Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 175 comments are related to the topic:
HBF survey

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 3 of 5  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 175
By:
Magic__Daps
When: 11 Apr 16 18:02
Thanks for the reply, not sure where or what you will get from the Gambling Commission though, so I wish you well with that one.

I know it is voluntary etc so nobody is expecting over the top communication, and I think people are disappointed that the likes of Tanya cannot even put a post up on Twitter etc at least showing there is a survey for anyone that has been restricted, it comes across to punters that being paid by the books is the priority here.

Hopefully the restrictions/closures will get somewhere with the books, but I do fear the worst and nothing will change as it seems that none of them have any interest in taking bets on the sport anymore (when you cannot get a bet taken with 8 online firms for the National you know there are major issues). You only have to open a new account with ANY of them and then see the deluge of emails promoting ONLY the casino/slots etc. I really would love to be wrong and hope there is some change with the discrimination against punters, but just cannot see it happening, but only time will tell.

Good luck with trying to get some sort of change - you will certainly need it in my opinion.

Hope that doesn't sound too negative!
By:
Magic__Daps
When: 11 Apr 16 18:03
I agree with greenhill regarding communication. Hopefully this thread can stay active.
By:
prufrock
When: 11 Apr 16 18:12
Thanks both. That's useful feedback. I will try to drop in here occasionally. I very much want HBF to make a difference in a tangible way, but simply existing and asking awkward questions alone has its merits. A number of people said they discerned a change in behaviour of some of the aforementioned bodies around the time HBF was created, though that may just be coincidence. You have my word for it that I have cheesed off quite a few individuals in a few of those bodies already :-)
By:
loper
When: 11 Apr 16 18:18
Simon,

apologies for getting your employment status wrong and I appreciate you making yourself known on here and setting the record straight. May I suggest that you update your personal profile on the HBF web page as it was the source of my misinformation.

To be fair to Betfair (and indeed Paddy Power now) this forum has been the main platform open to all and sundry to discuss and air views regarding all things sports betting related. They didn't need to set it up and must have been sorely tempted to shut it down many times since its inception.

It is universally recognised as the first port of call for gauging the mood among racing fans & punters. I would think it a good idea that HBF members should be seen to interact in this environment with those they seek to represent, assuming of course that Betfair/Paddy Power have no objections. It will certainly encourage greater feedback to the HBF which is surely one of its main aims.

As a matter of interest, Simon, were you able to provide  Steve Tilley with some valuable input regarding your own personal experiences of punting  restrictions?
By:
prufrock
When: 11 Apr 16 18:32
Apology accepted. My biographical details are correct on the HBF website. I don't think I can post links on here, but it involves uk hbf and org. That has been in existence for a month or so now. The piece on the BHA's site is a press release from the time HBF was launched and probably needs to remain as it was at the time it was published. Sadly, I will not remain 52 forever; gladly, I will not remain a wage slave forever, either. ;-)

I would dispute that Betfair Forum is "universally recognised as the first port of call for gauging the mood of racing fans & punters". It used to be, but that was before the proliferation of other forums and of social media. It is, nonetheless, important, which is why I appreciate feedback from it, whether personally (I don't always post when I look in) or through Steve.

I have not given Steve Tilley my personal experience of punting restrictions. I have not been restricted by anyone recently but do the vast majority of my betting on Betfair Exchange (and used to do Tote betting quite a bit), anyway. I have been restricted by a few bookmakers going back further. I want this to be about others not about the agendas of those who happen to be on the Forum anyway.
By:
greenhill
When: 11 Apr 16 18:44
Hi @prufrock i no longer use the exchange because of PC but started posting on here because it appeared to be the focus point for discussing HBF and account restrictions and i wished to interact and contribute.You have now created your own dedicated forum which is a positive but do not allow any of us to post on it.I hope this will be reconsidered because it would enable all interested parties to come together in one place which would surely also be helpful to you.?
By:
prufrock
When: 11 Apr 16 18:54
Ideal world = we'd have a Forum people could post to, moderated by HBF members (it would have to be moderated).

Actual world = we'd have to fund this, establish it, and find time to moderate it ad infinitum.

It may happen, some day, but I would not be in favour of dropping other initiatives to make this happen. Something would have to give.

