Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 2397 comments are related to the topic:
AFGHANISTAN

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 58 of 60  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 55 | 56 | 57 | 58 | 59 | 60 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 2,397
By:
dustybin
When: 01 Sep 21 16:21
Im asking a trump worshper about whether he thinks an action undermined democracy....
What a waste of time that one is
By:
Giuseppe
When: 01 Sep 21 16:23
haven't been following what Ghani did or didn't do

Afghan army has corruption problems, i'm happy to accept thatr
By:
dustybin
When: 01 Sep 21 16:26
Well you know he p1ssed off to save himself.

And dont you think that a corruptive army undermines collegues and could easily result in them taking casualties?
Do you think the British army soldier would take payment to leave their regiment out on a limb?
By:
dustybin
When: 01 Sep 21 16:38
I believe we have travelled all around the houses and returned with you agreeing with me
That he army had corruption issues, that religion is a major problem and that the people didnt believe enough in the ideology to properly fight for it.
By:
Whisperingdeath
When: 01 Sep 21 16:39
You would have stayed though dusty?

Give the millions of dollars away and have your goolies cut off and stuffed in your mouth and then be hanged in the town square because you are tough and a man of honour right?
By:
dustybin
When: 01 Sep 21 16:41
I wouldnt have taken the job because the idea of ruling over people doesnt bode well
But if I had I would have stayed as my conviction would have forced me to.
You know what they say about a coward dies a thousand deaths a day.
By:
Giuseppe
When: 01 Sep 21 16:44
dusty you have a finely balanced situation in Afghanista

most people are happy to accept a moderate, democratic, decentralised government

this is the type of state the regional warlords and their fighters want

but the taliban are very strong, partly due to foreign support
By:
Giuseppe
When: 01 Sep 21 16:47
religion isn't really problem in Afghanistan

there are some shias, but the vast majority of the population are conservative sunni muslims (though not as conservative as the taliban)

left to their own devices, Afghans would give women freedoms and social roles somewhere between what the west wants and what the taliban want
By:
Giuseppe
When: 01 Sep 21 16:49
the soldiers that gave up did so because they thought they would lose, plain and simple

nothing to do with ideology
By:
dustybin
When: 01 Sep 21 16:50
There were reportedly 300,000 Afghan army
60,000 taliban

If they thought they might lose it could only be down to the fact they knew they wernt any good
By:
Giuseppe
When: 01 Sep 21 16:52
that's quite a low estimate for the talibs

some estimates are as high as 200,000

the talibs also weren't relying on foreign air support and transport etc which was removed overnight
By:
dustybin
When: 01 Sep 21 16:54
Thats the figure The Economist put them as having
By:
Giuseppe
When: 01 Sep 21 16:55
Taliban: c.

US estimate:
75,000[50]

UN report:
55,000–85,000 fighters[51]

15,000 support facilitators and non-combatants[51]

Other estimates:

85,000[52]–200,000[53][54]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Taliban_offensive
By:
dustybin
When: 01 Sep 21 16:55
When you cant trust either your leader or the person stood beside you then you have no chance.
By:
Giuseppe
When: 01 Sep 21 16:56
ANSF: c.
Official figure as per US and Afghan government:
300,000[55]–354,000[56][53][50](officially; including police officers,[57] and many ghost soldiers)

Other estimates:

150,000–200,000 combat-oriented troops, including an unknown number of junior and ghost soldiers.[57]
By:
Giuseppe
When: 01 Sep 21 16:56
actual numbers were likely much closer

no way was it 5 to 1
By:
Giuseppe
When: 01 Sep 21 16:59
corruption and ghost soldiers were problems in South Vietnam too

didn't stop the ARVN (with US air support) defeating the NVA in 1972
By:
Giuseppe
When: 01 Sep 21 17:01
the ARVN all surrendered in 1975 too

it wasn't because they liked the communists or were cowards

it was because they knew the game was up
By:
dustybin
When: 01 Sep 21 17:05
Im sorry but for me Ghani was a coward
He said he did one to save bloodshed
Well what about all the bloodshed of civilians that were acceptable when it wasnt his
By:
dustybin
When: 01 Sep 21 17:19
BTW saying religion wasnt a problem....
How many scientists kill each other because they took exception with a paper they wrote?
By:
Whisperingdeath
When: 01 Sep 21 17:23
like Copernicus?

