We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
GEORGE I still remember that comment you made about me and salmon a few months ago and as far as I'm concerned you can f*ck off!
|
|
By:
The idea of incorporating the annual/rolling Naps Stats is interesting.
The tipsters at the top of that, play the tipping/betting game, how we'd all like to play it in real life. 30 days graft to tread water and finish where you started, with the same bank balance as the start of the month, totally defeats the object of semi/full-time betting. Those continually succesful on the annual/rolling Naps Stats, deserve far more (Betfair) kudos, than the paltry views those threads seem to get. |
|
By:
The idea of incorporating the annual/rolling Naps Stats is .... terrible.
We are in a league format and this skewers the NAP's table slightly. This has been looked at before and 16 of the top 20 were already in the prem!..... a one off 'blitz' would be very destructive IMHO..... someone has just mentioned that it was possible for someone to get promoted to the prem then be demoted before a ball is kicked...but someone in the prem could have scraped a couple of months and be relegated.. the rolling naps table should stand alone. |
|
By:
Totally agree with Ming
|
|
By:
I only judge myself by undecided's rolling naps table (and am found desperately wanting!
) but to bugger about with promotion/relegation in that way would be bloody stupid!I also don't see how making the Prem bigger and adding in an extra relegation place will make the slightest difference to Prem player strategy. However, I do question why the Prem isn't the same size at Div 1 and 2 in the first place? It's not like we have Champions League/Europa Cup committments is it! ![]() |
|
By:
I don`t think it will mad but at least you`ll have 2 extra people competing every month and it opens up an extra promotion place from div 1 every month too.
|
|
By:
So over a 12 month period, potentially you can promote new blood in to the premier an extra dozen times.
Also, potentially, you could have a completely different premier division every six months. |
|
By:
Obviously to get close to the above, those in divisions 1,2&3 must perform and be fairly consistant, maybe more so than at present. They have a large part to play in the scheme of things too.
|
|
By:
If you looked at the prem yesterday there were plenty of 'big' priced attempts.
|
|
By:
You could have a player sitting in div3 picking obvious odds-on shots but never getting promoted suddenly find themselves a few divisions higher. I think it would it would make things worse for div3 players because at the moment you have a few bad months going for long shots and then finally get one or 2 to get out the division. Whereas if you used the yearly tables to decide you'd get more players taking less risks and just waiting a few months to get promoted.
|
|
By:
You are a touchy one Soldier that's why I never say anything bad about you.
|
|
By:
![]() ![]() ![]() |
|
By:
Pete - did you receive a strange email from me? If you did, I wasn`t from me if you follow. I received one back with your email address but doubt very much you sent it.
|
|
By:
Stevie - not only are you a great footballer but have a good insight on how things would work if changes were implemented.
The Law Of Unintended Consequences. |
|
By:
Would you encourage more caution/strategy in say div 3? Quite possibly.
As I mentioned above, it`s down to the napsters in the lower leagues to up their game and knock the elite of their perch. Ming again makes a good point above. |
|
By:
I have no objection to increasing the size of the Prem to 30. Not that I've thought it through yet,but shane's arguments in favour of it seem to have some merit.
There is very little you can do to liven up the Premier Div without creating more work for the settler. And that's of paramount importance. But I do tend to agree that it needs livening up. It's become very dull, predicatable and boring. The only suggestion I can make, which would not create any more work, is to limit the type of races from which players can select. Handicaps only, for example, could be one idea. You don't get many short prices in handicaps. Once again, I haven't thought this through. It's a spur-of-the-moment idea which may well have been suggested before. Up to you to discuss it and then dismiss it. ![]() |
|
By:
Yes I received one from you something about a "Diet"
are you calling me a fat bas*****? ![]() |
|
By:
Yes it could do with livening up a bit HKF tried last month but only lasted 5 minutes.(useless he is)
![]() Once Reg and I get there, things will change for the better Sparks will fly , planets will explode and Soldier may even admit he is a cross dresser. |
|
By:
I still think its simple to implement - Limit (ONLY THE PREMIERSHIP REGED) Our odds on selections in the Premiership -simples- and before anyone bleats on about potential non runners creating "unwanted" odds on shots surely if you had used up all your lives as it were then you would be making sure that scenario couldnt happen. Surely it cant be that hard to implement Shane -or am i missing something-
Again the lack of input from the Premiership "allstars" is deafening which suggests they are happy with their lot but come on Shearer et al i know you want to chip in and have your say -the stage is yours .Either way Shane we should be allowed a vote to decipher what the real feeling is as i for one have held my hands up to "playing the game" as it were in the Premiership to the actual detriment of trying to win it and im sure many others now have the same attitude- that of survival at all costs- .It needs freshening up as its not working at present imo |
|
By:
I`ve thought of only using certain races momms, but decided aginst it. I feel we would be taking choices away from napsters and would feel restrictive.
|
|
By:
I don't do handicaps. That's why I've stayed in the Premiership for 3 years.
