We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
Steve Tilley, and others, seem to think this is a new phenomenon and that older punters experiences are not relevant.
I can send him copies of numerous 'Dear John' letters from credit bookmakers ending our relationship, most dating back to the mid nineties, all of which make much of reassuring me that this is a trading decision and nothing to do with my credit worthiness. Bookmakers have better technology these days to identify those whose accounts dont provide the required profitability to the company. This has merely extended their modus operandi and not repositioned it. The refusal to do business with winning punters has always been an unwritten rule of high street bookmakers who are, incidently, licensed by the government on behalf of the racing industry to make a book and are expected to make a profit from the resulting overround irrespective of who backs the winner. The fact that the 'rule' is unwritten tells you that it is totally at odds with the issuing of licences and that the bookmakers know it. The fact that the powers that be have never challenged this well known status quo tells you that whatever Steve and his colleagues recommend will at best be kicked into the long grass despite the likely official statements of gratitude for their extensive efforts. |
|
By:
And the Dear John letters themselves provide in black and white all the evidence required to nail this unacceptable practice.
|
|
By:
If it end in the long grass lets make sure that the world knows about it
|
|
By:
If we can maintain interest and momentum then we can set the long grass on fire.I still say that the HBF should be communicating more frequently with those who wish to support them but another is emerging Punters For Justice and based on what i have seen so far i think and hope that they will enable this.
|
|
By:
My typo its justiceforpunters.org They have a forum its worth a look.
|
|
By:
One other point that needs repeating. We must expect negative comments on this thread from bookmaker sympathizers. Their job is to make you feel that any protest is pointless and hence deflate the initiative. You must learn to recognize the bookmaker rep's on here who will doing anything in their power to get you to lie down and accept the status quo. They would like nothing better than for this to quitely disappear. The worse thing that can happen for them is change, the second worse thing is no change but a hell of a lot of fuss and bad publicity.
On Saturday it will be the biggest day of the year for casual once a year punters. I challenge you to go up to a cross sample and ask them this question. 'Do you know that when bookmakers find out that you are non losing punter or are even one for shopping around for best prices they will refuse your bets'. You will see that not only are they unaware of this they are also shocked. There response is usually 'how can this be' |
|
By:
@OliasOfSunhillow your above well said.
|
|
By:
'Do you know that when bookmakers find out that you are non losing punter or are even one for shopping around for best prices they will refuse your bets'. You will see that not only are they unaware of this they are also shocked. There response is usually 'how can this be'
The usual respons is "they can't do that can they". Most people who do not bet think you can just walk in a bookies and have a grand on anything you want - then again most of these have only listened to the lies that are peddled out by their reps on the tv (NAP). |
|
By:
Magic Daps, you've hit the nail on the head - the heart of the problem is that the bookmaking industry are freely allowed to misrepresent themselves to the general public, because virtually every last one of the people working in the racing and betting media is either bookmaker side salaried or trough deep in Birchy style 'advantages'.
It's not really the bookmakers who are the real issue - they are smart enough businesses that would be forced to quickly adapt if the PR was damaging enough to them - the problem is the fact that the racing and betting media are corrupt... |
|
By:
Unashamed bump
|
|
By:
Your bump is good but i would have hoped that an HBF member would have done so via up dating us on how many have participated in the survey.?
|
|
By:
Maybe C4 racing and Tanya will highlight the survey this morning!!!
In fact a start would be if they highlighted that HBF existed - but even that's not going to happen. |
|
By:
You can have 100/1 from me Oasis.
Truly it shows what contempt the gravy trainers have for punters that they won't mention the issue of closures or restrictions at all whilst happily allowing the reprehensible PR merchants as much air time to peddle their lies as they can get away with. |
|
By:
Parispike i e mailed C4 advising that i would no longer be watching because of the reason you give of course this will make no difference yet if all who have been restricted did so who knows.I have also read that said Bookmaker Reps pay to be allowed the air time.If this is correct it something else which needs investigating.
|
|
By:
If Bookmaker do pay for their reps to have air time then there is a strong argument that the "Product Placement" banner should feature.
|
|
By:
They all pay for the airtime, either through sponsorship or advertising during the programming.
