Forums

Classics 2016

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 170 comments are related to the topic:
So You Think he was a failure?

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 3 of 5  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 170
By:
Sterling Morrison
When: 16 Jun 11 17:02
http://www.theracingforum.co.uk/horse-racing-forum/horse-racing/you-think-route-apob-t84750.html
By:
Sterling Morrison
When: 16 Jun 11 17:03
http://www.smh.com.au/news/sport/horseracing/so-you-think-the-master-bart-cant-do-it/2009/10/24/1256147922687.html
By:
Sterling Morrison
When: 16 Jun 11 17:08
I can find many more easy enough but the point remains while he was winning in Aus, Europe was there for the taking, now it turns out he cant beat a medium level performer let alone a top ranking star there are a plethora of whining exuses followed by a denial that he was even rated highly back home.

BTW I am surprised the Aussies alllowed a horse to be called Black Caviar...........

Reminds me of Mary Hinge another one that slipped through
By:
Somerset_Moan
When: 16 Jun 11 17:13
I've had too much scrumpy this week STerling to munderstand what you're on about - care to spell it out?

i DO remember the owners of "Norfolk in Chance" getting the name refused and managing to get Finmental "EFF-inmental" past the censor...

As to Aussie's 132 rating... I assume he's talking about JUMPS ratings... clueless... absolutely clueless... wouldn't know a 132 rated horse if, symultaneously, it kicked him and Cummings Down Under!
By:
educeee
When: 16 Jun 11 17:15
Instead of whinging and moaning about Bart's hostile words, you should stop trying to discover quotes and have a look at this list instead..

http://www.bartcummings.com.au/g1_list.asp
By:
AdvantageAussie
When: 16 Jun 11 17:19
Ah - you ignore that as well

I'm not ignoring that run, just acknowledging that horses arn't machines.

BTW I find it a bit rich you accuse me of that when everyone including yourself conveniently ignore the runs of Planteur and Take Over.

I've still to hear anybody explain why both these horses perfomed well below par. They had perfect runs, both trailing So You Think and were in prime position to pounce. Both failed miserably.

OK lets take a different tack.

Lets say Rewilding is a late scratching and the Prince of Wales went ahead without him.

So You Think wins pulling up by five lengths, totally destroying Planteur and Take Over.

What would you have said then?
By:
ForceMajeure
When: 16 Jun 11 17:24
The Lulz continue.

The Betfair "trollform" ratings system is in full effect.

"
THE maestro Bart Cummings is convinced his former champion So You Think can soon make amends for his defeat in the Prince Of Wales's Stakes.

So You Think, unbeaten in his first two European starts, started a long odds-on favourite to win the feature English Group 1 but controversial race tactics and a questionable Ryan Moore ride brought about his undoing when beaten on the line by the late-surging Rewilding.

Cummings, who trained So You Think to win the past two Cox Plates, said he believed the champion looked "slightly underdone" for the race.

"I think he looked very well, and will improve with the run," Cummings said on Sky Sports Radio. "He over-raced and was rather fresh. He pulled a little bit and he (jockey Moore) may have gone far too early.

"The horse will still improve greatly from that and the experience will educate (trainer Aidan) O'Brien about what the horse probably needs."

There is also criticism of the role stablemate and pacemaker Jan Vermeer had in bringing about So You Think's defeat.

"I think pacemakers are completely unnecessary ... I think we're on the right track in Australia barring that idea," Cummings said.


*Bart Cummings is a legend and will be defended to the death.

*It would be a great feat if you muppets could win one Melbourne Cup let alone 12.....WAKE UP.
By:
Alf Awoody
When: 16 Jun 11 17:25
Sterling - Is that the best you have.

As Alf said still no quote that Bart said he was the best horse he's had.

Because the simple fact is he hasn't. [;)]

As for Bart Moaner, Very tough beating on an 83 year old who has been & is simply a genius.
By:
Somerset_Moan
When: 16 Jun 11 17:26
I'd have said what I said about Frankel - bloody good horse that won despite the tactics...