Hope you understand.
By:
greenhill
When: 11 Apr 16 18:59
Thank you for the prompt reply yes i do understand (although do not wish to) There is a good case to put to the BHA that they should fund it.?
By:
prufrock
When: 11 Apr 16 19:13
The BHA helped set us up, and they give us a room if we want it. They have been, and continue to be, helpful. But the intention always was that HBF would be independent of BHA - as refelected in many of our public utterances - and that is the way we have headed. This might be a step in the other direction. But the time might well be a bigger issue than the funding (we managed to set up our own website with no assistance). As I said, not ruled out. But would stop several other things in their tracks if implemented now.
By:
lmfao
When: 11 Apr 16 19:36
Too many members on here have - understandably  - whinged about bookies restricting accounts and exempting them from betting on advertised odds; in Australia the public cried foul - and public protest led to change. Did you know that our biggest bookies cannot now restrict /close accounts in NSW?
If you want this here - please do 2 things:

1. sign the petition
2 get a minimum of 2 others to sign it- and get them each to recruit at least 2 more - and so on.

If YOU do this we'll see some justice for  punters. At the moment bookies only want to take the cream off mug punters and FOBT addicts - when they restrict you, they will not discuss why and hide behind the storyline 'it is a traders decision, it will not be overturned and the person responsible for it will not talk/ discuss with you because he is not customer facing.'

That is a disrespectful and arrogant way to treat customers-a change must be imposed upon the bookies.

Petition
Make UK licensed bookmakers accept bets up to a minimum liability of £1000

It has become a common practice for bookmakers within the UK and those that operate in the UK to restrict or close the account of customers and / or to exempt some customers from participating in advertised promotions or enhanced offers. These widespread practises are unfair and discriminate.

New South Wales, Australia has recognised these inequities and has legislated to introduced the type of regulation we ask for in this petition.

https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/126319


As I type 108 have signed up- but now we need momentum!


can you get this on your other forum?
By:
OliasOfSunhillow
When: 11 Apr 16 19:49
I appreciate the need to let the forum members prove their credibility as punter rep's but there was understandable cynicism when Tanya was appointed. I thought we should all reserve judgement and hopefully she would rub our noses in it as she proved to be a valuable member. With this in mind I expected an opportunity like pushing the survey as a prime opportunity for her to silence the doubters. Tanya has a private Twitter account which enables her to express an opinion. We are not asking her to express an opinion we are simply expecting a tweet to her many followers and I thought she would have made sure to make one in order to silence the doubters. Sadly that has not been the case and she is missing an opportunity to put this doubt to bed.
By:
prufrock
When: 11 Apr 16 19:58
That's a fair point. I cannot speak on behalf of Tanya. I can, however, point out that she has not Tweeted about anything since January 25th.

Twitter just isn't the thing for some people, as others on here have made clear.
By:
IDKW
When: 11 Apr 16 21:00
Apologies prufrock, but let's put this a bit more bluntly.
Tanya is member of the HBF. The HBF was supposedly founded to look after the punter, and his/ her concerns.
Tanya has not yet publicly promoted the HBF survey regarding restrictions.
Tanya is side salaried by Betfred (apparently).

Do you, or indeed the forum as whole, not believe there is a conflict of interest here?
By:
prufrock
When: 11 Apr 16 21:39
HBF was created to represent the perceived interests of the British horseracing betting public, not to be a carbon copy of that public.

Collectively, I believe it does that well, not least because its members represent a wide range of skills and experiences, including the ability to connect with those who might bring about the desired change.

Each and every member is expected to declare any conflict of interest on any subject that comes up and step aside from discussion of that subject if necessary. Any member trying to give an individual bookmaker, or bookmakers in general, a soft time of things would get shot down by others (it has not happened).

Instead, collectively, we are in the process of engaging with several major bookmakers about the matter of restrictions and closures, a decision that Tanya (and every other HBF member) was involved in and details of which will emerge when a few more of those bookmakers get round to responding to our initial approach.

I do not see a conflict of interest here, given the framework in which the Forum is obliged to operate. None of my fellow Forum members has echoed your sentiments.

I won't be discussing the status of named Forum members on here subsequently, but you can contact me through the HBF e-mail address if you wish to take the matter further.
By:
prufrock
When: 11 Apr 16 22:21
I have to go away for a couple of days on family business, and need to try to earn a crust once I get back, so apologies if I do not respond immediately to any further messages on this thread.
By:
greenhill
When: 12 Apr 16 10:15
I want to bump this and keep the thread active.Thank you prufrock for your posts they have been informative and more of the same from yourself or any HBF members would prove helpful in maintaining interest because this will be needed.

The way i view the situation is that by supporting your efforts we are helping ourselves but with respect we should not have to beg for crumbs Re gleaning any progress or even lack of.I do appreciate the time issues but likewise do not feel its unreasonable to expect not just yourself and stevetilley but all or any HBF member to spare 10mins occasionally to keep us updated.

stevetilley how goes the survey have we reached the 1000 mark yet.?
By:
prufrock
When: 13 Apr 16 17:35
One "problem" about the Betfair Forum (or part of its appeal to some no doubt!) is that comments which require a response can be tucked away on a thread that is otherwise about Nicky Henderson or the effect of the draw at Chester. Even something titled "HBF Survey" can get lost against the background noise.