Now I've given the game away ![]() |
|
By:
The email wasn`t from me Pete, some sort of bleedin virus, I`ve had one from another Betfair dude but it isn`t
![]() |
|
By:
Dubai - to cap the price at say 1.5 (1/2) anything winning at under settled as a n/r isn`t difficult to police.
I now feel the settlers need to be in union regarding any changes no matter how small or widespread before anything would even be considered. Then we need a high number voicing their opinion for the said change. We just don`t have that at the moment. I understand fully your concern but at this time the best way forward is to increase the numbers in the premier and when 30 is reached have 5 promoted/relegated every month. Thanks for the input momms. |
|
By:
Shane , with the greatest of respect, increasing the size of the Premiership will have no effect whatsoever on the amount of odds on selections posted in Premiership - in fact i suggest it will only increase them -. Give us the vote in the Premiership to see just how people actually feel on the subject -that has to be the democratic way forward surely as then the "elite" will have to make a noise as it were. Strangely at present they are mainly quiet on the subject which does seem rather odd
|
|
By:
DP, I would say that restricting any vote on what happens in the Prem to current Prem players only is a non-starter. Divs 1, 2 and 3 are full of ex-Prem players trying to get back there. And everyone else is trying to get there too. That's the whole point of the exercise - to win the Premier title. So every player must have a say in what happens in the Prem.
But I do agree it needs a good shake-up. |
|
By:
Shanelee1966 17 May 14 12:01
I`ve thought of only using certain races momms, but decided aginst it. I feel we would be taking choices away from napsters and would feel restrictive. So you think you're a dictator now do you? ![]() I have to disillusion you and point out that the decision isn't yours to make. And yes, the whole point of only allowing certain types of races would be to take choices away from napsters and make it restrictive, thus making it a hell of a lot more competitive and more enjoyable. |
|
By:
Any rescriction on what you can and can't nap, whether it be limits on odds-on shots or only napping is certain races, is surely a non-starter. The whole point of a naps competition is to pick you best bet of the day and it shouldn't matter about price or race type.
|
|
By:
Spot on China!
|
|
By:
A dictator, I`ve never been called that before
![]() ![]() |
|
By:
No don't think restrictions on race type will work, besides some people may fancy taking on what they think is a poor odds-on shot in a maiden with a bigger priced horse.
|
|
By:
I think it`s a step too far. Who`s going to decide which races? All you will get is complaints.
|
|
By:
A Dic maybe
![]() |
|
By:
With China on that.
|
|
By:
I`ve always listened to everyone and encouraged debate from day 1.
My sole interest is keeping the comp going for everyone and having fun along the way. Reged has posted earlier in this thread and made his position very clear, kc has emailed me and wishes to keep things going as they are too. I`m fairly relaxed, so feel to take it any further would jeopardise the whole comp. Not only that where are the other dissenting voices? We are presently in a weak position regarding settlers, man of many moods has very kindly offered to step in but only on a temp basis which we are all very grateful to him for. Shane , with the greatest of respect, increasing the size of the Premiership will have no effect whatsoever on the amount of odds on selections posted in Premiership - in fact i suggest it will only increase them -. Give us the vote in the Premiership to see just how people actually feel on the subject -that has to be the democratic way forward surely as then the "elite" will have to make a noise as it were. Strangely at present they are mainly quiet on the subject which does seem rather odd I have to disillusion you and point out that the decision isn't yours to make. Who`s decision is it to make where changes are concerned? We have lost three settlers recently because of petty disputes. They all did a fantastic job but felt p1ssed off because of certain comments/critism. I will not allow that to continue, that does sound like a dictator I know but feel in the overall interest of the comp is warranted. What am I supposed to do, stand by and watch others go down the same route with no one prepared to step in. I along with the other settlers are guardians of this comp. My aim is as stated above and hopefully leave the comp in a better position than when I started. My point is, how many debates re changes are we going to have. Whatever we do many will feel aggrieved. My proposed change in numbers is no guarantee to alter things but surely it opens things up a little. What does everyone else think? |
|
By:
A Dic maybe
![]() ![]() ![]() More like it Pete, I have been called that before ![]() |
|
By:
Well said Maggie
![]() ![]() |
|
By:
![]() |
|
By:
Nowt wrong with the comp as it is, just needs some decent tipsters to get up to the premiership and shake things up and extra places could help in that respect.
|
|
By:
I say yes shane - make the prem the same size as the others.
No other changes needed. |
|
By:
With the current situation regarding a shortfall of settlers we need to tread very carefully to keep this going.
At the moment it is all boxed up with FRAGILE stamped on the front. I think it is best left to Shane to carry the box in the present climate. Shane is no way a dictator he is a very sporting player and good listener who does a Job second to none. For example he was against the change regarding LRF but still accepted the situation and got on with the job almost straight from the hospital bed. IT IS NOT THE TIME FOR A CHANGE maybe sometime in the future but not now. |