Forums
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 442 comments are related to the topic:
George's Juvenile Hurdler + / - Thread

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 9 of 12  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 442
By:
jamesdean
When: 08 Dec 19 13:27
Cannot argue with that ^

WD George
By:
jamesdean
When: 08 Dec 19 13:28
By:
Virgin
When: 08 Dec 19 13:33
Wd George Cool
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 09 Dec 19 18:29
Cheers James and Virgin

I've got Isle Of Wolves and John Betjeman as qualifiers at Fontwell tomorrow. The former's Flat form would suggest he needs better ground and he was tailed off over C/D behind Goshen on soft on his hurdles debut, while stamina is the obvious concern for the latter on this switch of code.
So with the French import put in at 1-4 early doors, no selection

The next juvenile hurdle is the opener at Warwick on Thursday.
By:
sageform
When: 10 Dec 19 13:38
Both ran well George but beaten by the second fav. John Betjeman should win a race. I did manage to find El Picador yesterday. Came out just top on RPR over hurdles but easy to back.
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 10 Dec 19 14:13
Well done with El Picador, sageform.

Oh well, the Law of Sod came into force and they both placed, albeit only one of them would have had the fav not fallen at the last.

It was probably was a weak enough contest outside of the fav, but JB seemed to stay the trip fine, while Isle Of Wolves didn't shape too badly, not knocked about up the straight.
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 11 Dec 19 08:32
I opined Isle Of Wolves was "not knocked about up the straight", and just seen in the results section that they were pulled in a for a running and riding enquiry, explanations were noted!
By:
sageform
When: 11 Dec 19 19:43
The Warwick race tomorrow looks potentially very hot. those that have run have not shown much so the winner will probably come from a newcomer. The one possible exception is Hurricane Hero who ran poorly over hurdles but was rated 77 on the flat.
The best flat performer was Kangaroo Valley who has been bought from Joseph O'Brien by owners who have been big spenders lately. The doubt is whether it is fast enough as it raced over 14 furlongs. Palladium is likely to start fav but only because it is Henderson and Rowland Ward appeals more as the likely winner. JP has yet another French import, Sainte Doctor that might be good but only won at a very small French track.
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 11 Dec 19 20:17
It looks interesting sageform, with a few useful recruits off the Flat. Regarding previous form, I see the French import I Like Him has been given an official rating of 130.

Hurricane Hero is one of my qualifiers, but as I pointed out the other day when he ran at MR, he best piece of form was at Southwell and his AW mark is higher. So a bit to prove on turf, and he was very weak in the betting on his debut for OM.

The Henderson horse was entered for the Class 2 at Sandown the other day at the 5 day stage, but maybe they didn't fancy taking on Goshen!
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 11 Dec 19 20:18
Ground query regarding Rowland Ward?
They pulled him out when he was due to go at Ludlow because of the ground.
By:
TheAnorak
When: 11 Dec 19 20:19
Goodness knows what prompted anybody to pay 105,000 euros for Sainte Doctor. The race she won was rock bottom, barrel scraping stuff by French standards. The second and third are now a 54 rated ten race maiden and a 51 rated rated nine race maiden respectively. Both of them have run lowly claiming races without attracting any buyers.
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 11 Dec 19 20:22
No shortage of qualifiers as I have 7 in today's race: Rowland Ward, Palladium, Kangaroo Valley, Twpsyn, Derry Boy, Tronada and Hurricane Hero.

The second highest rated of them off the level is Rowland Ward (OR 83). He won a 12f handicap at  Doncaster back in April, and that form worked out fairly well with the runner-up Beechwood Jude subsequently winning twice, the third horse Sapa Inca improving subsequently to win at Listed level, and the 4th horse was today's rival Palladium, who he gave 2lb and a 5l beating to. Rowland Ward ran just three more times and on the face of it didn't progress, although he did actually twice record higher RPRs in defeat, including when only seventh of 11 over 12f at Thirsk when wearing first time blinkers, on his final start for Ralph Beckett.

Soft ground is an unknown for Rowland Ward, his win came on officially good ground at Doncaster on a day when the times were on the slow side, but a strong wind half against probably had an impact on the clock. He did finish runner-up on good to soft on his 2YO debut at Sandown to none other than Too Darn Hot, albeit beaten an easy 7l. He was withdrawn from a juvenile hurdle at Ludlow last month when the soft ground was deemed unsuitable.

Palladium has joined Nicky Henderson from Martyn Meade. He would appear up against it with Rowland Ward given the aforementioned Doncaster form, and being officially rated 10lb inferior to that rival, however, he did run some good races in defeat after, when bumping into sharp improvers Moon King and Land Of Oz.

Interestingly, his new trainer did have him entered at the 5-day stage for the class 2 Introductory Hurdle at Sandown last week, perhaps an indication he has been working well at home, but he would have had to face Goshen there.

