We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
Carefule MIB, don't go all sexist on us.
|
|
By:
just for u we can have a chippen dale as well if you like. ;)
plan B, take a laptop, Car battery and a dongle to the races! |
|
By:
Given the probability that there will be a considerable reduction in levy raised and consequently a significant reduction in contribution to prize money over the next few years (irrespective of levy board using reserves), it might be useful to consider the likely effects. let's call this the Domesday Scenario.
In the HG submission, they refer to the situation in Ireland where at the point of submission (Spring 20100 the number of current owners fell 9.5% on the year and new owners down 28%. At least 1500 jobs (possibly 2000) are thought to have been lost as a result. According to RTE Sport (Jan 19 2010) attendances fell by 11%, on-course betting turnover fell 21% (bm's on-course -27%)6% in horse population, and a 32% decline in bloodstock sales.All this in a country where racing gets special treatment. No doubt that the financial crisis has hit Ireland badly, but we can also expect to see comparable figures in the UK which would be pretty serious as the industry is maybe 4 or 5 times bigger.The British horseracing industry must be much larger than Ireland's so I guess that the numbers would be larger.There were 18,500 people employed in the UK industry in 2008 so could the losses amount to 5-6000 or more? It wouldn't be too long before owners would want to send their best horses overseas, that foreign owners/trainers would be less likely to travel here and the best horses would be exported (Harbinger the start?) Given the possibility that al this could come about quite quickly, don't think that we should be too complacent.This makes the reticence of the racing media to air this issue rather irresponsible. |
|
By:
It's ironic that just as the British horse racing industry, one that employs 18,000 odd people and is reckoned to have an economic impact of £3.4 billion, seems to be facing a financial crisis, the betting companies that benefit from its existence are reporting ever better profit figures. Indeed, Betfair's flotation has resurfaced again and with the valuation put at £1.5 billion employing just over 1200 people and delivering profits last year of £70m, is clearly in good heart.But it is nothing like as important as the one of the sports from which it benefits.
I am not a supporter of the principle that horse racing deserves to benefit and is entitled to a legal levy on BM's profits. It would be far healthier if horse racing made money out of gambling because of commercial reasons rather than legal reasons. In a report in today's Times (p44) we can see the reasons why this anomoly exists. According to Nielsen, the market researchers, there has been a 40% jump in the number of Brits visiting gambling sites in the past year representing an additional 3.2 million people which amounts to a total of 8m people. Looking at the profile, it appears that the rise comes from younger, .Yet men 35-49 nincreased by 119%.well-off middle class people (+98% earning over £50k pa)and 46% of all are women. Where is racin's plan to get to this market? It doen't exist because racing is leaving the marketing of its product to the bookmakers who, not unsurprisingly, are directing their customers towards low-risk, non-levy bearing prosucts and sports. The horseracing industry is shooting itself in the foot hanging onto the levy mechanism for its income and it is throwing away its competitive edge by handing the key strategic decisions to the bookmaking industry. Mark Johnston is wrong when he says that racing should stick to its knitting. It may follow its income stream through to the point of contact with its consumer. Do oil companies stick to just getting the oil out of the ground? In the reverse situation, do supermarkets just distribute manufactures products or do they influence the manufacture at the point of production. Racing may know a lot about horses but when it comes to business strategy it is nowhere. How much would Magnier want to run British (and Irish) racing I wonder? Paul Dixon is one of the players at the ROA and the HG and the Levy Board. Let's hear from him on this subject.Lets hear from the RP and the newspapers. Lets hear from ATR and Racing UK. Raise your game. |
|
By:
Where is racin's plan to get to this market? It doen't exist because racing is leaving the marketing of its product to the bookmakers who, not unsurprisingly, are directing their customers towards low-risk, non-levy bearing prosucts and sports.
