Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 231 comments are related to the topic:
TAKING VALUE TO SERIOUSLY

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 2 of 6  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 231
By:
Trevh
When: 29 Sep 11 05:10
That's why I use 0.2% of my betting bank per stake GCI :)
By:
Trevh
When: 29 Sep 11 05:13
You may go 150 bets or more without the winner, then 4 come in the next 10 bets. If you can identify true odds and get matched at greater odds, and have a suitable staking plan, you cannot lose.
By:
THE-REVOLUTIONARY.
When: 29 Sep 11 07:24
trevh you automactically assume just becuase youve gone 150 bets without winning your bound to hit a winners soon it dont work like that infact value can only be obtain on the event once


you cant play a man united v stoke game 100 times in the exact same way with the exact same things happening

thats what happens with long odds bettors they go on a long losing run then think jsut becuase im on a losing run im bound to win now well im afraid to say no too football games are mechanically link its possible you go 300 games without winning


sports betting is about picking winners at the correct price  fact be it a 1.60 shot that should be 1.30  but the fact most prices are correct so its near impoosible to  profit
By:
racingguru
When: 29 Sep 11 07:55
"Value" is a perceived notion in most real betting situations as no one is gonna give you 6/4 heads etc. Value can only be perceived by a punter and how real it is depends on the skill/accuracy of the punter making the call and his ability to price an event accurately. So the debate on high prices and value is basically a red herring.
By:
Lori
When: 29 Sep 11 10:14
Trev you would have the balls to stump up again ang again after 40 losing bets to try and get that 50-1 winner that may not win you may go 150 bets befor eyou back your 50-1 winner, after all they don't win all that often do they???

It's not about balls, it's about maths.

Yes you'll have long losing runs. No this isn't scary if you're staking correctly. Annoying maybe, but not scary.

As to how often they win, you'd be pushed to find a day on here when a 50/1 shot doesn't win.
By:
GoldCoastinvestor
When: 29 Sep 11 11:24
I was going to actually make a note of how many horses start at over 50-1 accross all races today, but couldn't be fkd.

better spent at the golf course even though it was blowing the feathers off the birds, Must have been 60Kmph winds, but much better there than here?
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 29 Sep 11 11:40
You don't keep backing 50-1 SP shots every time one runs! You would have to be a total eeeejjjjiiiitttt to do that!

However, every now and then there are 50-1 SP shots that are well too high in odds, due to certain factors being in their favour in a horse race.

Don't believe anyone is a "mug" if they try to puzzle out what horse can win...........it is essential that you are aware of the horses most likely to run well for that particular race. It is the combination of working out where the winner might come from + backing the ones with "VALUE IN ODDS" that is a good approach to take.


If it so happens the horse is 50-1 SP, then that does not mean the market in correct re such odds ! It is just the market has not recognised the factors in race that give the 50-1 SP shot a chance to win that race.

As most punters are not aware of those factors ....the odds are "VALUE" for that race. Not every time that horse runs !
By:
Petrus Romanus
When: 29 Sep 11 11:47
TomWar
29 Sep 11 04:31
This is such a bad post. Believe it or not sports betting is not about picking winners, it's about finding opportunities where the true win probability is greater than the implied probability of the price you backed.


I could counter by saying that's the biggest load of boll0cks posted so far on this thread. Like I said below, if you aren't consistently finding WINNERS amongst your 'opportunities where the true win probability is greater than the implied probability of the price you backed' then you might as well set fire to your money.



Trevh
29 Sep 11 04:32
Your post sums up what not to do, beautifully, Swearbox :) Guessing outcomes is a mugs game, some may succeed but they would have to be unwittingly obtaining value.

Where did I mention guessing ? And regardless of price obtained aren't we all just guessing that our selection will win / lose ?

In your examples below (ie the 40 long losing streak) I refuse to believe that someone can diligently put in the quality effort time after time just to see their pick fail in the hope that sooner or later their 50/1 shot prevails. Anyone who bets professionally cannot rely on this method unless they have extremely deep pockets, in which case they probably aren't betting professionally in the true sense of what that means (ie, it's a job that puts food on the table).
By:
kenilworth
When: 29 Sep 11 12:01
I don't see how it's possible to calculate big prices for value in
sports betting.
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 29 Sep 11 12:03
15:50          Maiden Fillies´ Stakes(Class 5) (3yo+)  1m½f Standard

