Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 1242 comments are related to the topic:
The ©Schalke 04© 1 from 7 Challenge thread 2011

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 7 of 32  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | ... | 32 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 1,242
By:
takethestand
When: 07 Jul 11 22:25
and giving you free advice puma
By:
puma
When: 07 Jul 11 22:38
there is lots of value to be had on betfair takethestand...

but you are right in sport betting you cant judge value on one event, is not exact science and every bet is different and its impossible to know exactly what value, if any, you got even after the result...but you can judge it over a large number of results...

anyway the point is that all you can do is TRY to find value, not TRY to find winners...is that not obvious?

Cool
By:
Schalke 04
When: 08 Jul 11 02:09
Rocket to the FACE

Schalke you don't understand that you can't know your bet will win before you place it therefore your argument against value i.e value doesn't matter so long as you pick winners is useless in the real world because you don't know when the winners and losers will come. All you can do is get a price which means that the winners you have pay out slightly more than your total losses.

This isn't up for argument because it's a fact. If you're right and we're all wrong then prove it. Otherwise I think it's time you stop being stubborn, spend a few hours doing some reading and then put your effort into a value picking system.

If each one of your selections is going to win then why are you putting £2 on it? In case it loses? Exactly. Think about it.

------------------------

I have highlighted one thing from your message simply because I have NEVER ever said this in any post I have put on here, of course it matters !! What I am saying is that it's not the most important part of a bet, I have picked what I have considered good value bets in this thread, otherwise I wouldn't put them on but good value bets still lose but yes my winning selections must pay out more than my losses ... I want to pick winners with a good price, not losers with a good price !! Getting value does not mean you will win, you will only win if your selections win. 7 great value losers and my thread will be over !!

I am putting £2 on bets because I have made up a staking system, I treat my £2 bets the same as I would a £1600 bet, as long as I think it's going to win and I like the price of it
By:
Trevh
When: 08 Jul 11 02:27
Getting value does not mean you will win, you will only win if your selections win. 7 great value losers and my thread will be over !!

Then your staking plan is very poor and your stakes are grossly too high. Great value bets, win or lose, should be your aim. It's been said over and over again in this thread by professional punters.

Your statement I want to pick winners with a good price, not losers with a good price is absolute lunacy. You say it all the time in response, but it doesn't make it any the less fundamentally wrong.

Now guys, shall we give up?
By:
Schalke 04
When: 08 Jul 11 02:28
So who is to disagree that every bet on this thread has been "value" ...

You lot seem to talk about value "after" outcomes have taken place, but when you hear people say, oh Bolton @ 8/1 are great value to beat Chelsea, then Chelsea thump them 7-0 but you hear people still say "oh but it was great value" ....

I know from my experience what is a good value bet, and what a poor value bet is ... I have done very well in the past determining the level of a stake to the price on a bet and making it work, at times I have got it wrong, I have came up with manhy different betting systaems which I only use on the forum, I don't put every single bet I put up. I had Higgins @ 5/1 to win the World Title, which I regarded as fantastic value and I staked accordingly to how much I felt it would win. I have also staked lots of money on losing bets too .... but at the end of the day, without the outcome of a bet then you simply can't bet.

Someone asked me to prove how value doesn't win you money on a bet ... I placed a bet on a football match, 4/5 DNB !! Awesome value, I would consider the bet to be 1/3, but it's 4/5 !! I stuck £500 on it, but it finished a draw, the outcome (which does matter) = VOID !! BET VOID !! ... so, how did finding a great value bet make me win

If nobody got winning bets then EVERY single person betting would be skint ... without winning bets then your word "value" mean feck all !! You need bother winners and good prices to succed !!

I read Amarillo Slims book, and at the start he talked about getting better prices in order to win, it al lstarted in the intro with him playing table-tennis but with him choosing the bats, with this he put the odds in his favor, but that didn't guaratee him winning, he stil lhad to go out there and win the match, without beating the guy he wouldn't make any money, exact same thing in all aspects of betting, you need a RESULT !!
By:
Schalke 04
When: 08 Jul 11 02:33
How is any losing bet a good thing?

Yes, I place every bet with the same intention, that it is going to win !! And that it is going to win at a good price ... but just by getting good prices does not mean you will win, and for anyone to say so is a complete liar !! Youz have even been quoted as saying you can't find a winner, it just happens as you have no control over it, so it is very possible for every single good value bet you choose will lose .... it's unlikely, but it's still possible. So, thats why I say that value alone is not enough, you still need your bets to win ...
By:
Trevh
When: 08 Jul 11 02:44
Just one example was earlier on when you took 1.57 on Maguire, whilst he was matched at 1.9 on here.

I haven't looked at all your bets, but if I did I would probably say I wouldn't have taken any of them at the prices you did. Can I ask how many of your bets you beat SP on?

