We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
Good morning stevetilley.
Admirable that the HBF are finally getting their act together regarding restrictions and closures, but how does this fit with your own personal view that "bookmakers are entitled to do whatever they want"? Just wondered ![]() |
|
By:
Good morning Stevetilley another member Paul Haigh has pre empted you by also starting a thread on your survey.I have asked why limit to past six months which prevents myself and many others from participating.I wish to give my help and support but with respect you make this difficult.
|
|
By:
@IDKW as the current rules stand they can do what they like! They have their responsibility to their shareholders and will act accordingly. It doesn't mean it's right it's a description of where we are.
|
|
By:
@greenhill It is better to get up to date data to apply pressure however the survey has been amended so it you complete the first six month section you will be taken to a section where you can comment and put in the long term position. Hope this helps. We do try to listen
|
|
By:
Thank you Steve will do so now.
|
|
By:
The fact that Tanya has not mentioned this via CH4 or her blogs Racegoers etc and the Post has not felt it worthy of informing its readership tells it all.
|
|
By:
Do not expect Tanya to jepordise her lucrative position by helping punters. The survey does not work too well in Chrome by the way but I managed to fill it in. Everyone should get on board with this and give it a go or shut up forever about closures
|
|
By:
Tweet, blog, wear a T shirt but please get the word around on this survey. Do not expect the Racing Post to mention it or C4 racing
|
|
By:
Steve, make it clear that problems prior to 6 months can be added at the end. In other words state this on the first page to avoid readers saying 'oh this does concern me because I gave up on racing 3 years ago'
|
|
By:
I don't do all that social media stuff, but can someone please tweet Tanya and either ask for her stance on the situation or ask her to at least promote the fact there is a survey that can be filled in. Otherwise the cynics will always think that the HBF will never do anything for punters. I do in fact have a bit of sympathy for stevetilley, as at least he seems genuine and wants to try and do something proactive.
|
|
By:
i done it.it will be intresting if it gets any publicity etc..when its ocompleted
|
|
By:
It'll be interesting to see who's promoting the survey and who isn't as I mentioned earlier on the other thread I couldn't find anyone from thbf pushing it on twitter,hopefully that will/has change(d).
|
|
By:
geegeez are promoting it.id consider them reputable.
|
|
By:
I've said before on another thread that I thought Matt was genuine and he responded honestly to a few of us on here despite criticism (from myself initially) so that's good to hear.Let's hope others follow suit
|
|
By:
I have worked with Steve Tilley on betting conferences and can echo the sentiments that his engagement with this will be wholly from a punters perspective. I share some concern of others for one or two other members of the betting forum however, but I will be happy to be proved wrong should they at least come forward and mention the survey. This is an extremely newsworthy action and in an ideal world you would expect the RP to write a short article but of course we all know that is unlikely to happen. It is up to us to not only get behind this but spread the word, it can fail for a number of reasons and the first one is that the media's determination to keep it quite means that small numbers fill in the survey
|
|
By:
I know people are very jaundiced and cynical about anything getting done but at least we then have some ammunition to explain to some people in racing that closures and restrictions of accounts will be harmful to racing
Steve, with the greatest of respect, 'some people in racing' all have a vested interest in bookmaker profitability. The BHA get a share of the bookmaking industry's profits, not turnover, so, unequivocally, racing benefits from the restrictions. Obscenely, many, many members of the media are bookmaker side-salaried (some of them are on your panel), so they are sending the bookmaking industry their invoices. The business models of the media platforms, like C4, RUK, the RP, ATR etc now rely on the continued patronage of the bookmaking industry in sponsorship and advertising (much of which is spent to ensure their complicity, and the complicity of those who work for them.) The bookmakers have brilliantly created an ecosystem where everyone in this industry now benefits from their continued capacity to remove punters' money. Disenfranchising everyone but non winning punters is now a very successful business model for everyone in this industry, apart from its smartest consumers. I wish you the very best, but I would strongly suspect that when it comes to the bookmaking industry and genuine change the clearly well intentioned non media people on this forum are just being invited to act out a punters' version of Waiting for Godot... |
|
By:
My sentiments precisely, but stated with superior eloquence.
|
|
By:
I agree with millhouse BUT it has got to the point where they are restricting and closing accounts after 2 or 3 bets. There is no way they can know these accounts will not be profitable longterm after a couple of bets (unless it's a new account using same IP address etc).
