We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
Presenting spam as steak won't make it steak.
The arrival of satellite television and particularly the internet signalled the onset of a fundamental weakening of racing's position in the nation's sporting psyche. There are now many more interesting and attractive alternatives to a badly run, corrupt, unintelligible, saturated, minority-interest hobby. The racing industry has yet to accept its new position at the lower end of the pecking order, but the approaching years of general austerity will see to that. |
|
By:
I've just skim-read BF's submissions re. the Consultation Process & the levy, the treatment of BF & its customers etc.
http://corporate.betfair.com/sitecore/content/B/Betfair/Homepage/media/press-releases/2010/~/media/Files/B/Betfair/pdf/HBLB-Consultation-Exercise-Betfair-Submission.pdf This is the equivalent of a nuclear strike in written form.Detailed, tightly-argued, clear, logical, thorough, powerful. You can't fail to be impressed if you look at it. The best brains have been at work on this, for sure. Racing's case as contained in its March submission pales by comparison. It must surely be 1/100 that any rulings will go against BF and in favour of Racing, or trad. bookmakers. |
|
By:
oops. That should be 100/1 against! not 1/100 on.
|
|
By:
Here's a tasty little morsel from Australia, as reported on RP site:
Betfair considering its options after losing a Federal Court appeal over the payment of rights fees to Racing NSW. The online betting exchange challenged Racing NSW's right to charge a fee of 1.5 per cent of turnover under the Race Fields legislation introduced in September 2008, arguing they should pay a percentage of gross revenue At a stroke of a pen, legislation might be introduced which would solve the funding crisis. 1.5% of gross t/o amounts to a lot of ££'s.If BF's margin is around 4% with £300m income then their gross is about £7.5 billion which would realize around £110m or twice their last reported net profit. Hey ho. Who would be worst affected, assuming that BF pass it on? All the low margin high t/o traders & bot operators, that's who. Position players would be hurt but not wiped out because they are not as price sensitive ad the traders etc.It would make life very difficult for the arbers, no doubt, too. Don't say it would never happen because it just might. |
|
By:
My last 2 postings represent opposite ends of the spectrum demonstrating the fog of uncertainty surrounding this issue. Just a thought, but do you think this news from NSW is factored into the BF share price?.
|
|
By:
Sandown, the OFT stated many years back that they wouldn't entertain a levy scheme that discriminated against exchanges and stipulated "e.g. a levy on turnover". The BHA and the bookmakers were making turnover noises at the time having seen how successful betfair had become and how it was affecting their margins (this was before Lord Haw-Haw's SP "reforms"). Of course the tory OFT might see things differently.
|
|
By:
Yeh, I remember now Feck. And of course, my deliberate mistake was to use total t/o not horseracing uk t/o which is what , 40 or 50% of total. Still would make a tasty sum.I'd never say never when it comes to Govts doing u-turns on anything.
|
|
By:
I read the bf levy submission a few weeks back and was surprised by the lack of response on the forum. It is a very well written document and was interesting even just for an understanding of other areas such as gambling via bf being non taxable in uk etc. I really can't see how bf will lose this.
This NSW 1.5% turnover idea just isn't workable on bf under the current structure if I have understood correctly (if it were to be passed directly to customers)? An example of absurdity would be backing a 1.01 shot as this would lose you money whether won or lost? Maybe I have misunderstood - my stumbling block being the definition of "turnover". Would be interesting to know how turnover would be calculated on a bet from both backer's and layer's perspective i.e., chargeable on liability? I am assuming "turnover" is meant at bet level because a "percentage of gross revenue" is a percentage taken from the commission bf take? |
|
By:
I agree Getafix with both your points but it is possible to get around the second point. The BF submissions have indeed been excellent and like you say they have not been mentioned on here.
The t/o issue could be got round by the use of "implied" figures which BF themselves have introduced as a concept when working out implied commission. Just work up from an assumed margin of say 4% and Bob's your uncle- an "implied" t/o figure. |
|
By:
When the first ever internet exchange (interbet) started up the C&E insisted they paid turnover tax on both backer and layer stakes. Bookmakers were charging 9% on stake at the time (tax+levy+fiddle) and interbet had to do the same. Obviously it never took off. Betfair & Flutter got very very lucky in that they started up when most bookmakers were moving offshore and a gp tax was already being touted as a replacement. Had they started up at any other time (and I think the timing was pure luck) exchanges would've been strangled at birth. Obviously the offshore option would've been there but, unlike high street bookmakers, they would've had no advertising outlets bar the internet. When you consider how long it took them to get beyond the fiver swap shop stage within the UK it's quite possible they would never have taken off offshore.
|
|
By:
In full agreement with the above posts, the Betfair submission made the BHA documents appear as though they had been thrown together during an extended lunchtime pub session.
