We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
My main concern with this issue is in terms of bookmaker compliance, hence my earlier reference to the potential for kicking any suggested solution into the long grass however reasonable it might seem.
Being without any knowledge of the potential procedure for change and the hurdles that would need to be negotiated on the way to implementation, wouldn't something have to be added to the wording of the terms of compliance regarding the granting of bookmaker licenses? And, if so, wouldn't that involve legislation and therefore parliamentary time? |
|
By:
Well, HBF sure has no ability to compel bookmakers to act in a certain fashion. But it can attempt to persuade them to do so, in the belief that some of what has gone on has been counter-productive to more than just those bookmakers' erstwhile customers. And it can lobby bodies like the UKGC and the APPG on Racing & Breeding (both of which would be very likely to ask in the first place "have you talked to bookmakers, and provided evidence, about this?") to this end.
One thing that has been "achieved" in recent months is that account restrictions and closures, and individual bookmakers' relationships with the sport more widely, have been flushed into the open. And it is quite clear that some of those bookmakers hate the disinfectant which comes with exposure to sunlight. They may wish to avoid more of the same. We shall see. Have to dash. |
|
By:
OK, thanks Prufrock.
I currently have this image in my mind of Phillip Davies standing up in the Commons and talking all day to filibuster any attempt to bring his paymasters on side. His record of opposing worthy changes to legislation is a morally dubious one at best. |
|
By:
![]() ![]() ![]() If I ever feel a bit demoralised about all this - and it certainly happens - I remind myself of that particular individual and that motivates me. ;-) |
|
By:
Lol!
|
|
By:
Good work prufrock.
The SPRC should be asked why they allow conflicting shows from SIS and Turf.As the shows are supposedly from the ring,then there shouldn't be variations on the same horses. |
|
By:
Siralex - and others: if you want change re placing bets then get legislation to change it - this has happened in NSW Australia- and we will get change here if everyone gets actively involved
my earlier post on this thread refers please sign and promote the petition for change: if t worked for Will Hills etc elsewhere- it can work in the uk- please sign up : https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/126319 |
|
By:
I'm with those who think legislative change is a pre requisite of change. I just don't see that the b/m can be "encouraged" to to anything that might adversely affect their bottom line.
When all the procrastination, obfuscation and dissembling have been exhausted the b/m will hide behind the "fiduciary duty to shareholders defence". That's why a legal change is required. The egregious Philip Davies will no doubt endeavour to filibuster any attempt I expect. |
|
By:
The HBF and their "diplomatic" approach will amount to 0 I'm afraid.
Of course some Bookmakers will "indicate their willingness to engage". Getting them to actually take a decent bet is an entirely different matter. Stalling tactics, I think is the phrase. |
|
By:
Presumably those bookmakers who have indicated they are not willing to engage think "stalling tactics" are unnecessary.
We have had expert advice on these matters, and have discussed the appropriate approach at length between ourselves. If this does not work then we have other options. Leave it with us. |
|
By:
OK guys we're at about 820 replies. Can we get it to 1000 by Tuesday please? I'm on analysis duty then.
|
|
By:
It's fair enough that people want to vent their spleen at shoddy practices but they also need to understand the need for due process. The Judge didn't stick the black cap on as the defendant was walked in to the dock. First comes the allegation which has been made in this instance. Then comes the evidence gathering. This is the stage the HBF appear to be at. It is in all our interests to give them the ammunition they need to take it to the next stage of laying the actual evidence before the accused. It doesn't really matter how they behave at that stage. In fact the more intransigent they are the better because he who seeks equity should come with clean hands. The end of this process must inevitably be pressure brought to bear on the legislature but that can only happen after the due process I referred to earlier.
As has been pointed out it has happened in Australia and the sun still continued to rise. So let's not get side tracked with Tommy said this or Bobby didn't do that. Let's do our own bit to help facilitate change. Negativity is corrosive and self defeating. |
|
By:
Tweet, email, blog, talk down the pub but get it up to 1,000
|
|
By:
The racing press do nothing to report that the books only want losing customers. The HBF and the rulers in racing and the racing world know exactly what is going on. The government are not going to be too impressed with this situation and will find it difficult to do the job for them given that the more the books win the more they get.
|
|
By:
@rayman are the books winning more and the government receiving more.? Many of the winners or even perceived future winners closed down today would become losers on balance if given the chance to continue.The Australian Gov acted has this decreased there revenue.? None of us know exactly what's going on because we do not know the true numbers involved.Only the bookmakers concerned can provide this information.I do not expect that they will but i also think people would be shocked by the size if they where forced to.
