|
By:
I think the problem is right there in the first line.
'Coolmore owned' They'd have to be pretty confident that they haven't got one for the race to run him imo but if he did go he'd be half that price and would have to have a good chance |
|
By:
yes but the magicswine only go 8/1
|
|
By:
Undoubtedly, his participation will depend largely on how Recital and Seville will perform over the coming hours and days.
However, it's quite awhile since Coolmore won the Derby and they have thrown plenty of darts at it over the past few years, so they may go mob handed again. Just saw the recording of the race yesterday on ATR, he was impressive, won that easily. |
|
By:
surely runs....not like the stabled ever bothered about how many they entered in the past.
|
|
By:
Agree with ELG - they usually run 2 or 3 and this will surely be one of them
|
|
By:
No worries about the horse being Coolmore-owned imo. They supp’d Papal Bull in when Aiden had his usual army and Magnier’s proved time and again, as Tesio dictates, that the Derby is the most important race (certainly 3-y-o European race anyway) in the Coolmore Calendar. The only doubt would arise if connections feel he wouldn’t handle the track. He didn’t take the first bend too well yesterday but he hadn’t settled properly at the time and the home bend he negotiated far more smoothly. You would hope on Derby Day, with that long uphill run from the start, he would have dropped his head and be racing evenly before he encountered the first proper turn. I was a little surprised AdRD ruled out Vadamar so quickly, who was held up before the start and didn’t have the clearest of passages, but there’s no doubt Pour Moi was deeply impressive.
There is a little sub-plot here, of course. Sheikh Mo/Godolphin has 122 horses with Andre Fabre. The idea – a good one imo but clearly very expensive – being they station them with Fabre at 2 and over the winter, before transferring – hopefully in the Spring before the big European Classics – once the trainer feels they can be competitive in Group 1s. I have no doubt that Coolmore would find the prospect of winning the Derby with a Fabre colt, from a grand total of TWO horses in the yard, totally irresistible. The fact Barzalona may ride, a Fabre jockey before a Godolphin one, only serves to twist the knife. In truth, you could argue Andre is playing a dangerous game here – as many would view this as highly embarrassing for the Sheikh. Anyway, back to Pour Moi. If you aren’t on at bigger prices, the 20/1 is begging to be taken. In terms of the round of Derby trials, this guy is clubhouse leader. Obviously we still have the Derrinstown and Dante to go (and it’s always possible Goodwood or the Irish 2000 will throw something up) but it must be remembered that the front three in the Derby market look set to clash on the Knavesmire. While one will clearly shorten, there’s every chance two will blow out and it seems certain that the Derby market will look very different by Thursday night. Impeccably bred, trained by the master and already entered for Epsom, there is no doubt in my mind that if the Greff was run at Lingfield rather than Saint-Cloud yesterday, Pour Moi would be challenging for favouritism. Laddies are closest to his correct price imo and I would argue they should be even shorter. |
|
By:
No doubt Andre Fabre would love to win the Derby - he's won everything else. IMO his standing in the sport is such that he transcends any Coolmore/Sheikh Mohammed squabbles.
|
|
By:
20's taken
cheers HM |
|
By:
Is Ladbrokes actually telling us something else significant by so blatantly ducking Pour Moi -- 8/1 but 20/1 generally?
Is Ladbrokes telling us not that Pour Moi is good (he may well be but the form is in the book: there is no inside information there) but that the other main Coolmore contenders, Recital and Seville, are not considered Derby material? |
|
By:
love the conspiracy theory their HM.
|
|
By:
I very much hope you colect, BM!
Agree with you, AT. Fabre's bigger than all that stuff, but that removes all debate over whether O'Brien and Balydoyle are a better operation than Suroor/Rooni and Godolphin. This is the ultimate controlled experiment - all about the blood with no variation on surroundings or ability of trainer. Given that, and remembering it's 2 versus 122 , it would be hard for Big John and the boys not to be particularly satisfied if one of those 2 proved a Derby winner. |
|
By:
no 20 left now it will be single figures wen confirmed
|
|
By:
will be back out to 20s after recital puts on a show this afternoon.Have no doubt, this is aidan's main derby horse.
