|
By:
No doubt Facts thinks that Labour would have went into a lockdown weeks before etc and saved thousands of lives, I even heard one of the Labour MPs on QT about 5 months ago who started going on about the lockdown coming too late, and was surprised when Bruce interrupted him and asked "when did Labour call for one", and after squirming a bit he replied "a few hours before the lockdown was announced"!!! But still as Facts says this useless Government should have locked down earlier, as if Labour would have done anything different...
|
|
By:
to quote the way Sweden has dealt with the virus is disingenuous without stating what has happen to the countries either side of Sweden
Finland lockdown, cases 9976 deaths 345 Norway lockdown, cases 13698 deaths 274 Sweden no lockdown, cases 92466 deaths 5890 it is perfectly clear that Sweden has faired far worse than Finland and Norway so can we really say Sweden have achieved anything with no lockdown. Have included a link outlining the way China dealt with virus and were they are today, with some salient advice https://www.wired.co.uk/article/china-coronavirus-local-lockdowns |
|
By:
George, sorry about the delay I just could not stop laughing. I cannot believe anyone on here responds to your rubbish. And I have just done that so this will be my last contact
Your post of 8.14 am. With regard to Jenny Harris if you have the disease breathing it in will make no difference you still have the disease. With regard to Vam Tam, we know a mask makes no difference if you are well, ffs, but not everyone knows they are well and do or do not have the disease. You are such a clown and peddle such rubbish. |
|
By:
So Brigust1, unable to produce the evidence I asked for, you resort to abuse.
And what exactly are you laughing at, people losing their jobs, cancer patients going undiagnosed? Please elaborate. |
|
By:
trevor007, what happens when those countries come out of lockdown, or are they staying locked down forever?
and why not compare Sweden with the UK, does keeping it local suit your argument better? |
|
By:
You cant just judge it on covid deaths though. If you look at our excess death figures its already clear theres 10000 at least non covid unexplained deaths and that number will soar over the next couple of years.
They also fail to account for the fact that a huge percentage of covid deaths would have happened anyway over the next couple of years. So we have betrayed loads of people in their 30s,40s and 50s who will die from untreated cancers to have "saved" thousands in old people homes who were in their last year anyway. |
|
By:
brigust1, do you think the guaranteed extra deaths from other illnesses due to lack of diagnosis/treatment is a price worth paying, or could we not move the handful of covid patients- to these nightingale ghost ships perhaps- from these hospitals and get them back to what they were built for?
|
|
By:
We are only in this mess because of the likes of Ferguson and his ridiculous models. He was so off the mark it beggars belief how his forecasts got as far as government ministers. In terms of UK death figures, this virus is currently of the same magnitude as the flu epidemic of 2017/2018. It is not Armageddon, yet the consequences of lock down measures will be catastrophic.
|
|
By:
I thought the Nightingale hospitals can only treat people with just covid and in reality most with covid have lots of other issues so need a fully equipped hospital.
|
|
By:
Quite possibly Dotchinite. Our hospital is very large and has been given over to less than a handful of people at any one time for months now. Many staff are sick of it, and know they'll be dealing with a huge backlog in nearly every department.
|
|
By:
Answer Ireland's call. We need doctors.7,000 returned home.
You'll love this ! How many got employed .??? Wait for it! |
|
By:
2 yes two
|
|
By:
I volunteered to take people to and from hospital at the start of this, along with thousands of others. Turns out they didn't need any of us, as most appointments were cancelled until further notice.
![]() |
|
By:
My partner works for hse A/E dept.
They called it the mad house.ie.you needed to be insane to work theyre.60+hours per week. Last 3months it's empty. 40 hours. VHI ,private medical insurance roughly 2grand a year .pointless hse took over It's so wrong. |
|
By:
the average life expectancy of someone age 80 is 89.5, despite 90% of 80-y-os having one or more comorbids...it's presumptive and almost certainly erroneous imo to believe all the aged that died were at death's door anyway.
|
|
By:
In terms of UK death figures, this virus is currently of the same magnitude as the flu epidemic of 2017/2018.
if there had been a 3-month lockdown in 2017/18, they number of flu victims would have been much lower if there hadnt been a 3-month lockdown this year, the number of covid deaths would have been much higher take your pick |
|
By:
You think any country can afford to virtually close it's economy every year or two?
|
|
By:
Virus don't disappear , they never have,never will!
We build anti bodys. Duncan |
|
By:
thanks for your response George B
I compare with bordering Sweden because these countries our demographically and geographically similar, compared to the UK. Agreed when we compare the UK with any country and in particular and our nearest neighbours France, Spain etc. we haven't don't well, the European lockdowns were more draconian that the lockdown in this country. Your premise that lockdowns dont work is not bourne out, Finland and Norway after lockdown introduced mandatory 14 day isolation for anybody entering there country as did the Chinese and many other countries in the far east. It is this policy that allows the good work of a lockdown to be carried on and the lifting of restrictions. We have seen in this country after the lockdown with no International TOURISM, rates remained low, people were moving about freely from the 1000's who went to Bournemouth and Brighton beach on the bank holiday early summer, (when we were told there will be a huge spike in cases) right through the summer with the huge number of tourist travelling around the UK. No significant spike in cases happened. I suspect the lockdown had the desired effect. As were all finding out its not the lockdown that's the problem its what you do after lockdown that matters and until we say that all people entering this country have to isolate for 14 days no ifs or buts and this is also the case for people going on holiday and coming back, this problem will not go away. |
|
By:
duncan. What is the life expectancy for those in a care home. You are also failing to take into account the fact that its the unhealthier old people who are predominantly dying.
