Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 2105 comments are related to the topic:
*****Yeates Murder Case***** (Wed 5th Jan 2010)

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 13 of 53  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | ... | 53 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 2,105
By:
Rocket to the FACE
When: 07 Jan 11 14:39
IF what the groundsman saw was the murderer then it does suggest that it was just one person?
By:
M T wallet
When: 07 Jan 11 15:33
Two people reported screams at 9pm
(both outside)
If screams came from victims flat surely they would be
heard inside by other tenants
By:
kkkatt
When: 07 Jan 11 15:37
nirvana
agree with most of your synopsis.however i still have issues over time of death.as far as im aware, police have still yet to confirm if the body was clothed in green sweater and dark pants as seen on cctv.autopsy cannot confirm that the pizza was eaten.assuming she planned to eat the pizza on arrival home, this leaves two scenarios.firstly,she gets home and is murdered before she ate the pizza.this puts time of death 9 to 9-30pm on friday.
if she eats the pizza, she didnt die until sunday,otherwise autopsy would confirm she ate the pizza.
i know everyone thinks its obvious she died on friday night,but show me a quote where police confirm this.
if the body is clothed as seen on cctv,we most likely have our time of death...friday pre 9-30pm.
By:
1st time poster
When: 07 Jan 11 15:37
body found 3 miles away
no immediate or obvious signs of death
no sign of forced entry
no pizza
no sightings in or out of building
boyfriend didnt see any signs of struggle in flat

what do the police no that we dont that convinces them she was killed in the flat
By:
wur
When: 07 Jan 11 15:42
Just that she arrived back at her flat and was not abducted en route and that she was found without her boots.
By:
A_T
When: 07 Jan 11 15:52
99% certain killed in the flat IMO
By:
1st time poster
When: 07 Jan 11 15:54
wur there is no sightings of her arriving back at her flat
By:
A_T
When: 07 Jan 11 15:56
So she was killed/snatched in the street? Then her shopping, boots and coat were put in the flat afterwards by someone? Makes absolutely no sense.
By:
Nirvana
When: 07 Jan 11 16:00
True, AT. But then it makes no sense killing her in the flat and moving the body - unless the killer was closely conected to the flat and wanted to give himself time to hide the body and put some distance between him and the crime.
By:
1st time poster
When: 07 Jan 11 16:03
if you had access to flat ie bf , LL,  what would you choose given the choice,placing phone ,bag,cider etc in flat,or remove dead body, neither makes sense but one is no stranger than the other
By:
A_T
When: 07 Jan 11 16:11

Nirvana Joined: 08 Jun 06
Replies: 8640 07 Jan 11 16:00   
True, AT. But then it makes no sense killing her in the flat and moving the body - unless the killer was closely conected to the flat and wanted to give himself time to hide the body and put some distance between him and the crime.


Nail hit on head IMO

By:
Nirvana
When: 07 Jan 11 16:26
Also hard to imagine she was abducted from the flat.  That would have entailed a struggle and needed two people: one to keep hold of her; the other to drive the car.

More likely, she was killed in the flat and her body moved later when the area (parties, etc) ahd quietened down.
By:
curious-cat
When: 07 Jan 11 16:28
... but then what if she freely goes outside ( perhaps lured by a pretence - someone claiming they are lost or someone she knew ) expecting to go back to the flat almost immediately so no coat etc.

She could have been murdered elsewhere.
By:
curious-cat
When: 07 Jan 11 16:29
It's difficult to find a reason for the missing pizza whatever you think happened.
By:
Nirvana
When: 07 Jan 11 16:33
But no footwear either, c-c?
By:
Nirvana
When: 07 Jan 11 16:36
Yes, pizza another puzzle. Did she have time to cook and eat it? If not, the killer must have taken it for some reason.
By:
PatPongSexWhale
When: 07 Jan 11 16:41
Because it was in the oven cooking and someone who cared about the flat would take it out of the oven as not to start a fire...
By:
GT
When: 07 Jan 11 16:42
Nirv, do you think the Landlord likes Pizza?
By:
Nirvana
When: 07 Jan 11 16:44
No comment, GT.

