|
By:
you forgot cauthen
|
|
By:
when did OOSG head Big Orange ?
|
|
By:
Likes of and etc etc encompasses the "Kentucky Kid", could of listed plenty that would have had more talent in the saddle than Mr Moore, those listed were just to give you a taste, feel free to post others who in your view would tactically leave him in their wake.
|
|
By:
On the bob maybe 70/80 yards from the post, was the side shot on RUK that showed it clearest from memory
|
|
By:
Excellent piece Cork very interesting read top work.
I have real real problems with Ryan Moore when he holds horses up. I lay off my bet the second he holds one up he is absolutely useless coming from behind. I'm nearly certain a massively high percentage of his winners are placed forward within a race. He is one of the better riders riding today but he is far from one of the worlds best. He does get the worlds best mounts though and that affords him the experience when it comes to the debrief. |
|
By:
Not a personal attack Cork, but I would love to see 'could of' completely abolished and a return to universal use of 'could have'.
Yes, when did George head BO?! |
|
By:
i watched it a few times and the closest he got was at the line,in my opinion he was
too far back,made hell of alot of ground to get to Big Orange. US Army Ranger was the same. |
|
By:
Good post Cork, agree with most if not all of that. On a forum where the jockey seems to be the be all and end all most of the time, it's a refreshing change to read something well thought out and articulate in their regard.
|
|
By:
Apologies ellis, allow me to retract the BO/OOSG statement, was confusing it with Highland Reel being headed by Ulysses and Decorated Knight and then getting back past them, just watched again and as you correctly state BO was never headed, if James Doyle is to be believed in his interview he said BO picked up again when OOSG got to his flank, so maybe he wouldn't of ever got past him on that occasion.
|
|
By:
Yep, good analysis Cork.
I'd personally cut him a bit of slack on the basis of the volume of rides - 30 rides, discuss with connections beforehand, debrief connections afterwards, media obligations when he rides the winner, hot weather, making sure he keeps hydrated, managing his weight, maintaining concentration during races to make sure he's alert to any potential race defining moves by his counterparts. He strikes me as pretty tough mentally so I doubt he worries about being under the microscope or the pressure of expectation but there must come a point where the odd error creeps in due to mental fatigue as much as anything. He's not a robot. At some of the other meetings he could skip the odd ride in the early races to focus on the feature event but the Ascot cards front load the pattern events so that's not really possible. |
|
By:
no probs cork,i dont think L Piggot would of lost on OOSG or USAR but thats another story
![]() |
|
By:
ReaseHeath,
Good valid points, I was going to point out that the criticism increased on the last day, especially for his last four mounts and perhaps earlier criticism and a mixture of anger and tiredness had an effect on his decision making, but having re-visited the last four rides I didn't think a case could really be made on that basis because to my eyes he didn't do much wrong on any of them. For me if he did have a poor day, it was most certainly Thursday, which if he could no doubt live again, he would probably have a treble. |
|
By:
Funny you should say that ellis, as beforehand on Saturday morning I had visions of Moore riding US AR akin to Lester aboard John Cherry
|
|
By:
ann stokell would have won on OoSG
|
|
By:
Moore as given some of his mounts appalling rides recently , when he continually had his mounts way to far behind in races , one in particular ride was on Humble Hero at Lingfield got beat a nose after coming from miles behind , he seemed to go to sleep . and how he kept Rain Goddess out of the frame at Ascot beggars belief. again way out of his ground... many more examples recently .. he seems to have morphed into Jamie Spencer.
|
|
By:
Any other jockey riding THE LADS horses would have as good a record as him, if you think he got there to soon on OOSG, oh dear, he has no idea how to change tact in a slow run race, no plan B, a decent jockey, yes, and that is all
|
|
By:
greedy got the gig.
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ,ponty g1 horse in a listed trotted up evens![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
|
By:
An excellent analysis Corky, but
the fact remains he does make tactical error's in high profile races ! His positioning of Order Of St George was very poor, and I think you'd have to agree he should of won the race ! ?... I thought his ride on U S Army Ranger last years Derby was atrocious.. for me if he'd of got the horse in a more prominent position before Tattenham Corner, he'd of won the race ! The horse hasn't won since, and to me he did the beast a lot of harm that day with his ride ! All about opinion's, but like other poster's not a patch on P E, L P, W S, S C, W C, G M, J M, M K et al ! |
|
By:
Moore did not appreciate early enough in the meeting making up ground on the round course was almost impossible
|
|
By:
All that effort and you still can't grasp the blindingly obvious. Got there too soon on Order Of St George? If you can't get that right it really isn't worth looking at anything else.
At least four duff rides out of six on the horse. If they cared about the horse he would already have been ditched. There was nothing iffy about the horse before Moore started taking liberties with him. His two best performances were the Irish St Leger and the Arc. In the first he led three furlongs out and in the other he was sent forward. He didn't need to be held up and he didn't need to lead on the post. It is habitual for Moore to sit out of ground. That is his 'style'. When it doesn't work he is arrogant enough to keep doing the same thing. He got away with a poor ride last year, he didn't this year. I would consider a good ride to be something that most of the weighing room couldn't achieve. In my opinion Moore rides far more bad races than good ones. Most of his rides are just average because given the quality of his mounts that's all they need to be. |
|
By:
A well written piece Corky, Bit wasted on here though imo.
