Forums
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 351 comments are related to the topic:
X factor voting figures

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 4 of 9  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 9 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 351
By:
TheFink
When: 09 Dec 12 22:38
District 3 third the week they did backflips. They should have ditched the harmonies!
By:
five leaves left
When: 09 Dec 12 22:39
It worked for Diversity Fink
By:
nigelpm1
When: 09 Dec 12 22:39

Dec 9, 2012 -- 5:38PM, five leaves left wrote:


That's what I was trying to do nigel.I think we can safely say James won tonight too.


Yep convincingly as well.  He polled 1.23x Jah's vote.

By:
Ski-Wiz
When: 09 Dec 12 22:41
If you lot are calculating it this way as below.

1000 votes

James got 517
Jah got 315
Chris got 168

Since Chris's eviction

Another 1262 votes totalling 2262

Chris 168
James 1214 - 517 = 697 (Sunday)
Jah 880 - 315 = 565 (Sunday)

So James got more votes since Chris's eviction.

What i did was calculate it without Chris's votes, hence a tad confused at first but can see where FLL is going.
By:
TheFink
When: 09 Dec 12 22:41
Angels Jahmene's lowest % since week 2 - bad choice for final.
By:
nigelpm1
When: 09 Dec 12 22:42

Dec 9, 2012 -- 5:41PM, Ski-Wiz wrote:


If you lot are calculating it this way as below.1000 votesJames got 517Jah got 315Chris got 168Since Chris's evictionAnother 1262 votes totalling 2262Chris 168 James 1214 - 517 = 697 (Sunday)Jah 880 - 315 = 565 (Sunday)So James got more votes since Chris's eviction.What i did was calculate it without Chris's votes, hence a tad confused at first but can see where FLL is going.


Ski - just follow my workings above - definitely spot on

By:
nigelpm1
When: 09 Dec 12 22:42

Dec 9, 2012 -- 5:41PM, TheFink wrote:


Angels Jahmene's lowest % since week 2 - bad choice for final.


absolutely terrible - why didn't he go for "At Last"

By:
five leaves left
When: 09 Dec 12 22:44
He did that last week and was nearly evicted Grin
By:
nigelpm1
When: 09 Dec 12 22:44

Dec 9, 2012 -- 5:44PM, five leaves left wrote:


He did that last week and was nearly evicted


true Excited

By:
Henry VIII
When: 09 Dec 12 22:46
I'm impressed with all you guys doing maths now. I'm too knackered to see the keyboard properly.
By:
five leaves left
When: 09 Dec 12 22:48
Given a sympathy vt every single week, Jahmene actually did pretty cr@p.
By:
five leaves left
When: 09 Dec 12 22:50
Looking at the week before the James/ Ella B2, the percentages were

Week 6

Christopher Maloney 23.6%

Jahmene Douglas 14.9%

James Arthur 14.0%

Ella Henderson 13.0%


They could have chosen any of the 3 to win then. Though not sure what more they could have done for Jahmene. They chose James.
By:
GeorgeBrush
When: 09 Dec 12 22:52

Dec 9, 2012 -- 5:41PM, TheFink wrote:


Angels Jahmene's lowest % since week 2 - bad choice for final.


Eggy effect Cool

By:
donny osmond
When: 09 Dec 12 22:52
Cowell has got 4 or 5 lps if he wants them

Not sure too many of them will be making a second lp
By:
five leaves left
When: 09 Dec 12 22:54
lp's?  I thought I was the only one who still played them
By:
Ski-Wiz
When: 09 Dec 12 22:55

Dec 9, 2012 -- 5:36PM, nigelpm1 wrote:


Ok here goes assuming 45k votes on sat and 55k votes on Sun - Sat James - 23,265Sat Jah - 14,175Sat + Sun James - 53,700Sat + Sun Jah   - 38,900Sun James = 30,435Sun Jah = 24,725


If you are talking about that then no as you can't assume the 55k. How many votes since Chris left is based on the percentage thus hence i worked out for every 1000 votes pre chris there is 1262 post chris

By:
TheFink
When: 09 Dec 12 22:55
Week 6 is interesting cos all of them were +10%. Union J were bottom two despite a voting increase from their 4th place the previous week! I think it was wide open at that stage.
By:
Ski-Wiz
When: 09 Dec 12 22:57

Dec 9, 2012 -- 5:48PM, five leaves left wrote:


Given a sympathy vt every single week, Jahmene actually did pretty cr@p.