1,Starfala                N/R
2,Duty Doctor          12                                             AM 3/9***
3,Tableau Vivant                      3RD 2-1    AM 9/9
4,Arabian Art          14                                             AM 4/9***
5,Wood Chorus                         2ND 4-5F                        AM 1/9 *** Straight Forecast: £61.76  Exacta: £126.10 
6,Saphira's Fire                      1ST 33-1   AM 8/9                          Straight Forecast: £61.76  Exacta: £126.10 
----------------------------------------------------
7,Idesia            11                                               AM 2/9
8,Come On Molly        250
9,Pennygee    100
10,Fluoree         150
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 29 Sep 11 12:06
17:00          Handicap(Class 5)  4yo+ 6f Good To Soft

1,Kensington                       1ST 20-1      AM 10/13 VALUE BACK   CSF £235.06 Ex £477.60
2,Savile's Delight                 2ND 11-1      AM 11/13 VALUE BACK
3,Equuleus Pictor         10                                         AM 4/13 ***
4,Blue Charm               14
5,Makabul          7
6,Valentino Swing    15-2
7,Cheap Street                      3RD 15-2TRICAST £1827.87 TRIFECTA £0.00 Not won. Place 6 £417.48, Place 5 £283.76.
----------------------------------------------
8,Dualagi                    12                                      AM 7/13
9,Farefield Lodge          N/R
10,Cinnamon Hill            8                   AM 13/13
11,Bateleur                N/R
12,Memphis Man                       4TH 5-1F                         AM 2/13
13,Proud Killer         17-2                                          AM 3/13
14,Hits Only Cash        12                                           AM 6/13
15,Resplendent Alpha        N/R
16,Jimmy The Guesser        16
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 29 Sep 11 12:11
The fulcrum of the profitability long term of a gambler is(=) the mind set of perceiving value

When a gambler cant research what is positive and negative about a runner, race, price or conditions
to arrive at value then he plots to win, placing singles, doubles and the like to hopefully win big for a small stake he has no assurance what so ever that he is betting profitably and is not in control of his balance, stake size or selections.

A pro punter does all the research, bets on less runners and plays the long game, he could be backing favorites or even outsiders but he accounts for losing runs by using the right stake size compared to his balance, trevs statement for betting 0.2% for outsiders is quite correct but if you are backing favorites you could increase the stake size accordingly as the risk of acquiring long losing runs is less.

revolutionaries belief that backing outsiders is wrong because they hardly ever win shows that he
is plotting to win without any idea of an edge, stake size, losing runs and so he is better
just doing what most recreational punters do and back favorites as he wont be able to manage
a long term plan at all.
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 29 Sep 11 12:17
Be aware when using outsiders in a system that the win cycle on average may be as low as 50 losers per winner and that its quite possible to get 3 times the amount of losers when you start, thats a win cycle of 150 losers before a winner, thats why 0.2% stakes is about right to absorb these huge cycles of stakes compared to returns.
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 29 Sep 11 12:20
To balance that a wee bit ....you can also get 6 winners in a day at "good" odds........not all 50-1 SP thoughDevil
By:
swift-tuttle
When: 29 Sep 11 12:25
beautiful thread
By:
Petrus Romanus
When: 29 Sep 11 12:26
Something that hasn't been mentioned so far in this thread is the fact that we don't have to bet in the time honoured way the bookies would prefer. The exchange model sees to that.

I wonder how many of the punters who bang on about how they get value prices let their bets ride in running, ie don't lay off that 50/1 shot that's currently trading at 20's wit half the race gone ? Not many I reckon.
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 29 Sep 11 12:28
How true [;)], The great Barney Curley managed last year/ this year to get some big priced winners all in on the same multiple bets but of course he knows all the people that train and plot massive priced runners to win all kinds of race, trouble is he has only ever been paid a small amount in his returns as he used bookmakers who of course don't want to pay him out, he is taking them too court not for the money but to show the world what a conning bunch of robbers the bookmakers are, nice one BarneyCool
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 29 Sep 11 12:35
Read the story about Barney Curleys Massive win here

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/people/profiles/barney-curley-nobody-will-win-as-much-on-horse-racing-in-100-years-1988728.html
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 29 Sep 11 12:40
Read this quote about what drives Barney, sure brilliance.

So why persevere with the precarious adventures that redeemed him from the penury of younger days? "It's not for the money," Curley says. "It's for the buzz. Beat the system, you know, beat those bookmakers, those smart-arses. You go into a betting shop and see them robbing these poor fellows, with these gaming machines. They're as addictive as crack cocaine. You see them coming back to the counter with their credit cards, for another tenner. Of course the great thing about those machines is that number nine won't go to even money and win five lengths."

