Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 231 comments are related to the topic:
TAKING VALUE TO SERIOUSLY

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 6 of 6  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 231
By:
GoldCoastinvestor
When: 05 Oct 11 09:50
The point to the above post is most of you people wouldn't even know what price to put up for the event, so if you can't price the event yourself you don't know what the right odds should be so how do you know what is value if you can't price an event??

Your all just sheep.
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 05 Oct 11 10:05
Perhaps betfairs success tax or premium charges are the only viable solutions to maintain the system for the benefit of all customers generally now and in the future, but a further increase would put there position as market leader well and truly at risk.
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 05 Oct 11 10:08
GCI, lets say we were all sheep, would your last post make you the top ram or is it that we wont take you on as we are all sheepishBlush
By:
LordBobbbin
When: 05 Oct 11 10:48
GCI, you are right to point out that most people can't actually price up an event. That's one reason why so many people struggle to make money betting - if you don't have an idea as to what the price ought to be, how can you start to determine whether you think there's value?   

I'm not yet sufficiently well-developed so that I can come up with a precise price for a market, although I am starting to get to the point where, in certain limited situations, I can tell that a price is 'wrong', and that I'll be getting some value if I back at that price. Hopefully, as my experience gets greater, I'll be able to spot these 'wrong' prices with greater regularity. And, in time, I may even be able to say exactly what I think the price should be for a particular market.

I think knowing that you've got to look for wrong prices and that you need to bet only when you think you've found such a situation is the key to making money over the long term. The more accurately you identify those wrong prices, the more often you'll be locating value - even if you're not totally sure yourself exactly how much value there is at that price.
By:
Lori
When: 05 Oct 11 11:14
The point to the above post is most of you people wouldn't even know what price to put up for the event, so if you can't price the event yourself you don't know what the right odds should be so how do you know what is value if you can't price an event??


I always price up the NFL fixtures before checking the prices and I bet accordingly. That's kinda the point.
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 05 Oct 11 11:20
True lori but GCI has patented the process and called it the gold coast law of betting, what a smart arse[;)]
By:
LordBobbbin
When: 05 Oct 11 11:20
Yeah Lori, but you are rather shrewder than the majority on Betfair.
By:
GoldCoastinvestor
When: 05 Oct 11 11:33
BFF


go lick yourself
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 05 Oct 11 11:35
he he Cool
By:
Lori
When: 05 Oct 11 11:47
Sent you a PM you might like Bobbin (It crossed with your post).
By:
LordBobbbin
When: 05 Oct 11 12:18
That's great Lori. I've pasted your collected wisdom into a text file (along with the pics), and I'll have a good read through it all later on today.   Many thanks for doing that for me.
By:
catfloppo
When: 05 Oct 11 14:08
I bet lori is a more profitable sheep than goldcoastinvestor
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 05 Oct 11 15:54
Yes cat, I think so too, some reckon this thread is some sort of testament to a misconception that most customers don't know what value is, but what does come to the surface is that most do understand it, some can find it, and some imagine only they have it and everyone else is stupid, this cant be true as the whole concept of an exchange is to attract and promote profitable value, and then if you get good at it , to give most of it back to betfair, somehow this doesn't seem right does it but of well lets not keep bringing that up[;)]
By:
LordBobbbin
When: 05 Oct 11 15:58
Well you do seem to bring it up pretty much every time you post BFF!  (And that's several dozen times a day!!)
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 05 Oct 11 16:02
Yes, I have a hell of a memory don't I Blush
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 05 Oct 11 16:05
Well I hope to back and lay on the hounds soon and I have to beat the track, the other dogs, the grader, the general market , the traders then pay comms then if I did make it big the pc1,2 and 3

A tall order for sure.
By:
catfloppo
When: 05 Oct 11 16:45
BFF, I don't understand why it isn't right to pay bf for using the site?
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 05 Oct 11 16:50
It is ok, just love posting [;)]
By:
paulme
When: 05 Oct 11 19:59
If I went to the casino and someone offered me 50/1 for the zero to come in next on the roulette wheel.

Would I back it? Yes.
Do I expect to win? No.


from page one.

superbly put!!
By:
kenilworth
When: 11 Oct 11 19:43
If someone offered me 11/10 red on a roulette table..
Would I back it ? Yes
Would I expect to win ? No.
By:
Sandown
When: 12 Oct 11 11:42
This topic crops up with such regularity, its a wonder that there is anything new to say, but I'll try.

