Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Your Competitions

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 169 comments are related to the topic:
How Can We Make The Premiership More Exciting!!

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 2 of 5  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 169
By:
Lampus
When: 14 May 14 09:45
This thread is a wine up  or even wind up  thread
one of the best  ones for years
well  done all Laugh
By:
stealthgun
When: 14 May 14 20:10
223, I was thinking that but then how do you determine relegation if 10 napsters fail to hit the mark at all during the month and all finish on 0. Only 5 can go down. Also, what if somebody in the last relegation spot has the same total as the napster in the spot above and both have had the same number of wins during the month?
By:
learning thegame
When: 14 May 14 22:08
I am guilty of going for odds on winners, (time and laziness is to blame). So what ?  The whole point of this game is to win it isn't it ? I know that the best I can hope for is mid table or just avoid relegation with too many odds on shots. To win the league you must go for bigger priced selections some of the time, i.e. when you think you have found one. Isn't this what betting on horses is all about ?
I say let people select what they want, don't mess about with the rules which have been fine for many years. In fact I would go back to the days of no selection is -£1(minus 1). If you can't post for a few days because of holiday or something then allow them state FRF or LRF for their selection in advance.  Simples?
By:
Shanelee1966
When: 14 May 14 22:13
Keep the views/opinions coming.
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 14 May 14 22:15
Relegate anyone with a negative total for monthDevilLaughTongue Out
By:
salmon spray
When: 14 May 14 22:19
learning thegame has the most sensible post imo,except he probably doesn't know the rather technical reason for not allowing FRF ( I've forgotten it tbh ). Having said that we had a democratic vote to get rid of LRF and I don't think we can revisit it yet. Might be reasonable to do so rather sooner than the 40 years,or more,we are going to have to wait to vote on Europe again.
In my case it's a bit of a myth I always pick odds-on. I go for a reasonable number that aren't but they rarely win. People don't notice those of course.
By:
stealthgun
When: 14 May 14 22:21
Salmon, FRF doesn't work as you can see if it wins, if it wins then don't post, if it doesn't win then you can always post a selection.
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 14 May 14 22:22
21 players with negative tally in PREM......and 9 positive scores in DIV 1.....so if stayed that way til end of month......9 get relegated and 9 get promoted.
By:
Stevie Gerrard
When: 14 May 14 22:24
I like DFC's idea
By:
stealthgun
When: 14 May 14 22:25
Surely even more odds on shots would get picked under that idea as people would try and safeguard once they get into positive figures or solidify if they are in a small negative.
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 14 May 14 22:25
Currently 21 players in DIV 1 with negative tally.....and 10 in positive in DIV 2....so 10 down and 10 up!( What do you think Reged?Laugh)
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 14 May 14 22:27
19 negative scores in DIV 2.....and 13 positive scores in DIV 3......so 13 promoted and 13 down!DevilLaugh
By:
Shanelee1966
When: 14 May 14 22:28
Ground breaking idea DFC Shocked
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 14 May 14 22:31
Fast track your way to higher DIVISION if you can get into positive score for month.....and will shake up those treading water on negative scores , to grab a good odds winner....say 2-1 SP for PREM league.....and you shoot up board!DevilLaugh
By:
salmon spray
When: 14 May 14 22:37
As long as people in the red in Div 3 are disqualified for 6 months.
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 14 May 14 22:39
stealthgun-

There are currently quite a few players in DIV 1 that would say just need a 5-1 SP winner to get into positive position etc........


10               101d1-1     grey shark (1)                      Master Mariner - 4.10 Winc          LAST            -1.00          -£0.54        
11       +2      1121d-1     Andrew In Sweden (1)                Gwanako - 4.40 Winc                  Won 1/2f          0.50          -£1.09        
12       -1      0201d-0     Ricky Santini (1)                    Sirpertan - 5.35 Bev                2nd 2/1        -1.00          -£1.37        
13       +2      11101-2     Kentish Man                          Final Pass - 2.20 Sedge              Won 2/5f          0.40          -£1.82        
14       -2      122d3f1     eccentric (1)                        Bells 'N' Banjos - 8.35 Sthl        lost            -1.00          -£2.08        
15       +5      21n31-0     SilverBuck1                          Virtuel Doudon - 6.10 FfosL          Won 4/6f          0.67          -£2.68        
16       -2      22201-0     Poppydog                            Handwoven - 5.00 Bev                lost            -1.00          -£2.70        
17       -1      02110-0     Ashmal                              Bells 'N' Banjos - 8.35 Sthl        lost            -1.00          -£3.61        
18       +4      1p030-2     dogdayafternoon                      Final Pass - 2.20 Sedge              Won 2/5f          0.40          -£3.85        
19       -2      2032000     top2rated                            Apache Gold - 7.55 Kill              lost            -1.00          -£4.00        
20       -2      02100-1     Red Bloom                            Triggers Broom - 2.30 Bev            lost            -1.00          -£4.17        
21       -2      21331-0     kwalker                              Molko Jack - 5.30 Sthl              2nd 4/1        -1.00          -£4.28        
22       -1      33000-1     hong kong fooey                      Al Muheer - 4.00 Bev                3rd 15/2        -1.00          -£4.50

