We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
but he never really leaves
![]() Swearbox, as a betting veteran, for the pros is it still about picking either winners or picking odds that are going to shorten favourably? |
|
By:
Ask a pro Paul...I don't do this professionally.
|
|
By:
you did
|
|
By:
Well in my case it was all about picking losers. I layed as opposed to backed.
|
|
By:
Value ALONE simply isn't good enough IF your selection method sucks.
Value is all you need from your selection method. |
|
By:
cat flap - got the red wine ready?
|
|
By:
you need to know why things lose and win you just can say that is value or no value incase of laying
|
|
By:
yes and you have to know why something is value or it isnt. we're not just talking about horses being a big price here...we're talking about horses being 8/1 when they should be 9/2 and 12/1 when they should be 8s.
|
|
By:
well that's why you need a sensible staking plan and a proper bank GCI. Not stupid staking plan and a toy bank.
not directed at anyone, just a point that needs making. pro's don't use 2k banks mate |
|
By:
I've been involved in betting for a long time, probably longer than some of the posters on here have been alive. A number of years ago I made my living solely from betting which, as anyone who currently does that will tell you, isn't the easiest thing to do.
lol that you made a living doing this. I'm glad you had a lucky run once upon a time because you sure never had an edge. I know all the theory...the value prices, the proportional staking, betting bank ONLY used for betting, etc etc. Unless they are extremely dedicated and disciplined most gamblers consider the end of the week 'the longer term', some probably the end of the day. When you do this for a living it's not the case...there is no end date. Now, going back to a point that Jamesblake made about maybe not being in profit after the first 50 but in front after the first 5000 you have to ask yourself whether it's worthwhile waiting that long. Good job once again at failing to understand probability, expected value and just basic stats in general. If gambling is a hobby then I don't care what you do and how you do it but if it's the way you feed yourself and your family then it matters. Value ALONE simply isn't good enough IF your selection method sucks. Now that previous sentence is all I have been trying to convey. Those two words ALONE and IF are the key. They go together. If you're getting value selections that are winning regularly then all is well, and that is what all the betting books will tell you. If you aren't then frustration and the poorhouse await. I make my living betting sports and I swear by everything that I've said in this thread. I could explain to you in under 5 minutes precisely what my edge is and could back it up with historical data. You on the other could not, and no "Picking winners/Picking losers" is not an edge. |
|
By:
TomWar
I make my living betting sports and I swear by everything that I've said in this thread. I could explain to you in under 5 minutes precisely what my edge is and could back it up with historical data. You on the other could not, and no "Picking winners/Picking losers" is not an edge. Fire away...I'm reading... |
|
By:
There seems to be very little value in Betfair prices these days. Yes its market forces but after paying commission, there seems to be no advantage. Can anyone tell me why Betfair returns horse racing industry prices in decimals? The industry prices are always fractional.
|
|
By:
Fire away...I'm reading...
I refer you back to my first post: "Believe it or not sports betting is not about picking winners, it's about finding opportunities where the true win probability is greater than the implied probability of the price you backed." If you can beat the closing price in large efficient markets then you are doing the above and if you actually bothered to gather historical data and run simulations you would realize that this is a +EV strategy and one of the very few ways to make money in sports. However I doubt you'll ever be able to do this since you lack basic math skills. This is as far as I will hand feed you. |
|
By:
You are missing the point Tom, the question was about value. I do,nt care if i back an odds on winner or a 100/1 shot. Today i have had a industry 20/1, 25/1, winners amongst others. No great difference in the Betfair price, by which i mean that i might as well have put my bets on anywhere.I am not talking probabilitys. You might be amazed to know that i understand 1+1 = 2.
|
|
By:
Sorry i missed the point. 3 runner race, 1/2, 3/1, 12/1. Then the value bet is the 12/1.Why risk £2 to win £1, or £6. thats not value.
|
|
By:
I think you're very much missing the point Filho, as are quite a few of the posters here. Backing at value doesn't mean you back a 12/1 shot rather than a 1/1 shot. It means you believe the horse's true chances of winning are greater than the odds suggest.
If a horse goes off at 1/1, the market is giving it a 50% chance of winning. If you believe that horse actually has a 75% chance of winning, then you're getting value by backing it at 1/1. Of course, you won't necessarily be right in your assessment of the horse's value. However, if you're backing a 1/1 shot when its real chance of winning is only 40% (or a 12/1 shot when its real chance of winning is only 4-5%), you're going to lose over the long term. The more accurately you work out a horse's true value, the better you'll be at making good picks. |
|
By:
Interesting debate TomWar v Swearbox.
