Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 435 comments are related to the topic:
The funding crisis in horseracing

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 8 of 11  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 435
By:
Lori
When: 20 Sep 10 12:35
Just fwiw, on this occasion I meant the "turgid" aimed at the bottom end of the meets, not my own personal viewpoint. (As many fans seem to think there is too much racing , which I'm in no position to comment on)

In the same way as a women's first round between two nobodies in tennis would be turgid, or a mid table 3rd division soccer match.
By:
Lori
When: 20 Sep 10 12:36
Aha, the legal status is what I was missing I believe.
By:
Sandown
When: 20 Sep 10 12:50
Lori

yeh, boring or turgid fixtures exist in every sport. I never look beyond the premiership and most of the time I'm only interested in the top 5 or 6 sides  even then (which includes my own team, of course. But of course, people follow teams for all sorts of reasons and loyalty becomes a way of life. If you don't like a lot of the racing, simply don't look at it or bet on it- just ignore it.the problem is that the levy boards directs money to these fixtures and dilutes the total. Of course, this helps the grass roots and there is an argument for doing so.
By:
Lori
When: 20 Sep 10 13:04
It's a complex problem, which is why I'm fascinated with it all.

I think a lot depends on what whoever is in charge really want (beyond those that are lining their own pockets, which is of course no use to anyone).

There are contrasting aims (Don't pander to the masses vs Raise interest levels (money) being the crux of the matter) and it seems that someone or some body of people needs to sit and work out where on that scale racing is going to aim to occupy.

At the current time it seems that racing wants everything. Of course, we all want everything, but without a sensible final aim, it's hard to construct a gameplan that achieves that aim, as there will always be a "yes but if we do this, this negative happens"

Racing, imo, should work out which negatives are worth accepting in order to achieve whatever positives it may require.
By:
Sandown
When: 20 Sep 10 14:44
The response from the BHA to my email referencing this thread resulted in this peronalised, detailed, informative response which illustrated  that they had read the thread and taken on-board the issues contained within it. I am now reassured that they have the answers.

Dear Mr

Thank you for your email and apologies for the delay in responding.

We have been waiting for the launch of the Levy Charter campaign which went live today and is run under the banner Racing United: Campaigning for a fairer Levy.



Details of this are available on the dedicated website - http://www.racingunited.co.uk/ and for further information on the problems Racing faces in terms of Levy and funding, please visit our website here.

It is our aim, that should Government and the Horserace Betting Levy Board, readdress the present Levy system, Racing will continue as a strong and healthy sport. Unfortunately, as you will see from these two links above, with bookmakers’ present contribution levels, the sport as we know it is unsustainable.



Please show your support by signing the petition on the Racing United website.



Kind regards





Turia Tellwright  Communications Officer
By:
Lori
When: 20 Sep 10 14:53
Good lord. lol.
By:
birch2
When: 20 Sep 10 17:58
they just cant see beyond 'bookmakers' present contributions levels'

If the gov intervene with new legislation - the end result will be that they will get less than they get now

insanity still prevailing
By:
Sandown
When: 20 Sep 10 20:55
MP Davies warns racing over levy negotiations

By Howard Wright 2:34PM 20 SEP 2010

ONE of the House of Commons' chief supporters of horseracing and betting has warned racing interests about what he sees as the dangers of failing to reach agreement with the betting industry over the 50th levy scheme.

Discussions on the central funding scheme that begins next April are coming to a head, with senior figures on both sides indicating they believe the October 31 deadline will pass without resolution, after which the matter goes to Jeremy Hunt, secretary of state at the Department for Culture, Media and Sport, to settle.

Philip Davies, Tory MP for Shipley, warned on Monday that he could see no upside for racing if the matter went to government for determination.

He said: "Racing is asking for £130-150 million from the next levy scheme. That's cloud cuckoo land, and I can'tsee any way

that the government would settle for that amount.



Not much chance of him signing the petition thenLaugh
By:
askari1
When: 20 Sep 10 23:18
Sandown, w/ regard to net winners paying into the levy, my feeling is that the arguments, and the definitions that underpin them, are simpler than you make out.