Why would the put fallon on his back.Fallon is the man they want riding him at epsom, given that more could well be on carlton house. |
|
By:
recital has been well backed from 10 downwards during the last 24 hours they expecting a good run i assume needs to improve from last run
|
|
By:
I dont buy into this sub-plot stuff. They have horses with Favre because he is a top class trainer. If the horse is good enough they'll send him over and give him his chance. Winning the Derby is difficult enough as it is without people (Coolomore etc) throwing theirs egos into the mix. They're satisfied with horses doing what they are suppsoed to do and win races.
|
|
By:
essexguy
Recital certainly put on a show - the sort usually seen at Krufts! |
|
By:
Just to make it clear, there is no suggestion that Coolmore have two horses with Fabre simply hoping they can rub the Sheikh's nose in it. Equally, I doubt oneupmanship would be the main reason for deciding to run any horse in the Derby. It is just a rather delicious side dish to the main Derby-winning course for Coolmore.
Would disagree they'll send him over if they think he's good enough, too. It's quite obvious he's good enough to run in a Derby. The decision will be based on whether they think he's mature enough for Epsom. Apparently the oft-quoted '50-50' is the current view from the trainer. |
|
By:
cryoftruth, that may be the case, but have you seen one to beat him yet?
|
|
By:
Oh yes.
I think that Pour Moi can beat him, and I actually think that the Sandown run of Genius Beast has been underrated too. I suspect one of the two maiden winners at the head of the Derby market will turn out to be better than Recital and I prefer the Queen's hose personally (even though I am republican)! |
|
By:
I would suggest the main reason Coolmore have sent horses to Fabre is that AOB simply hasn't delivered over the past few years (considering the volume and quality of blue-bloods at his disposal) particularly in view of the English Classics. The same argument applies to Godolphin setting up a 2nd UK base and, on the jumps, the increasing number of JPM horses now being trained by Henderson.
Like others on here I was underwhelmed by Recital's attitude yesterday although he clearly has an engine and may be a serious horse on a suitable track. Seville may be the answer but on 2 yo form he is pretty much the same horse as Casamento which might not be enough. The Dante will hopefully throw up a serious contender but at the moment the Derby is pretty much a case of everyone ignoring the elephant in the room, or to be more precise the monster that will be ducking the race and heading for the St James Palace. |
|
By:
On youtube now. Not that impressed here - workmanlike.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zkfQqPHcapQ |
|
By:
'not that impressed' 'workmanlike' !!!!
![]() |
|
By:
Sorry
Having said that he will probably imporve over further and at least for a Montjeu his head carriage looked OK. |
|
By:
If he was declared a definite runner I'd have him as favourite right now before the Dante is run.
|
|
By:
That was the first time I've seen the race and have to say that was far from workmanlike!
Very impressed with that. |
|
By:
It was impressive in that he was pulling early and a bit awkward around the bend, so to still have the energy at the business end to speed away and win suggests he is pretty good. But im not convinced just yet he's a Derby winner. A patchy profile with 2 defeats and 2 victories.
|
|
By:
I'm not going out of my way to disagree with you, sint! Don't think his record is patchy at all, though. Fair enough debut then wins a Class 2 at Longchamp, is put away, turns up behind the Aga's best 3-y-o and does everything wrong in the race but still finishes under 2 lengths adrift, then bolts up in the strongest Derby trial run to date, looking like he might be learning (slowly, at the very least) what he's supposed to be doing out there. A strong upward curve, for me.
|
|
By:
am going to watch it now. getting excited .......
|
|
By:
[:D]
20/1 & counting ££££££££££ thanks HM. Makfi part 2 |
|
By:
very few horses in those French races make up 8 lenghts from the back of the pack to the front and win going away like he did. the ones that do are more often than not high class.
|
|
By:
Spot on ELG. I'm trying not to pop my cork too soon but, Frankel apart, I'm also struggling to name a better 3-y-o performance so far this term in GB, Ire or France. Pour Moi is going to win Group 1s whether he runs at Epsom or not. Let's just hope they roll the dice with him.
