his fastest.  The course record at Newbury means nothing, the races were short of the distance after they moved the rail and all he did was beat a couple of handicappers.  He is clearly very good but has yet to prove he can do it at Grade 1 speed.  Of the two, Sanctuaire is the one who has beaten a winner of an open Grade 1 chase, and beaten him pointless, and in a terrific time.
By:
CVByrne
When: 01 May 12 18:16
Yes we can all say our opinions, and find angles to say one is better than the other. But we'll see what happens when they meet. I personally don't worry too much about times, races are run differently. Bottom line is Sprinter has done miles more than Sanctuaire over fences.

I'll not rate Sanctuare based on one win at end of the season where he got a soft lead. It'll be interesting how he runs when people don't underestimate him, when horses keep closer order.

Then the real test in the Tingle Creek. I think Sprinter will murder him. But we'll have to wait to then to find out.

Does anyone here think Sprinter will lose to Sanctuare in tingle creek?
By:
buddeliea
When: 01 May 12 18:40
To be honest,i aint sure how we can know which one is the better till they meet.
They have both won their chases impressively beating different horses,i think that French Opera is the only horse they have both met(may be wrong on that)and they both beat that one easily.

We can have our favourite and opinions based on visual impression,but until they meet,nowt is known for sure.
By:
Mr Eboue
When: 01 May 12 18:43
If Sprinter sacre did what Sanctuaire did on Saturday he'd be a 4/7 shot for the Champion chase.

SS will be an odds on fav in the tingle creek but he'll have to be on his form to beat Sanctuaire who i think is a very serious horse.
By:
CVByrne
When: 01 May 12 19:11
True, we'll have to wait and see. But for me, Sanctuare caught a poor field on the hop and a good horse was given an easy lead and never surrendered it. The easy lead will not be given again and he'll face a test. While also he'll face true top class horses at Sandown.

What I'm trying to say here is please a show of hands who is getting carried away with this Celebration Chase performance and thinks Sanctuare will beat Sprinter in Tingle Creek or Champion Chase?

People are saying stuff but it's all vague. Anyone want to nail their colours to the mast?

Sprinter had his 2 run away wins and "arrived" when he beat Peddlers. People knew he was serious then, but he ran 3 times more and they could do nothing to thwart him. Sanctuare has "arrived" now, but has yet to be tested since... there is the big difference. Sprinter was beatable until he won the arkle at a canter.

Anyway, this is all great for racing. We'll have a great Tingle Creek in store and it should allow Sprinter fans one chance to get some decent odds on a Tingle / Champ Chase double of maybe 4/1
By:
shockster
When: 01 May 12 19:20
That's my point Mr Eboue.  If SS had run that race on Saturday and won by 17L, then judges would have thought it believable that Somersby had run to 166.  It is safer to judge the rating on Dan Breen, however I believe there would have been a different mind set had SS done this.

The Tingle creek will answer some questions, but as I stated previously Sanctuaire has not won before end of January and may be more of a spring horse.
By:
wellchief
When: 01 May 12 19:30
Anyone giving Sizing Europe a chance?

He certainly doesn't look to be regressing to me and has just had a great season.  It was a unique set of circumstances in the Champion Chase, and I definitely don't have him as a 10/1 shot.

Being an 11 year old next year may be an issue, but its no 2 horse race at the moment.  Him and Finians were a class apart and Finians didn't exactly let the form down at Aintree.
By:
buddeliea
When: 01 May 12 19:31
Not answering that one CV,just depends on the day and how fit they are.
I cant seperate them right now.
By:
wellchief
When: 01 May 12 19:34
Re The Tingle Creek - Sizing was devastating there last year and could have gone round again.  Might not look the strongest line up now, but he smashed them.