Leviable bookmakers are those who have been licensed as such. The clients of bookmakers are punters and do not fall liable to taxation on their winnings. The 2004 Treasury ruling into whether exchange 'layers' should be subject to taxation on some basis stated that some exchange customers ran through complex strategies that involved multiple offsetting bets, but that these did not in themselves make them bookmakers.

Betfair pays more than its share of levy; and it is not for a tax collector to seek to decide whether operators should follow a high-turnover, low-margin business model or the other way round.

The narrow point on which the ABB is pressing is whether there are people carrying bookmaking 'in the way of a business' on the exchanges. This issue turns on the meaning of a business. First, bf wd have to disclose the winnings and strategies of a number of profitable clients, in a way that Ladbr*kes, for example, wd not unlikely to disclose the betting of Michael Tabor. Then it wd have to be shown that these players (presumably sitting on fat cash cushions) had to bet on the horses in order to make a living.

And then, further, the Treasury wd have to go through the paperwork of offering exchange winners e.g. quite possibly arbers rebates on their racing losses elsewhere.

I cannot see bf losing the argument, not the collection of a levy slice from botted-up exchange winners getting off the ground.
By:
askari1
When: 20 Sep 10 23:20
Lori, the BHA thinks that either the horses are so utterly compelled or bettors so pathetically addicted that they will keep betting whatever the overround.

Poker is something to do with their antique fireplaces.

Other than finding other sports more interesting than the pastime of kings ;), you  are not the person missing a trick here.
By:
askari1
When: 20 Sep 10 23:21
*Laddies would not disclose Tabor's punting
By:
askari1
When: 20 Sep 10 23:23
Fwiw, is Telia Tellwright in any way related to Kirkland Tellwright, the famous Haydock course-waterer and -measurer?
By:
Lori
When: 21 Sep 10 00:43
Cheers askari, then I'll continue to read with interest and a touch less paranoia Grin

FWIW The sport of kings isn't the part of horse racing I don't enjoy, I have fond memories of the likes of Arazi from the days when I did gamble regularly on them. (I didn't even have a bet in that race)

The fact I find it hard to beat and the fact many races are without real purpose is what turned me off the sport.
By:
Sandown
When: 21 Sep 10 10:18
askar1

I can't second guess what action any or all of the the parties (IR, Treasury, Levy Board, Govt.) might do about the (few? many?) large regular winners on BF but we must remember that the political climate now is one of sweeping budget cuts and sharing the pain. The amount raised is less important than the political significance of such action.

Traders on the stock exchanges are subject to taxation. Income tax and corporation tax applies, does it not?

What's  different about traders on a sports exchange?

The new style players who play within Betfair and who are part of the operating mechanism of the market are performing a function that BF itself can(and does?) perform in ironing out inefficiencies. This is not about risk-taking this is about technology almost guaranteeing a profit.These operators, imo, can be said to be running businesses. If so, maybe they should be subject to the tax rules that generally apply.

I grant you that arbers will escape the net because in general they lose on the exchanges. One friend of mine has lost £5m+ to BF over the past few years and he obviously has won much more through the books. He won't be picked up.I am talking about those players who run bots day and night and just leave the bots to get on with it.

There is also the case of unlicenced bookmakers who hedge on the exchanges. They are part of the wider problem of underground, unlicenced betting which is a separate issue.

The only defence that I can see that BF have is that such action would unfairly discriminate against them and put their business model at risk. On the other hand, it is their existance, not the traditional bm's, that have made this new "business" possible.

How much relevence all this has to the thread title, I'm not sure. Probably not very much in the scheme of things so it would be gesture politics.
By:
heynoodles
When: 21 Sep 10 10:41
askari1 Joined: 29 Nov 01
Replies: 289 20 Sep 10 23:23   
Fwiw, is Telia Tellwright in any way related to Kirkland Tellwright, the famous Haydock course-waterer and -measurer?



It's horseracing of course she is! Daughter I believe.
By:
Muqbil
When: 21 Sep 10 11:31
Sandown, comparing the stock exchange and betting on horse races is like comparing apples to pears. They are entirely different. Betfair is a bookmaker who balances their book almost perfectly, We are simply placing bets in the same way we would do at a traditional bookmakers simply with a different charging mechanism.