Equally, he remembers sitting in hospital and reading about footballers on £100,000 a week. "I know they're the best at what they do," he says. "But here's me, the best at what I do. And every year, when I came to a certain figure, I said: 'That's enough'. But now I thought: 'I've been underpaying myself the last 15 years. My job's a lot harder. It's about time I caught up with these fellows.'"
By:
OnTheSnaff
When: 29 Sep 11 16:44
Dev,Fack off
By:
TomWar
When: 29 Sep 11 16:53
I could counter by saying that's the biggest load of boll0cks posted so far on this thread. Like I said below, if you aren't consistently finding WINNERS amongst your 'opportunities where the true win probability is greater than the implied probability of the price you backed' then you might as well set fire to your money.

This is akin to saying you would not back a 10/1 price on a fair 6 sided dice roll landing on 1 because you don't believe the 1 will come up this particular roll. Do you see why your wrong now? If not you should go brush up on your stats.
By:
Petrus Romanus
When: 29 Sep 11 17:33
TomWar
29 Sep 11 16:53
Joined:
30 Mar 11
| Topic/replies: 2 | Blogger: TomWar's blog
I could counter by saying that's the biggest load of boll0cks posted so far on this thread. Like I said below, if you aren't consistently finding WINNERS amongst your 'opportunities where the true win probability is greater than the implied probability of the price you backed' then you might as well set fire to your money.

This is akin to saying you would not back a 10/1 price on a fair 6 sided dice roll landing on 1 because you don't believe the 1 will come up this particular roll. Do you see why your wrong now? If not you should go brush up on your stats.




Did you read my post before you replied ? I'm not saying that having value on your side is a bad thing...I'm saying that backing a selection based upon value alone isn't good enough. Every event has more than one value opportunity in it somewhere so how does one decide which one to go for ?

I stick to what I said earlier...value is all fine and dandy if your picks win at a rate that ensures you keep ahead of the game but if they don't you might as well stick a pin in the race card and bet on whatever it lands on.
By:
Trevh
When: 29 Sep 11 18:45
Swearbox : I wonder how many of the punters who bang on about how they get value prices let their bets ride in running, ie don't lay off that 50/1 shot that's currently trading at 20's wit half the race gone ? Not many I reckon.

I don't lay off, even if the price is down to 1.1 I don't lay off.

That may sound crazy to some, but it isn't a random conclusion, I've studied greening up at length and it proved impossible for me to positively determine value when laying off in running, hence there was no benefit long term.
By:
jamesdean
When: 29 Sep 11 18:58
Trevh I'm liking your posts more every time you post, you talk sense.
By:
jamesdean
When: 29 Sep 11 18:59
the only thing missing is a smiley [:)]
By:
dlarssonf
When: 29 Sep 11 18:59
Let your green run and cur your reds should always be your strategy.  to often people are quick to green up and hence given away their value and let their reds run
By:
Trevh
When: 29 Sep 11 19:11
Haha Jamesdean, thanks, I hate the BF smiley's though :) Laugh
By:
TomWar
When: 29 Sep 11 19:13
I'm saying that backing a selection based upon value alone isn't good enough.

Yes it is.

Every event has more than one value opportunity in it somewhere so how does one decide which one to go for ?

Find the opportunity with the largest expected growth and bet it.

value is all fine and dandy if your picks win at a rate that ensures you keep ahead of the game

Go read up on probability/expected value before you come back and say this non sense again.
By:
Petrus Romanus
When: 29 Sep 11 22:22
TomWar you're fvcking irritating me now...

What you are saying is tantamount to blindly backing what you consider to be value regardless of how your picks are performing over the longer term. That's fvcking suicidal. If your 'value' picks don't win then they aren't fvcking value you idiot.

Here's a tip - don't bother replying until you've really thought about why you are betting in the first place...it's to win money NOT to get a value price and think that on that basis you are a pro bettor.
By:
mythical prince
When: 29 Sep 11 22:24
patrick veitch in his book didn't like the word value, he preferred to describe a horse as "underestimated" or "overestimated" by the betting public. can't actually remember why though!
By:
mythical prince
When: 29 Sep 11 22:28
if your value picks don't win then they arent ****g value...

hmmm... lets say sarafina runs in the arc this weekend. she starts at 100-1. she gets beat. would you have said that she was not value because she got beat? or do you simply think that every scenario is going to play out exactly the same way?

on the same theme, I think deep impact started 1-10 in the arc a few years back, in the one won by rail link. If he had won would he have been value?

The original poster was trying to make a good point in some respect, that most people are pyschologically unsuited by classical "value" betting. as human beings its a natural reaction to get angry when we lose, but I think you can take this argument to extremes.
By:
racingguru
When: 29 Sep 11 22:32
All this talk about "value". It is meaningless unless you have the skills to be able to determine "value" which to have any meaning should be backing at something at a price higher than its respective chance of winning. Again, this is a perceived notion and only of any use if the person making that call is skilled enough to do this accurately. Price has zero to do with value.
By:
Petrus Romanus
When: 29 Sep 11 22:47
if your value picks don't win then they arent ****g value...