Easily his best performance outside of the Festival and is definitely in the mix in the big 2m races here and in Ireland.
By:
buddeliea
When: 01 May 12 19:39
Ah,now we are talking. SE the ex champion chaser,unlucky loser it can be argued,and one of the best QM winners ive ever seen last season.But can he still be as good next season? i have my doubts on that one.
By:
shockster
When: 01 May 12 19:39
Can't argue about Sizing, but do think time will catch up by the festival.
By:
CVByrne
When: 01 May 12 20:00
shockster
01 May 12 19:20 Joined: 26 Oct 05 | Topic/replies: 469 | Blogger: shockster's blog
That's my point Mr Eboue.  If SS had run that race on Saturday and won by 17L, then judges would have thought it believable that Somersby had run to 166.  It is safer to judge the rating on Dan Breen, however I believe there would have been a different mind set had SS done this.


Yes there would be a different mind set because this would have been the 5th class 1 race he had won. He would not have been given an early 15l lead and people would know fully what to expect from Sprinter.

So if Sprinter won the race by 17l it'd be just another accolade. Try think of this in context of Sprinters run away drubbing of then Arkle fav Peddlers Cross. People were impressed but many had doubts.

So your statement is flawed in it's point. Sprinter hasalready proved himself 4 times in class 1 races before Sandown. Sanctuare was proving himself in his first. Also there is no way anyone at all would believe Somersby ran to 166, no matter who beat him on Sat.
By:
CVByrne
When: 01 May 12 20:02
As far as Sizing, if he's beaten well by Sprinter in Tingle Creek they'll avoid him at Cheltenham.
By:
strontium
When: 01 May 12 20:03
Sizing's no back number. He might not have beaten Finains at the Festival, but more or less everything that could go wrong for him that day did. As Wellchief says, Sizing was most impressive in the last Tingle Creek. He'll be a great yardstick if he, sprinter and Sanctuaire all show up in December. I can't see Finians staying at 2 m though.
By:
shockster
When: 01 May 12 20:16
CVB what my point is and I think you get it.  Is that had SS won the race on Saturday he would have been given a higher rating.  Don't get me wrong, I am not knocking SS, I think he is the best around, however Sanctuaire may be not far behind.
By:
CVByrne
When: 01 May 12 20:23
Sprinter wouldn't have been given a higher rating. Dan Breen would still be used to rate the race and Sprinter simply would have beaten him as expected. Sprinter Sacre was rated 169 going into the Arkle and is still rated 169 having won Arkle and at Aintree.
By:
shockster
When: 01 May 12 20:39
Seems strange to me that the whole race is rated on officially the worst horse in the field.  Doesn't it seem a bit far fetched that only Dan Breen ran exactly to its mark and every other runner was way below par.  Seems more likely to me that DB prob ran 5lb higher which then means all the others weren't quite as below par as 1st seemed.  This then puts Sanctuaire on 174 for the run.  Just my opinion.
By:
CVByrne
When: 01 May 12 20:47
That race is always full of horses who run below par given it's the last race in the calender. French Opera was clearly not travelling and was making mistakes, while Somersby and Wishfull had long long seasons and can't be expected to run to form. That leaves Dan Breen who looked to run a good race left to be the horse to rate the race through.

Rather simple really.

Also no horse goes up in the weights for taking a 18l hammering. None, so thinking Dan Breen goes up 5lbs is rather daft really.
By:
shockster
When: 01 May 12 20:53
Point taken on being raised 5lb.  However, we have no idea what they ran to and basing the race on officially the worst horse is also daft, it's the soft option. Maybe DB ran to 130, 140, 150. We don't know do we.
By:
strontium
When: 01 May 12 20:55
Nevertheless, this demonstrates yet again that ratings are just a matter of opinion.
By:
shockster
When: 01 May 12 20:58
Roll on next season for some answers.
By:
CVByrne
When: 01 May 12 21:22
Also novice ratings are always going to be flimsy at best. Both these horses are open to improvement when they face the seasoned horses next season in competitive graded races. The Tingle Creek will be the first real test of both. Sizing Europe will defend his crown and he'll be a good benchmark to sort the real from the pretenders. He won't hang around. He may well put them in their place.
By:
Steeplechasing
When: 01 May 12 21:53
CVB, long time no speak - I hope you're well.  Before moving on to dissect your quotes let me paste one from WellChief:

Well Chief mentioned Sizing 'being devastating' in Tingle Creek for which he recorded a topspeed figure of 121: Sanctuaire's topspeed on Saturday was 150.