I don't under-rate SYT - after all I had him in three Five folds inc Frankel, Timepiece, Fame and Glory and permed the 1st leg... that loss in total cost me over two grand... I just think Cummings should learn some manners, realise his ex star is going to be meeting far better horses than it ever has before and AOB needs to put the Coolmore marketing tongue back in his head and just let his undoubted talent and the horses' performances do the talking

I am a huge fan of AOB - went to Coolemore with the mater after IStabraq retired and met him at the racecourse the day Petrushka won and still think there's genius there... but the mouth... listen, listen, listen... just watch henry cecil or Michael Stoute, Aiden... and learn... you have 25 yrs more of this game, don't give yourself grey hairs and a heart attack by putting undue stress on yourself and the horses with the hype...
By:
Somerset_Moan
When: 16 Jun 11 17:31
ALf Awoody... Cummings' age is irrelevant - he has been quoted in the press as rubbishing the Derby and European racing... yet at the first serious test, his ex-horse is beaten by a younger animal beaten in the previous year's Derby...

It's about his lack of GRACE and bad manners, not his lack of judgement - we all make mistakes and by all accounts he doesn't make many...

But learning to stfu at times is a lesson to be learned and about time he did... and it is simply lacking in breeding and class to bad mouth, by default, the next trainer in the shape of AOB...

THAT is the real issue
By:
Somerset_Moan
When: 16 Jun 11 17:34
Ditto Force Majeure...

Manners maketh man, meeting Triumph and disaster with honour and grace maketh a man!
By:
ForceMajeure
When: 16 Jun 11 17:53
If anyone should STFU it's Aidan O'Brien, at least Bart tells it as it is, unlike O'Brien with his relentless verbal diarrhea of complete BS.

"simply lacking in breeding and class".....WAKE UP you muppet!Laugh this is the internet, not a UK public school for ****s.
By:
ForceMajeure
When: 16 Jun 11 18:03
The "trollform" ratings have just been released for trainers.

..............LOSE

..............WIN


Current horse ratings are still being compiled.Grin
By:
Dark Destroyer
When: 16 Jun 11 18:13
OK lets take a different tack.

Lets say Rewilding is a late scratching and the Prince of Wales went ahead without him.

So You Think wins pulling up by five lengths, totally destroying Planteur and Take Over.

What would you have said then?


Same as I have tried to tell you half a dozen times already. Beating a 113 rated horse by 6 lengths puts SYT in the high 120's. Take Sri Putra out of the race and you have a point. The trouble is he ran.

Jeez its hard getting through sometimes.
By:
Somerset_Moan
When: 16 Jun 11 18:22
I wonder who it is at BF deleting some of the posts here... [;)]
By:
Somerset_Moan
When: 16 Jun 11 18:24
Force... you're onto a loser here:

Your horse was beaten,

Your Trainer's looking an old mouthy classless git who should stfu...

And you're starting to look like a grade A plonnkker

Class and Breeding and honour is nothing to do about Public School: it is to do with manners

There's an old joke that Says: "What's the difference between a pot of Yoghurt and Australia? Leave the yoghurt out in the sun for 200 years and it will grow a culture of its own!"

These days it's alterred to - "We sent our criminals and orphans to Australia 200 years ago so they might grow up in a different environment and have a fair chance - not worked: They're still crooks and bar-stewards!"

NOT something to which I tend to adhere... HOWEVER, your behaviour isn't helping change the opinion of those that do!
By:
Somerset_Moan
When: 16 Jun 11 18:28
Incidentally, AOB has trained more horses rated 120+ than Cummings has had hot dinners this year, so the latter should REALLY learn to stfu... his star has gone, it's elsewhere, it's meeting better horses, it may get beaten now and then... it's gone, you don't train it now... find the next one. AND find some manmners while your there.
By:
hippie
When: 16 Jun 11 18:40
Somerset, dozens of those plying their trade in Europe have jumped at the chance for a work placement with the great man over the years.

If Bart Cummings has something to say then us lesser mortals should listen however curmudgeonly he might say it.
By:
ForceMajeure
When: 16 Jun 11 18:48
You are rambling on like a muppet now, im too busy trolling @LulzSec on twitter to be bothered anymore with this rather weak debate which is now about how many convicts were sent out on a boat over 200 years ago.

