Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 231 comments are related to the topic:
TAKING VALUE TO SERIOUSLY

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 4 of 6  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 231
By:
hejik
When: 02 Oct 11 22:59
bff it isn't opinion if it's a statistical probability
although if you are a "god believer" then there's probably no helping you Laugh
By:
LordBobbbin
When: 02 Oct 11 23:01
Well we are talking opinions here, but those opinions are pretty damn crucial. True Odds exist for every single runner in every single event. In mathematically-based events like roulette, we can accurately determine those true odds. In sports betting, we can't - unless we're fixing the event! But we still need to try and estimate what the true odds are, and the more accurate we are with those estimations, the better we'll be at spotting the runners that have value - ie, a 2.0 shot that ought to really be priced at 1.75 etc.
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 02 Oct 11 23:02
If you lack the wisdom to work out if I do or do not believe in god correctly, or even attempt to know with any punity on the little sign that I have given you then you are best advised not to believe in any opinions other than your own as it seems you own all the facts.
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 02 Oct 11 23:09
I think the metal block here is based on the misconception that an opinion as opposed to a fact is seen from a singular observation point when in fact, all facts are still opinions.

all probabilities are either accurately or inaccurately expressed but still opinions as are any representations of fiscal value observed.

Furthermore any observers value of value is an opinion, need I go onConfused
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 02 Oct 11 23:12
wikipedia "OPINIONS"

in general, an opinion is a subjective belief, and is the result of emotion or interpretation of facts. An opinion may be supported by an argument, although people may draw opposing opinions from the same set of facts. Opinions rarely change without new arguments being presented. However, it can be reasoned that one opinion is better supported by the facts than another by analysing the supporting arguments.[1] In casual use, the term opinion may be the result of a person's perspective, understanding, particular feelings, beliefs, and desires. It may refer to unsubstantiated information, in contrast to knowledge and fact-based beliefs.
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 02 Oct 11 23:17
If betting was all fact and no opinions then there would be no value at all, it is the difference in opinion, especially on a more accurate and realistic exchange market that creates the value.

betting value is powered by difference in opinion, fact.
By:
HARRY22
When: 03 Oct 11 01:06
^ spot on imo
By:
TomWar
When: 03 Oct 11 01:13
betting value is powered by difference in opinion, fact.

I don't even understand what this means because it doesn't make any sense. Prices offered by people/books are opinions or estimations on the probabilistic outcome of an event. The expected value of your bets depend on what prices you got when compared to the true probability of the participant.

Keep arguing value is an opinion (whatever this is even supposed to mean) you provide lols for us with a clue.
By:
LordBobbbin
When: 03 Oct 11 01:32
But Tom, I think his point is that, while an event may have a true probability, there is no way for us to determine precisely what that true probability is. We can have an opinion on what we believe the true probability is, and the well-informed participants with effective tools for assessing probability should be getting quite close to the true probability time after time.

Ultimately though, everybody must come up with an opinion as to the true probability of any entrant winning. Some opinions will be incredibly well informed and may be very accurate again and again. But they are, nonetheless, opinions.  And if our idea of the true probability of winning is an opinion, then so must be our assessment of value.
By:
cpfc4me
When: 03 Oct 11 02:45
If you can't determine what the true probability is, why would you have a bet?

The measure of how good your opinion of value (which exists) is can be found in your P&L.
By:
LordBobbbin
When: 03 Oct 11 03:24
You would have a bet because you think you've got a pretty strong idea what the true probability is. However, that isn't the same as *knowing* what the true probability is. Your opinion of the true probability might well be a lot better than the next person's, but it's still an opinion. You can't know the exact probabilities of one horse winning, even though you could know exactly what your chances of winning were if you placed your money on Red at the Roulette table.

Yes, your P&L will give you a fair idea of whether you've been able to spot value in previous bets. However, it doesn't tell you that if you calculate a horse's true price today as being 2.76, its true price actually will be 2.76. You'd presumably hope that your calculation produced a price that was very close to the real thing, but it's still only an opinion.