The more of us who campaign or become actively involved as per this threads survey then the more more impressed the Gov will be because they may have to be.? |
|
By:
Greenhill-The Government must be asking the question though. Is it not very strange that the leaders are not even commenting on this issue.
Total silence form the Top and forget the journalists in the nationals who have had success on many campaigns. The Post have lost all the principles that a dedicated paper should be addressing you can only assume that they have been threatened by their providers. |
|
By:
rayman - I agree so the last hope becomes ourselves.If we work collectively given encouragement and guidance then i believe we can bring some change.I can well understand the frustrations and cynicism but lets all at least give it a go.
![]() |
|
By:
Bump
|
|
By:
All against someone who lost 10's of thousands for 20 years of my gambling life and now cant try and win it back.
Its a disgrace. A member is good enough to share the above.How many to a lesser extent have experienced similar treatment.An account which is still losing long term on balance gets restricted because the customer enjoys a little purple patch.No wonder people feel angry. |
|
By:
greenhill - I do not want to take this off on a tangent but all siralex does is bet pricewise/tipsters (probably dirty each ways in the tipsters) and mostly the night before.
As much as I want the books to lay advertised prices (shouldn't be advertised if they don't want to lay it), even I don't expect them to lay hundreds to a single customer on those horses, and then walk to the next shop to try again and again. Anyone who bets the night before in all honesty gets what they deserve, there are ricks everyday, but if you take them at 6pm the day before you are marking their card and also your own account for pennies. I rarely bet the night before as it is pointless imo unless it is the festivals/top class racing, betting a selling handicap hurdle the day before will do your account no favours whatsoever (or in shop). |
|
By:
Hi MD Cheers for the info and i agree your points.As the HBF attempt to engage with the Bookmakers perhaps this is an aspect they could investigate on our behalf.Assuming a small minority will make a long term profit would the Bookmakers be willing to inform us what is acceptable business under these circumstances.
Many years ago winning accounts where not always closed or made SP only when deemed fair business ie the customer was seen to be betting off his own judgement and effort and not attempting snides.I know FOBTs EPs and other aspects have changed but it would be nice to know. |
|
By:
I think we start losing this argument if we start justifying what the Bookmakers do. If they don't want to take bets overnight, don't put prices up - if you don't want to take "dirty" each way bets price up accordingly.
I have never followed Pricewise, only tinkered with some tipsters (some time ago) but have used each-way possibilities for more than 50 years until I give up that strategy several years ago (because bookies were pricing up defensively and then because I had no accounts left). Ultimately the issue is that bookmakers are discriminating against those they perceive will not lose bundles to them. What strategies people use is a side issue and bookmakers have shown they are quite capable of dealing with these without discrimination. |
|
By:
I agree with that, I would be more than happy with no overnight prices. I would also be happy if this place didn't open markets up until 11am etc, but the books get marked for pennies and this place seem to think that if a market is open for a longer time they generate more commission which is ridiculous.
But I do think that you cannot realistically expect a book to take thousands on a pricewise horse per person, when there is no way of actually making a book etc. The trouble is most of the books don't have decent compilers anymore since the inception of the cash cow that is FOBTs, so they are not willing to risk anything - even if they are laying under the odds. |
|
By:
The trouble is most of the books don't have decent compilers anymore since the inception of the cash cow that is FOBTs,
As much or maybe more since this place used to have good liquidity overnight and they thought this would be a an everlasting free tissue. |
|
By:
Magic - But I do think that you cannot realistically expect a book to take thousands on a pricewise horse per person, when there is no way of actually making a book etc
No I don't and if they set limits (value, time or both) then fine but let it apply to everyone (albeit that big losers will be allowed to circumvent it). |
|
By:
Agree 100%, I was mainly referring to the way siralex punts, in that he thinks it's his right to have as much on as possible on everything he wants at overnight and early prices.
|
|
By:
What does it matter how anyone else punts?