@LulzSec are taking over the world as we speak, there are more important things going on right now my furry friend.

"TrollForm" ratings will be back next race bigger and better.
By:
ReaseHeath
When: 16 Jun 11 20:00
fitness angle makes me laugh - you'd think he was the only horse in the race even after he got beat.

Rewilding had n't been on the track for 81 days and had only had one run in 277 days, why would n't he strip fitter next time? (admittedly connections think he's 'best fresh'). Godolphin usually take until September to get going though.

For what it's worth, the form is clearly solid with the first two pulling well clear but they both had hard races so,depending on where they're seen next and who the opposition is, might be worth opposing.

SYT will still be overbet because people will buy into the hype - all the better for those of us who are n't too idle to thoroughly assess the merits,form and chance of every horse in the race.
By:
AdvantageAussie
When: 16 Jun 11 23:19
Yes connections have found the key to Rewilding, keep him fresh, as in only start him once every three months LOL probably skip everything and go straight into the Arc.

Front on slow motion video was interesting, comparing the width So You Think and Rewilding.

So You Think definately looked like a big muscular sprinter next to Rewilding's slim profile.

Lightly framed thing is Rewilding, it would be interesting to compare their respective weight. It might explain how he ran down So You ThinkLaugh[:p], there was obviously a stiff tailwind that day.Grin

So You Think will definately improve on the run but I don't see him getting revenge anytime soon, in fact he may be retired to stud before Rewilding's next start LOL
By:
AdvantageAussie
When: 16 Jun 11 23:24
Same as I have tried to tell you half a dozen times already. Beating a 113 rated horse by 6 lengths puts SYT in the high 120's. Take Sri Putra out of the race and you have a point. The trouble is he ran.

And your trouble is your evaluating this race based only on those horses that fit in with what you want to believe. BTW despite me asking a few times, still have not heard a valid excuse for Planteur and Take Over.

Back to Sri Putra, I'm not sure how long you've been watching horse racing (and someone else mentioned hot dinners) but I've had less of those than watched races where the seemingly outclassed 100-1 shot runs on stoutly and gets much closer to the winner than his "rating" would suggest.

It's called a one off performance, you know, bit like England and Football Laugh
By:
ReaseHeath
When: 16 Jun 11 23:25
why not? That's what they do in France. You won't see any of theirs after the Grand Prix de Paris on Bastille Day until Arc trials day.

Of course, the SYT Arc excuse will be: ' He's a Southern Hemisphere horse who has been on the go for a full calendar year.'

Don't know what you're getting so worked up about anyway, not even an Aussie horse on breeding - like me claiming Sea The Stars is British!!
By:
ReaseHeath
When: 16 Jun 11 23:32
Planteur needs cut. Twice Over is 6yo - can't remeber the exact stats but very few 6yo winners of Prince of Wales.
By:
ReaseHeath
When: 16 Jun 11 23:35
...and in both cases their best form is over 10f
By:
duffy
When: 16 Jun 11 23:37
on the comments from bart cummings about our racing not worth 2 bob.....when atr had him on the phone the other day it was pretty obvious he wasn't talking about the quality of our horses but literally about the prize money on offer, because he started talking about the fact that once all the deductions were taken out and everyone paid...there was nothing left....so he wasn't sl@gging the quality of our horses imo.
By:
tommyjone
When: 17 Jun 11 01:27
does anyone have a good guess where SYT will run next, is the eclipse a genuine possibility?
By:
AdvantageAussie
When: 17 Jun 11 03:03
Planteur needs cut. Twice Over is 6yo - can't remeber the exact stats but very few 6yo winners of Prince of Wales

Planteur obviously a little bit prissy, from what I heard there was enough rain in England in days leading up to Prince of Wales to make the surface Good to Soft in places. Certainly the surface had a nice cushion and if a horse can't perform on that, to borrow from Bart, he's not worth two bob in my book.

I don't see that as a valid excuse, he was beaten 6 - 7 lengths because he simply wasn't good enough.