Anyway, I now see that you will never understand that value when backing is identifying and obtaining odds greater than the true chance of an outcome, NOT thinking you can predict that outcome.

Takethestand thinks there are no ways to identify value in sports, of course there are, he isn't trying hard enough.
By:
Schalke 04
When: 08 Jul 11 02:46
Banks: 1) £2.01 2) £6.03 3) £20.09 4) £60.27 5) £181 6) £543 7) £1629

Increase every £13.40 = 1) 1p 2) 3p 3) 9p 4) 27p 5) £1 6) £3 7) £9

Total Won: £53.95

Current Winnings to carry: £12.55 --- Total Withdrawn: £28

34. (Tennis) M.Gonzalez/Riba DOUBLE - £2.01 to win £1.44 - lost
35. (Football) Livingstone to bt Hibs DNB @ 4/7 - £6.03 to win £3.45 - WON
36. (Tennis) Hass to win set 2 v Berrer @ 4/6 - £2.01 to win £1.34 - WON
37. (Tennis) Pennetta/Volandri DOUBLE - £2.01 to win £1.38 - lost
38. (Football) Argentina to bt Columbia @ 4/9 - £6.03 to win £2.68 - lost
39. (Snooker) S.Maguire to bt L.Wienbo @ 4/7 - £20.00 to win £11.43 - WON
40. (Tennis) Isner to bt Bogomolov @ 1/4 - £1.98 to win £0.50 - WON

©Schalke 04©
By:
Schalke 04
When: 08 Jul 11 02:55
1.9 was a fantastic price for Maguire today, I considered the 4/7 to be a fantastic price so to get that was awesome, but I am not using Betfair at the moment so I wouldn't have got it ...

You havn't even looked and said you wouldn't have taken any of them, whatever (that is the comment of a complete up himself ****) You come on and slate me for my bets (which are in profit)

Anyway, I now see that you will never understand that value when backing is identifying and obtaining odds greater than the true chance of an outcome, NOT thinking you can predict that outcome ... well in order for you to get greater odds than the chance of an outcome you still have to come up with what the chances of that outcome will be !! And one set of odds going with rankings, stats, h2h are all completely different in sports ... there is no mathematical law to say that any player will play to his true odds or that what you are getting is better than the chances of it happening, that is all up to each individual to decide what they think the outcome will be ....
By:
Schalke 04
When: 08 Jul 11 03:05
Ok, the odds on this thread failing are roughly 2000/1 ... would you say thats value or not value? I have already won £53 and I am at bet 1 in the system ....
By:
Schalke 04
When: 08 Jul 11 03:07
next bet: (Snooker) S.Murphy to bt P.Ebdon @ 4/9 - £2.00 to win £0.89
By:
Cramped_With_A_Nun
When: 08 Jul 11 03:25
mate wtf is the point in wasting your time trying to win 89 pence, it's embarrassing to watch, I knwo I know, "don't watch then" ok.
By:
puma
When: 08 Jul 11 04:51
value alone is not enough, you still need your bets to win ...


schalke can you please just shut us all up and post in big bold letters: 'BEFORE the event, value is all that matters'

Cool
By:
puma
When: 08 Jul 11 06:16
the odds on this thread failing are roughly 2000/1 ... would you say thats value or not value?

you do realise that 2000/1 would be the approx odds of this thread failing if this thread were 7 bets long?

you are already on 40 bets, and in a 2000 bet sample you should expect a losing run of 7...

given how many bets it will take you to bank your original stake, your are about twice as likely to win your next bet as you are to succeed with this challenge...

best of luck dude...

Cool
By:
catfloppo
When: 08 Jul 11 09:13
Ok, Schalkes here's a challenge for you.  Answer the following question with a straight 'yes' or 'no'.

At the point you placed this bet:

next bet: (Snooker) S.Murphy to bt P.Ebdon @ 4/9 - £2.00 to win £0.89

did you know what the outcome was going to be?
By:
takethestand
When: 08 Jul 11 09:30
catflappo, do you know what the real price of the match is and what is value?
By:
h-bomb
When: 08 Jul 11 09:44
If you pick more winners but get lower odds, it's the same as getting higher odds but selecting fewer winners (because by refusing what you believe to be poor value, you are sometimes refusing winners)

Put very, very simply (ASSUMING A FIXED STAKE):


AVERAGE ODDS X NUMBER OF WINNERS x STAKE = RETURN TO PUNTER


The stake is fixed, only odds and winners are variable. Schalke focuses on number of winners. Most people here are advocating focusing on the average odds (but they're assuming they can still pick the same number of winners)