Kangaroo Valley
, formerly trained by Aidan O'Brien,  is the highest rated of these on the Flat with an OR of 86 (down from 91), though whether he's worth that mark is open to question, given he was initially rated 69 after three maiden runs, before being raised a whopping 22lb for winning a 12.5f Tipperary maiden on yielding ground by 8 lengths. The horse he beat into second, Yonkers (rated 80), had previously finished 14 lengths behind the winner on his sole handicap start (when rated 83) , and hasn't run again since being beaten by Kangaroo Valley.

Kangaroo Valley failed to justify the sharp hike in the ratings in two handicap runs and his mark has been dropped 5lb, but the ground was good to firm both times and it could be he needs softer ground to be seen to best effect.

My other four qualifiers are all rated in the 60s on the Flat and would appear up against it, perhaps Twpsyn has the best credentials of them for this switch of code, being a 12f winner on the level and a half-brother to a hurdles winner, though soft ground is an unknown for him.

Of the others, Sainte Doctor is another JP McManus French import. She shouldn't fail for stamina having won a 2 mile race on the Flat.
I Like Him has been handed an OR of 130 after eight starts in France, and debuts here for Ali Stronge.
Hydroplane won three handicaps for Sir Mark Prescott this year and is currently rated 78. He makes his debut today for Ian Williams.
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 11 Dec 19 20:23
Thanks for the analysis, Anorak
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 11 Dec 19 20:33
I've not decided on a selection yet, with the more obvious ones well found in the market, and the ones rated in the 60s on the Flat, perhaps a bit too much on the speculative side, though Tronada is shorter than I expected her to be, perhaps on stable reputation?
By:
chavman
When: 11 Dec 19 20:34
nice succinct analysis anorak,some people could learn from your concise synopsis.
By:
TheAnorak
When: 11 Dec 19 20:35
Just to add that if Ali Stronge wins a race with I Like Him off 130, I'll nominate her for trainer of the year!
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 11 Dec 19 21:25
Kangaroo Valley, 1pt win @ 8-1, 12.20 Warwick

I usually prefer not to make selections the evening before cuz it annoys me when I wake up the next morning to discover they've doubled in price Cry

As I posted above, it's debatable whether his maiden win at Tipperary was worth a 22lb rise, but he did impress with how he maintained the gallop on the front end and the time was 1.7 seconds quicker than the proceeding handicap over the same C/D.

He failed to justify the hike in the ratings in two subsequent handicap runs, but it could have been the ground was quicker than ideal for him on each occasion.

Given how he went through the race at Tipperary, this track could suit if similar tactics are adopted and he takes to hurdling.
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 11 Dec 19 22:02
I don't know the answer to this question so would be much obliged if someone could help!

Since Joseph O'Brien started training, which would be the best future hurdler to have left Aidan and not gone to Joseph, and / or be owned by JP McManus?

I'm just curious, cuz I kinda wondered, given his fairly high Flat rating, why isn't Kangaroo Valley now being trained / owned by Joseph / JP...and that's just me rightly or wrongly presuming they'd have first call!

For example, like the ill-fated Sir Erec.
By:
sageform
When: 12 Dec 19 08:05
Another related question. Joseph is having a lot of success on the flat. Will he move further in that direction and wind down on jumping as his father did?
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 12 Dec 19 09:05
I would guess the plan is for him to take over from his dad one day, sageform

Missing info from me little write up, Palladium & Kangaroo Valley both gelded ahead of their hurdle / stable debuts.

Price tags off the Flat:
Rowland Ward: 75,000 gns
Hydroplane: 65,000 gns

Anyone know what they paid for Kangaroo valley?
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 12 Dec 19 09:08
Palladium into 11-8 on here Shocked
By:
sageform
When: 12 Dec 19 09:42
KV cost MV Magnier 200k as a yearling. He was offered at the horses in training in Oct 2018 and again in Oct 2019 but not sold. Assume it was a private sale after that. The Vac pouch company have been spending lately but I would worry about connections for this horse. Henry Oliver????
As Aiden shows no sign of retiring I imagine that Joseph has a limited number of boxes and would prioritise flat.
By:
TheAnorak
When: 12 Dec 19 10:07
Vac Pouch is owned by the bloke that was caught out bragging about his winnings last week on the horse that had been a non trier at Warwick on its previous start.

So perhaps three runs for a handicap mark would seem more likely than a debut success?
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 12 Dec 19 10:09
Cheers sageform, interesting that he went unsold this year. Maybe he didn't meet a reserve?

Joseph takes in 50-odd rated horses like Marylebone that they've picked up for peanuts, so presume he must have plenty of space!?

Apparently Donnacha is going to have a much smaller string and concentrate solely on the Flat.
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 12 Dec 19 10:12
And having watched the Sastruga ride last night, Anorak, clearly a yard to be wary of, IMO.
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 12 Dec 19 10:59
I've decided to have a second selection, this time on a more speculative one

Twpsyn, 1pt EW @ 66-1, 12.20 Warwick

Twpsyn has a bit to find on Flat ratings with a few of these, but he comes here fit off the Flat having won easily over 12f at Southwell last month, and while his sole turf success to date came only in a 3 runner affair in Guernsey, he might have scored at Windsor over 11.5f at Windsor in July, but for unseating his rider 2f out when seemingly travelling the best.