Great summing up. Absolutely spot on, Sandown. At the moment Betfair promote racing prominently I would say but if the Levy come after them for more money who's to say BF won't just direct their customers to other products and avoid it (levy charge) wherever possible. Paul Dixon writes in the Thoroughbred Owner Breeder magazine every month... but it's the same old stuff, we must act now, something must be done, it's time to stand up and be counted etc etc and then he does nothing. |
|
By:
Magnier wouldnt be high on my list of potential saviours though. Unless he declares a new policy of not rushing horses off to stud at 3 for the good of the sport.
|
|
By:
sandown
It's ironic that just as the British horse racing industry, one that employs 18,000 odd people and is reckoned to have an economic impact of £3.4 billion, seems to be facing a financial crisis, the betting companies that benefit from its existence are reporting ever better profit figures. Indeed, Betfair's flotation has resurfaced again and with the valuation put at £1.5 billion employing just over 1200 people and delivering profits last year of £70m, is clearly in good heart.But it is nothing like as important as the one of the sports from which it benefits. Whilst I agree with nearly all your input on this thread, your 'comparisons' as above, are not logical If the betting industry had to rely 100% on horse racing, then your comparison is justified - but to compare a growing concern with 20 growing products and 1 dwindling product, then insinuate the growing concern is resposible for the dying products' employees and sport itself is short sighted in the least. a r |
|
By:
Perhaps I didn't make my point clearly enough. I'm not attaching any blame to betting companies for racing's demise but just saying that it is ironic that betting, which is dependent upon sports including racing, is thriving and generating the sort of income that is way beyond what racing could ever hope to achieve. It's much the same point as saying that the people with real opinions on the outcome of horse racing appear to be less successful betting-wise than the traders, with little or no knowledge of the sport, who need the position players to create the market in which they can make their money.
It's a funny old game as Greavsy used to say. |
|
By:
Well take a look at it this way
A stationer supplying independent bookmakers has a thriving business as he supplies stationery to schools, HMRC. etc etc now, you cannot compare the indies plight on the stationery supplier, because he is creating his wealth elsewhere Your comparisons are putting too much emphasis on betting companies being responsible for horse racings' plight, whereas in your last post you say you do not attach any blame to betting companies - then why the comparisons? |
|
By:
birch2
I don't attach BLAME to bookmakers for racing's plight because they are acting in what they see as their own best interests and they have no direct responsibility to racing or the people employed in racing but their actions have a CAUSAL effect on racing's finances. If racing is to improve its position it needs to have a DIRECT line of communication with the people who bet on racing. By doing so it will be acting in its own best interests. What I find ironic is that bookmakers make far more out of racing than do the people who take the risks - the owners - who whilst maybe doing it for their own entertainment, nevertheless are the reason why racing exists in the first place. My concern is not however principally for the owner's position but rather all those people who enjoy racing, enjoy betting on it, are employed within it and who are dependent in some way for their livlihood. |
|
By:
Why not do some market research on who these new people accessing the gambling websites are? Racing for Change did some of this, and it was one of the few non-ridiculous things their consultants came up with.
Some will be people wanting to chance their arm on a quick spin of the wheel, and racing is unlikely to be able to compete w/ other providers in this segment. Many will be people e.g. poker newbies who want to win based on skill. For these web-literate new gamblers, a racing-ownedbetting organization must put itself in the marketplace by offering better odds than its competition. It wd require a paradigm shift in mindset of massive proportions for this to happen, though, since breeders, trainers etc. customarily view winning gamblers as parasites who get something out of nothing. |
|
By:
It wd require a paradigm shift in mindset of massive proportions for this to happen, though, since breeders, trainers etc. customarily view winning gamblers as parasites who get something out of nothing.
I agree askari1, that the prevailing establishment mindset is that punters are below the salt, to be tolerated as a necessary evil,the staff below-stairs whose function is to aid those above-stairs to live the life of Reilly. Leadership is required and the industry isn't getting it. The organisation that should be providing it is the BHA whose boss is Nic Coward. How often have we heard from this man? Once even? He seems a man caught up in due process. His handling of the Findlay issue is a case in point. I sent him an email outling sthe existance of this thread and urged him to read it. Have I heard anything in reply, even an automated out-of-office acknowledgement? You know the answer. Evolution isn't working so I guess we must try to figure out how to start a revolution! |
|
By:
Nic Coward views bookmakers as agents for collecting the levy that is racing's rightful due. Racing offers punters an interest and a flutter, which is all they can hope for.