A pure turnover tax would surely kill exchanges stone dead? |
|
By:
Here's evidence that changes to the current state of affairs are afoot and a little closer to home. From the RP site:
HORSE RACING IRELAND said on Friday it was "pleased" that the Irish Bookmakers' Association had aligned itself with the position it holds on betting tax. Chief economist Colm McCarthy has recommended that the Irish government doubles off-course betting tax to two per cent in next month's budget and applies it to all betting and gambling companies operating in Ireland, And just to make all those low margin-high voulme players on exchanges think twice about how easy it is to make money on exchanges without ever having to have an opinion, there's this tasty morsel : McCarthy's report also suggests a levy of one per cent "on both layer and bettor" on the betting exchanges. Of course, it could never happen here. Could it? ![]() |
|
By:
I would like to see Betfair move offshore.
|
|
By:
Muqbil
I would like to see Betfair move offshore. I will not be surprised if this loophole is closed very soon. |
|
By:
Could a levy tax on exchange users be the final nail in the coffin for the racing industry? If the bookies are to be believed that most money is now diverted through betfair a 1%+ raise on top of the betfair commission could move most liquidty providers to other sports where such a tax is not applicable. For many such a hike will make the sport unplayable - though they may just get replaced by even more efficient players? It will be interesting to see the effect of the NSW case if tax is forced...i.e., what it does to liquidity/volume traded here (I am assuming betfair covers these markets?). I may incorrectly believe that today's punters are more price oriented hence an exodus and thus death of the industry (assumption based on the huge client base of betfair - they must be here for a reason)?
|
|
By:
they must be here for a reason
obviously the ability to lay is a main reason for such a huge client base and advertising etc just thinking/questioning out loud. |
|
By:
The bookies would get control in such a scenario but not sure the money racing needs would be released as bookies will only take mug money, which is being eaten by fobts, virtual racing etc.
|
|
By:
Sandown When: 20 Nov 10 10:44 Muqbil
I would like to see Betfair move offshore. I will not be surprised if this loophole is closed very soon. What will be the legal basis for disallowing companies based offshore to accept bets on uk sporting events? It would make a mockery of the European free union. Going back to the Irish point, when considering the sad, sorry state of their economy, even compared to the uk, following the Irish lead might not be the brightest move in the world! |
|
By:
sandown
I will not be surprised if this loophole is closed very soon. why do you consider this a 'loophole'? You may not agree with European Law, but it is not a loophole. Their continued delay (years of moaning but no action)in challenging this, indicates to me that they know they will be on a loser! |
|
By:
A pure turnover tax would surely kill exchanges stone dead?
I don't think it would. I realise the 1% site isn't exactly a hive of activity, but there's plenty of pre-off action available. Of course, it may not be applicable to horse racing, which is the topic of this thread, but I don't think exchanges themselves suffer through it. |
|
By:
Consider the turnover in a typical midweek race with an odds on fav. Say one million matched (turned over). The actual positions taken of that million figure are a tiny fraction. Why should Betfair have to pay 1% of the matched figure as per the comical BHA submission? Makes no sense at all.
|
|
By:
Consider the turnover in a typical midweek race with an odds on fav. Say one million matched (turned over). The actual positions taken of that million figure are a tiny fraction. Why should Betfair have to pay 1% of the matched figure as per the comical BHA submission? Makes no sense at all.
What really makes no sense Muqbil is that betfair present them with these joke figures by including ping pong money and then doubling them. |
|
By:
Big blow to prizes as rates cut by up to 68%
By Howard Wright 4:49PM 24 NOV 2010 THE stark reality of the prize-money plight facing racecourses in 2011 has been laid bare with the publication of the Levy Board’s contribution to basic daily rates (BDR) for prize funds at each track, which reveal cuts of up to68 per cent from the original 2010 starting point. Source RP Now the reality begins to dawn. First the cutbacks, then the declining interest in the sport will accelerate. The optimists point to increased attendances and head-in-the-sand like ignore the diving betting turnover. Nevermind, the single day in October that will be Flat racing's Grand Finale will solve everything. Meanwhile, the key issues remain unadressed.It's like giving a starving man a whistle and a party balloon and telling him he will soon feel OK on the premise that if he looks happy he won't notice the hunger pains. |
|
By:
I don't buy the Racing Post so there is a good chance I have missed the annoucement of how expenses within the BHA will be slashed?