I'd consider myself to be a "Value betting pro" and lean towards TomWar's statement of "Believe it or not sports betting is not about picking winners, it's about finding opportunities where the true win probability is greater than the implied probability of the price you backed." If you can beat the closing price in large efficient markets then you are doing the above and if you actually bothered to gather historical data and run simulations you would realize that this is a +EV strategy and one of the very few ways to make money in sports. Now this is correct but "true" is impossible to be 100% certain of [requires a huge amount of skill to determine very accurately] and an assumption is made that large efficient markets retain no value at off which again is false. This is where Swearbox's argument although not made very sophisticatedly holds true as it is entirely possible to beat SP consistently and lose long term. |
|
By:
I think you're very much missing the point Filho, as are quite a few of the posters here. Backing at value doesn't mean you back a 12/1 shot rather than a 1/1 shot. It means you believe the horse's true chances of winning are greater than the odds suggest.
If a horse goes off at 1/1, the market is giving it a 50% chance of winning. If you believe that horse actually has a 75% chance of winning, then you're getting value by backing it at 1/1. Of course, you won't necessarily be right in your assessment of the horse's value. However, if you're backing a 1/1 shot when its real chance of winning is only 40% (or a 12/1 shot when its real chance of winning is only 4-5%), you're going to lose over the long term. The more accurately you work out a horse's true value, the better you'll be at making good picks. Very well said, this is essentially what I've been trying to convey. And racingguru I 100% agree that the market won't be perfectly efficient (these only really exist in theory), but efficient enough that finding value right when the event starts is significantly harder than finding value at any other point in time and that beating these prices will yield long term success. Aggregate market forces shape the market. |
|
By:
IF YOU CANT PICK WINNERS THEN HOW ARE YOU MEANT TO WIN
IF A THING DOSNT WIN THEN HOW THE HELL CAN YOU WIN IF YOU BACK MAN UNITED AND THEY LOSE THEY HAVE LOST FACT YOU HAVE TO BE ABLE TO PICK WINNERS A BETTER ODDS THAN WHAT THEY SHOULD BE YOU SAY ITS NOT ABOUT PICKING WINNERS THEN YOU CAN NEVER WIN A BET AND STILL WIN THATS WHAT YOUR BASICALLY SAYING IF YOU NEVER BACKED A WINNER HOW CAN YOU POSSIBLY WIN |
|
By:
Revolutionary, in your quest to become enlightened its apparent that you have too much doubt which underlines a lack of self-confidence which is the most important attribute to all successful persons, perhaps you should work to have more self belief before you aspire to change your life in other ways.
You have the rhetoric of a beaten man, not good at all. |
|
By:
If your 'value' picks don't win then they aren't fvcking value you idiot.
Mine are. |
|
By:
If a horse goes off at 1/1, the market is giving it a 50% chance of winning. If you believe that horse actually has a 75% chance of winning*********************************************************
OK lordbobbin that in effect sums up exactly what i have been saying If you believe......................... In other words pn your opinion. Value is your opinion, it can't be measured it is not exact and what you deem value others may think is unders. value is an opinion. |
|
By:
value is an opinion.
In most events it can be calculated closely enough to be considered fact.Especially in non-horse racing. If I know a price is somewhere between 2.12 and 2.14, I can comfortably bet 2.08. I don't know precisely how much value I'm getting, but I can stake as if 2.12 is the correct price and do okay out of it. Of course for those who have less time or cruder models, they may only be able to divine that same price is between 2.10 and 2.16. |
|
By:
Stating value as an opinion doesn't then declare its accuracy, the fact you are more accurate lori than say the average in your field doesn't negate the fact that its still an opinion, opinions can be right or wrong, hence theres is probability involved with all betting, nothings certain.
|
|
By:
It's still an opinion but if we're having an argument (it's not a debate as only one side are presenting reasons) about whether value exists it can be calculated accurately enough for the argument to be pointless most of the time. It's like trying to argue with Heisenberg about the exact location of something and saying "Well I can see it's there so of course I know where it is"
|
|
By:
Your value is hoping that your opinion is better than the general opinion expressed as a price through a betting platform, lori, hardly a fact?
|
|
By:
Lori
Not trying to catch you out but when you stated I don't know precisely how much value I'm getting is that tantamount to saying that you're not able to evaluate your edge? |
|
By:
For a large number of my bets I know the price I'm getting is better than the true value.