...actually I'll retract that statement as it's incorrect...I typed while wound up. I just can't believe some of the sharp minds on here can't see through the fog and understand a simple premise that if you can't pick horses that win (or whatever your poison is) then obtaining value is of no consequence.
By:
mythical prince
When: 29 Sep 11 23:11
I think a better way of putting it might be to say horse's that "can win" rather than, horses which win, which implies hindsight that only operates on a one way street.

I agree there are plenty of horses in plenty of races that i'd give no chance to. people will then say "oh, but they must have some kind of chance"

lets just give a random example, lets say power in next years 2000 guineas. i'd be amazed if he's good enough to win a guineas. so i'd be happy to lay him at pretty much any price. at the moment he's trading at around 15.5 on here, but again value is an subjective thing, because there are plenty of people who could make a realistic argument for him winning the race.
By:
JamesBlakesHugeArse
When: 30 Sep 11 03:59
Swearbox - he is correct in what he is saying,

If you look at the extreme long term then the fact that he is picking value means that he will be ahead, he may not win the first 50, but he will be ahead after the first 5,000 and this is the important issue.  You point about picking winners isnt so valid - if you had a crystal ball and were able to pick winners consistently then sure value is not important, you would be winning no matter what, but no-one (unless they are a friend of Filippo Volandri) has this ball.

The value picker may of course be incredibly unlucky, betting on heads at 2.01 over 1000 spins, can, in theory, put you at a loss, but the longer that goes on for, the more likely he is to be in profit.
By:
Rob_The_Bantam
When: 30 Sep 11 10:25
I just can't believe some of the sharp minds on here can't see through the fog and understand a simple premise that if you can't pick horses that win (or whatever your poison is) then obtaining value is of no consequence.

Hmmm.  Depends on how many bets you're placing.  If someone offered me infinite spins of a coin at 2.05 for tails, I wouldn't care if the first 50 didn't win because in the end I'd be in profit.  Probability says so.  Long term, value is the only important thing...picking it isn't easy, though.

Fairly sure that Schalke04 started a discussion on this some time ago with your reasoning.
By:
duncan idaho
When: 30 Sep 11 10:32
''Did you read my post before you replied ? I'm not saying that having value on your side is a bad thing...I'm saying that backing a selection based upon value alone isn't good enough. Every event has more than one value opportunity in it somewhere so how does one decide which one to go for ?

I stick to what I said earlier...value is all fine and dandy if your picks win at a rate that ensures you keep ahead of the game but if they don't you might as well stick a pin in the race card and bet on whatever it lands on. ''



Swearbox, if they aint winning at a rate that ensures you're in profit then they werent 'value' selections in the first place (given a reasonable sample size).
By:
catflmasppo
When: 30 Sep 11 10:49
If you could look into the p&l of posters who pay the correct attention to value and then into the p&l of those who pick winners the debate would end instantly.
By:
paulme
When: 30 Sep 11 11:15
cat flap your still here. hope you have some red wine in for the weekend chap
By:
Petrus Romanus
When: 30 Sep 11 13:49
OK...I knew this would happen and to save everyone a lot of time and effort I'm bowing out of this debate (but I reserve the right to return if need be).

I've been involved in betting for a long time, probably longer than some of the posters on here have been alive. A number of years ago I made my living solely from betting which, as anyone who currently does that will tell you, isn't the easiest thing to do.

I know all the theory...the value prices, the proportional staking, betting bank ONLY used for betting, etc etc. Unless they are extremely dedicated and disciplined most gamblers consider the end of the week 'the longer term', some probably the end of the day. When you do this for a living it's not the case...there is no end date.

Now, going back to a point that Jamesblake made about maybe not being in profit after the first 50 but in front after the first 5000 you have to ask yourself whether it's worthwhile waiting that long.

If gambling is a hobby then I don't care what you do and how you do it but if it's the way you feed yourself and your family then it matters. Value ALONE simply isn't good enough IF your selection method sucks. Now that previous sentence is all I have been trying to convey. Those two words ALONE and IF are the key. They go together. If you're getting value selections that are winning regularly then all is well, and that is what all the betting books will tell you. If you aren't then frustration and the poorhouse await.

Good luck to all you value seekers and those who really don't care what price you get as long as it wins / loses. In the words of the thread starter I NOW LEAVE.

LaughLaugh
Page 2 of 6  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com