The ground is an unknown, but he should be fine stamina-wise, and while he disappointed back at Southwell on his latest start, hopefully with the visor being kept on, he's not running today just for the experience.
By:
stridingedge
When: 12 Dec 19 12:11
GL George interesting Stuart Edmunds pitching one in against Nicky (the former with the higher rated runner from flat).

We saw he has a good record in these races with newcomers, a well backed winner earlier on the fred.
By:
sageform
When: 12 Dec 19 12:12
Good luck with that George. I am staying with Rowland Ward but it is a minimum bet race with hopefully some good ones to follow next time out.
By:
sageform
When: 12 Dec 19 12:20
Market makes it look a 2 horse race with Hydroplane the only other one backed. Some nice prices if you fancy anything else.
By:
stridingedge
When: 12 Dec 19 12:26
Stuarts other one at big odds Laugh
By:
stridingedge
When: 12 Dec 19 12:27
His first string was running a promising effort when falling off a pretty quiet ride from the rear early, hopefully horse ok.
By:
sageform
When: 12 Dec 19 12:30
Fillies allowance and recent experience in bumpers paid off. Right trainer, wrong horse. I thought that Rowland Ward ran OK considering he was a long way back at halfway. Making ground in that mud is impossible.
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 12 Dec 19 12:45
They pulled Rowland Ward out last month because of the ground but let him run this time, though tbf, it was given as good to soft in places, but clearly it had deteriorated through the morning.

The market got it right regarding which of the Flat recruits would fare best and Palladium pulled well clear of the rest, but a twice-raced bumper filly proved just too good.

As for Kangaroo Valley, they rode him with a bit of restraint and all he did was plug on to finish on the heels of the placed horses.

I took a flyer with Twpsyn, but of my eligible 'rags' it was Tronada which fared best in 4th.
By:
stridingedge
When: 12 Dec 19 12:54
I thought it had travelled fine on the ground GEORGE tbh as Sage alluded to just given a quiet run from the back and very difficult to make up to much ground.

I wouldn't be surprised if the fall has not dented it's confidence to see much more to come there.

Post race Stuart basically saying you don't want to make up too much ground there today but he wanted to get Rowland ward settled. His other runner obviously ridden completely different to suit conditions.

Easy to say after a 55 winner but have mentioned on here previously he is under rated in these races
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 12 Dec 19 13:02
The moral of the story, striding, if you were doing a Stuart Edmunds Juvenile Hurdler + / - thread, let the prices dictate and there'd be a + 54 going into the P/L column Wink
By:
stridingedge
When: 12 Dec 19 13:06
Thankfully these are not my races George as intent is often questionable and the ?? are often endless, I think your approach is certainly as good as any for such races.

55.0 shots for you are like even money punts for others, real shorties. Grin
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 12 Dec 19 13:12
Thankfully managed to a find of couple of winning longshots since the thread started, striding, or else it would have been x-rated stuff  Blush

Three juvenile races on Saturday, a Grade 2 at Doncaster, a Class 2 at Cheltenham, and a maiden 3YO hurdle at Fairyhouse.

Running P/L: +196.2
By:
jamesdean
When: 13 Dec 19 15:27
Elysian flame?
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 13 Dec 19 15:37
He's not one of my qualifiers, James, but with a Flat rating of 91, he's obviously potentially useful if he takes to it, and they're throwing him straight in at the deep end.

Spittin' also runs George Ridsdale (also not one of my qualifiers) in the opener at Donny tomorrow in a handicap, he was a bit disappointing last time at Catterick, but maybe the combination of bad ground and penalty did for him. His previous win at Musselburgh is working out with the runner-up El Picador winning easily recently.

I see the sole 3YO in the field, Repetito (8-1), won the 1.20 at Cheltenham today.
By:
GEORGE.B
When: 13 Dec 19 17:20
Grade 2, 2.45 Doncaster

My only qualifier in the Grade 2 at Doncaster is Robeam, who won comfortably on his hurdles and stable debut at Sedgefield when well backed, in what probably wasn't the strongest of races, and I picked him last time at Newcastle on heavy ground under a penalty when he was up against Navajo Pass (who was worn down only close home under his penalty, and also runs here) and some other much higher-rated recruits off the Flat, and he wasn't good enough.
So unless the better ground makes a difference, it's hard to see where the improvement is going to come from, and not surprisingly he's been put in as the outsider of the six runners.

The intriguing one is French import Tombee Du Ciel, who's being pitched into a Grade 2 on his debut for Nicky Henderson, with James Reveley over to ride him, and no surprise that he has been put in the short-priced favourite.

Lord Lamington was the beneficiary at Market Rasen when the heavily backed Zoffee made one mistake too many, but he travelled well through the race despite the doubt about soft ground based on his Flat form, and who knows, maybe he'd have won whatever.

No selection

The bad news is I probably will be posting selections for the other two 3YO races Cry
Page 9 of 12  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com