What they cannot see is (or just don't care) is nobody will be betting on racing in years to come, as not one single new young punter/gambler will bet on it - why would they? The stories are rife now that you are not allowed to win at horse racing, therefore anyone with half a brain will go and bet on football/cricket/tennis/golf etc. All are growing markets - and easy pickings for the books. The current personnel at the BHA are on huge, ridiculous salaries and no doubt massive pensions, they won't jeopardise any of that for the sake of the future of the same sport they have basically stolen a salary from. They will still get their massive pensions as the proverbial hits the fan, and it will not make a jot of difference to any of them (in my opinion of course). |
|
By:
superb from millhouse
|
|
By:
''The BHA get a share of the bookmaking industry's profits, not turnover, so, unequivocally, racing benefits from the restrictions.''
I'd hazard a guess that the vast majority of those suffering restrictions/closures will be losers in the medium/ long term. So racing doesn't benefit from the restrictions overall : they are reducing future levy payments and killing interest in horse race betting. The bookies squealed in New South Wales when they were forced to reopen closed accounts and lay everyone to take out the equivalent of £1000 at quoted prices. In fact they discovered that a majority of the previously closed /restricted accounts turned out to be profitable to them. The vast majority of punters will always lose : they don't keep records, the bet when p*ssed,they do ludicrous multiples and most of all ....they chase losses. Closing/restricting punters because they have a lucky spell or manage to back some losers which shorten in price is short sighted by them and damages racings income from sharing in their future losses going forwards. |
|
By:
@Sir Epicure Mammon your above is well said.We will only bring change if we work collectively and part of this would be to get those not currently restricted on board.Re the law in NSW my understanding is that this was down to UK firms attempting the same tactics there as they use here.Yet they remain there.?
|
|
By:
Which would be more lucrative to Racing and even to Bookmakers
1. Restrict and close all punters that beat prices and show any inkling of a brain and hence see the betting turnover shrink as existing punters turn away and new punters do not arrive. Kind of like a greater ROI but lower turnover 2. Allow an Aussie type system where winners allowed to certain individual bet liabilities. Winners now feel free to be more visible which in turn encourages new players into the sport who of course in the majority will lose. Net result lower ROI but much greater turnover = greater profit than option 1 In many ways the above scenario is rather like betting on here V betting with bookmakers. With Bookmakers you can make a greater ROI but you cannot get much on if anything at all. When you switch to bet on here you have to learn that ROI will shrink so turnover must be vastly increased. |
|
By:
Bump!
|
|
By:
It's a ridiculous state of affairs.
My records show that 8-12 years ago, it was possible to get £2k/£200 with any of the bigboys with little or no problem. Laddies in particular were more than accommodating. This all at early prices evening before/morning of race. Clearly they were making money then, and were able to absorb the winners, like a true "bookmaker" should. So, what changed? FOBT's, that's what. Until these damned things are heavily restricted ( how ironic) or done away with altogether, we will never see the return of "Bookmakers". |
|
By:
thats not totaally true either idkw.pee pees restricted me in 2009 and there is no fobs in ireland. the bastids are just greedy.whats needed is a challange to there licences to practice bookmaking. let them open up amusment arcades or casinos instead if they come out with we just want the recreational types.
|
|
By:
IKDW, I would also suggest it's worth considering that 12 years ago the Racing Post was owned by the Mirror Group, which, whatever you thought of it back then, was at least a proper newspaper. I can remember it giving the bookmaking industry a difficult time on many occasions, and it didn't fear taking on the establishment, as seen in the Fallon/Ramsden trial.