You are right--these people have no clue! |
|
By:
I've just been going over the BHA's website to see what they might have to say on this issue, if anything. My first impression was that the site itself works pretty well and does a good job in presenting racing to the public.
My first port of call was a sound interview with Nic Coward (recorded at York races in Aug) on the state of British racing. Ha ha, I thought. Now I'll get to hear something important. Nic C didn't disappoint. Apparently, the industry is in "rude health" with attendances rising. But there are financial difficutlies and these are laid squarely at the door of the exchanges and bookmakers who are getting away with underpayment to the levy. Something to do with loopholes and all that. There will have to be cutbacks in the racing programme (for finacial reasons - no mention of the important non-financial reason of too much racing). But it's not all bad news. The RFC initiative is making things happen and the key point that RFC is focussing on apparently is the quality of British racing. I must have missed that bit when reading RFC's proposals. That was it. So, I investigated further and there iis a Chief Executives blog. That must be where the issue will be discussed, I thought. Amazingly, there is only one entry and that's dated August 2009. On the ball, then. I thought that might just check out what the BHA is supposed to do. This is taken from the site under "Overview". It is the British Horseracing Authority’s role to ensure the continued health and successful development of the sport. As both the governing and regulatory body it is the British Horseracing Authority’s responsibility to: provide the most compelling and attractive racing in the world be seen as the world leader in raceday regulation ensure the highest standards for the sport and participants, on and away from the racecourse promote the best for the racehorse and represent and promote the sport and the industry. Throughout its work, the British Horseracing Authority will be: strong - providing leadership, taking tough decisions where they are needed independent - acting fairly and with integrity in the best interests of racing as a whole responsive - listening and consulting, making sure we understand issues challenging - asking hard questions, of ourselves and others open - having the confidence to explain what we think, and able to explain why dynamic - professional, innovative and focused, delivering a quality service All good corporate claptrap. Wonder what sort of score out of 10 most people would give them. Finally, I decided that the Chief Executive they appointed, Mr Nic Coward, must have the best available background to make things happen. So, I checked out his CV, listed on the site. i will leave you to draw your own conclusions as to whether he is the best qualified man for the job: Nic Coward - Chief Executive Nic Coward was appointed as Chief Executive-designate of the British Horseracing Authority in November 2006, and assumed the role of Chief Executive of both the British Horseracing Board and the Horseracing Regulatory Authority in February 2007. He had previously spent ten years with the FA, having joined in 1994 as its first solicitor from City Law firm Freshfields. He became Corporate and Legal Affairs Director, and was also joint Acting CEO for almost two years. He left the FA in 2004 to join public affairs consultancy AS Biss & Co, where he was Deputy Chairman and he advised major national and international sports bodies. He was also an adviser to the board of the FA Premier League, concentrating on regulatory and media rights issues. He has also been a non-executive director of the Sports Dispute Resolution Panel, Honorary Treasurer of the Central Council for Physical Recreation, and the first chair of the Sports Rights Owners Coalition. His family own and breed a small number of racehorses. If you want to see for yourslef, here's the link http://www.bha.org/inside_horseracing/about/directors.asp |
|
By:
PS
We don't want the thread removed so no abuse re:said Mr NC or the BHA |
|
By:
Well done, Matt Chapman, for raising in today's Weekender, an issue which relates to the biggest crisis facing horse racing in decades.