It's a see-saw where you are arguing that one side is heavier than the other, when in fact it fairly balanced.
By:
catfloppo
When: 08 Jul 11 09:45
Not a clue although there are ways of finding out
By:
takethestand
When: 08 Jul 11 09:49
how exactly?  there are far to many variable factors.  its basically a best guess that may or not be accurate.  there is NO way to find out the correct price
By:
takethestand
When: 08 Jul 11 09:50
and unless you know this then you cannot accuratly judge value before the event
By:
catfloppo
When: 08 Jul 11 10:11
Well, I don't know enough about snooker to judge for myself but there are plenty that do and some of them offer prices on here.  So if I look at the betfair market I can with a considerable degree of confidence conclude that the real price of the match is somewhere close to the midway point between the back and lay values.
By:
catfloppo
When: 08 Jul 11 10:12
Provided the market is sufficiently well populated of course.
By:
catfloppo
When: 08 Jul 11 10:13
Value only exists before the event
By:
Cramped_With_A_Nun
When: 08 Jul 11 10:56
Value only exists before the event

value exist in running, like when Youzhney took the first set of Federer at Wimbledon, lumped on so I did.
By:
catfloppo
When: 08 Jul 11 11:00
Ok, value only exists before the end of the event[:p]
By:
Lori
When: 08 Jul 11 11:03
Just as a reminder from the previous thread, there is very strong evidence that you're not finding value.

Here is the breakdown by bank. A reminder that all bets are in PENCE.

Bank    Number of bets    Average of stake    Average of result    Percentage gain
1    120    62.98    -5.40    -8.57%
2    47    190.36    -17.47    -9.18%
3    19    582.63    -36.95    -6.34%
4    7    1910.00    754.29    39.49%
5    1    5050.00    4270.00    84.55%
By:
Schalke 04
When: 08 Jul 11 11:07
Banks: 1) £2.02 2) £6.06 3) £20.18 4) £60.54 5) £182 6) £546 7) £1638

Increase every £13.40 = 1) 1p 2) 3p 3) 9p 4) 27p 5) £1 6) £3 7) £9

Total Won: £54.84

Current Winnings to carry: £0.04 --- Total Withdrawn: £28

35. (Football) Livingstone to bt Hibs DNB @ 4/7 - £6.03 to win £3.45 - WON
36. (Tennis) Hass to win set 2 v Berrer @ 4/6 - £2.01 to win £1.34 - WON
37. (Tennis) Pennetta/Volandri DOUBLE - £2.01 to win £1.38 - lost
38. (Football) Argentina to bt Columbia @ 4/9 - £6.03 to win £2.68 - lost
39. (Snooker) S.Maguire to bt L.Wienbo @ 4/7 - £20.00 to win £11.43 - WON
40. (Tennis) Isner to bt Bogomolov @ 1/4 - £1.98 to win £0.50 - WON
41. (Snooker) S.Murphy to bt P.Ebdon @ 4/9 - £2.00 to win £0.89 - WON

©Schalke 04©
By:
Schalke 04
When: 08 Jul 11 11:15
next bet: (Snooker) A.Carter to bt Y.Delu @ 3/10 - £2.02 to win £0.61
By:
catfloppo
When: 08 Jul 11 11:17
Ok, Schalkes here's a challenge for you.  Answer the following question with a straight 'yes' or 'no'.

At the point you placed this bet:

next bet: (Snooker) A.Carter to bt Y.Delu @ 3/10 - £2.02 to win £0.61

did you know what the outcome was going to be?
By:
Cramped_With_A_Nun
When: 08 Jul 11 11:31
point remains, wasting you time making 61 pence, don't know what point you're trying to make but it's - pointless.
By:
h-bomb
When: 08 Jul 11 11:39
Here's a point then. If everybody on Betfair would each give me 61 pence, I'd be most grateful.
By:
Lori
When: 08 Jul 11 11:46
Not if you had to give them back 67 pence each on average.
By:
Lori
When: 08 Jul 11 11:52
Schalke 04 Joined: 10 Apr 05
Replies: 7654 04 Jul 11 21:30   

Banks: 1) £2.01 2) £6.03 3) £20.09 4) £60.27 5) £181 6) £543 7) £1629

Increase every £13.40 = 1) 1p 2) 3p 3) 9p 4) 27p 5) £1 6) £3 7) £9

Total Won: £47.36

Current Winnings to carry: £10.28 --- Total Withdrawn: £23.68

27. (Tennis) Bryan/Bryan to bt Melz/Petz @ 1/3 - £2.00 to win £0.67 - WON
28. (Tennis) Sharapova/Volandri DOUBLE - £2.00 to win £1.82 - lost
29. (Football) Fjolnir v Leikner DRAW @ 1/2 - £6.00 to win £3.00 - lost
30. (Snooker) B.Hawkins to bt N.Bond @ 8/11 - £20.00 to win £14.55 - lost
31. (Tennis) Bryan-Bryan/Nadal DOUBLE - £60 to win £48.33 - WON
32. (Tennis) Glushko to bt Kostova @ 1/16 - £2.00 to win £0.13 - lost
33. (Tennis) Lisicki/Stosur to bt Erakovic/Tanasugarn @ 4/9 - £6.03 to win £2.68 - WON
Schalke 04 Joined: 10 Apr 05
Replies: 7654 05 Jul 11 22:17   