As for Take Over, I would suggest that one year should not make 20 lengths difference in his performance. And 6 years old is hardly over the hill.

And BTW counting how many previous 6 Year olds have won the Prince of Wales is useless without knowing how many 6 year olds have even entered and tried to win it.
By:
AdvantageAussie
When: 17 Jun 11 03:11
does anyone have a good guess where SYT will run next, is the eclipse a genuine possibility?

Your Guess is as good as mine. But I've heard he's been nominated in most of the good races, even the Sussex Stakes over a mile.

This link has some info, including an explanation of Bart's comments.

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/superracing/aidan-obrien-thinking-about-big-english-mile-for-so-you-think/story-fn67r1j3-1226065140104

AIDAN O'Brien has added to the So You Think program puzzle by entering the dual Cox Plate winner for the Sussex Stakes in England.

What is intriguing about the nomination is that unlike all the other races in which So You Think has been entered, the Group 1 Sussex Stakes, at Goodwood on July 27, is over 1600m.

Since So You Think joined his Ballydoyle stable in Ireland, O'Brien has repeatedly dropped hints that the four-year-old has the versatility to drop back to 1600m.

"He has the class and speed to win a Group 1 over a mile," O'Brien said this month after So You Think won his first two European starts at The Curragh, Ireland.

Neither O'Brien nor anyone else at Coolmore, which owns the six-time Group 1 winner, will declare what So You Think's itinerary is past the Group 1 Prince Of Wales's Stakes (2000m) at Royal Ascot on June 15.

Many believe O'Brien may be tempted to freshen So You Think after Ascot, run him in the Sussex Stakes, then the 2000m Irish Champion Stakes at Leopardstown in early September on his way to the 2400m Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe at Longchamp, Paris, on October 2.

Under one possible scenario, So You Think will make his final racetrack appearance in the 2400m Breeders' Cup Turf at Churchill Downs, Kentucky, on November 5.

So You Think and his former trainer Bart Cummings are making headlines throughout Europe.

Cummings' dismissive line about British racing - "it's not worth two bob" and it would collapse if "the sheiks pulled their money out" after So You Think's Group 1 Tattersalls Gold Cup win last week - caused a stir.

Outspoken trainer Mark Johnston, recently appointed a director at the British Horseracing Authority, came out firmly behind Cummings.

"I couldn't agree more with Bart Cummings. Their racing is very well funded and is progressive. Our racing is seriously under-funded and in decline," Johnston told the Racing Post.

"We have had our head in the sand for years, talking about having the best racing in the world. I don't think we have now and certainly won't have in the future.

"Bart is right when saying if Sheik Mohammed took his horses from England, our racing would be in deep trouble."

sLuca Cumani was more circumspect, but basically agreed with the tenet of Cummings' view.

Cumani noted that English racing had to be very grateful for the Maktoums and Khalid Adbdullah and handful of big concerns.

"Without these people racing would go downhill rapidly, but we have very good broodmares and stallions here and in Ireland, so we have the potential to continue breeding very good horses.

"It's a question of whether they will remain here to race when prize-money is at its current level."

Only John Dunlop seemed at odds with Cummings. His only comment was "I would simply say that Bart is an Australian".
By:
AdvantageAussie
When: 17 Jun 11 03:15
...and in both cases their best form is over 10f

For horses that need more than 10f, given a 10f with good speed on throughout, I would have thought they would be running on strongly at the finish like Rewilding, not giving it up halfway down the straight.
By:
tommyjone
When: 17 Jun 11 03:18
Pretty obvious cummings wasn't actually saying the horses in europe aren't any good, clealy they are. He was just saying the way racing is set up is poor.

And the reason I ask about SYT's next race is I heard a few people saying he might not race until the irish champion stakes. Then I googled it and saw it isn't until september Shocked
By:
tobermory
When: 17 Jun 11 03:37
Would be ridiculous if he didn't run for 3 months .Would expose the 'he isn't fit enough' excuse for nonsense. Be suprising too.