Surely they are now taking drastic measure to prune all the deadwood at the top of the BHA tree? The pension pot contributions alone add up to many many millions. As you point out the attendances are a total misnomer. The tracks are happy as they are making a few bob from their pop concerts with a few races tagged on the back. |
|
By:
Compare this from the RP......
THE Levy Board's three independent members have recommended that a target yield in the range of £75-80 million should be set for the annual levy scheme beginning next April, compared with a forecast of around £65m for the current scheme. The range sits between racing's claim for a levy increase to the region of £130-£150 million and an offer from bookmakers reported to be nearer to £50 million. RP ...... with this from The Times Racing reacted warmly to encouraging financial indicators yesterday, with news that the independent members of the Levy Board have recommended to government a levy yield of £75 to £80 million for next year — £20 million above the amount bookmakers were expecting to pay.The Times Online To my mind, £75-80m is an awful lot closer to £50m than it is to £150m. So, why did "Racing" react warmly to "encouraging financial indicators?" If falling short by approx 50% gives rise to "warmth" just how hot would they have been if the figure had been say £100m? Boiling point? And if they had seen a figure of £150m I presume they would have been not so much "over the moon" as "cinders." This is especially odd as the levy rate of 10% might become 9%. Curious spin, to say the least. When is a defeat a victory? When I say it is of course, said Humpty Dumpty Roy. |
|
By:
Todays news delivers the first part of all that racing has campaigned for Paul Roy RP p4
How deluded is this gimp - its a proposal you dumbwit - ie not decided |
|
By:
What a job that man has done. You just can't keep these city boys down. "Masters of the universe" and "the finest of international minds" just doesn't cover these guys (IMO).
|
|
By:
Maybe switching the stall numbering on right handed tracks will fix things and boost the falling levy?
|
|
By:
The "Law of Unintended Consequences" is a must for anyone who suffers from the delusion that they can, in some way, influence human behaviour, usually for their benefit. It's existence proves to be the nemesis of many over-inflated ego's.
Take Betfair. They introduced the PC because they felt that some winners were winning too much and it was therefore unfair for the rest who by definition would be losing too much or at too fast a rate. The extra income would help BF find new punters. Right. What happens? Those who are winning consistently say , OK I don't have anywhere else to go to for my methods, so I will continue hoping to become more effective and to find ways to diminish the PC. Those for whom it was intended to help, consistent losers that is, noticed that their incentive to continue on the journey to the Promised Land of consistent profit was given a nasty kick in the hollyhocks. Even if they managed to get there, the nasty BF were going to take 20% of their profits. OK, so I don't know that for sure, but it is a pretty obvious thing to conclude if you have an understanding of the Law of Unintended Consequences. It may not be the reason why BF's profits from horse racing are down as they say in their defence of their share price fall, but other causes. But I say, beware. Horse racing is the canary in the cage for other markets. It will show here first what will happen elsewhere. Those who want more money for horse racing should reflect on 50 years of adversarial argument with bookmakers who have always been said to be the reason why there is a less than fair levy. If the Law of UC was foremost in their minds, critics of BM's might have realised sooner that BM's would look elsewhere to find their profits, somewhere easier than horse racing. Lo and behold, that is what has happened. Nic Coward has resigned from the BHA, ironically over, to quote from today's Times "frustration over funding inadequacies." What a joke. His role in dealing with the crisis has been at best , poor. Mark Johnston, in his recent blog, clearly states the consequences of lower prize-money levels. He also says that the industry is too "betting-led." Yet where does he think that the funding increases might in future come from, other than from betting? He doesn't say. The point is that racing needs the bookmakers to be on-side but that the tail should not wag the dog. Otherwise, we get to another wonderful example of the Law of UC. Introduce more lower grade racing to boost the levy. Ignore the fact that more dross will act as a huge turn-off to racing fans and so reduce the amount of betting on the sport. It doesn't do much to attract newbies, either. |
|
By:
Sandown could i add to that the unintended consequences of RUK charging much more than setanta did for home TV coverage of their tracks; which did drastically reduce my betting on those tracks. And when RUK asked betfair for too much money, their video service ended, which i have little doubt reduced punter betting and levy intake yet again.