To be honest, I think we're arguing over a very tiny point here. I agree pretty much totally with Tom - GCI and his cohorts, frankly, are idiots.  It's important to be looking for value. However, our assessment of whether or not it exists in any one particular case is only ever an opinion. Provided our opinion is well-grounded, we should find value more often then not and make money over the long term.
By:
cpfc4me
When: 03 Oct 11 04:31
I certainly wouldn't apply my comment to horse racing. There are far easier sports to calculate the 'true' probability in, and I was thinking of those. Baseball is the best example, a sport where the probability of a team winning from every game state is known based on 100 years of data. Check out The Book - Playing The Percentages In Baseball - by Tango, Lichtman and Dolphin.
By:
LordBobbbin
When: 03 Oct 11 05:19
Thanks for the book recommendation. I'll go and check it out.  (The downside of betting on baseball is that I might have to watch some baseball...  No amount of money is worth that punishment!! Laugh)
By:
racingguru
When: 03 Oct 11 05:57
cpfc - whilst past data helps reflect "true" probability think it is naive to think that is the be all and end all. True probability is an opinion and whilst really good punters/judges may be able to get really close in their estimation it is just that and estimation. They profit by knowing that their estimations are close enough that over many events betting at odds above their estimations they will profit.
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 03 Oct 11 09:07
If the outcome of an event is not known as it is not completed and also the outcome is uncertain then any bet placed on its outcome can be classed as an opinion as is any price that reflects its chance and any method used to predict its chance, even if a completely automated process, the process itself can be classed as the product of an opinion, of course other posters if they feel that betting is not based on opinions can put there opinions on this matter forward at the possible expense of there own creditability as sensible posters.
By:
catfloppo
When: 03 Oct 11 09:15
Just because people have an opinion on what is value and what isn't doesn't make it subjective.  True odds exist for any outcome just as there are an actual number of marbles in a jar.
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 03 Oct 11 09:26
Wrong example as there is no "jar" involved in a sporting event, the fact a jar of marbles is a defined amount makes its amount invariable, thus probability is not involved in this process , of course persons could guess what the amount was and this would be an opinion.

"true odds" ? , cat would you care to enlighten us to what this means? anti-post, pre-race , post start, in-play, tissue prices from a multitude of speculators or just marbles in a jar??????

This is getting better[;)]
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 03 Oct 11 09:32
The closest you will get to the "fixed marbles in a jar" scenario is a virtual race or FOBT gaming machine game, did you know that all managers can view exactly how much a person is winning and there credit amount when playing a machine, it seems data protection stops when one enters a LBO as it does when one has an account with any betting company therefore a customers value to the company becomes the subject of opinionLaugh
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 03 Oct 11 09:40
How can betting companies get away with advertising that they payout winnings and winners when they hide there rules about how much you can win in t & c or covert practices towards customers and there accounts?

Its a bit like easy jet saying "come fly with me" and then turning the plane round mid-Atlantic and throwing the passengers out the cargo door as they are perceived as UN-profitable by the company on this particular trip!
By:
catfloppo
When: 03 Oct 11 09:57
If it's invariable how many marbles are in the jar?
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 03 Oct 11 10:01
Unless there is a change in the condition of the jar of marbles the amount thats in it is invariable, it is a "constant" amount.
By:
catfloppo
When: 03 Oct 11 10:02
Ok, what is that amount?
By:
hejik
When: 03 Oct 11 10:04
BFF don't really care if you believe in god or not, nor does it have any relevance to this "debate".
I think you read too many books.

Also, I'd be interested to see if we could quantify the [b]VALUE[/b] of betting advice from someone who as far as anyone knows has never even placed a bet
By:
hejik
When: 03 Oct 11 10:06
i'd imagine it would come a pretty close second to a chimpanzee picking runners with a blindfold and a pin
but that's just my "opinion" [;)]
By:
THE-REVOLUTIONARY.
When: 03 Oct 11 10:08
what if someone thinks a price should be 1.75 and the othe guy thinks it should be 1.76ShockedShockedShockedShockedShockedShockedShockedShockedShockedShockedShockedShockedShockedShockedShockedShockedShockedShockedShockedShockedShockedShockedShocked
By:
THE-REVOLUTIONARY.
When: 03 Oct 11 10:10
hejik YOU DONT HAVE TO PLACE A BET TO HAVE A KNOWLEDGE OF SPORT FACT NOT FICTION
By:
hejik
When: 03 Oct 11 10:10
what difference does that make? if you can take 2.0 then it matters not a jot you moron
By:
THE-REVOLUTIONARY.
When: 03 Oct 11 10:13
YOU GOT ANGER ISSUES MATE
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 03 Oct 11 10:13
I amazes me the amount of posters that seem to magically know of my betting frequency on betfair, it seems that, how much we bet, what our views are about company practices, how much we have won, how much we can keep is all data at the disposal of persons happily working outside of the premise of general data protection consensus to bolster up there own inadequateness's as a company, individuals or "fair" persons.

just my opinion of course
By:
hejik
When: 03 Oct 11 10:14
no i don't mate, i just think clueless people shouldn't be posting on intelligent topics
the point you tried to make was idiotic
By:
hejik
When: 03 Oct 11 10:17
i don't know anything about your betting bff, nor do i care.
win/lose it don't make a difference to me but you are continually spouting nonsense about a concept that you clearly don't grasp.

you mate revolutionary is the same. open sup like 5 threads asking the same question, shows a clear misundestanding of the topic under discussion yet wants to argue an idiotic point with people that do understand it (the same people he'd asked for help in the first place)
By:
THE-REVOLUTIONARY.
When: 03 Oct 11 10:18
THE POINT IS HOW CAN PEOPLE ESTIMATE VALUE TOO EXACT ODDS