Banks: 1) £2.01 2) £6.03 3) £20.09 4) £60.27 5) £181 6) £543 7) £1629

Increase every £13.40 = 1) 1p 2) 3p 3) 9p 4) 27p 5) £1 6) £3 7) £9

Total Won: £48.71

Current Winnings to carry: £10.95 --- Total Withdrawn: £24.36

29. (Football) Fjolnir v Leikner DRAW @ 1/2 - £6.00 to win £3.00 - lost
30. (Snooker) B.Hawkins to bt N.Bond @ 8/11 - £20.00 to win £14.55 - lost
31. (Tennis) Bryan-Bryan/Nadal DOUBLE - £60 to win £48.33 - WON
32. (Tennis) Glushko to bt Kostova @ 1/16 - £2.00 to win £0.13 - lost
33. (Tennis) Lisicki/Stosur to bt Erakovic/Tanasugarn @ 4/9 - £6.03 to win £2.68 - WON
34. (Tennis) M.Gonzalez/Riba DOUBLE - £2.01 to win £1.44 - lost
35. (Football) Livingstone to bt Hibs DNB @ 4/7 - £6.03 to win £3.45 - WON



I know better than to doubt your records, but you’re 9p light on bets 34 and 35 here.

You made a profit of £1.44 on those two bets combined, but your total only went up by £1.35
By:
Lori
When: 08 Jul 11 11:58
You stole back a penny on bet 36 though.
By:
Trevh
When: 08 Jul 11 13:34
next bet: (Snooker) A.Carter to bt Y.Delu @ 3/10 - £2.02 to win £0.61

"did you know what the outcome was going to be?"


Hehe, What I don't get is how on Earth he can take that price (and every other price) and then say he bets at value. Once again that bet was matched at 1.49 on BF (only for £2) but that would have been enough for Schalkes.

The more I look the more bad prices I see. Schalke, if you ditched the crazy staking plan and tried to match your bets 10-20-30% higher than the poor prices you currently take, you would be laughing all the way to withdrawal day.
By:
Schalke 04
When: 08 Jul 11 17:01
If I had to use Betfair at the moment, I would be getting Comm charges, CC deposit charges, CC interest charges ... thats why I am not using BF, if I take into account those charges then I'm better off at the bookies right now ....
By:
Schalke 04
When: 08 Jul 11 17:03
catfloppo
Date Joined: 16 Nov 06 Add contact | Send message
When: 08 Jul 11 11:17 Joined: Date Joined: 16 Nov 06 | Topic/replies: 915 | Blogger: catfloppo's blog
Ok, Schalkes here's a challenge for you.  Answer the following question with a straight 'yes' or 'no'.

At the point you placed this bet:

next bet: (Snooker) A.Carter to bt Y.Delu @ 3/10 - £2.02 to win £0.61

did you know what the outcome was going to be? ........... Yes
By:
Schalke 04
When: 08 Jul 11 17:06
Trevh ... thats the best post you have put up on here, yup, I know I could be making more at Betfair, but right now funds are tight and I aint brining a CC to betfair at the moment, once it's built up then I shall. cheers
By:
Schalke 04
When: 08 Jul 11 17:06
cheers Lori, I will look into the missing winnings, cheers ...
By:
Schalke 04
When: 08 Jul 11 17:11
Banks: 1) £2.02 2) £6.06 3) £20.18 4) £60.54 5) £182 6) £546 7) £1638

Increase every £13.40 = 1) 1p 2) 3p 3) 9p 4) 27p 5) £1 6) £3 7) £9

Total Won: £55.53

Current Winnings to carry: £0.73 --- Total Withdrawn: £28

36. (Tennis) Hass to win set 2 v Berrer @ 4/6 - £2.01 to win £1.34 - WON
37. (Tennis) Pennetta/Volandri DOUBLE - £2.01 to win £1.38 - lost
38. (Football) Argentina to bt Columbia @ 4/9 - £6.03 to win £2.68 - lost
39. (Snooker) S.Maguire to bt L.Wienbo @ 4/7 - £20.00 to win £11.43 - WON
40. (Tennis) Isner to bt Bogomolov @ 1/4 - £1.98 to win £0.50 - WON
41. (Snooker) S.Murphy to bt P.Ebdon @ 4/9 - £2.00 to win £0.89 - WON
42. (Snooker) A.Carter to bt Y.Delu @ 3/10 - £2.02 to win £0.61 - WON

©Schalke 04©
Page 7 of 32  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | ... | 32 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com