|
|
By:
Hazel
That's classic. It's like Govts who introduce the 50p in the £ plus tax rate which is intended to raise/increase the total income tax take but which in actual fact always decreases the total take, the evidence for which is substantial and from all over the world over many years. Nevermind the reality, how does it look! |
|
By:
Little comment followed the remarks made by William Haggas at the Gimcrack dinner when he said
"We have been raped for the past 50 years (by the bookmakers) and it is no surprise to note that the four best-financed racing associations in the world - Hong Kong, Australia, Japan and France - all have one thing in common: no off-course bookmakers. We have a fantastic industry and it is just a shame that the bookmakers do not seem to appreciate it." I have no special love for the big bookmakers personally. I have had my accounts closed and bets refused or offered insulting sums or prices just like many others. Their business practices are aimed at franchising the losing punter and disenfranchising the winning punter. But who could say that they are not abiding by the law? Racing needs the bookmakers in this country to not just contribute towards racing's costs but to actively promote racing to their customers to help reverse the declining interest in the sport.Does William Haggas, and others, really believe that the best way to create a strong working relationship and to maximise racing's income is to insult the other side? Haggas's language is way over the top but no doubt reflects the views of many who can be described as "horsemen" as well as more than a few racegoers and punters who would all like to see a Tote monopoly. Yet this is a "dead parrot" of an argument, one that is all wishful thinking without an ounce of realism. It demonstrates a reluctance or an inability to see the big picture. Worse than the emotive language used, is that the point that the statement is made on the back of a false premise, namely that it is the bookmakers who are responsible for the financial position in which racing finds itself. The levy was introduced 50 years ago to compensate the racing industry for loss of contribution via on-course and Tote as a result of the law which allowed off-course bookmakers to develop. To my mind, 10% of gross profits, as it became, is a fair settlement, in line with common practice in business as a commission rate. Of course, racing is dependent upon bookmaking to honestly and fairly declare the right figures but it is bound by law and the tax authorities to do so, so racing should have little fear of being short-changed. Basing the figure on future income increases the room for debate but overall, racing will get its 10%. I, therefore, see no case to argue that racing has been unfairly treated and to use terms like "rape" is wide of the mark and counter-productive. The fact is, that racing has grown fat and complacent. It has taken the dosh without questioning the source i.e. punters being sufficiently interested to bet on horse racing, and that racing therefore has a responsibility to offer a product that punters want to bet on.It has only itself to blame for going down the route of low-grade racing because bookmakers pushed it that way. Racing did not have to buy that argument but it or Savill to be precise, was short-sighted. It saw the money but did not see the consequences despite many pointing them out. Now bookmakers have found other products for punters to bet on, ones which do not involve a 10% levy. It would be surprising if they did not pursue that strategy. If Haggas and others want a thrive racing industry they must work with not against bookmakers in encouraging them to promote the sport. Perhaps whoever buys the Tote will provide some sort of answer but let us be realistic about what they will be able to achieve. Bookmakers are too big, too entrenched, too good at being commercial, for them to disappear. Betfair has not been able to take more than a 6 or &5 share of the market despite an innovative product so why should we expect a new Tote to do that much better? Co-operation is the way forward, not hostility. If Governments can recognise that they have no chance of winning the war in Afghanistan and will have to eventually deal with the Taliban, how much less of a compromise is it for racing and bookmaking to learn to work together? |
|
By:
why do all and sundry within the 'racing' industry jump on the 'blame the bookmakers' bandwagon, instead of facing up to their own inadequacies?
dont they realise they are in a unique position for any sport? I see the levy reducing to an insignificant amount, whereas if there was a will within racing, then a commercial deal could have been acheived years ago. Now, its too late - the bookmakers have the legal challenges necessary to pay virtually nothing So, nauseatingly, its going to get a whole lot worse |
|
By:
It's time for the Levy Board to start playing "hardball". Start threatening them with either increased payments or they will lobby the government for a Tote only off course system. It wouldn't be a hard sell as they can use the other Tote only countries (Aus, France etc) as good examples of just what revenue can be made with such a monopoly.
|
|
By:
Aussie
You've misunderstood the argument re BM's contributions and your solution is not possible given UK legislation re. trade restrictions,etc.Anyway, such a course is not within the Levy's remit - their role is to find the compromise between the two sides.In fact, the Levy Board is part of the problem in that it forces people into opposing camps. |
|
By:
|
|
By:
Shouldn't be too long before we hear of the Govt's settlement of the current levy dispute. It will be no surprise if the final figure is well below £100m, but whatever it is, it is relatively unimportant for the longterm.