AOB will usually run his best horses once a month. Can't think of many lightly raced ones. Rock of G, Giants Causeway, Henry The Navigator,Duke of M all ran about 6/7 times in their best seasons, always Group 1s . Galileo,Hawk Wing,Dylan Thomas 4 or 5 during the Summer/Autumn . Fame &Glory + Rip Van Winkle kept on going too, even against a horse they couldn't touch.

The Eclipse is the logical target . As St Nicholas Abbey and Await The Dawn are running over 12f you'd expect one or both of those to go to The King George.Though of course, with the races 3 weeks apart, any of them could run in both.

But SYT would seem the most plausible contender for Sandown.
By:
AdvantageAussie
When: 17 Jun 11 03:38
Don't know what you're getting so worked up about anyway, not even an Aussie horse on breeding - like me claiming Sea The Stars is British!!

Which is partly why I'm puzzled at the vitriol directed his way. He is the best performed son of High Chaperal as far as I know. Irish born and an English Derby winner.

And it isn't so much about how good he is, what really got me riled is the bagging of what is obviously a very couragous horse, who always lays it all on the line and never shirks his task.

Unlike many of his opponents in the Prince of Wales, he's not some limited animal that needs everything to go his way to perform.
By:
tommyjone
When: 17 Jun 11 03:43
Depends how you claim a horse really. Rocket man was bred in Australia by aus/nz horses, but no one in Australia will claim he's Australian.
By:
sootyfive
When: 17 Jun 11 05:40
i understand the rivalry between aussies and poms, So you Think shouldnt be part of this, we should all appreciate what this horse has and "will" contribute to horse racing.

Aiden O'Brien is on record during a docuementry made a week before his Royal Ascot run that he has no idea if the horse So You Think is under done, reason being he has such a high cruising speed and his stride is nearly twice that of any other horse and his wins have been way too easy, it stated he will know and learn more about So You Think after Royal Ascot if he was fit enough.
now the race in question, Many things brought down So You Think. from the start, the stuff up with the young jockey on the lead horse who serverly checked So You Think, and race way out in front causing So You Think to over race a furlong. then the jockey going for home 3 1/2 furlongs out?? seriously that left So You Think a sitting duck for a swooper, So i ask who was really the lead horse, So You Think??? it turned out that way. To be beaten a 1/2 neck in near track record time on a good to soft going speaks volumes for So You Thinks ability. lastly,So You Think is an on pace runner who runs fast sectionals, wtf they used a lead horse for, yep agree with frankie, obrien played into their hands. dont give up on So You Think yet as he is even capable of breaking track records over a mile and mile 1/2

bart cummings wasnt rubbishing English horse's  ability just the prize money offered. typical media headlines in the UK and Australia trying to beat up a story.
By:
zilzal1
When: 17 Jun 11 08:48
Where has this g/s going description came from?? Wednesdays times give a total lie to this for a start as virtually every race was around or under standard. The rain came on thursday morning.
By:
Sterling Morrison
When: 17 Jun 11 09:00
Would be interested to see SYT in the Eclipse against some decent horses

John Dunlop quote says it all
By:
ForceMajeure
When: 17 Jun 11 09:29
Would be interested to see SYT trained by someone who new what the fuc$ they were doing, preferably without a half wit son trying to take the horse out during the race because he cant ride his horse for $hit.

Bart Cummings quote says it all.
By:
Sterling Morrison
When: 17 Jun 11 09:39
Trouble is that race often cuts up to about six or seven runners

Don't know if a summer break would benefit the horse so would like to see it aimed at all the top 10f races

Bound to pick up a G1 some time, or a G2 if desperate.

Have agree re AOB, poor training and tactical performance from the Irishman.  Would like to see the horse demonstrate he is a world beater and salvage some dignity.
By:
ReaseHeath
When: 17 Jun 11 10:02
i understand the rivalry between aussies and poms, So you Think shouldnt be part of this, we should all appreciate what this horse has and "will" contribute to horse racing.

Yep, completely agree - don't you think there should be the same level of appreciation for the horse who actually won the race, showing at least as much courage and bravery?

More thread and comment about SYT than Rewilding - says it all about hype.
Page 3 of 5  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com