Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Horse Antepost

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 395 comments are related to the topic:
2020 prix de,l,arc de triomph

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 4 of 10  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 10 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 395
By:
elisjohn
When: 29 Sep 20 17:47
Sadno,
By:
Sandown
When: 29 Sep 20 18:01
Every year the issue of the going arises and every year we re-learn the lesson. French descriptions and penetrometer readings do not match ours.

As an example, this years trials in September were given as on "good" ground. My going allowances suggested that it was "firm." The Racing Post used the description "FirmX". (I'm not sure what the X means.)

The course for the Sunday is on fresh ground for up to 5 metres or more from the rail which always rides much faster than that used on the Saturday.

The last year that there was really soft ground was when Solemnia beat Orfevre and even then it was nowhere near heavy.

My assumption is that "good to soft" in our terms will be how it rides, until such time that we have actually seen the first race on the Sunday.
By:
Sandown
When: 29 Sep 20 18:13
Racing Post 2019 Race
Enable ran an absolutely brilliant race. WALDGEIST came late and strong after they went a good pace. Frankie committed and went for it and with the ground testing her, it's hard to show that turn of foot and WALDGEIST has outstayed her on the ground. I'm happy with the race but she doesn't have the same explosive turn of foot on soft, she quickened up well but was outstayed in very testing conditions - John Gosden, trainer.


John Gosden's comment should be noted for those who believe that Enable will be OK on "soft" ground.

The official description last year was "very soft." The RP TS description was "good to soft." My going allowance was similar.
By:
impossible123
When: 29 Sep 20 18:54
I'd be surprised if there was a sterling pace on sunday given the probable very soft going. If Order Of St George could not win this race I doubt very much Stradivarius can either. And, beaten by AVD who'd not won since Epsom until then is no recommendation either.

I firmly believe both Stradivarius and In Swoop have been backed purely on going and not merit.
By:
Figgis
When: 29 Sep 20 18:57
Completely in agreement with Sandown. The Solemia Arc would probably have suited the description "very soft". The last time there was ground bordering heavy was 1999 when Montjeu put up what, for me, was the best winning performance in the race by a 3yo during my time.
By:
impossible123
When: 29 Sep 20 19:07
When is the draw made and a new market formed?
By:
Ramruma
When: 30 Sep 20 05:15
There seems to be a degree of whistling in the dark about the going being better than stated on Sunday. The forecast is not encouraging and the French trainers seem to be worried, for instance Jean-Claude Rouget says he can't be sure Raabihah will handle heavy ground.

"We simply have a question mark over the ground for her. It's not that we think that heavy going will be a definite hindrance to her, it's more that we have no way of knowing how she will handle it, as she will never have run on anything so deep."
https://www.racingpost.com/news/members/arc-countdown/rouget-sottsass-better-than-ever-and-primed-to-run-a-massive-race-in-arc/452532

(Oh, and Rouget says Sottsass can run into a place, so he is a tad less bullish than the Racing Post headline writer.)
By:
harry callaghan
When: 30 Sep 20 09:26
As an example, this years trials in September were given as on "good" ground. My going allowances suggested that it was "firm." The Racing Post used the description "FirmX". (I'm not sure what the X means.)


totally agree sandown, it was like a road or they ran the races over a shorter distance
By:
harry callaghan
When: 30 Sep 20 10:40
I have no doubt whatsoever that while Waldgeist ran his best ever race last year Enable was below her peak and would've still beaten the improved Waldgeist if she'd run to form. Nevertheless, I'm not convinced that it was down to the way she was ridden. That's the way she was usually ridden. When she won her first KG the ground was actually softer than Longchamp last year and she took up the running well over 2f out. When comfortably holding Waldgeist in last year's KG she was asked to lead 2f out in a strongly run race.

Personally, I believe she was slightly over the top after her earlier efforts in the season. It can be argued that this season she's had an easier prep leading to the Arc. However, she is now a 6yo and so there is a little extra doubt as to how long she can remain in peak form.





whilst i had the same opinion as yourself figgis in regards her running below par last year because of waldgiest whom was only trained for one day, i have changed my thinking and actually think she ran right up to her best in last years race

people will argue sea of class was unlucky (i backed her) i still think enable was much the best on the day, it just depends how you want to read speed in a horse race and also stamina, i'm certainly not knocking opinions here by the way

in regards to last years race i actually think they went very quickly and enable covered that pace set(the winner came from out of the pace)...

her speed/class allowed her to cruise to the front similar to the previous season, however it was a proper stamina test and it was stamina that beat her and a horse whom had only one race to win that season and was primed for the race who stayed in a attritional race...