Now CVB, to some of your quotes:

As to Somersby and WT having 'long seasons': The former had 7 races, the latter 8 - Sanctuaire 6, hardly a huge difference.

French Opera 'not travelling and making mistakes' - possibly from trying to keep up with a very fast horse?

'Sanctuare caught a poor field on the hop and a good horse was given an easy lead' A common belief about the performance on forums and elsewhere but a massively flawed one imo. This was not a 20/1 chance, he was 9/2 3rd best. Horses who are mistakenly given too much rope tend to be pursued at full pace much closer to home than Sanctuaire was - halfway down the back some were already being scrubbed along: turning away for the last time most of them were under pressure (bar the winner). The reason he appeared to be given 'a soft lead' was because the others could not go with him - hence the splendid time performance. This is a crucial factor in judging Sanctuaire's true ability and should not lightly be dismissed.

The horse has phenomenal early pace; this allied to his superb fencing technique makes him a fearsome proposition for anyone to take on over the first few - even Sprinter Sacre whose jumping is certainly spectacular but far from economical. Sanctuaire would have taken lengths out of SS at every fence on Saturday. Okay, SS with his big chasing frame and scopey leaps would have looked the breathtaking one, but Sanctuaire's fencing style would have aced the Henderson horse every time.

"What I'm trying to say here is please a show of hands who is getting carried away with this Celebration Chase performance"

If I might say so, it didn't need the Celebration Chase for me to be alerted to the horse's potential:  here's my blog post from just after the festival:

I can find no record of tipsters in The Old Testament although I suppose you could class prophets in the same group.  Anyone recommending a bet on David against Goliath would doubtless have been laughed off the track - in this case The Valley of Elah.

A valley in the Cotswolds is where my David in the shape of Sanctuaire will hopefully face Goliath next March in the QM Champion Chase. Sprinter Sacre is already as short as evens for the race. Sanctuaire is 50s with Coral.

I need not list the talents of Sprinter Sacre who could be one of the best we've seen. But much can happen in a year and a key event comes up in three weeks time in the shape of The Maghull Novices' Chase at Aintree. That's the next planned run for Sanctuaire and he could well get an early sight of Sprinter Sacre alongside him at the start.  The Arkle winner appeared to take little out of himself and connections will be tempted to run at Aintree.

But between now and then, I doubt Sanctuaire will get any longer than 50s for next year's QM and he might go shorter on the run up to the Maghull.  If Nicky Henderson keeps his 'black aeroplane' at home over Aintree then Sanctuaire will, I believe, have a strong chance of winning the race.  Last year's winner, Finian's Rainbow got a post-Maghull quote of 10/1 for the QM and supporters  collected on that last week.

Even if he finishes runner-up to Sprinter Sacre at Aintree, he will be much shorter than 50s for next year's big race.

Sanctuaire was a talented but moody sort over hurdles.  More evidence is needed that fencing has changed his attitude, but in his two steeplechases so far, he has looked as though he cannot wait until he reaches the next fence so he can fly it. After his Sandown victory last time, his trainer, Paul Nicholls (who has a fine record in The Maghull) said this:

"He got a bit fed up with hurdles and had a few hard races, but he´s an awesome jumper and fences could be the making of him. He´ll be really interesting next year and could be very good in the big two-mile chases. Horses who gallop and jump like that can take a bit of catching and he could be good in a race like the Tingle Creek."

Sanctuaire's chasing victories have been class 4 small field events - from those to running a big race in the QM is an awful long way. But he's only 6, we know from his hurdling career he has talent and his trainer seems to be eyeing the big 2m prizes for next season. He might not be good enough to beat Sprinter Sacre at Cheltenham but he could easily be placed and at 50s, I think an EW bet is very good value.