Why should users of a betting exchange be singled out for a higher level of taxation than those using a traditional bookmaker?

There is no valid argument that I have read or heard anywhere that can support the claim that users of a betting exchange are acting differently to those using tradtional bookmakers. It is quite simply down to the level of investment Betfair have put into the technology to enable the operation of markets near 100%. There is nothing to stop traditional bookmakers making their own markets more efficient in the same way.
By:
hazel
When: 21 Sep 10 11:51
Sandown referring to your post of 10.18.  You are seeing this from your own standpoint.  I could say that anyone who has contacts with a racing stable and bets on known "live" ones  is running a business.  Whether they bet with an exchange or a traditional bookmaker makes no difference.  Someone else might say a person who bets with fast pictures is running a business.  What about the form book expert, he too may be seen as a professional.  This list goes on. Any body can purchase the technology to run bots day and night, not that I do, but to single them out as having an "advantage" would be wrong.
By:
Sandown
When: 21 Sep 10 12:22
Muqbil, Hazel

I understand your arguments, I really do and I have sympathy for them. In some ways, what we are discussing is "definitons." The introduction of exchanges has changed the debate significantly. Look at things this way. BF is a business, is it not? Indeed, it is classified as a bookmaker and holds a licence. No dispute there, I hope.

What it does is to provide a platform through technology in which players are matched at an agreed price.

It could if it wants to, make certain that there are no inefficiencies left, no crumbs off the table, for anyone else to capitalise on.

Enough entrepreneurs have seen that BF does enable crumbs to fall off the table for them to make a good living essentially arbing between available prices.They have computer systems which are de facto extensions of the technology which BF uses to wipe out the inefficiencies. What makes them any different to BF? If BF did it there is no dispute. If someone else doe it there should also be no dispute. They are in effect sub-contractors to BF.

This has nothing to do with using traditional bm's and making comparisons. it has nothing to with "insider" information or form-book expertise. They all quite clearly fall into the category of people with opinions betting against other people with opinions.

Muqbil, I don't agree that we are talking apples and pears at all. In both cases people are placing bets on price movements irrespective of whether the underlying activity is equities, commodities, derivitives or sports outcomes.
By:
Muqbil
When: 21 Sep 10 12:44
On the stock exchange people are actually buying an asset.

On Betfair the bookmakers people are simply betting on the outcome of an event.

How are the two alike? How is Betfair any more like the stock exchange than a traditional bookmaker save for the more advanced technology used by Betfair?


The fact that a few people have the mathematical nouse to be able to back several outcomes within one event to produce a guaranteed income does not make them a business anymore on betfair as it would at Ladbrokes.
By:
Sandown
When: 21 Sep 10 12:47
On the stock exchange people are actually buying an asset.

A fures price is not an asset, its a price. A derivitive is not an asset.  Whether something is an asset or not is immaterial.
By:
Sandown
When: 21 Sep 10 12:51
The fact that a few people have the mathematical nouse to be able to back several outcomes within one event to produce a guaranteed income does not make them a business anymore on betfair as it would at Ladbrokes.

A currency exchange is a business, is it not, based on the arbitrage between currency prices. What's the difference?
By:
Muqbil
When: 21 Sep 10 12:59
Ladbrokes is a business. Why should someone placing bets with Ladbrokes be treated any differently to someone placing bets with Betfair simply becuase Betfair have invested in better technology?
By:
Sandown
When: 21 Sep 10 13:10
Because the existance of that technology makes it possible operate as a business
By:
jabmast
When: 21 Sep 10 13:17
Enough entrepreneurs have seen that BF does enable crumbs to fall off the table for them to make a good living essentially arbing between available prices.They have computer systems which are de facto extensions of the technology which BF uses to wipe out the inefficiencies. What makes them any different to BF?

Sandown, is the above based on hearsay or do you know of anybody personally who is doing exactly as you say above.