He writes about RFC's idea to introduce Premier grading of courses and meetings and raises an important possible negative consequences of doing that. However, it's not Premier racing that for me is the interesting point. Matt has interviewed Nick Attenborough, RFC PR Director and this is what he has to say about the reasons behing the idea. Note again there is no mention of trimming racing because it has become over-endowed so to speak. "Premier fixtures are to guide what one might see as the less knowledgeable or novice racegoer or fan." Matt chooses to argue that if that were the aim, then newbies should be directed towards low-class races rather than class races because you have more chance of winning.That may or not be right,but, what interests me is the objective in the first place. Apart from being rather patronising ( newbies can't work out what is the best racing on any given day apparently - as Matt says they only have to look at what's on terrestial TV for the answer), the objective assumes that this is where racing should be going to solve its problems. Is anyone on RFC numerate? I don't think that kind of analysis (what analysis?) would get them very far in any top consultancy or ad agency. We know that that around 17% of adults bet on racing in any given year. That's about 6m people. Let's divide that into say 2m regulars and 4m occasionals. The annual gross win of bookmakers from racing is around £1 billion so that's an average of £166 loss per punter. More likely its probabably at least twice that for the regulars so lets say its £320 pa for the regulars which would make the occasionals losing around £90 p.a. Now, to raise say an extra £10m levy each year you have to increase the gross win by £100m which works out at £17 extra loss p.a per average punter or say £34 extra from a regular and £9 from an occasional. Now let's look at newbies. How many do you need to achieve the same increase? Let's assume that they would be prepared to lose as much as an existing occasional punter, i.e. £90 p.a. That works out at over 110,000 new punters to be found. What do you think is more achievable? Getting an existing punter to lose another £34/9 depending on his usage, or find 111,000 new punters? Remember, we are in an environment where there is a wealth of betting alternatives and where very people have not had any exposure at all to horseracing.And we are in an economic mess with 25% cuts in public expendiure (therefore income and jobs) looming. To find an extra £50m from the levy, which is what is needed to just bridge the downturn, you need to find 5 times that number of newbies i.e. 555,000. Feasible or what? Do you think that the strategy (what strategy?) is correct? Answers on a postage stamp please. |
|
By:
PS
I don't think it would be unreasonable to assume that newbies would spend less than your average occasional punter. In which, if they spend half then you can double the number of newbies needed. Do you think RFC's ideas can find another 1 million punters new to the game? Dream on. |
|
By:
Sandown - I think working out the averages in the manner you have is somewhat misleading.
You may have median figures there but I would guess the true "average" figure would be massively skewed by a few thousand people who bet a phenominal amount at the top end. People who bet millions a year. It's all about attracting a few more of these - but that's far easier said than done. |
|
By:
klaksvik
I agree with you but finding the "high rollers" is a case of contacts, and where the bookmakers are in pole position.Ladbr okes show these players as a special profit centre. Can't imagine, can you, that the "high-rollers" are unaware of the relative betting opportunites. VC have been very successful as well in attracting the Far east biggies but as I understand it they all bet mainly on football. |
|
By:
Despite RFC's best intentions, if it is not managed properly, is in danger of alienating punters rather than bringing in new ones
Your last post clearly illustrates why the levy is dead, and no chance of revival Lobbying govt for new legislation to get betting companies to pay more will never happen, due to the bookies outlet with European rulings. The data/picture rights have been a fiasco from racing ownerships' point of view and there is little to see any change. The BHA leaders are vociferous by their silence and dont seem to have any idea where to turn A shrinking of the industry is inevitable until racing finds its level within the leisure sector. I also care very much about the sport, sandown and while I lay the blame at the door of the BHA, I dont blame their leaders entirely, because the seeds were sown well before their time. Nevertheless, their ongoing 'inaction' prompts me to ask just how can they draw their salary, while many friends of mine are in danger of losing their jobs |
|
By:
birch2
I agree with your post especially the bit about the leadership. Take a look at the published report of any major bm, say Lads or WilH ill. Look at how they go about their business, their planning, their l/t thinking. The competitive environment in which they operate has caused them to become very efficient, ruthless operators. The fact that they have a clear profit motive, can take important decisions and act on them, the experience and ability of the indivuduals involved, above all the single focus on what business they are in, and compare that with the fragmented structure of the horseracing industry, the fact that no dominant grouping exists, that the old class divisions still feel alive and well within it, that it attracts administrators/lawyers rather than businessmen. In a match you would have to price it up at 1.01 BM's and 1000.0 racing. I find it odd that the TV channels don't have a programme at least which concentrates on the business side of racing instead of continously running the same old stuff which is directed at the lowest common denominator of an audiance.As for the RP well they couln't run a serious paper if they tried. |
|
By:
I would like to see Sean Boyce be given such a programme. I think he could do a reasonable job. Otherwise, all we have is McCririck who is more concerned with himself than the industry.J A MaGrath could probably do one well. Pity Sir Peter O'Sullivan is too old.