Pat, why not just turn off the oven? Far easier than disposing of the pizza and the box.
By:
1st time poster
When: 07 Jan 11 16:44
maybe the boyfriend told her at lunch he wasnt going till after tea , and ther arranged to have a pizza, still doesnt explain no wrappings etc
By:
Nirvana
When: 07 Jan 11 16:50
Her bf had left at 7pm (ish), so she knew she would be alone. That's why she went to the pub, I suppose, for some company. Pizza not huge anyway, and she could have saved half for another day if not that hungry.
By:
GT
When: 07 Jan 11 16:51
If there was footprints in her flat forensics woulda picked them up i'm sure..

However, perhaps the murderer didn't enter the flat with shoes/boots on etc?
By:
TELL DEL
When: 07 Jan 11 16:51
boyfriend sent txt messages and calls to Jo while he was away with no response,
unless they had a row surely that was a bit odd not to get any reply at all (?)

huge amount of forensic activity at flat so police must believe that is where she died,
so if that is right you'd think the killer would have just run, why move the body (?)
even more risk of being caught, unless the purpose was to put distance
between the flat as a crime scene (?)
By:
good value losers
When: 07 Jan 11 16:53
ffs why are ppl still posting about the lack of response to texts and calls? Cry Cry Cry
By:
1st time poster
When: 07 Jan 11 16:59
because we havnt been told if she read,aknowledged calls and just ignored them,or that the messages were unread
By:
good value losers
When: 07 Jan 11 17:04
sorry, i wasn't clear enough as i was SEETHING at reading the same old stuff over and over. i meant why are ppl still suggesting the bf should think it odd her not replyinh when it's been said 77,764,233,555 times that it wasn't unusual for her not to respond.
By:
curious-cat
When: 07 Jan 11 17:05
Nirvana  07 Jan 11 16:33 
But no footwear either, c-c?


If she was murdered outside the flat it's easy to envisage perhaps the sock being used for the murder .. if so why bother to put the shoes back on a dead body .. and it's easier to burn/dispose of the shoes separately than attempt to carry a body with the shoes on anyway.

If you disregard the pizza it all points to the murder being committed outside the flat - but if so why is the pizza missing.
Perhaps it was being cooked and the murderer went back to switch off the oven in case it caused a fire - leading to the discovery of Joanna missing 2 days earlier.
By:
maveric
When: 07 Jan 11 17:07
Surely the most likely Pizza explanation is that she met someone at last minute who suggested she bring it over and eat it there for company? She may well have been in the flat for a min. when she got a call and thought 'why not'?'  There's no reason to think she went in socks; I am sure she had other shoes apart from the boots, and quite likely neither the bf or parents knew exactly what shoes she possessed.
By:
curious-cat
When: 07 Jan 11 17:08
good value losers

the boyfriend would have had to lie to the police and plan the murder.
I assume as has been reported that his petrol receipts checked out -
also what possible motive would he have had ?
they appeared to both be very happy.

If you have just moved in with someone and it doesn't work out you just leave.
By:
The Magic Flea
When: 07 Jan 11 17:10
shirley the coroner would be able to establish whether she was strangles using hands or a sock or other. The police are keeping schtum for a reason. No need to give away all the details that only the murderer(s) may know about, whilst hoping for a slip up
By:
Aceme
When: 07 Jan 11 17:11
She was strangled with a ligature
By:
curious-cat
When: 07 Jan 11 17:11
maveric - that fits

someone she knew turns up in a car - suggests she goes to their place and takes the uncooked pizza with her.
By:
curious-cat
When: 07 Jan 11 17:12
Her mobile isn't missing so presumably there was no last minute phonecall.
By:
curious-cat
When: 07 Jan 11 17:13
Aceme  07 Jan 11 17:11 
She was strangled with a ligature


Do you know or is that a guess ?
By:
curious-cat
When: 07 Jan 11 17:14
As well as the absence of the pizza is the absence of any motive.
By:
Aceme
When: 07 Jan 11 17:15
curious-cat 07 Jan 11 17:13
Aceme  07 Jan 11 17:11 
She was strangled with a ligature

Do you know or is that a guess ?






Well thets what the police have said
By:
curious-cat
When: 07 Jan 11 17:15
sorry, I didn't know.

perhaps the sock ?
By:
Aceme
When: 07 Jan 11 17:16
But if she went elsewhere wouldn't she take her coat, keys and phone?
By:
curious-cat
When: 07 Jan 11 17:17
Aceme

I think your posts are amongst the more sensible posts on the related threads.

but I've got about 12 pages to read on this particular thread Happy
By:
pixie
When: 07 Jan 11 17:18
I'd like to see someone try and strangle another with a sock.Laugh
Page 13 of 53  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | ... | 53 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com