|
|
By:
matso - Rain Goddess finished 2nd, perhaps it was another ride you are thinking about
deptford/differentdrum - if you read the replies, ellis already pointed out my error regarding OOSG, which I retracted and explained hd - I don't believe anyone is disputing that he makes plenty of mistakes, as I said he is fortunate that he rides the quality of horse that often enables him to get out of trouble that he makes for himself, as for US AR that is pure conjecture and whilst I accept that is your own opinion, personally I would question the horses will to co-operate more than anything else, just seems to have his own ideas when racing. differentdrum - using the Irish St Leger as an example is pointless, look at the calibre of the opposition that day and what they have achieved since and you will see that OOSG could not have lost that race if you or me had ridden it...! As for the Arc, being a 12f race, obviously the tactics had to be completely different to those employed before and after, or he would have been left for dead, it is also worth mentioning that those two performances came on good ground in Ireland and France, where good is often softer than good ground in the UK, the three victories it has on good to firm here were all against poor opposition, so perhaps the real fast ground was a contributory factor to it not managing to pass Big Orange last week. The statistics and the fact that Coolmore primarily, and many others, still see him as the go to jockey would seemingly contradict your opinion of his ability, he is certainly fortunate that the talent pool at this time is so dearth in numbers, or maybe he would be put under pressure to retain his position of number one. |
|
By:
jesus corky thats some read ffs, u got far too much free time on ur hands i feel lol, my actual opinion is that hes just a jockey of no class compared to the piggotts cauthens etc and a very fortunate man to be riding amongst such a shower of colleagues
|
|
By:
Long time no hear "thomas", things still ticking over and keeping your head above water I hope....
Think you have summed up most peoples view of him, very much a case of being in the right place at the right time, any of the greats and a few others who had limited chances in their own careers because of the competition for rides would ensure that Moore stayed in the shadows rather than being in the limelight. You are quite right I do have too much time on my hands these days, might have to consider taking up the dogs and US racing again....! |
|
By:
lol get back on the bags scene corky crayford misses you yeah and im good hope your winning
|
|
By:
Moore mistakes like everybody but still the best jockey in Europe by far. We get much more in the way or racing on tv, replays and analysis than ever before and consequently people can pick holes in Moore and the others like they could never before. Piggott was in a league of his own but Moore is the best since then. The reason nearly all the top trainers clamour for his services is because he's the best. Anyone who thinks that jockeys in previous generations were much better needs to go back and look at old video's. They simply weren't. It's just whilst now we see thousands of races per year, we only used to see a small percentage.
|
|
By:
After reading the stuff on here about Moore. Makes you think that he'd be better off packing in riding and getting himself a milk round.
What a load of toss. |
|
By:
asparagus - respect everyone is entitled to their own opinion, couldn't agree that Moore is the best since Piggott, in saying that you are putting him ahead of someone like Cauthen, the Kid would have left him in his wake imo
Dr Crippen - that is not what is being said in this quarter, he is the best currently for me, but only because the competition is so poor with no obvious pretender in our midst |
|
By:
I was ridiculing the criticism Cork Langer.
|
|
By:
Dr Crippen - yes I appreciate that, but anyone reading your post may have thought you were inferring that the whole thread was criticising him
|
|
By:
Of his 30 Royal Ascot rides, 20 were for Coolmore and 6 for Stoute so only 4 were spares.
I have no problem at all with Ryan Moore but there are probably 30-40 jockeys based in UK and Ireland alone who could do the job just as well. There really isn't much between any number of senior jockeys. Smullen was offered the Coolmore job twice. If he had taken it he would now top the opinion polls for the world's/Europe's top jockey. Having a big name retained rider is very useful when things go wrong and owners are not happy with a ride.... " hey it was Ryan Moore,he's the best jockey in the world,these things happen now lets move on".If it keeps the lads happy then that's fine but I would safely say Aiden O Brien would have no problem with any of his own jockeys getting the top job. |
|
By:
Jockey Min Weight Wins Rides Strike Rate Level Stake Win Prize Total Prize
Silvestre De Sousa 8-2 56 254 22% +12.56 £317,889 490,224 Ryan Moore 8-7 36 155 23% 16.95 £2,234,847 3,366,708 what do people think of this ? |
|
By:
Tells me one has membership of the inner circle and the other doesn't and never will do, irrespective of his will and ability to get horses home in first place
|
|
By:
good thread corks
![]() RM expected number of winners from BSPs was 6.6 so 6 winners about a par week SDS a top jockey on the long term jockey figures but if you speak to people who have had dealings with him it is mostly not positive feedback I think that might have a lot to do with it |
|
By:
Agree wonders, not as obliging or savvy when it comes to protocol which is why he has missed out with a number of stables/owners
|
|
By:
I would love to see Soumie riding for Coolmore. The man has all the talent in the world.
As for Moore, i actually think day in day out he is very decent, but , he does make far too many mistakes in big races to my eye. Obviously his employer(s) do not agreee. i would have Greville Starkey before Moore as an aside. ![]() |
|
By:
who happened to make the biggest balls up of all time in the Derby itself of all races
![]() |
|
By:
Royal Ascot top jockey seven times in the last eight years. Says it all for me.
|
|
By:
Moore hasn't been quite at the same level as he was at before his back injury for me. Also, tactically he doesn't control enough races. Dettori is still head and shoulders in front in that regard. Moore gets away with it in most of the top races, as there's pace or his firm ensures there's a strong pace. Of the current crop, I still have Dettori in front, albeit he's probably not quite as strong in a finish as he was at his very peak.
|