Good luck
By:
tomdeane
When: 01 May 12 22:04
Like everyone on here, I was impressed with Sanctuaire on Saturday but am surprised how easily won over some have been. A few have said it is unlikely that everything else ran below par, and thus, Sanctuaire should be rated very highly indeed. I take issue with this - I think it is very likely that everything else did run below par. Somersby and Wishfull Thinking have both had long, up and down seasons to different degrees, and the rest are not really good enough to be used as genuine markers.

The more pertinent issue in my mind is this: April/May form is simply not as strong as it is earlier in the season. James Pyman and co can come up with as many stats-laden assessments as they like to suggest horses still run to something approaching their best, but it's just codswallop in my opinion. Who really thinks Somersby, a Grade One horse at his best, ran to the same mark (or was ready to) as when winning the VC?

The other issue is this: This was a classically impressive two-mile Sandown performance. We've seen it before. When very good horses get into a good rhythm from the front, they can be made to look like worldbeaters when those in behind don't find such a rhythm. Twist Magic was all but unbeatable here but wouldn't have been as dangerous anywhere else. Who can forget Champion Chaser elect, Big Zeb, looking like a handicapper here behind him in a Tingle Creek?

As CVByrne said earlier on this thread, Sprinter is the best jumper of a fence there has been for a long, long time. Watch him wing the third last in the Arkle and then ask yourself whether Sanctuaire's jumping would have him in any sort of trouble. If he ever beats Sprinter over two miles I will be shocked.

One last thing - Finian's Rainbow is a very, very good two-miler. He stays further under ideal conditions but wouldn't want to go more than two in my mind, and I fully expect him to attempt to defend his crown in the Champion Chase in March. He is the serious rival to Sprinter, not Sanctuaire.
By:
tomdeane
When: 01 May 12 22:09
Steeplechasing - not for one minute arguing 50-1 isn't a great price. You've done really, really well there and as always, there is real substance in your reasoning. Apart from one thing:

Sanctuaire would have taken lengths out of SS at every fence on Saturday. Okay, SS with his big chasing frame and scopey leaps would have looked the breathtaking one, but Sanctuaire's fencing style would have aced the Henderson horse every time.

In my opinion, this is just plain wrong.
By:
CVByrne
When: 01 May 12 22:31
Hi steeplechasing, been travelling round the world for most of past year so haven't been around. Hope you're well.

Firstly, we're not talking about either horse not being very talented. What we're discussing is who is better.

I agree with tom that it's crazy to think Sanctuaire would take lengths out of Sprinter. I've never in my life seen a horse as good at jumping a fence as Sprinter Sacre, he has this unreal athletic ability, the water jump in the game spirit for example he took of far too early and winged it. He has the ability to jump fences that far away, while he can put himself right if he's a little closer. He has a skill that is stunning and I've never seen it before.

The next is he is finishing his races running at a stunning speed, I mean it looks like he's just picking up when he reaches the top of the hill in the Arkle, never mind hard held in his other races. He is always going too slow at early in his races too, he want to go faster than they can. So I think Sanctuaire will benefit Sprinter immensely next season, giving him a toe for a good part of the race.

Finally, we forget Sanctuaire had had 2 class 4 runs this year, his last before Cheltenham then came here to Sandown a fresh horse and caught horses like Somersby, Wishfull Thinking etc at the end of many hard high class races this season. I simply cannot rate this race, especially given he was gifted at 15l lead, something that will not happen in the Tingle Creek as Sizing and Sprinter will love to have give them a toe.

Finally, Sanctuaire was ridden out by Noel, and will have to carry 5lbs more when he returns to Sandown in the Tingle Creek and 8 more at Cheltenham. I think Sanctuaire is a very good horse, but as yet, not in Sprinters League. We'll see what happens next year.