Now, having been bought by a private equity firm, in which I would bet big money William Hill were among the investors, it's a totally different animal that's only really interested in generating revenue streams, to the point where the news content is virtually entirely propaganda (and it's exactly the same with the new media that followed it, RUK, ATR and C4) The bookmakers therefore know that, unlike in the past, as long as they keep paying the ££££££ to these media organisations, they can do what they like when it comes to their customers, and it will never be questioned or reported by anyone... |
|
By:
Nail on the head there again millhouse..
Has anyone heard from Tanya yet regarding this? As many cynics are out there regarding the HBF - surely it was put together to at least help (or try to) help punters, unless I am missing something. If the people on the forum are not advertising this survey (apart from Steve) what are punters meant to actually think about the members representing punters?? All of them should be trying to get to the bottom of this episode for the future of racing - or have the rest of the board not taken enough out of the game yet? What has the head of the BHA has to say about the group so far, and maybe he could give a view about the longterm effect of the account restrictions/closures himself? Possibly he could promote it himself to engage with punters.... |
|
By:
The silence, Steve T aside, is ominous.
Especially from Tanya S who has the platform of an established media presence from which to preach yet seemingly remains mute. |
|
By:
Check their twitter pages as Matt Bisogno and Simon Rowlands have the link on theirs not sure about the others
|
|
By:
Is this the same Tanya that appears on C4 with an endless stream of bookmaker PR reps and just invites them to spew their lies without so much as questioning a single word they say?
|
|
By:
There is also a twitter page https://twitter.com/HbfBritain/with_replies
|
|
By:
Yes millhouse; it's why she was such an obvious pick to represent punters.
|
|
By:
As much as plenty were against them at the start a fair few gave them the benefit of the doubt when Steve came on and actually said what was what, and that he was certainly not any puppet for them.
I can understand why the bookie reps won't be promoting any change, but how the likes of Tanya etc are not is nothing short of a disgrace imo. I honestly never thought I would get to the point where I thought McCririck could actually do something for punters (rather than shout nonsense). |
|
By:
I welcome the survey but despite stevetilleys case that last six months is more relevant i still believe that it should have been past five years all in or perhaps from the date that the FOBTs where allowed.This would give a truer picture and a better understanding of how many are penalized in this way.It has now been changed to allow prior to past six months as an addition but which fig will be presented.?
One of the first stated objectives by the HBF was to engage with the Bookmakers in order to establish the full extent of the problem and i would ask Steve how goes this.? Once we have a proper idea of the numbers involved and i suspect its many thousands then we would be better placed to organise some mass collective action because this is what it will take to bring change.It will also take publicity and i agree the above posts Re TS being well placed to assist in this yet so far reluctant to do so. I would thank Steve for at least using this place to keep us part informed because imo the HBF offer poor communication the excuse for this increasingly being that they cannot spare or are not prepared to give there free time to do so if this is the case i would respectfully suggest that those who feel this way should step down.I still wish to support you but you make this difficult. |
|
By:
Keep the entries coming chaps. If the last 6 months clause worries you just apply your last 5 years experience to the 6 months question. I agree the last 5 years or more should have applied to the single question
|
|
By:
There is space to put any comments on the second page, you can mention past 6 months etc (I mentioned FOBTs on my submission). It was never going to all be in punters favour due to the bookie reps on the forum. It's at least a start, small steps and all that...
Is Tanya advertising this yet or has she firmly nailed her colours to the gravy train? I did put something similar up a minute ago but it has disappeared.. Keep them coming and pass it on to anyone who has had accounts closed. |
|
By:
bookies wud drop horse racing from their shops in an instant, the product is dead on the high street, they just want fob money, it's a guaranteed winner for them ****s
|
|
By:
I wanted to bump this thread so that it does not disappear.@stevetilley please update us on the numbers who have now participated also your thoughts on how many will be needed to give you enough of the ammunition you seek to make the survey effective.
|
|
By:
The books can have a figure in seconds from their databases on the exact numbers of restrictions/closures - why won't they just disclose it? Is it because the number is ridiculously high and would probably make a decent piece in a newspaper?
|