Some of us will try to come on here occasionally, but in return perhaps some of you could alert us to your concerns on Twitter (even if we then come on here to continue the discussion at more length).

Thanks
By:
greenhill
When: 13 Apr 16 18:37
Hi @prufrock i agree and suggest we keep this thread as a one stop place for HBF and account restriction topics but with respect communication is a two way street.Once again i ask stevetilley how close are we to the 1000 participants in the survey which is his target.This would be a good example because this important information should not need to be sought.

Many questions have been asked via different threads on this forum Re HBF yet there has seldom been much response from HBF members i am aware that they do reply to e mails but i feel most are better severed by an open and general response.When this does not happen then people who have a genuine interest lose it and as you say the thread fades into the back ground and gets forgotten which is what the Bookmakers would wish.

I do not do twitter but hopefully other members will do as you ask but i have taken the time to post this and all i ask is that all HBF members at least have a look and think about what the people on here have to say (much of it is positive informed and supportive).
By:
duncan idaho
When: 13 Apr 16 19:00
Maybe they should appoint a 'greenhill' correspondent solely to keep you in the loop, mate   Crazy
By:
prufrock
When: 13 Apr 16 20:12
A reminder that this Forum is run by, and moderated by, a bookmaker, who doesn't (or at least didn't) allow blunt criticism of its own policies, mention of its competitors or links to external material. As such, it is not the ideal platform on which to discuss HBF business. But, as long as everyone is aware of that and makes allowance for it, we will do what we can, when we can.
By:
timbuctooth
When: 14 Apr 16 03:58
prufrock and stevetilley, I`m amazed at your patience in dealing with these ungrateful bast@rds. Who the phuck do they think they are, coming on here demanding this, expecting that, and dismissing everything you`re doing? Tell them to phuck right off; let them set up their own forum, if they`re so unhappy with what you`re doing.
Unbelievable, the self-importance of these arrogant nobodies.
By:
parispike
When: 14 Apr 16 09:37
^^^^

It is perfectly possible and rational to support the objectives of the HBF whilst holding some reservations about potential conflicts of interest relating to some forum members . That is my position. Perception is important and I remain uneasy that some HBF members receive remuneration from bookmakers; such creates the perception at the very least of conflicts of interest.

I am grateful to the forum members for what they are doing and recognise that progress on the issue of closures and restrictions is unlikely to be swift.
By:
saddo
When: 14 Apr 16 10:02
"Perception is important and I remain uneasy that some HBF members receive remuneration from bookmakers"


Exactly so, who could possibly be expected to publicly bite their employer's hand. Tanya in particular should should choose a side.
By:
Deltâ
When: 14 Apr 16 10:08
she should should, indeed ..
By:
saddo
When: 14 Apr 16 10:14
Whoops
By:
prufrock
When: 14 Apr 16 11:55
HBF has issued a statement today regarding Grand National over-rounds in response to press enquiries on the subject, as follows:

STARTS

"HBF was encouraged by the return to a more acceptable level of over-round in this year's Grand National, with the 148.7% figure being the second-lowest this decade. The % increased only slightly from 144% about half an hour before the off.

Nonetheless, HBF continues to have concerns about the starting-price process, not just in relation to the Grand National but on a day-to-day basis. It made those concerns known to the Starting Price Regulatory Commission as part of that body's consultation process, and it made it known that it found the report that emanated from that consultation to be deeply unsatisfactory.

To date, SPRC has not responded to HBF's open letter about this matter, despite the suggested deadline having recently expired.

The integrity of starting prices, and of other betting matters, is far too important to be left to an under-resourced body that is limited in its powers. Last year's Grand National [in which the SP % was 164.9] showed how easily starting prices could become weighted heavily against bettors, and lesser races are not immune to this threat either."   

ENDS
By:
ged
When: 14 Apr 16 12:02
Is that the problem with the SPRC - that it is an "under-resourced body that is limited in its powers"?


..or, perhaps to put it another way, are the people that make up the SPRC well-intentioned?
By:
prufrock
When: 14 Apr 16 12:04
I would rather leave it to others to speculate about that, but I HAVE MY DOUBTS.
By:
ged
When: 14 Apr 16 12:16
I would say that, from a punter's pov, they appear to be hopelessly biased against the punter, and therefore not fit for purpose. But of course a punter would say that wouldn't he. It would be nice to know the answer from someone in a better position to give a less biased opinion, as "lack of resources and power-limitation" is something which can cause a group to receive unfair criticism whilst at the same time having the best of intentions.