RUK were shameless in admitting this, when they supported the BHA's recent Authorised Betting Partner deadlock with the bookmaking industry, by saying they were refusing to take the money from the non ABP bookmakers to appear in the coverage. On C4, it seems to be the advertisers in the commercial breaks that get to take turns to lie about they way they operate, obscenely, with BHA punters forum member Tanya Stevenson. Betting product placement is indeed against OFCOM rules, according to their website: "The product placement of tobacco, alcohol, gambling, foods or drinks that are high in fat, salt or sugar, medicines and baby milk is banned by UK legislation. The rules state that product placement must not impair broadcasters' editorial independence and must always be editorially justified". |
|
By:
Just to let you know my personal target for the survey is over 1000 replies which we are well on the way to. I'd like to reiterate to Loper and others I certainly know that this has being going on for a long while however immediacy of data is important. There is opportunity for those long term account sufferers to comment in the survey. We have also as the HBF being in contact with a number of bookmakers concerning this issue it has been interesting comparing the replies so far received to the results of the survey so far and our prior knowledge of the situation.
|
|
By:
Hi stevetilley "well on the way" quoting the exact number would be helpful and perhaps more encouraging for those yet to participate.If or when your personal target of 1000 replies is met may i ask how you intend to use it.Has the Racing Post been informed of the survey has any publicity been actively sought and generated other than on here.
There are still people who wish to support the HBF but imo your communication is found wanting and causes a decline in interest plus an increase in the fears you express in your OP.This will please the Bookmakers concerned.Your group have started there own forum why not use it for more regular up dates and also allow interested people to post as this would bring all together in one place. |
|
By:
As of this message 792. The racing post has been contacted with sadly little apparent effect. One of the problems we have with resticted accounts is that various stakeholders in racing (Yes I am being deliberately vague here because we can't go round upsetting people we want on our side in the future) either don't believe they exist, or if they do they are only affect a few professional punters and will have no effect on the interest in horse race betting and the resultant returns to racing. The purpose of the survey is to show the incidence of account restrictions, the effect this has on peoples interest on horse racing, why peoples accounts are restricted according to both the bookmakers and punters, how many bets does it take to restrict an account and to collect anecdotal and verbal evidence from punters. It is this last one I feel actually carries most weight in some ways as the views expressed are generally not just the usual "bookmakers are scum and won't take a bet" posts but offer concern for horse racing itself rather than their own financial interests.
The website has only just come on line and more interaction will hopefully follow in due course. |
|
By:
@stevetilley thanks for your above.
|
|
By:
Stevetilly, perhaps screenshots of refusals of £10 steak as "too high" and an offer of pennies would have some effect and prove that restriction is rife. Many on here could supply you with examples of this daily.
|
|
By:
*Stake
![]() |
|
By:
The restrictions is a massive problem and not just to winners (which is becoming more apparent). Even if it was just professionals that they banned/restricted, those professionals would not encourage a single person to bet on the sport in the future (most of who would end up being longterm losers) - they would be doing the exact opposite.
The argument that they only ban these so called pros does not hold any water whatsoever, a lot of the books restrict punters and even close them after literally a handful of bets (ie BF Sportsbook, boils, Fred, Sport bet, Lads) even if they are losing accounts that have managed to beat the SP. As I have said before you could stick a pin in the paper and beat the SP more times than not imo, so it is just an easy way out of not accepting a bet by anyone who doesn't go to their casinos/games or chase a loss straight away. The bottom line is if a book is top priced on a horse and you take it you are marked and do it again and you are restricted - years ago a book would be top price because they would want to take money on the actual horse. The books are no longer bookmakers at all in any sense and that is what is killing the sport. The sport is on its' knees and interest is declining hugely - and as much as I think Steve is trying, you need the rest of the HBF to have the same views for change, rather than some getting paid by the industry. |
|
By:
Some members of the HBF stand accused of a conflict of interest,presumably the BHA where aware of the potential for this prior to choosing them and i now wonder if this was done with purpose.? It does appear that stevetilley stands alone.This survey is a first and positive step and it would be good to note other HBF members posting thier thoughts and support.
|
|
By:
Steve - I agree with the posters above. You really need other HBF members to actively promote and support not just the ongoing survey but the forum as a whole. Their silence is deafening.
