











,ponty g1 horse in a listed trotted up evens



Jun 26, 2017 -- 5:00PM, Cider wrote:
Moore hasn't been quite at the same level as he was at before his back injury for me. Also, tactically he doesn't control enough races. Dettori is still head and shoulders in front in that regard. Moore gets away with it in most of the top races, as there's pace or his firm ensures there's a strong pace. Of the current crop, I still have Dettori in front, albeit he's probably not quite as strong in a finish as he was at his very peak.
I think most people, if they're honest, would agree with that. I also think he hasn't become as good as he can be because of the tripe that now rides on the flat in the UK. He only has to be a cetain level and no more. Far too many bad jockeys are earning a good living because there's so much racing.
Jun 26, 2017 -- 4:31PM, wondersobright wrote:
good thread corks RM expected number of winners from BSPs was 6.6 so 6 winners about a par week SDS a top jockey on the long term jockey figures but if you speak to people who have had dealings with him it is mostly not positive feedbackI think that might have a lot to do with it
Could you elaborate on the SDS stuff wonders? I'm interested, is it that he is too hard, or that he won't do jobs, doesn't know when to give up? I'm interested as he should really have a stable job on his figures.
) but no smoke without fire, he's moved around quite a lot which is worryingJun 27, 2017 -- 11:37AM, Blackrock wrote:
What constitutes as the 'best jockey'?Being in the correct position at the right time? Power in a finish? Difference between winning a short nut or losing a short nut? Judgement of pace?As far as being the best rider today, i would have Pat Smullen every day of the week. Moore does have some horror rides,[ Rhododendron, Order St George]. Gave Big Orange way too much rope when he was always going to be OOSG's biggest danger.Has horses too far back [when riding for AOB] when usually he is on the best horse. Why take that risk when he could be closer to the pace, and in a position to attack no matter what happens up front?
Think they actually tried to get Smullen, first, but he wanted to stay in Welds. Personally, I think Moore had the name value & CV they probably needed & I'd say they are just as happy with him.
Thanks a mill, Wonders & Cork, you are dead right Wonders, Moore looks a different person with connections.
Jun 27, 2017 -- 1:08PM, gutfeeling wrote:
Every yard in the country & every owner would take Moore over anyone else currently riding in a heartbeat if he was offered to them, That in itself tells you all you need to know.People only appreciate how good someone is once they're gone, If Cauthen, Eddery, Piggott, F Archer ect ect were riding today you'd get threads on here saying how average they are & they make too many mistakes.
Did you ask them all?
Jun 27, 2017 -- 8:14PM, gutfeeling wrote:
I expected some pedant to ask this question, No surprise it turned out to be you
I could generalise just as well and say there's no Irish trainer or owner would have Moore ahead of Smullen
Jun 27, 2017 -- 8:37PM, gutfeeling wrote:
other than the biggest trainer & owners in Ireland you mean
You mean the people Smullen turned down before Moore was offered it?
Jun 28, 2017 -- 7:20PM, Cork Langer wrote:
Hard to make a case for PJ on the stats, only hit 20% s/r once in his career, Moore has managed it 11 years running, fairly safe to say the boys are delighted at being rejected by Pat
If he rode the exact same horses your comparison might have a semblance of truth
Jun 28, 2017 -- 7:37PM, Cork Langer wrote:
It could be argued that riding for DK he rides a lot of horses in races where there is limited competitive opposition
I think you're clutchng at straws there.
Jun 28, 2017 -- 9:02PM, Cork Langer wrote:
Not at all, are you saying the races he rides in here at home are more competitive than those that Moore rides in over in England....Leave aside 2017 because PJ is having limited success and there is still half a year to go, take the last full year ie 2016, PJ managed 6 pattern race wins for outside stables, in the same period omitting both O'Brien and Stoute runners, Moore managed to ride 11, it is only your belief (and some others), which I respect, that PJ is a better rider than Moore.There is no factual evidence to support your opinion but that is not to say you are wrong, just that at this moment all the stats and percentages put Moore in a different parish to PJ.
Fair enough. How many of Moore's pattern wins for outide stables were in Ireland? I'm sure there is some stat out there that says Richard Johnson is a better jockey than Barry Geraghty, going by the last year or so. That would be bolix of course but the stat says otherwise so it must be true.

If Moore was a American jockey he'd be a workrider at best!
Jun 29, 2017 -- 7:30AM, workrider wrote:
Boy I thought I was early !
Gym at 7. I haven't got this body by accident 
Jun 29, 2017 -- 9:43AM, Cork Langer wrote:
You tell me MJK, I am merely working with the evidence that is documented and before me, I would have no idea about PJ's preference, but in my 50 years of following racing I don't remember ever seeing any reports or stories circulated about jockeys declining an invitation to ride abroad on occasions when the opportunity arose or was offered, unless already engaged elsewhere or suspended.To use your own words, I think it could be said you are now clutching at straws, when you say about AOB waxing lyrical about Moore's rides, anyone that listens to any interview with him will tell you that any winning ride is world class, be it he is talking about Moore, Heffernan, O'Donoghue or Beggy, that is just a habit that he has unfortunately gotten into, and not a diversionary tactic to convince anyone about Moore.I somewhat doubt that AOB would take any notice of people voicing dissent on track about Moore anyway, he would perhaps think again if the "boys" said it to him, but given who else is available at this time I think that very unlikely.
Dermot Weld said at the time that the two reasons Smullen didn't take the job were down to loyalty to him and the fact he'd have to travel a lot more than he wanted for family reasons.
Jun 28, 2017 -- 7:20PM, Cork Langer wrote:
Hard to make a case for PJ on the stats, only hit 20% s/r once in his career, Moore has managed it 11 years running, fairly safe to say the boys are delighted at being rejected by Pat
Some of those Irish handicaps with massive field sizes Smullen rides in make it tough to maintain a high ratio, I'm only guessing.
Both very good.

true !