There is a clear paradox at the heart of this issue, which needs to be understood.

1. You cannot make a profit at gambling (or anything else for that matter) unless the price you get exceeds the price you pay.That is the simple definition of "profit."

2. Unlike other products, the gambler cannot tell whether on a single play, his judgment of the potential profit (value)was correct or not because the outcome, whilst determining the actual profit or loss, doesn't provide proof of the notional profit prior to the outcome. It is only in aggregate i.e after s large sample, that the cumulative profit/loss demonstrates whether the collective judgment was proven to be right or not.

3. Therefore, it follows, that any perceived "value" ( the existance of it and the amount of it) in a bet prior to the outcome can only be a matter of opinion no matter what the basis of that opinion, statistics or anything else. (Anyone arguing that a "real" probability must exist is arguing that the unknowable must exist, which is of no practical use to anyone.)

So, the paradox is that "value" can exist, must be pursued, but cannot be measured prior to the event and can only be recognised in aggregate. This makes it extremely hard to learn from experience and to correct the methodology for making judgments as to value. Given enough practice and time, skills do develop, but even the most experienced odds compiler can never be certain that he has his odds "right". But what he will realise, is that he cannot beat the market (wisdom of crowds) over every event every day so to profit, must focus a lesser number of events than does the market.
By:
baconONtoast
When: 12 Oct 11 12:46
Yup, the problems of assessing success are fairly significant.

It's an argument towards markets and methods that produce larger volume imo. You can adjust sooner.
By:
Do wah Diddy
When: 15 Oct 11 18:41
YOU CANT GET VALUE ON A ROULETTE WHEEL IN A CASINO ,AND YOU CANT GET VALUE ON A GAMEING MACHINE IN THE  BOOKIES ,YOU NEED LUCK AND EVENTUALLY THAT WILL RUN OUT ,

VALUEIDITY IS WHEN YOU GET SOMETHING CHEAPER THAN WHAT YOU PAY FOR IT
By:
Do wah Diddy
When: 15 Oct 11 18:42
THATS IF ITS WORTH IT
By:
Do wah Diddy
When: 15 Oct 11 18:47
WHEN YOU HAVE A GO ON THE LOTTERY THERES NO VALUE IN IT ,BUT IF THE LOTTO JACKPOT ROLLS OVER FOR SIX WEEKS THERES VALUE IN IT ,AS THERE IS MORE MONEY IN THE POT ,THAN TICKETS THAT CAN WIN IT
By:
Do wah Diddy
When: 15 Oct 11 18:48
I HOPE THE ABOVE HELPS YOU IF YOU ARE UNINTELLIGENT
By:
Do wah Diddy
When: 16 Oct 11 01:14
MAXIMUM YES I KNOW THAT ,BUT THERE IS VALUE IN THE POT ,AND ITS VALUE THAT YOUR LOOKING FOR
By:
Do wah Diddy
When: 16 Oct 11 01:57
MAXIMUM THANK YOU ,BUT I AM EMPHASIZEING IT ,IVE WROTE IT IN CAPITAL LETTERS ,LIKE I WRITE EVERYTHING TO EMPHASIZE WHAT I SAY ,

BUT I STILL LIKE YOU
By:
Do wah Diddy
When: 16 Oct 11 01:57
MAXIMUM THANK YOU ,BUT I AM EMPHASIZEING IT ,IVE WROTE IT IN CAPITAL LETTERS ,LIKE I WRITE EVERYTHING TO EMPHASIZE WHAT I SAY ,

BUT I STILL LIKE YOU
By:
Do wah Diddy
When: 16 Oct 11 02:03
PS IM GOING TO BED NOW TO DREAM OF ,HOW TO SPOT A HORSE WITH VALUE ,WHEN YOUR AN IDIOT LIKE ME ,I ONCE LOOKED ON THE T V AND SAW TWO HORSES THAT DIDNT LOOK RIGHT TO ME AND THEY CAME FIRST AND SECOND
By:
Do wah Diddy
When: 16 Oct 11 02:05
PS I LAID THEM BOTH ,I THINK THEY WERE TRAINED TO NOT LOOK RIGHT ,

GOOD NIGHT
By:
LordBobbbin
When: 16 Oct 11 02:26
Perhaps they were just cross-eyed, Diddy?
Page 6 of 6  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com