We need to work on the principle that if a price is advertised, then it should be available to ALL, no matter what time of day or night, and to a pre determined minimum liability. What we have now is a situation whereby overnight prices are available to but a select few. Just have a read of Birchy's diary in the RFO.......it's enough to make you puke. |
|
By:
What the hell does it matter how I punt ??? I have found a way of trying to beat the bookie and get some of my fortunes lost back. I haven't followed price wise for nearly 2 years now. There are thousands of tipsters out there online, in papers, on here, on the Internet, etc etc. I spent almost 3 years tracking who was good at making a long term profit and then narrowed it down and followed them. Some involved overnight betting some didn't.
The point is that I lost nearly 6 figures and have won about a third of that back over a 4 year period. I have lost a load the last year as have nowhere to bet except on betfair. I didn't put hundreds on, i also never bet dodgy each way and I certainly didn't do any Arbing! I wanted £50ew or £100 win, hardly massive bets. But because I bet singles, follow tipsters, make a profit, beat sp and don't bet on their casino sites I am banned everywhere. |
|
By:
Good god how easily you are all distracted. A question for Mr TILLEY or PRUFOCK. When you were all round the table and decided to have a survey what form did the discussion take with regard to publicizing it?. I have this naive vision of each one of you stating 'well I can do so and so' or 'I can get in touch with this guy'. Now at any point did any look at Tanya and say, 'Tanya you have a strong online TV Twitter etc presence can you announce it via all or at least some of these mediums ?'.
If this venture is to fail it is because the vast majority of people are still unaware of it. Trust me the vast majority of affected punters have no idea this survey exists. |
|
By:
siralex - anyone who punts overnight gets marked, it is the quickest and easiest way to get an account gone in double quicktime, every punter knows this. Also if you follow tipsters that beat SP you know your fate with the books before you start following and betting them. The books know you are following them by your betting, so as soon as you open another account in someone elses name and place exactly the same bets you are gone again. You have to put other bets through accounts, other sports, a few mug bets, take a shorter price with them now and again. It may cost you a few quid, but in the long run it is the price you pay to keep an account open that bit longer.
|
|
By:
The more you all whine and groan about individual examples the more the those that want to see this venture fail rub their hands. Keep the survey underpublicised and claim that only a small handful of punters whinging about there own self interest have been found. The way forward is to show that the current state of affairs is to the detriment of Racing. A new model with racing income not tied to Profit but turnover and some rules that allow interested punters to take part instead of being turned away ie minimum liability aka Australia, is a model that would encourage more newcomers to join and stay within the sport. This has to benefit Racing not a bunch of selfish gits (myself included) whinging on here.
|
|
By:
magic_daps, you just don't get it do you?
Yes, we all know the current situation...........it's precisely that which we are trying change. The point is, if a Bookmaker prices an event up, then that price should be available to ALL......not a select few. It shouldn't matter what time of day you bet, or what you are punting on. The principle is, there should be no discrimination. |
|
By:
I know that, the point is there is no point bleating about the closed/restricted accounts. If you bet in that way they will be gone and that is the current situation. I am hardly saying the books are right in what they do am I, quite the opposite.
|
|
By:
![]() |
|
By:
Its not like the bookies say, well u cant bet on overnight prices, but we will allow u to bet after midday on the day if the race or even at sp, they restrict u at sp as well!!! Not only that they stop u betting on other sports, i cant bet on the football this evening unless i use betfair or go to the shops and even then they have to phone my £5 correct score bets through!!! And as for betting on golf at say 66/1 thats impossible!!!!
|
|
By:
Is this survey still active ?
|
|
By:
Ends today I believe.
|
|
By:
Well at least they'll have had their eyes opened a bit as being in their positions they wouldn't have experienced what the rest of us have trying to place a bet! Only shame is there'll be so many that have given up long ago and grown tired of it all that they won't get the FULL picture but hopefully they have enough info to go to war with
|
|
By:
Do you think Tanya gets restricted fatlad, or will she be accommodated like Birchy?
|
|
By:
done
|