I don't believe that there is a band of professionals who make their money this way. I think it's far likelier that the vast, vast majority of people who make it pay on here do so by working on their own opinions some of whom then enhance and optimise these with automated strategies.
By:
Sandown
When: 21 Sep 10 13:20
Anyway, all I am saying is that a case is possible, and that if i can see it so will others who may be in a position to do something about it. BF introducing the PC is a virtual admittance of that. Whether anyone will, I do not know. It may be too small a hare to chase.
By:
hazel
When: 21 Sep 10 13:38
Sandown these people (if there are any) that pick up the crumbs do so with no advantage over you or anyone else.  Every price offered and taken can be activated by anyone, whether by robots or manually.  Every user can work manually or purchase ready made freely available software.  I can lay at 1.1 and back at 1.11 manually, whilst someone else can do it robotically, we have equal opportunity throughout the process. If one is a business then the other is also.
By:
birch2
When: 21 Sep 10 13:47
sandown

I actually think you have a point re the stock exchange comparison, the technology and the business points.
But I would really like someone to define exactly the criteria that makes a bf customer a business, without affecting all other supposedly 'leisure' customers
By:
Sandown
When: 21 Sep 10 13:58
hazel

Same is true of other exchanges but they are still taxable.Anyway, I do not want this thread to go off on a tangent any longer so if you want to debate it further can you start a separate thread. Thanks.
By:
askari1
When: 21 Sep 10 14:26
Lori, I think the purpose of a lot of races is to keep trainers and stable staff in a job and to provide an interest to small owners.

And nothing wrong with that--though the way in which the betting volumes dwarf the prize money could be thought an inducement to corruption.
By:
askari1
When: 21 Sep 10 14:37
Sandown, you do not pay any tax at all if you win at spread betting on such vehicles as derivatives of indices, individual shares, currencies and bonds. The spread betting bookie seeks to guarantee itself a profit by building a spread into its prices and is charged corporation tax.

Share trading gains attract capital gains tax, but I am not sure that private individuals wd have to pay either income or corporation tax.

Apart from the separate issue of unlicensed bookmakers hedging into bf, it will be very difficult for any administrator or taxman to prove that there are regular exchange winners operating in the way of a business. Any attempt to determine this wd surely be resisted by betfair, as it wd expose its clients to an asymmetrical level of scrutiny vis-a-vis those of the conventional books.
By:
askari1
When: 21 Sep 10 14:43
Heynoodles, this kind of thing tells its own story.

There was a RP story where she went on a freebie to Billies' operations in Gibraltar and said nothing about the company's laughable £10 limits. (On one account I got down to £0, then I 'learnt' to have some mug bets on the Premiership).
By:
askari1
When: 21 Sep 10 14:58
Betfair is classified as a bookmaker and holds a licence. No dispute there, I hope.

What it does is to provide a platform through technology in which players are matched at an agreed price.


Betfair could if it wants to, make certain that there are no inefficiencies left, no crumbs off the table, for anyone else to capitalise on.

Enough entrepreneurs have seen that BF does enable crumbs to fall off the table for them to make a good living essentially arbing between available prices.They have computer systems which are de facto extensions of the technology which BF uses to wipe out the inefficiencies.


It's still the case that these people essentially undergo risk in operating their strategies. Their technology could fail at any point. The exchange cd suspend a market arbitrarily.

Bf are also a bookmaker who undergo risk in the sense that their technology cd also go belly-up. In theory, the company's technology eliminates risk, but eventualities mean this is never any more than a goal. Remember what happened what bf massively marketed themselves before the Grand National and ended up with an overround of something like 136%. The company enters into commitments with its clients to meet a certain price and has to abide by this whatever happens with its technology.

Muqbil, they bm s have heavily invested in technology; and its effect e.g. is to prevent arbers making over-the-counter bets. It's a funny kind of investment that puts a lid on sales.

Anyway, to drag Sandown's thread main to its main topic, for me a good first step wd be to negotiate contracts to offer prices on individual meets (this is Sandown's idea) and also vary the takeout on tote pools (wh/ cd be more heavily advertised) depending on contract sales. This wd make racing's own prices competitive.

Sadly the tote will be sold out of racing's hands anyway.
By:
Lori
When: 21 Sep 10 19:10
Cheers again Askari to give me understandable reasons for things :)

As an aside, it's interesting to me that Betfair are a) Always keen to point out to regulators etc that they're a bookmaker as they stand all the bets and then farm them back out

and b) Advertising that they cut out the middle man.