There are folks on here that really want to support your initiatives but the conflicts of interest and silence from other HBF members tells us everything we need to know. It must be most frustrating for you. What do you feel they are bringing to the party on the account closures / restrictions issue? |
|
By:
Tanya brings precisely nowt, must be proud of herself.
|
|
By:
Surely if the BHA don't think there is an issue regarding restrictions/closures they should advertise this survey as well, to at least try and get the true reflection. It seems to me that they just don't want the truth, it should be in the Racing Post and should be on each members social media page(s) etc.
Anyone contacted any newspapers (Guardians Greg Wood could be a good call)? |
|
By:
It's IMPOSSIBLE for everyone in racing to be unaware because if bookmakers were acting fairly and the same to all NO OWNERS OR TRAINERS COULD GET ANY MONEY ON WITHOUT BEING IMMEDIATELY RESTRICTED.Can anyone imagine Sir Mark Prescott setting one up for a big h'cap,logging on and trying to get a few grand on at 12's only to be to told £0.10 MAX.There would be an outcry.Clearly those within racing can still bet and us on the outside (who've helped to fund the game for years) are discriminated against despite being in an unfavourable postion.Bookmakers must be lying to the BHA and connections that can bet MUST be keeping quiet.
|
|
By:
Guardian crew wood he's too busy helping his buddy buddy **** Geoff I'm a plonker banks take on the world
|
|
By:
If this survey took off and people were filling it in who wasn't restricted and the numbers went above the actual amount restricted, the books would then be a bit quicker to provide some information. As they all know that it won't be promoted by the ones so say trying to provide some change and actions, the books have nothing to fear.
|
|
By:
Just to show how bookmakers discriminate....
I've had about 60-70 accounts closed or restricted, but there is only one that I can still use, despite having been closed by the same firm on a number of other occasions. The reason this account still exists, was because over 3 years ago I talked to a rep via twitter, who had the account re-opened. I've had no problem since. This proves that they differentiate between punters, can can override their "traders decisions" if it suits them. They probably think I'm a racing celebrity ! I'm deliberately not naming names, because I want to keep this account. |
|
By:
I and I suspect most who have contributed are grateful to Steve Tilley for what he done so far. However and it's a huge however the whole credibility of the HBF for me (and others?) is adversely affected by the inclusion of people with links to and/or on their "payroll" (I use "" to signify that payroll includes people paid by as well as technically employed by) bookmakers. Quite what the rationale for their inclusion was is beyond me.
If evidence were required, the deafening silence of Tanya Stevenson, media platform already in situ, on the matter of the HBF survey says everything. It analogous to foxes being invited on to the committee set up to protect chickens. There's only one result that will be of any use to affected punters and that is the BHA as part of their ABP criteria insisting that IF a bookmakers wishes to offer a price they MUST lay it to a realistic and reasonable sum to any punter. The amount would be flexible dependent on race status/level but £250 would be my view of a minimum level. I do not think it reasonable to insist on prices being available hours before the race but if the b/m wishes to quote them that is the quid pro quo. If the BHA will not support such a position we will know that the creation of the forum is naught but a smokescreen and that change will never happen. I'm not holding my breath. Steve - what say you? |
|
By:
on their "payroll" - should be on the "payroll" of
|
|
By:
One suggestion lets keep all of our thoughts on the HBF and account restrictions on this thread.Others have been started containing good posts and they then get buried and forgotten which will please the Bookmakers.This would be an additional way of giving stevetilley the ammunition he requires.?
We where informed that the HBF was implemented to help us so they should be accountable to us but the bottom line being it was a BHA initiative done on the cheap.I recall the days when racing was run by the Jockey Club with us punters being seen as a necessary evil.The BHA where supposed to change this attitude yet based on what we are now witnessing our plight is far worse and nothing is changing. |
|
By:
In terms of conflict of interest, Tanya seems to be getting the worst of the criticism yet the chairman, who one would assume would be most visible in terms of broadcasting the forum's intention to champion punters rights, is no where to be seen.