if you look at waldgiest he had improved that season but then was beaten at ascot without having a hard race...the key for me though in last years arc is magical who is up with the pace and finishes very tired the fact enable sustained her run for so long was very admirable in my book

the sea of class race i'd say she was slightly below her best but she still was much the best horse, still showing that turn of foot before tiring inside the furlong, once again it was stamina which allowed sea of class to get so close but the actual speed was shown by enable

whether the mare is as good this season i'm not so sure with very little evidence to go on but i'm not going out of my way to get her in this spot against these horses, much to ponder
By:
cryoftruth
When: 30 Sep 20 11:06
Re last year, Enable did quicken when asked. Its a fact that Frankie rode her the way he usually does. But on that going it was not the right way, as he and Gosden have admitted since. Of course she might have lost anyway if she has been held onto for another furlong, and the outcome if she had been is a matter of opinion.
But is there a Waldgeist lurking in this field?
By:
San Quentin
When: 30 Sep 20 11:12
No Waldgeist lurking. Been over all form race replays etc etc and I just can't see the forums fascination with Sottsass. Time will tell.
By:
penzance
When: 30 Sep 20 12:34
Sepentine's a runner.
By:
ashleigh
When: 30 Sep 20 12:52
i know he is part japenese owned, but surely the lads wouldn't want yutaka take riding japan.Surprised
wonder if o murphy will now get back on deirdre.
By:
Figgis
When: 30 Sep 20 13:43
There seems to be a degree of whistling in the dark about the going being better than stated on Sunday. The forecast is not encouraging and the French trainers seem to be worried, for instance Jean-Claude Rouget says he can't be sure Raabihah will handle heavy ground

Take a look back, loads of them were saying the same thing last year. They say the same thing every year there's rain. Always handy to get the excuses in first.
By:
1st time poster
When: 30 Sep 20 16:35
whe running in staying races gosden always puts up soft ground never mind heavy as an excuse pre race for strad,now its a positive heavier the better,obviously brings his stamina in to play,but surely he,s no well backed 3rd fav
By:
elisjohn
When: 30 Sep 20 16:36
elisjohn • October 6, 2019 6:06 PM BST
well im opening a thread and im going to start betting on it asap, because ive decided im actually going to go there next year, as long as the reviews on here say its improved from last year

im actually not going thereGrin
By:
FOYLESWAR
When: 30 Sep 20 16:53
love 5/1 on here now
By:
kevinglass
When: 30 Sep 20 19:20
Whatever the French say is Soft, Heavy, or whatever......Have a look at the forecast for Paris till Sunday.

It's going to be a slog.
By:
1st time poster
When: 30 Sep 20 19:49
everyone seems convinced love wont like ground so must be a non jigger come sunday
By:
impossible123
When: 30 Sep 20 19:59
What a shame the Longchamp weather has turned inclement. It was much better last weekend.
By:
giggitygiggity
When: 30 Sep 20 20:31
Yeah your weather forecast prediction 2 weeks before the race that there was only going to be a smidgeon of rain before race day obviously wasn't very accurate..come back Michael Fish all is forgiven Silly
By:
penzance
When: 30 Sep 20 20:41
Laugh
By:
A_T
When: 30 Sep 20 20:53
Roland Garros is on at the moment - how much play has been lost so far due to rain and how much will be lost? That will give an indication as to how much rain is falling
By:
Figgis
When: 30 Sep 20 21:08
Not all courses ride the same after the same amount of rain and some courses react differently at different times of the year. Some people may have different opinions of what warrants the description heavy ground. For me, personally, it all comes down to how much the ground is actually slowing the horses down. Historically Longchamp on Arc day has been able to take a hell of lot of rain bashing before the ground slows the horses down to an extreme degree. 1999 was the last time the ground was genuinely heavy. That is in spite of seemingly every other year being warned to expect swamp like conditions.

I've already mentioned the inconsistent readings the penetrometer used to produce when it was introduced. I don't know if that was due to the actual instrument, the incompetence of those using it or the lack of interest shown by the courses in providing up to the minute readings. Longchamp also used to have a less efficient irrigation system that could've contributed to inconsistent readings. For what it's worth, the penetrometer reading in 1999 was 5.1, and apparently that was the highest since records began 27 years previously. Even the heavy ground that day wasn't as bog like as some race days I've seen here and in Ireland.

I may change my mind on the day after racing is underway, but for now I'm not expecting anything slower than average soft ground at the very worst.
By:
A_T
When: 30 Sep 20 21:21
Figgis do you think Love has to improve to win the Arc? Likewise do any other the principles have to?
By:
Figgis
When: 30 Sep 20 21:44
A_T no I don't think she needs to improve at all to win this year's Arc. I said after Epsom she was the joint fastest Oaks winner since I've been following racing. Sometimes I will have to downgrade a race as the season progresses, but, in spite of a lot of people saying the form hasn't held up, I feel even more confident about how good a performance it was. It should be put into context though that it isn't as bold a statement as it may sound, as most Oaks winners are nowhere near the standard required to win an Arc, an average Oaks winner sets a pretty low benchmark.