This is not always the case and sometimes I'm betting on opinion and hoping, but many of my bets have a very precise number that I can bet very confidently. People overthink these things. |
|
By:
looks like we are gliding into the jungle of mixed metaphors, lets all avoid[;)]
|
|
By:
If I know a price is between 2.12 and 2.14 and the price on offer is 2.18, I can only confidently bet as if the true price is 2.14 (There's probably a proof lying around somewhere than I can bet as if it's 2.135 or similar and get away with it in that circumstance).
In that respect then I don't know my exact edge, but also I can comfortably value bet the event and not worry about some of the crazy arguments presented here. Yes they're technically right but in the real world they're meaningless. |
|
By:
Talking of value, anyone had a look at Bet-tor dot com, seems like a good site , early days but impressive.
|
|
By:
Nothing is certain.........but opinion can be generally "correct" in long term........and if the opinion is converted to a systematic way to rate horses, then you have a strong basis to indicate where "VALUE" exists using RANK position and the odds.
Markets are consistently "wrong" re odds of certain horses that have factors in favour for a particular race on the going at the distance at the time in year etc etc .......and it is a fact that they have been "wrong" in past and it is very very likely they will be "wrong" in the future too. Are any of you non-value believers saying the odds are always "correct"? FOOTBALL odds are far lower than HORSES...........so with such a sport it must be far harder to find "VALUE" as the fractions are so small. The "edges" that exist are probably mainly based on knowing the way markets move.......and exploiting that in certain matches where "factors are in favour"...... Many will do same with HORSE betting too.......exploit market moves......but the skill factor is far higher on trying to find the winner, and the rewards are higher value odds ( more than 3 outcomes in a 15 runner field etc ). Such "edge" is far more clear in HORSE betting than FOOTBALL betting......Exploiting market moves applies generally to all sports betting, therefore is not in the same category as finding horses that are likely to have a good chance to win/place....and their odds are in your favour. Finding the "VALUE" ones is where the FUN is and, as it takes skill to do so, then to "take it too seriously" is ESSENTIAL otherwise the FUN of getting winners at VALUE won't happen! |
|
By:
Isn't that the place that bots Betfair's prices and charges you more commission for being loyal? Something along those lines. There was a thread a while back.
|
|
By:
Well it benifits all new bettors with a very low comms, but the more you make the more your charged, isn't that what betfair now do, only they do it with a karate chop instead of a couple of percent.
|
|
By:
Fair point
|
|
By:
'THE-REVOLUTIONARY.
01 Oct 11 06:21 IF A THING DOSNT WIN THEN HOW THE HELL CAN YOU WIN IF YOU BACK MAN UNITED AND THEY LOSE THEY HAVE LOST FACT ' If someone said you could have 3/1 about Man Utd in every Prem game this season, would you lose much sleep if they lost their first game 1-0? Revolutionary, you are either fishing or beyond help, and for that reason i'm out. |
|
By:
bf-fanatic - you clearly have no idea what "value" is. It's not opinion based - that's the whole point of it. it's true probability and the right price for the event occuring.
we don't just price things up random to the nearest point mate. still i'd really rather this debate stopped because it benefits me greatly that you don't believe it's real. when you start betting give me a shout what you're on [;)] |
|
By:
Please some of you get a copy of Value Betting by Mark Coton, it's a good place to start.
|
|
By:
hejik
bf-fanatic - you clearly have no idea what "value" is. It's not opinion based - that's the whole point of it. it's true probability and the right price for the event occuring. How can you declare value isn't opinion based as every market price is the direct result of generalised opinions otherwise the prices would be un-dynamic and not change? Of course there are a mutitude of scientific methods to arrive at a more accurate figure but even the most accurate figure of value as profitable differece of percieved chance against implied chance via a market position, it would still be an opinion as its not certain, just probable. What is it that value is or isn't an opinion debate that is difficult for posters to understand? even Einsteins general theory of relativity is an opinion, a highly accurate and proven one but still when viewing certain tensor formulas involving high gravity fields, it starts to become inaccurate and thus underlines its divinity as an opinion. even god is an opinion, expressed only with clarity by opinionated people or other lifeforms yet universally known[;)] |
|
By:
IF you want even stranger than truth information, do you know that its only a generalized opinion that the whole human race is made of something as opposed to nothing as if you took all the empty space between the particles in all the atoms of all the people on this planet, you would have a sugar cube size of energy of a matter form, this again is composed of quantum particle activity that suggests nothing actually exists only in the instance that you measure it so thus having the profile of something made from nothing explaining how all creation came from nothing as this is probably what it is made of to justify its initial resource.
Mind boggling data do you not agree but of course its only an opinion that is the creation of minds that are made form atoms made of well, nothing [;)] |