Darwin?

No pressure on them!
By:
saddo
When: 01 Sep 21 17:23
If only we cared about our own country as much as we do this one.
By:
moisok
When: 01 Sep 21 18:26
they are coming here
By:
xmoneyx
When: 01 Sep 21 18:40
Just had a harrowing phone call with Afghan translator in Kabul.  Described Taliban going door to door calling people out of their homes and executing them in the street
By:
Giuseppe
When: 01 Sep 21 19:10
people aren't killing each other in Afghanistan over religion
By:
dustybin
When: 01 Sep 21 19:19
Except those who interpret sharia law differently to those who dont abide by it.
Remember, this theocracy has been a coupe, they are not a legitimate government.
By:
dustybin
When: 01 Sep 21 19:22
We should invade Devil
By:
potlis
When: 02 Sep 21 08:09
The “ what was it all for” question will be even more difficult for the politicians if in a few years Afghanistan, under Taliban rule, isn’t the disaster the media seem to be hoping for.
By:
moisok
When: 02 Sep 21 08:24
From my favourite paper the Guardian - hysterical stuff.  Less than one hundred of 700 women journalists now working.  In an unrelated story others are throwing their jeans away!!!
Don't they realise they are much safer following Tally advice by staying at home.  Less likely to have their heads blown off by a rocket from the sky?
By:
A_T
When: 02 Sep 21 08:58
could be a Taliban-controlled Afghan government becomes a key ally of the US - the new Saudi Arabia if you like. And that might have been the sub-text to Trump's agreement which Biden saw through.
By:
potlis
When: 02 Sep 21 08:59
Personally I think the Taliban are missing a trick here, my first move would be to sell tickets to the west at say £20k a pop.

Given the “get them all out” cry from the media our Government would be forced to fund the tickets, that along with the outrage from the locals when the figure reaches 500 thousand arrivals would see the politicians pleading with the Taliban to stop, along with an offer/bribe of £Billions in aid of course.
By:
A_T
When: 02 Sep 21 09:13
skyscanner shows scheduled flights from Dubai and Qatar to Kabul - it's tempting but is Afghanistan on the COVID red list?
By:
Timber
When: 02 Sep 21 09:23

Sep 2, 2021 -- 3:13AM, A_T wrote:


skyscanner shows scheduled flights from Dubai and Qatar to Kabul - it's tempting but is Afghanistan on the COVID red list?


I'll buy you a one way ticket

By:
Timber
When: 02 Sep 21 09:25
Lock up your children, the streets will NEVER  be safe againCry

https://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/312906
By:
mecca
When: 02 Sep 21 10:52
American authorities are advertising for Afghan interpreters... so that they can communicate with the tens of thousands of Afghan interpreters that have been evacuated from Afghanistan to the US..

Most of them have been taken to "swing states"... along with the new arrivals from the southern border
By:
A_T
When: 02 Sep 21 11:04
Most of them have been taken to "swing states".

good idea
By:
Timber
When: 02 Sep 21 11:09

Sep 2, 2021 -- 5:04AM, A_T wrote:


Most of them have been taken to "swing states".good idea


Donald will send them all back, along with the all the diseased criminals from south of the border

By:
dustybin
When: 02 Sep 21 12:14
It has to be shocking value, for each interpreter used a council over here needs to find a council house that fits around 8?
I don’t know the exact size of these extended families on average, but I haven’t yet seen an example of just man and wife.
Robert Generic said they were giving 5 million pounds to help…pmsl
The party that have sold off and stifled new builds for decades thinks councils getting a share of 5 million will sort it?
There will be further need for more mosques too.
By:
mecca
When: 02 Sep 21 12:20
Don't forget we need interpreters to communicate with all these "interpreters" who can't speak or understand English

Figure that one out
By:
xmoneyx
When: 02 Sep 21 12:29
How did the Taliban win a war without Trident
Page 58 of 60  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 55 | 56 | 57 | 58 | 59 | 60 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com