CLUELESS YOU HAVNT PROVEN YOUR WORTH ON HERE SO YOUR NO BETTER THAN ANY ONE ELSE SO YOUR IN NO POSITION TO ACT THE BIG SHOT 

AND THE FACT YOUR TRYING TO ACT HARD ON THE INTERNET MAKES IMO YOU A SAD VILE INDIVIDUAL


PLUS IM NOT WRITING ON A JOTTER SO HOW CAN I JOT ON I THINK YOUR THE IDIOT LaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaugh
By:
LordBobbbin
When: 03 Oct 11 10:19
Whether there is or isn't a jar involved doesn't make a difference as to whether true odds exist. Obviously the more factors (the more marbles) there are potentially, the more difficult it is to determine the true odds. Seeing that there's a jar will allow us to put a top figure on the number of marbles and then work our way down from there.

If we looked at enough jars of a same size, and estimated the number of marbles again and again, over time we'd become better at telling from a glance how many marbles there are. (Incidentally, this brings us over to the idea of Rain Man-style 'Autistic Savants'. Some Savants supposedly have an unerring ability to tell, for instance, the number of marbles in a jar. It's tempting to put this down to some amazing ability they were born with when, in fact, the truth is very different. Autistic Savants become obsessed with doing the same things again and again. If their particular obsession involves counting marbles in a jar, they might do that thousands (if not millions) of times in a day. Their ability to tell the number of marbles is simply a by-product of having done that same thing billions and billions of times over their lifetime.)

However, every event has a precise chance of being successful. If you were to play that event several million times, you would see its 'true odds'.  All of us have to estimate what we believe those true odds to be, and the closer we get, the more effective we'll be at working out whether there's value (ie, a significant difference between what the price should be and what it actually is) at the prices given.   To a certain extent, we all have to strive to become Savants in our fields as much as possible.
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 03 Oct 11 10:19
i'd imagine it would come a pretty close second to a chimpanzee picking runners with a blindfold and a pin but that's just my "opinion"

Of lets not debate on issues hejik, just debase into hatred and anger, humans count on there fingers, chimpanzees would happily bite them off as they haven't evolved the unique way we have, yourself excluded Blush
By:
LordBobbbin
When: 03 Oct 11 10:20
Dev, don't start bringing up that drivel about 'proving your worth'.  You're getting as tiresome and idiotic as Paulme.
By:
catfloppo
When: 03 Oct 11 10:23
BFF, how many marbles in the jar?
By:
THE-REVOLUTIONARY.
When: 03 Oct 11 10:25
MATE I THINK I KNOW WHAT VALUE IS THE POST WAS ABOUT SOME PEOPLE TAKE VALUE TOO SERIOUS START GOING DOWN THE PATH OF BACKING 1000-1 MULTIPLES AND BACKING OVER 6.5 GOALS THINKING A BIG PRICE IS AUTOMATCALLY VALUE


YOU HAVE TO KNOW WHAT WINS AND LOSES BEFORE YOU LOOK FOR VALUE


THIERS NO POINT BACKING A FOOTBALL TEAM BECUASE THERE 5/1 AND BETTING IT BLINDLY BECUASE THERE 5/1

YOU KNOW IT AND EVERYONE ELSE KNOW IT PEOPLE PLACE 10 FOLD ACCAS FACT NOT FICTION

IF I DIDNT UNDERSTAND VALUE THEN I WOULD BACK EVERY 1.01 BLINDLY EVERY DAY

FACT NOT FICTION


I NOW LEAVE

LIKE I SAID YOU HAVE NOT PROVEN YOURSELF TO ANYONE  THERFORE YOU ARE IN NO POSITION TO THINK YOUR A BIG SHOT

YOU CANT POSSIBLE KNOW EVERYTHING ABOUT EVERY SPORT THEREFORE YOU ARE IN NO POSITION YO COMMENT ON THINGS YOU DONT KNOW ABOUT

YOU CAN ONLY RELATE TO WHAT SPORT YOU KNOW FACT NOT FICTION


I NOW LEAVE
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 03 Oct 11 10:25
Brilliant post lord bobbin and how very true.
By:
THE-REVOLUTIONARY.
When: 03 Oct 11 10:28
its true lord these guys cant possibly know about every sport



why dont they play at fifa for money if they think there big shots that right they wont play a thing where thier in control

i now leave
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 03 Oct 11 10:40
REvolutionary, are you for real, gotta be a wind-up, if you are leaving have you considered any new avenues to explore, spoon bending could be just the thing, if rubbing it with your little finger doest work you could bend them round hejiks little todger.
Page 4 of 6  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com