Say they are get a 5-1 SP movement between now and end of month.........that would shake up those in PREM truddling along with a negative score.


Incentive for fast tracking to PRE from lower DIVISIONS.....and only the cream.....or lucky ones...will survive in PREMIERSHIP.
By:
learning thegame
When: 14 May 14 22:49
To work the FRF must be stated in advance(1 hour rule) and for the total number of days.  eg " I am on holiday, FRF for 4 days starting on Monday "  No instruction would result in a no selection penalty ie -£1 per day.
By:
soldieroffortune
When: 14 May 14 23:01
My vote ...... leave it as it is!
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 14 May 14 23:06
8       -1      01d1-11     stealthgun (2)                        5.45 - Timbuktu              Lost              -1.00          -£0.04    
===================================================================================

YUP ....can see why you vote status quoDevilLaugh
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 14 May 14 23:07
Ooooooooooooooooooopppppsssssssssssssssssssssssssssss sorry stealthgun.......wrong bodBlush
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 14 May 14 23:09
8       -1      01d1-11     soldieroffortune (2)                  5.45 - Timbuktu              Lost              -1.00          -£0.04


Both on same score ....both negative ....both had same losing selection....and both have had 2 days not selecting......easy to get you tooosssssseeeeeeeee   mixed upExcited
By:
soldieroffortune
When: 14 May 14 23:13
Wow if only you put this amount of effort and analysis into picking your selections you might not be 14th in Division 2! LaughLaugh
By:
Reged
When: 14 May 14 23:15
* yawn *
By:
petemac
When: 14 May 14 23:48
"God forbid if petemac ever got here he would go straight back down again" Angry
No worries on that score Salmon I am picking 6/1 winning Naps and getting deducted a point in Div 2 so looks like I am Reg Bound.Grin
It's not so bad in Div 3 some real good uns get found on a regular basis" and the chappie who runs it always looks after his own as well as being a very lenient and fair man LaughLaugh
Unlike that Sheffield SlutLaugh
By:
salmon spray
When: 15 May 14 00:37
You have obviously given up on ever reaching the Premiership pete       Grin
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 15 May 14 04:17
soldieroffortune - Only about 7 points behind you in yearly naps table for this year....and this is at SP.

However, probably well ahead of you at BF SP ....as probably only 1 or 2 odds on shots amongst winners in my guesses, and I suspect you have a fair few of them SOFDevilLaugh.( Just 1 of my winners halved in SP from 33-1 to 16-1 in short period before the off.......and at BF SP when backed about hour before race was substantially more than 33-1 SP!)

So won't take too much effort to over haul you before year is out SOFDevilCool

GL with bets.
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 15 May 14 04:24
Savello     55.00     4.00     Back     14-Mar-14 17:01     216.00
Savello     23.00     6.00     Back     14-Mar-14 17:12     132.00
Savello     5.00     36.00     Lay     14-Mar-14 17:12     -144.00


Just to indicate the difference between the 16-1 SP ( from memory that it won at ) and 55sBF odds backed at .
By:
Stevie Gerrard
When: 15 May 14 05:03
I say leave it as it is too as unless there were prizes
for finishing in the top 3 then there's nothing to
be gained for going for bigger prices. It's just about trying to avoid
relegation and giving yourself a chance on the last day.
I'd like to see just 1 division where everyone throws in say
50 quid and then the winner at the end of the month takes all.
By:
Stevie Gerrard
When: 15 May 14 06:19
As for the limiting odds on shots idea, would not
those odds on pickers then just switch to short odds
against favs, would it make that much difference?

I don't think it is the comp itself that makes the tipsters boring as
China castle has been in the premiership a long time and he does
not seem to keep picking odds on shots so it's best to leave it
as it is imo.
By:
Ming_the_Merciless
When: 15 May 14 08:38
Stealthgun wrote: I was thinking maybe 2 days a month you could have a golden selection. Like a golden ticket as you can have a no lose shot as if it loses, it gets settled as a non runner.