If there was a proper top level Gp1 older horse in the race at the peak of its powers I wouldn't fancy Love to win, but there isn't one in my opinion. For me, there are only two runners proven over the trip and good enough to win an average Arc. She is one and obviously Enable is the other. On ratings, taking what I rate as Enable's best performance as an older filly/mare, last year's King George win, I have Love 1lb ahead on Sunday's wfa terms. Regardless of what some people may think, most ratings users don't strictly adhere to backing a top rated horse, especially one with only 1lb in hand. I only use them as a base on which to make other judgements. I believe that Love is more likely than Enable to run close to her peak form.

How do you see it?
By:
Figgis
When: 30 Sep 20 21:49
Just to add, I reckon if Persian King repeated his latest win to the pound over this further half mile he'd beat this lot (and most Arc fields) easily. However, aside from the obvious stamina doubt I have further doubts about him repeating that effort next time anyway.
By:
Lucky Sod
When: 30 Sep 20 21:58
AIDAN O'BRIEN warned "nothing is on or off” as he admitted heavy ground could “definitely" cause Love to miss Sunday's Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe.

The ground at ParisLongchamp was yesterday described as “very soft" by officials, who reported a penetrometer reading of 3.9.

Further rain is forecast for the French capital in the run-up to Europe's middle-distance championship, and a worried O’Brien conceded deteriorating conditions could force his dual Classic heroine - winner of the Yorkshire Oaks on rain-softened ground in August - to miss out.

“I would definitely say so,” said the master of Ballydoyle, whose daughter of Galileo is now out to 3-1 with Ladbrokes.

“When you start getting into extremes - especially when you start talking about heavy ground in France - we have to be realistic.

“We have to make a decision at 9.30am on Friday. Nothing is on or off until we believe things are right.”
By:
San Quentin
When: 30 Sep 20 22:41
What a pathetic misleading statement by AOB. How does a decision have to be made at 9.30 am Friday? Rubbish Rubbish Rubbish.
By:
penzance
When: 30 Sep 20 22:50
decs and quite possibly travel arrangements.
By:
driver2
When: 01 Oct 20 03:14
I believe that the final declaration stage is at 10.30am French time on Friday. Regardless of what the forum idiots have been telling you (impossible it p1ssed down last sunday and the ground was already soft and figgis you are a total guesser) the ground will be very testing on Sunday, it's going to rain on and off every day umtil the race, I told you all on the 20th September. 1st time poster, did you see the Ascot GC, Gosden changed his mind after seeing Stradivarius quicken up on the ground, he reveled in it!
Friday's final decs will be interesting, Johnny G may well end up with the 1st and 2nd favs and quite honestly there is little or no value left in the race, the happy ones are those of us who took the 16/1 about no hoper Stradivarius Laugh
By:
Figgis
When: 01 Oct 20 04:01
figgis you are a total guesser

I am indeed guessing.

the ground was already soft

As is anyone who thinks they can tell you what the ground was riding like on a French racecourse on a day when there was no racing Happy

How about something we don't need to guess on? What was the going at the most recent Longchamp meeting?
By:
driver2
When: 01 Oct 20 05:33
Racing Post 29 sept     YOU DON'T NEED RACING TO READ THE GOING

The penetrometer reading at Longchamp was 3.5 or soft on Friday and weekend rain is likely to remove any chance that conditions will be unsuitably quick for Telecaster.

Sporting Life yesterday

France Galop reported at total of 14.4 millimetres of rain had fallen this week at ParisLongchamp up to Wednesday morning, leaving the ground very soft.

figgis this morning     WHAT A STUPID STATEMENT

As is anyone who thinks they can tell you what the ground was riding like on a French racecourse on a day when there was no racing
By:
driver2
When: 01 Oct 20 05:36
I'll tell you what figgis, I'll make a guess. Love wont run and I'll be laying off Stradivarius at 4/1, maybe even shorter!
By:
ElT
When: 01 Oct 20 07:26
Were the Japanese horses not allowed to travel? I guess the unbeaten Contrail and Daring Tact are going for the respective Triple Crowns, but they could at least have send Salios to add some spice.With the withdrawls from Ghaiyyath and Magical,they´d have had three horses in the top 5 in the betting.

Sottsass as 4th fav to win the Arc. Maybe I´ll do some match bets against him with some of the longest outsiders.
By:
harry callaghan
When: 01 Oct 20 09:39
driver 2

you're clearly not convinced by stradavarius considering you are wanting to lay off your bet, with like you say him having his absolute ideal conditions to boot...

i thought the bookies just cut stradavarius for the sake of getting him to an un-backable price (a standard procedure now) because they certainly haven't taken any bets on the horse and you couldn't get 2 pounds on the exchange for weeks

anyway all the best with the arb pal and anyone wanting to take 4/1 will need there head testing...you can have that for free
By:
penzance
When: 01 Oct 20 09:53
Love N/R.
By:
harry callaghan
When: 01 Oct 20 09:54
love out
By:
UnseatedRider
When: 01 Oct 20 10:00
Market suspended, love removed from betting.
By:
UnseatedRider
When: 01 Oct 20 10:01
The market told the story
Page 4 of 10  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 10 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com