If the SPRC is truly stuffed with plants, can't Nick Rust be persuaded to see that that is so, and that that is bad, ultimately, for all concerned, and do something about it?
By:
Brian
When: 14 Apr 16 12:34
I had forgotten that HBF existed before this thread. Now following on Twitter to keep up to date with what I hope will be positive developments.
By:
dodgydog
When: 14 Apr 16 12:39
The HBF is akin to a terrier forever pulling at its master's trousers, one day it will bite or dropLaugh
By:
prufrock
When: 14 Apr 16 12:49
"We don't have the resources or the power" was part of the SPRC's own whinge in their whitewash - sorry - report, rather than "we don't care". The former is easier to prove than the latter (not least because they have owned up to it), even if the latter were to be truer than the former. And it amounts to much the same regarding their fitness for purpose. 

The SPRC is a non-profit company (though one which may pay its officers) limited by guarantee which was established by SIS/PA/MGN and is funded jointly by SIS and Turf TV. Only something called "The Nominations Committee" can appoint or remove Directors (it is unclear who is on this Nominations Committee).

Not sure there is anything Nick Rust can (or would wish to) do. But we won't be giving up.
By:
prufrock
When: 14 Apr 16 12:52
SPRC has just responded to missing the requested deadline for answering HBF's open letter about the unsatisfactory SP report (which deadline expired at midnight last night) by saying that their Directors have been unavailable due to the House of Lords being in recess!
By:
prufrock
When: 15 Apr 16 10:53
Worth reading report in Racing Post on Grand National starting prices (page 8).

Credit to Jockey Club Racecourses for being pro-active in this matter.

HBF's next meeting (June 6) will include representatives from the Racecourse Association and an agenda to discuss the on-course market, as well as future data provision, between the two parties.
By:
siralex
When: 15 Apr 16 11:10
They need to do something. I have just lost my last 3 accounts because the person who opened them for me wants to get a mortgage and doesnt look good having hundreds of pounds going thru his bank account every week. I now have absolutely nowhere to bet except betfair. Cant bet on sports anywhere except the shops and even then they have to phone up every bet i place. Sp only in the shops on the horses or betfair sp as no liquidity the night before.
All against someone who lost 10's of thousands for 20 years of my gambling life and now cant try and win it back.
Its a disgrace. I spoke to bbc radio about it and they used my account restriction letters on the shownthat i emailed them. Hasnt made a blind bit of difference though. Hope this group can actually do something.
By:
WFT
When: 15 Apr 16 12:39
Even if the HBF is successful in it's endeavours to get bookmakers to play fairly, I fear that all of us already "punished" will still have nowhere to bet.

It is pretty clear that the cull has already taken place, the software is pretty much in place to stop repeated accounts, and successful punters have either moved on to the exchanges or packed it in altogether.

For it to be deemed successful, in my eyes, the bookmakers would have to put forward an amnesty, and re-open closed accounts. This will not happen, realistically.

Any increase in bookmakers liabilities will only affect current customers and new customers. The already punished will still not be allowed to play.

Best of luck, though.
By:
IDKW
When: 15 Apr 16 12:59
Question is, what does the HBF plan to do with the results of their Survey?
Go back to the BHA and say " see, told you there was a problem."
BHA sit on the results too afraid to rock the boat given they want the Bookies onboard as ABP's.

Sorry, but the ONLY way to achieve anything is to get the issue into the mainstream press.

Ask the BHA for a decent budget to achieve the same, and see what response you get?
By:
prufrock
When: 15 Apr 16 13:08
It will be a more realistic aim to get something into the mainstream press with some evidence to support any claims.

HBF is independent of BHA, and I believe that is how it should remain.

As HBF's own website says "The HBF has a good working relationship with BHA but operates independently of that body, and does not speak on behalf of it in any way. Indeed, HBF sees holding authority to account on behalf of UK horseracing bettors to be a central part of its purpose"
By:
IDKW
When: 15 Apr 16 13:17
My understanding was this survey came about at the suggestion of the BHA?
Apologies if I've misunderstood, but I'm sure this is what was stated on a previous thread?

Personally, I'm much more of the opinion that Punters should go on the attack, rather than **** foot around the Bookies hoping for them to throw a few crumbs back our way.
By:
prufrock
When: 15 Apr 16 13:24
It came about as a result of HBF recognising that it needed better evidence to back up its claims in order to convince some bodies and individuals of the extent of the problem. That includes BHA.

Some bookmakers have indicated that they wish to engage with HBF on this and other matters. Some have indicated the opposite.

There is nothing to stop you, or others, "going on the attack", or HBF for that matter if more diplomatic approaches prove unsuccessful.
Page 3 of 5  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com