|
|
By:
Newsflash
THE Tote is to move a step closer to being put up for sale, the Department for Culture, Media and Sport has announced, with the government set to invite bids for the state-run bookmaker. Gambling minister John Penrose: promised close liaison with racing In a written statement to parliament on Wednesday, minister for gambling John Penrose outlined plans to sell the Tote and launch an "open market process" this autumn. The government expected to be able to update parliament in the new year, Penrose said, and there would be close liaison with the Tote board and with racing interests. Nic Coward, chief executive of the BHA, said in response that the sport had been in "close dialogue" with the government about the Tote for months and that the process would have "the interests of racing at its heart". |
|
By:
BHA launches charter for 'fair return' from betting
BY RACINGPOST.COM STAFF 12:16PM 16 SEP 2010 THE BHA has introduced a new charter - billed as 'Racing United: Campaign for a Fair Levy' - and will seek the support of the public in a bid to secure the financial future of the sport following an 'unacceptable' fall in its funding. The initiative - launched jointly by the BHA, the Racecourse Association (RCA) and Horsemen's Group - is aimed to close loopholes inthe levy system that has seen funding for racing drop by more than a third in two years from £115m to £75m in 2010. Nic Coward: behind new campaign PICTURE: Edward Whitaker Nic Coward, chief executive of the BHA, said on Thursday: "The launch of this public campaign is the latest step in pressing home racing's case, a comprehensive case that is built on rigorous analysis, and which we have been advocating on behalf of the sport. "Our objective is to secure what is right for the future of the whole sport, and the campaign is intended to leave no-one in any doubt as to the strength of support for it across the whole of racing and its followers." Stephen Atkin, the chief executive of the RCA, has also thrown his weight behind the campaign. He said: "The levy, in its current form, is failing to deliver a fair return to horse racing because it has not kept pace with the modern betting market. It can and must be fixed. "We join together with our fellow stakeholders in the sport in calling the governmentand the Levy Board to act now to right this wrong." Anyone wishing to sign the petition can log onto www.racingunited.co.uk Yep - a petition should sort the problem out ![]() |
|
By:
Hopeless!
|
|
By:
Changing who own tote will have no change at all.
If anything, whoevere buys the tote will probably just sit and wait untill there is no levy at all then buy. Would you buy it with raceing as it currently stands?? Money down drain! |
|
By:
As with most of your threads, I wish I had time to read through it all, Sandown.
Having jumped in and read the last few posts, it is incredulous that racing would trust or back anything involving Nic Coward, he is a hopeless chancer. His latest initiative is another load of the same nonesense we have come to expect from the guy earning half a mill plus from racings coffers. Whilst trying to get the public 'onside', will he be explaining how the mechanism of the levy works? In so much as the more they lose the more levy racing receives. He might want to spell it out in clear terms they understand; "We want you to back our plea to close loopholes in the levy scheme. You may well ask what is the levy scheme? It is in the best interests of racing to make sure you (the general public who has absolutely no voice in racing at all) lose as much as possible to the bookmakers. To that end we have taken many draconian measure over the years. We tried a wholesale reduction in maximum handicap field size to 15. We try and randomise the effects of the draw ensuring many of your bets are a 'lucky dip'. We withhold important information to further hamper your attempts to win money off the bookmakers. This is certainly not an exhaustive list but you should agree we the BHA are doing a grand job of trying to tuck you; the general public up like kippers. So, will you get behind our bid to further tie ourselves in knots by backing our crazy ideas?" |
|
By:
'It has not kept pace with the modern betting market...'