On a wider note, with BM kindly reminding us of Makfi, it does appear to me that the French horses are where the value is ante-post atm. For years a number of people, myself included, have been hunting down German, Japanese and Italian horses (thinking they were over-priced, which they probably were) to such an extent that the most obvious nation to start with has been ignored to a degree. A good handful of French trainers seem to be up for travelling right now, so, while the big prices last, France looks the best starting point. Genzy looks another interesting one on Sunday. I thought he looked the best horse in the Noailles, despite finishing fifth, and crucially he is not entered in the French Derby - so if he bolts up on Sunday they'll have to supp him in somewhere and there's no reason why Epsom wouldn't be first choice. He'll have some stiff competition from Grand Vent, who must be nearing a Godolphin transfer now, and a really interesting horse, Lindenthaler, who looks the leading German 3-y-o right now and also isn't entered for anything yet. Potentially a hot heat, then, and all in all the most interesting Hocquart for ages from an ante-post point of view. |
|
By:
Just to back up what HM & ELG have said about Pour Moi's likely participation in the Derby, I'll give you a few quotes courtesy of an interview John Magnier gave to JA McGrath which was printed in the Daily Telegraph before the 2009 Derby, The article was titled 'Derby rules for John Magnier';
'Somebody alluded only last week to Tesio's quote about the relevance of the Derby, saying that it has been that piece of wood, the winning post of the Epsom Derby, that has influenced the selection process that has led to the breeding of the thoroughbred. He was right, Vincent (O'Brien) was right.' 'Maybe, it has lost some of it's gloss, but it is the race where all the qualities of a colt are tested. We continue to support it, and run as many as we can, because of this. We run those we feel are entitled to run. It's a chance for them to prove themselves.' 'I known there are some people, who would like to see it run over a mile and a quarter, but they did that in France, and I don't think it has improved the French Derby. I'm sure that was a mistake...The Derby at Epsom has got history and tradition - all people have to do is leave it alone.' |
|
By:
Pour Moi has been steadily backed. I would personally be surprised if he didn't run and think he will start favourite.
The Dante is being built up as the trial to sort the race out, but the three principals appear to be a decent winner of a soft ground Newbury maiden - Carlton House - (albeit by 9 lengths from the Craven third Yaseer), a nice winner of a 3yo Newbury maiden over 11 furlongs - World Domination - from another unraced promising sort trained by the maestro, and Seville, beaten by Casamanto in the RPT, who is bred to stay 2 miles without any problem at all and will surely lack ther pace to win a Derby, unless the going becomes very testing indeed. I am unconvinced by Recital, who is either an utter dodgepot, or may really need soft ground and is looking like a dog because he cannot cope with the fast going he has had to run on (interesting he ran well on soft going after a workmanlike performance on good ground first time out). I am very sorry that they are missing the Dante with Genius Beast as he would have a serious chance in the Dante and an excellent chance in the Derby too imo. |
|
By:
20, 16 and 14 now gone.
12/1 top price...personally didn't think Seville ran too badly at all but the market seems to think PM is more likley to travel post-Dante than he was before the race? |
|
By:
Re PM,Is this horse more likely to run now that we have seen recital and seville run?
personally i feelthe two obrien colts put up fair trials, and therefore i can see PM going for the french derby. |
|
By:
Beryl's post quoting Magnier says it all for me. Can't believe they'd leave PM on the sidelines given his breeding - out and out 1m 4f horse imo.
|
|
By:
Boomakers just slashing the odds because they can. They're filthy.
I got the impression from Fabre that he would come over anyway, the race looks wide open. |
|
By:
i think he'll run.
There is no really outstanding candidate from Coolmore. Recital is a bit dodgy and Seville looked a bit to slow today. Its hard to read Coomore but they would like to win the Drby, usually fire all their guns at the race. This year I would expect they will get one of theirs to try and set a fast pace as this would certainly suite Fido (otherwise known as Recital). |
|
By:
Just a quickie on Vadamar....
The more eagle-eyed among you may have spotted Dildar and Pareo have both been scratched from the Derby this week. Connection? Both with De Royer-Dupre. I thought at the time the trainer was a little quick to rule out Vadamar post-Greff - the colt clearly had one or two excuses on the night - and the fact he remains in the Derby indicates that initial reaction has softened. Might be worth a couple of bob at 200 plus. |