I still like this idea, it would be a 'free bet' selection.... stake non-refundable....

Maybe if I repeat it enough times in this thread someone will agree Excited
By:
petemac
When: 15 May 14 11:20
"You have obviously given up the race for the premiership Pete"

Salmon or Mr Consistency either will do. You see as a former Title holder and currently 4th in this Months premiership (mind you we can't read too much into the form with Shane being in 5th) I really can't understand how anyone from the lower Divisions can knock you. It is very rare to see you struggling for relegation so we can only put that down to you being a Class above the rest of us.
So it is only us from the lower regions being  jealous of your success that explains the remarks on this thread so keep on keeping on and I for one will never slag you off until I reach the heights that you have achieved.
So my message to all the Premiership Slaggers is PUT UP AND SHUT UP.Whoops
By:
salmon spray
When: 15 May 14 11:31
^^^^^
The Voice of Reason     Happy
By:
DubaiPrince
When: 15 May 14 11:47
There is very little skill involved in picking short price certainties every day and I like many others have resorted to picking endless odds on shots just in order to stay with the pack as it were- a kind of " if you can't beat them then join them" attitude if you like.There was such a row when LRF  instructions were done away with as there were clearly  pros and cons to both sides. And yet despite Reged saying the new rules are working fine they clearly aren't in the premiership as all it's done has made the Premiership even more negative than before.as has been said before the Premierships a different beast to all the other divisions in that it's a survival at all costs policy first and foremost for most of us so all I have suggested is looking at ways to make it a more competitive division to participate in and as far as I can see the main problem is that far too many of us pick too many ridiculously  short priced selections day in day out.Not too many premiership posters have commented  on the thread with their views which leads me to think  that maybe everyone is happy with things as they are but I for one propose that we put it to the vote and ask them whether we should be restricted to a set amount of odds on shots every month- it would be interesting to see how the vote went and I don't believe it would be hard at all to  police if used in conjunction with the no post days. So come on Shane GIVE US THE VOTE
By:
salmon spray
When: 15 May 14 11:54
I wouldn't quarrel with democracy DP.
Though I might emigrate if the vote went the wrong way.
I had a taste of being in Div 3 last month when I posted for somebody who was away. Felt free as a bird. I might like it there   Happy
By:
Reged
When: 15 May 14 12:39
I'll be blunt. If there's any more changes at this stage I'm off. This new system is only just up and running and some people want to change it already. I spent a fair bit of time adjusting our spreadsheets for that change and I aint doing it again awhile. As I say, when I get a spare nanosecond I will try to see to what extent DP might be right. But to be honest, I find it a bit odd for someone to criticise something and then say they do it themselves. There's no bleedin money at stake so why stress so much about relegation? I suggest the first thing for the likes of DP to do is 'heal thyself' and be more bold rather than call for changes to save him from himself. Angry
By:
madhatter
When: 15 May 14 12:48
I agree with Reged.

If avoiding relegation is the limit of people's ambition (and there is no doubt most of the Prem tipsters can't see further than that) it is a pretty sad state.
Try being a China Castle rather than an Alan Keyte for once.

However, I also say that it is a napsters right to pick what he wants without penalty. If he wants to pick 30 horses between 4/6 and 1/10 then so be it. It's up to us (you) to pick better value horses and get a bigger monthly total.

People like China and deadbrain and HKP must love it that no-one ever makes a realistic attempt at taking away their crowns
By:
salmon spray
When: 15 May 14 13:04
I think Reg has put it to bed tbh. We are already one settler short so we can hardly afford to lose another one. I thought there were pros and cons about getting rid of LRF but I eventually voted against. The vote went the other way but I've not complained about it.
By:
china castle
When: 15 May 14 13:12
As Reg says just leave it as it is and concentrate on your own selections instead of worrying about what everyone else picks. Does it really matter if you get relegated after all its only a bit of fun with no money involved.
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 15 May 14 13:15
My initial post was "tongue in cheek".......but I still believe this change would make leagues more competitive  and encourage going for horses at odds against.

Take what I said below -

DFCIRONMAN 14 May 14 22:39 
stealthgun-

There are currently quite a few players in DIV 1 that would say just need a 5-1 SP winner to get into positive position etc........