The key isssue is the declining interest that punters have in betting on horses. Buried within the Gambling Commission's figures for the 12 months ending last March is the fact that on-course the number of bets was down 23%. Yep, that's TWENTY THREE percent. Off-course, the decline was 10%.Better but still severe. Perhaps the slight upturn reported for course attendances in the past year may show a slowing of that decline but I doubt it. With 2011 bringing all sorts of consequences resulting from the austerity measures to cut the structural UK deficit and with unemployment expected to rise by the best part of 1m and with inflation ready to rip, the threat to racing is that the figures can only get worse, not better.At 23% pa, the racecourse could see the number of bets fall to 45% of the 2009 total by 2012. More on-course bookmakers will give up the game, for sure. I wonder if part of the problem is that those in charge of racing seem to come mainly from financial or legal backgrounds (cf Roy, Coward, Savill)and have no experience of building businesses in commercial markets where understanding the needs of consumers is of paramount importance and tailoring their products/brands to meet those needs. A restructuring of the top of the game is fundamental to the development of a strategy that will work long-run. I have yet to see anyone argue with the mantra that "young" people must be targetted for the future. I strongly disagree with this conclusion if it means that is the only group targetted, but have yet to see any journalist raise the issue and to present the arguments for alternatives. |
|
By:
Did you see Tony Smurthwaite's column in the Racing Post this week, Sandown?
More incredible incompetence from 'racing' as the racecourses receive only around half of the media rights' payments from bookmakers, with the other half going to SIS and Turftv. How is this possible and why the **** do they keep signing long term deals with these leeches? |
|
By:
heynoodles
Only just read the article. Works out at about £70k per meeting paid by BM's or just about £11k per race or £22k per hour approx. which sounds like the going rate for sports OB but I can't be sure anymore. Still, I'm sure that it bears a strong relationship to the market rate for the job. I doubt if the TV companies make more than 15-20% profit on their 43% of the total i.e £5-7.5m . Don't suppose more than a third goes back to sharheholders so we're not talking about big numbers for 25% or so of total held by courses and 25% of total held by BM's.And its a basic requirement, isn't it, to show pictures. If the courses get 57% or about £61m that's about £1m per course on average. Sounds OK to me. Guess a lot of that goes into prize money and the figues show that racecourses wouldn't be making money (apart from Cheltenham, Ascot, York etc0 without their non-racing income streams. But it does highlight what BM's have been saying which is that you have to include media TV rights payments along with the Levy which means almost the same again. BM's are not getting away with it as racing keeps making out. At the receiving end, |
|
By:
Just had a look at the Racing For Change website http://www.racingforchange.co.uk.
It's a very professional site and the content shows that they have done their homework well and no doubt have been advised by specialist Brand agencies or Ad agencies. End of year report shows that they have had a number of real successes such as the A P McCoy campaign for Sports Personality. Included in their Target broup aims is the over 55 age group so that satisfies me although I still haven't seen anything related to any initiatives. Their success in getting broad agreement for an end of Flat season Grand Finale is also an achievement even if there are a few quibbles. they might be able to get it brought forward to a period when the ground might be less of a factor. As far as the main issue is concerned i.e the thread title, I don't see any real progress. They have used the right words re. the need to reverse the decline in interest in racing for punters but I don't get the feeling that they really understand the betting side too much even though there are bookmakers on the main board. Perhaps their views are not being listened to or maybe the BM's have a different agenda. Who knows? Without success in this area, thge rest will come to nought. They can increase attendances all they like but without a reversal of the trend in betting on horses the income for racing will continue to decline. I think it should be their main priority not just one item in a long wish-list of aims. I hope someone from RFC is reading this thread because they would have more of an idea or two to go on if they did. |