I think they kept on at it because Chris was above Jah.....bad mistakes IMO

By:
five leaves left
When: 09 Dec 12 22:57
I still think week 6 was planned.
They'd thrown the kitchen sink at Jahmene and he couldn't beat Chris. So they had to get rid of James or Ella and then push one the other one.
They chose James, but Ella would have won just as easily.
By:
donny osmond
When: 09 Dec 12 22:57
Are they called albums these days ?
By:
five leaves left
When: 09 Dec 12 22:57
week 7 I mean
By:
GeorgeBrush
When: 09 Dec 12 22:58
Never really wide open - as certain acts have far bigger potential as vote grabbers

James and Ella ultimately, or who survived the longest
By:
five leaves left
When: 09 Dec 12 22:58
yep, albums I think donny Grin
By:
GeorgeBrush
When: 09 Dec 12 23:00
downloads I think
By:
TheFink
When: 09 Dec 12 23:00
James Arthur - v interesting looking at his vote compared to singing position. Given pimp slot each time following his lowest votes.
By:
GeorgeBrush
When: 09 Dec 12 23:00
That's TCO fink
By:
TheFink
When: 09 Dec 12 23:05
Melanie given pimp slot after poor vote in week 1. Didn't help :).
By:
five leaves left
When: 09 Dec 12 23:17
Everyone was in bed by the time she performed and those who were still watching will have wished they'd been in bed.
By:
Dizzy42
When: 09 Dec 12 23:48
So I still think Ella was TCO until week 3/4 when they started to doubt. Coincided with some awful song choices : performances of course. But with Chris top and Jahmene unable to debt his lead they panicked and needed to ditch one of Ella or James to put weight behind remaining act as the one to beat...

All very cynical, but it does show how TPTB can manipulate this to the end, without the desired put one for the first 7 or so weeks. It's all about momentum going into Semi and Final. They honed their skill with Little Mix last year and executed it to perfection with James this year.
By:
aljohnson
When: 09 Dec 12 23:52
Has anyone got a list of deadlock and judges choice's?
By:
TheMadness
When: 10 Dec 12 06:41
"Looking at the week before the James/ Ella B2, the percentages were

Week 6

Christopher Maloney 23.6%

Jahmene Douglas 14.9%

James Arthur 14.0%

Ella Henderson 13.0%


They could have chosen any of the 3 to win then. Though not sure what more they could have done for Jahmene. They chose James."

Some people are saying this to justify their continued belief that Ella could have won. I don't buy it. James won, not so much because he became the chosen one above Ella and Jahmene, he won because he justified the support. His performance of Falling in the bottom 2 was probably the best performance of the series. His momentum continued with Let's Get It On and Power Of Love. He was just better than the rest of them, and that's why he won.
By:
squares
When: 10 Dec 12 06:55
IS this what you want al?

Wk 1 Rylan / Carolynne

Nicole - Carolynne (send home)
Gary - Rylan
Tulisa - Rylan
Louis - Carolynne

Wk 2 - D3 / Mel

Louis - Mel
Tulisa - Mel
Gary - D3
Nicole - D3

Wk 3 - MK1 / Kye

Louis - Kye
Gary - MK1
Nicole - MK1
Tulisa - Kye

Wk4 - UJ / Jade

Louis - Jade
Tulisa - UJ
Nicole - Jade
Gary - Jade

Wk 5 - Rylan / Kye

Nicole - Kye
GAry - Rylan
Louis - Rylan
Tulisa - Kye

Wk 6 - D3 / UJ

Louis - refused
Gary - D3
Nicole - D3
(Tulisa would have said UJ)

Wk 7 - Ella / James

Tulisa - James
Nicole - Ella
Louis - James
Gary - Ella

Wk 8 - Rylan / UJ

Nicole - UJ
Louis - Rylan
Gary - Rylan
Tulisa - Rylan
By:
hemsby
When: 10 Dec 12 07:02
Have to disagree TM.James simply wouldn't have been allowed to sing Lets Get It On if he wasn't the favoured act.

I think the vast majority of the forum would agree with you that he was the best act,but he still needed help from TPTB to get over the line...

1. Saved when in bottom 2
2.Given voter friendly songs to sing from that point onwards
3.The constant celebrity endorsement
4.The continued Judges ramping
5.Powerful VT's in the final in particular

If Ella was saved in the sing-off,then recieved the same help that James did from the prods,I don't think it's too far fetched to believe she would have won.
By:
TheMadness
When: 10 Dec 12 07:06
I don't disagree that he was the favoured act. The point is he justified the support with performances of a much higher quality than Ella was capable of giving imo.
By:
hemsby
When: 10 Dec 12 07:14
Quite possibly yes....but I think some people on here (myself included) believe she still would have won ,even if her performance level wasn't as high as what James produced.All about opinions of course.
By:
TheMadness
When: 10 Dec 12 07:24
I think she would have lost to Jahmene
By:
GeorgeBrush
When: 10 Dec 12 08:32
Cobblers.  It would have been 1% closer

People were stick of the little potato-formed tragedy magnet
By:
squares
When: 10 Dec 12 08:33
Laugh
By:
GeorgeBrush
When: 10 Dec 12 08:33
Sick as well
By:
GeorgeBrush
When: 10 Dec 12 08:36
The voting shows he wasn't even nearly as popular as people imagined.

Without the ramps and vt's he'd have gone mid series
Page 4 of 9  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 9 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com