10               101d1-1     grey shark (1)                      Master Mariner - 4.10 Winc          LAST            -1.00          -£0.54       
11       +2      1121d-1     Andrew In Sweden (1)                Gwanako - 4.40 Winc                  Won 1/2f          0.50          -£1.09       
12       -1      0201d-0     Ricky Santini (1)                    Sirpertan - 5.35 Bev                2nd 2/1        -1.00          -£1.37       
13       +2      11101-2     Kentish Man                          Final Pass - 2.20 Sedge              Won 2/5f          0.40          -£1.82       
14       -2      122d3f1     eccentric (1)                        Bells 'N' Banjos - 8.35 Sthl        lost            -1.00          -£2.08       
15       +5      21n31-0     SilverBuck1                          Virtuel Doudon - 6.10 FfosL          Won 4/6f          0.67          -£2.68       
16       -2      22201-0     Poppydog                            Handwoven - 5.00 Bev                lost            -1.00          -£2.70       
17       -1      02110-0     Ashmal                              Bells 'N' Banjos - 8.35 Sthl        lost            -1.00          -£3.61       
18       +4      1p030-2     dogdayafternoon                      Final Pass - 2.20 Sedge              Won 2/5f          0.40          -£3.85       
19       -2      2032000     top2rated                            Apache Gold - 7.55 Kill              lost            -1.00          -£4.00       
20       -2      02100-1     Red Bloom                            Triggers Broom - 2.30 Bev            lost            -1.00          -£4.17       
21       -2      21331-0     kwalker                              Molko Jack - 5.30 Sthl              2nd 4/1        -1.00          -£4.28       
22       -1      33000-1     hong kong fooey                      Al Muheer - 4.00 Bev                3rd 15/2        -1.00          -£4.50

Say they are get a 5-1 SP movement between now and end of month.........that would shake up those in PREM truddling along with a negative score.


Incentive for fast tracking to PRE from lower DIVISIONS.....and only the cream.....or lucky ones...will survive in PREMIERSHIP.
============================================================================================================================


If you were in PREM DIVISION, and in a relegation spot, you would know that it is not just getting above the one just above relegation line, but you would know that there is every chance that say 9 positive scores in DIVISION 1 will be promoted........so you need to aim at 10th bottom spot in league in PREM to try to avoid relegation! This makes it very likely that those just below relegation line in PREM , and those up to 9th bottom of PREM would have to set there sights higher than they would under present rules.

It gives greater incentive for those in lower DIVISIONS to get into positive tally for month, and thus get promoted.

The need to get odds against winners from those in say bottom 14 in PREM to reduce chance of relegation ( Currently 9 positive, I think, in DIVISION 1 at present) will invigorate those up to 14th bottom spot in PREM...................as with some of players just in negative figures down to say -5 tally are well capable of getting into positive tally by end of month, thus likely to increase those promoted from 9 to say 13/14 !

So far more incentive to get into positive score in all DIVISIONS. Generally should raise standard of scores across the DIVISIONS.

Those who choose the odds on route can still do so whenever they wish to, but they know that if in negative tally by end of month in PREM, then they are wide open to relegation!

More people will be involved in promotion and relegation battle , and should invigorate all the DIVISIONS.

If some choose not to participate in a more fierce competition, then that will be "sad". If they decide to give it a go, then hopefully they grab some better odds winners late in month to enjoy the competition more.

Is it fair to those in negative positions in PREM that they can be relegated with -.04 points tally? IMO....YES, as PREM should be for those who get positive scores, as they will survive the change.

For those who are really looking towards winning the YEARLY NAPS comp, so what if relegated because in negative position in one month. They will know that if they get a positive tally next month, then fair chance they will be promoted again.


(If PREM has 4 negative scores at end of month and DIV 1 has  10 positives.......there will be minimum of 5 promoted....so you can still be in positive in PREM and still be relegated ( the exception being that if the 5th bottom player in PREM has a greater positive score than the 5 highest player in DIV 1, then they stay in PREM!)

Such changes would make it more interesting for all the players in DIVISIONS.....if any decide to stayTongue Out

Sorry for posting more thoughts on such a change.......but dubai did ask the questionDevilLaugh

Status quo is ok by me......but a change would definitely shake things up a bitTongue Out
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 15 May 14 13:21
Understand Reged how you feel, and other controllers. (Never saw your post til finished above one Tongue Out)

Leave things alone.....but something to put "fear" into those in negative figs in PREM...DIV 1 DIV 2 DevilLaugh

STATUS QUO is fine !
Page 2 of 5  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com