Either way nobody can say someone of 84 should be protected at the expense of people with curable diseases half their age. |
|
By:
You can go back and forth with lockdown till 2100.
It won't make any difference. Like any virus the weakest suffer! The rest will brush it off. I refer to the 306 deaths under 60 |
|
By:
Ireland 1700 deaths
Under 60 is 11 |
|
By:
I hope that people who want us all to hide and ruin the country on the back of numbers like that feel ashamed one day, new shoes.
|
|
By:
It's fact .. I'm sorry to say
|
|
By:
Here's another funny 1! Well not funny at all
At least 50% of schools in Ireland don't have warm running water. Now wash your hands.lol |
|
By:
trevor007, thanks for your reply.
I'm not necessarily arguing lockdowns don't work, I suppose if vast numbers of the population are effectively put under house arrest, then yes, you'll stop the spread of anything, my main point / question is whether or not that is the right thing to do given the economic consequences and impact on other areas of health. However, interesting points you make about international travel, maybe the solution is in there somewhere. |
|
By:
You lockdown the numbers go down.
You open up numbers go up. How many years of lockdown are you prepared for! Forever? |
|
By:
Why is Vallance still calling the shots and making another TV appearance later? Surely his impartiality has been brought into question after the Daily Telegraph article on his £600k shareholding in a vax company? Even if he hasn't broken any rules, his credibility is shot now.
|
|
By:
Inflazome, which are developing new treatments for covid.
Set up 2016 Company now sold 380million The Irish vallance. |
|
By:
I'm not necessarily arguing lockdowns don't work -- well you should George. No one can guarantee a 100% lock down. These fools have gone power mad and think they are King Canute. You cannot ever stop a virus. In every other epidemic throughout history you isolate the sick, not lock down the healthy population you need to create the wealth to look after them.
|
|
By:
Lockdowns are great at cutting the spread of a virus. Its ending them thats the problem.
|
|
By:
duncan. What is the life expectancy for those in a care home. --- 14 months at he moment. over 1/2 million in care homes so 30000+ a month die. The virus did very little harm in care homes when all other things taken into consideration. The majority of those that dies only lost weeks of life. 98% of people in care homes survived the deadly virus March to June. Their immunity is so low at this stage if Covid didn't kill them something else would have (unitary tract infections, Flu etc). When yo take the numbers of care home deaths from the total there isn't much left.
|
|
By:
truehoncho, I should have added "in theory", but the fact is hospital deaths peaked April 8th before the lockdown, which commenced March 23rd, could have had such an impact, which would suggest the numbers were going to decline anyway.
|
|
By:
truehoncho, I should have added "in theory", but the fact is hospital deaths peaked April 8th before the lockdown, which commenced March 23rd, could have had such an impact, which would suggest the numbers were going to decline anyway. 100% correct. keep up the good work George. You only have to look at any flu season breakdown of deaths and thats exactly how it works. The peak deaths come quick and then fall off just as quick.The only reason the Covid dragged on is because of the restrictions on people but it didn't save anyone. Don't forget at the time he reason for the lockdown was to ensure we didn't crash the NHS so that everyone could get treatment. Now they are all acting like King Canute to try and stop a virus. Total lunacy.
|
|
By:
' Don't forget at the time the reason for the lockdown was to ensure we didn't crash the NHS so that everyone could get treatment.'
Everyone who has covid only, everyone else can bugger off or wait. The irony would be amusing were it not so tragic. |
|
By:
The UK government has caved in to demands that MPs be given a vote in parliament on any new UK or England-wide coronavirus restrictions, after up to 100 Conservatives threatened a rebellion.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/sep/30/rebel-tory-mps-fail -in-bid-to-get-more-say-over-covid-restrictions |
|
By:
The former Labour cabinet minister Ben Bradshaw called it a “meaningless concession, which excludes the draconian ‘non national’ measures imposed without local consultation with local communities and gives the executive a get-out clause on the national measures”.
|
|
By:
There's talk about expelling students for education if they go on the drink again. Thousands flaunt rules up down the country,with signs of
Let's party like it's covid 19 99. Also calls for army to be deployed. The insanity . |
|
By:
to be fair, we have a few too many students here in Bristol and if a few got shot by the Army, nobody would complain.
|
|
By:
Students are the future imo need to be supported.
This kinda talk ,expelling,army ,fines will end badly over here ,most are armed better than the army. Adding to my predections. Mass revolt. |