But then his full time job working for Paddy Power Bookmakers must keep him fully occupied. |
|
By:
A good point well made loper. I had forgotten that connection!
|
|
By:
Does anyone else think that the forum meeting once a quarter is insufficient? I'm sure various issues are being worked on in the background but meeting four times per year doesn't allow much time for progress. Call me sceptical but isn't that what the BHA and bookmakers want, i.e. little progress.
Maybe other forum members aside from Steve would like to interact on this thread? Time for a tweet....... |
|
By:
if they read this thread, the entire forum will jack it in tomorrow, which will ensure litle progress for you
![]() |
|
By:
Hi there.
I am Simon Rowlands, Chair of HBF. I used to be very active on here - as old-timers will recall - but have many more calls on my time these days and have deferred to Steve Tilley to engage on here on HBF's behalf, which I appreciate greatly. A significant call on my time is HBF work. I am currently in communication on behalf of HBF with, among others: SPRC, BHA, RCA, IBAS, and am attempting (so far have failed) to establish contact on behalf of HBF with the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Racing & Breeding and the UK Gambling Commission. I am also representing HBF in seeking to make contact with a number of CEOs of large betting companies regarding the very issue this thread started about - account restrictions and closures - and I answer some, but not all, of the correspondence HBF receives from the public. I do this as a freelance racing/betting analyst, having left Timeform the day before the merger between Paddy Power and Betfair. "Loper" would seem to be unaware of this, or of the fact that I have been championing punters' rights for decades and have been very active on Twitter about HBF in recent months. I would appreciate if his future comments about me reflected that reality. A few other points: Racing Post mentioned the existence of this survey when it came out, which was only a week or so ago; no members of the Forum are on the staff of bookmakers; when choosing the Forum members, with the assistance of the BHA, I felt strongly that they should be able to interact not only with punters but with those who might be able to solve the problems which punters face; you may have reservations, or stronger, about some of those Forum members, but I am absolutely sure that the ability to understand the betting landscape and tiptoe through the minefield that it involves was desirable; HBF members are collectively behind this survey and other initiatives, but, as individuals, their ability to promote it may be more limited (editors and producers dictate content, not usually writers or broadcasters); Tanya interviewed me about HBF on Channel 4 shortly after it came into existence, so, contrary to what has been stated above, it has been covered there. HBF is not going to get everything right, and I am unlikely to have got everything right in helping to establish it (having lobbied for it extensively until someone - Nick Rust - came in who was finally prepared to do something about it), but Rome was not built in one day. What I would like to establish is something which has relevance and endures long after I as Chair and the other Forum members have moved aside to be replaced by others. Whether "others" will come forward to do something which is unpaid and which can take up a significant amount of time could now be questioned. The endless questioning of motives and performance comes with the territory, but it is proving exceedingly unhelpful when, as is proving to be the case, the same mistruths and misunderstandings keep having to be addressed and corrected. You have an open line of enquiry to the HBF through its e-mail address, and you have an open means for understanding what HBF hopes to achieve, and how it hopes to achieve it, through the HBF website. Please use this, while remembering that the body is unfunded and voluntary, and that each Forum member also has to try to have a life outside such commitments. Incidentally, HBF hopes to have a public day at a racecourse in September, in which Forum members are available to meet the public they seek to represent. I hope some of you come along. Organising this required establishing a good relationship with the racecourse in question, which will be giving up facilities at no cost, and no small amount of correspondence. I personally felt that was a better investment of time and effort than some of the alternatives. Further details will follow in due course, as will details of the various initiatives mentioned above. Simon Rowlands |
|
By:
Hi Simon cheers for your above during which you have shared more detail about The HBF thoughts actions and progress (or even lack of down to negative response by those you have attempted to engage with) than i have seen elsewhere inc on your dedicated sites.I think we are all well aware that building Rome took time but details of the foundations are helpful when shared with those of us who wish to support the build and imo more regular communication as per your above would prove helpful in this respect.
|