Isn't someone important at some point going to notice this apparent "having it both ways" about the situation?
By:
Sandown
When: 24 Sep 10 09:48
The 2011 fixtre list with its Championship day at Ascot and the shift to a Saturday for a number of major races is a result for RFC, one which is several notches better than anything else they have achieved. The fact that only 20 meetings have gone, a token number, is the counter-side.

Will this have any effect on funds raced? Well, it won't do it any harm for sure, but somewhere in the deep recesses of the racing hierarchy's collective brain (contradiction in terms?)surely people have an idea that punters have only so much to lose, and that the only issue is how long it takes them to lose it. If I lose my money on a mid-week evening meeting I wont any any or at least less to spend on a Saturday. Next year we will be seeing the full effects of the 25% budget cuts and I wonder if that might just be more of a factor in terms of the effect on the levy (if there is one).

Nevertheless, high fives for some progress.

For those of a nervous disposition, the article on p6 of the RP regarding the possible introduction of an additional 1% tax on winnings in Ireland (to go to the State not to racing) should have a few on here who work to small % on large churn,having a few sleepless nights.Might it happen here? Never assume that it wont and don't rely on a 1920's ruling about no tax on winning punters. All sorts of horrors are possible.
By:
Sandown
When: 24 Sep 10 09:50
funds raised... won't have any
By:
topkat
When: 25 Sep 10 12:58
There is no funding crisis in British horseracing. Whilst the levy is down for the simple reason that punters are betting less on UK horseracing, traditional bookmakers are actually paying more to "racing" than ever before.

The reason? Massive increases in TV media rights fees, which bookies pay for the right to broadcast TV pictures of racing in their shops.

The increase in media rights fees has more than offset the fall in the levy over the past 3 years. The BHA complain vociferously about the fall in levy, but are mute on the increase in racing's income from media rights fees. SIS announced a 7% increase in their fees to bookies within the last few weeks, and more increases are expected to follow.

The levy is not supposed to deliver a "fair return" to racing. The law requires that it be set at a level that "balances the needs of racing with the ability of bookmakers to pay".

Racing's needs have fallen because of their increased income from media rights fees. Bookmakers' ability to pay has fallen for the same reason plus the decline in betting on racing. Therefore it is right that the levy should have fallen.
By:
Rollo Tomasi
When: 25 Sep 10 14:10
Sandown,
Are you sure about all this "shifting" to Saturday being such a good idea? The midweek program is being diluted all the time and becoming wall to wall dross. Is racing really picking up enough racegoers and betting turnover on these now rare days where racing is worth watching - to compsensate what must be reductions midweek?

Take Ascot today. This used to be a good 3 day meeting televised on BBC Thu to Sat. Now only Saturday is on terrestrial. OK the BBC don't cover as much racing now but is the lack of days worth televising part of the reasons why they don't?
By:
topkat
When: 25 Sep 10 15:41
The lack of public interest is why the BBC don't cover as much racing as they used to.

Racing is the only sport that has to pay Channel 4 to televise it!
By:
Sandown
When: 26 Sep 10 12:58
topkat

Your analysis is not correct. The HG submission does recognise the combined total of levy plus media rights payments increased from £120m in 2002 to £160m in 2008 an increase of 5%. However, the share dropped from 19% to 155 as greater increases were recorded by owners training costs (+14%) and consumers (+13%). Since 2008, the decline in levy payment is significant as has been discussed on this thread. This has caused the drastic cuts in prize money forecast for 2010/11. I agree with you about the definition of the basis of contribution and there is a sense that racing is trying to take the moral high ground by using the principle of "fairness".
By:
Sandown
When: 26 Sep 10 13:03
15% not 155

Rollo Tomasi

The evidence that is available suggests that Saturdays draw bigger crowds than midweek aprt from perhasp the Cheltenam fixture. The Tuesday of R.Ascot draws only half the Sat crowd despite the card being higher class. The Derby figs suggest that the move from a Wed to a Sat has helped. On the otherhand, Sunday is not a negative for the Arc, and a lot of top Irish and European racing is also on a Sunday. I don't think this is a silver bullter and I can see the case for some high profile meetings continuing with mid-week starts (Goodwood, York) but on balance it might help give the week more focus.
Page 8 of 11  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com