I just do not write off horses on one run and do not rate horses on one run. It works wonders for making correct betting decisions.
By:
Steeplechasing
When: 01 May 12 23:04
"James Pyman and co can come up with as many stats-laden assessments as they like to suggest horses still run to something approaching their best, but it's just codswallop in my opinion."

Tom, Mr Pyman and Timeform do not 'come up' with assessments: they research facts, produce solid evidence and base their articles on that.

Evidence, in my experience, invariably proves more reliable than 'opinions'.

If, Lord forbid, you had a serious disease and your doctors advised you, based on evidence and statistics, that a certain course of action was advisable, would you dismiss it as codswallop based on your gut feel?
By:
tomdeane
When: 02 May 12 02:24
Steeplechasing -

Apologies for what will likely be a briefish response - I wrote a huge one moments ago but it didn't post and has now disappeared.

Firstly, what I am about to say is not coming from someone simply looking for an argument, but from someone who has followed and bet on racing for many years as well as having earned a postgraduate degree in Biostatistics.

Your analogy of the serous disease is an interesting one. Of course, most times I would follow physician's advice, but it might not be so simple as you'd expect. The medical profession is obsessed with finding a problem and treating that problem in isolation, rather than asking why the problem exists or treating it holistically. I believe the same is true with the approach taken by Timeform, Pyman etc. They put their stock in attributing time and weight per length indices as gospel in evaluating race results. I don't believe it is ever that simple.

The Woolcombe Folly example that cropped up earlier on this thread is a good one to illustrate the point - the ratings boys were lauding him as a Champion Chaser in waiting after he ran a faster time than Master Minded and won a hot handicap off a really high rating. But who really thought he was as good a horse as Master Minded? As it turns out, Master Minded could have picked him up and carried him, and most people instinctively knew this was the case despite the facts and figures apparently providing 'evidence' that this was not the case.

As I've said before, I don't think it takes much of a leap of faith to believe that the main players behind Sanctuaire all ran considerably below their best, whereas Sprinter Sacre was faultless in the Arkle at Cheltenham in March, when everything in the race was ready to run for its life. I can't believe people are really suggesting that the likes of Follow The Plan would be competitive in Grade One races earlier in the season? Of course you get some horses that run to form at this time of year - Finian's Rainbow had a quiet campaign and was likely still very fresh when dotting up at Aintree. Riverside Theatre had two very hard races in quick succession and wasn't. The point is, I think you have to be much, much more subjective in your rating of end-of-season races than you do when watching the mid-season main events.

For what it's worth, Sanctuaire has always been talented and is probably capable of winning at the highest level over fences, especially around Sandown. But I stand by my earlier comments - everything in my intuitive psyche tells me Sprinter Sacre is in a different league, even if the Timeform mob suggest they are closely matched.
By:
thieveslikeus
When: 02 May 12 02:44
For Shockster, just a point of interest that Dan Breen achieved a Raceform Speed Figure that is around 6lbs faster than he has ever run before so your theory has some evidence there to back it up.

Can I just say that I look at things rather differently than some on here.  I look at different interpretations as a means to finding value.  If one horse is better on form ratings and the other better on the clock I will usually be on whichever is the bigger price.  If the odds are as expected come the Tingle Creek then the chances are I will be backing Sanctuaire.  Doesn't mean I think he is the better horse, means I think there is a high enough percentage chance that he is the better horse to back him if I can get the right price.
By:
thieveslikeus
When: 02 May 12 02:53
One other thing, people look at times of races far too simplistically - Woolcombe Folly has never done a Grade 1 Raceform speed figure in his life.  The run people are referring to achieved a 113, around 8-10lbs short of Grade 1 class.  That was and is, his peak speed figure. 

Sprinter Sacre's only grade 1 Speed Figure so far was in the Supreme.  He clearly can go faster than he has so far and will undoubtedly run one at some point but he hasn't yet.  The language people are using of the last 2 Champion Chasers testing themselves against the Arkle winner is hype of the highest order.  Even in SS's case it is the other way round surely?
Page 2 of 6  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com