The blighters! Their only solution is to hit the exchanges! They are being done up like a kipper by the bookmakers, they are dependent on the punter losing, they are commercially clueless and yet they use words with no reference or meaning in the current context like 'rigorous', 'fair', 'united', 'levy' and 'racing' to license what is basically a price-gouge.... Is there not someone who can see that the way to attract a public is by engaging it and giving it a chance to win? |
|
By:
same rhetoric - different day
until they explain HOW they intend to increase funding from bookmakers, they have no credence I really believe they want to prolong the current 'inaction' by continually spewing out words of nothingness, so as to draw their substantial salary and pensions, without accepting responsibility for the sports decline The bookies have got you Coward, hook line and sinker |
|
By:
Nothing ive seen or heard from them has made me want to sign the petition. Half the signatures so far appear to be BHA staff.
|
|
By:
noodles, the petition is about wanting to charge betfair more, so presumably commission goes up, the exchange becomes uncompetitive and racing goes back to raking it in from their partners, the bookies.
These people need a kick up the backside. Formula 1 is not funded by a levy. Why shd horse racing be? |
|
By:
Presumably, the aim of the petition is to increase leverage on the Government so that the current levy wrangle is settled favorably for racing. By showing that there is (massive) support for racing's plight (of being treated unfairly by the bookmakers), the levy board or if not them, the Govt Minister responsible, will be swayed by the popular support in favour and rule in favour of racing's demands.
Well, as a racegoer and a punter , I see nothing in the petition that relates to me; there are no reasons why I should sign,indeed there is no mention of the existance of a fan base which is losing out. Perhaps I am expected to work out for myself that what is good for racing is somehow good for me. Racing is a sport first and an entertainment second. But the entertainment aspects are vital to the business model. As a fan, when I go racing I expect to be entertained through the spectacle, the facilities , the sport itself and the opportunity to gamble. I pay twice, through entrance and course expenses and through gambling losses, which overall, is the net position. Surely, my needs should get a mention. When they do, I will sign a petition. Until then, I won't. |
|
By:
Describing the levy as "flawed" and not "a commercial vehicle", Patrick Nixon, the chief executive ofthe ABB, the leading trade organisation for British betting operators, said the government should set a date for the end of the arrangement so discussions could begin over a replacement. RP 17/9/10 p2 quoting Patrick Nixon,Association of British Bookmakers
"we are committed to the suitable replacement of the levy with a creation of a modern market, in which betting operators wanting to offer a bet must enter into enforceable contracts for the right to do so" RP 17/9/10 p2 quoting Racing United document Looks like both sides want to replace the levy. What chance agreement can be achieved on what that might be? |
|
By:
There needs to be a facebook group or something where 'the public' who are being targetted by this latest initiative can learn exactly how they are being tucked up by the BHA.
|
|
By:
askari not sure if theyre going to charge betfair more or go after individual users. Do BF have to supply them details of their customers accounts - doesnt seem right really?
Will Mr Roy be declaring his own betting accounts for the year? And his friend Mr Tabor? They landed a touch earlier this season. They shd try working with betfair instead of treating them like the enemy. |
|
By:
*try to charge
|
|
By:
Just looked at Sean Boyce's blog and what sense he talks. At last , a racing commentator who knows what he is talking about.In his latest post he comments on Racing United's pathetically misjudged attempt to get the public behind racing's plea for more handouts via the levy.He must have read this thread because what he says about the future for racing might be a summary of the posts on here.
He concludes; A genuinely united front for Racing would have the modern punter right at the heart of its strategy. Every tactic and objective would be informed by the desire to bring that punter the product that he wants. A Racing United that put the punter first and that embraced technological change and opportunity, that was willing to sever old ties and build new ones, that was willing to look forwards rather than backwards would get my vote. And what’s more, as a punter, I’d sign that sort of charter. Go to http://boyciesbettingblog.com/betting-news/racing-united-but-facing-backwards.php to read the whole post. One week on and there are 164 signatures so far, most from the BHA or others directly involved with the industry. The general public is clearly under-whelmed. |
|
By:
There are a couple of fundamental issues which need to be addressed in more depth and with some sound reasoning because these will have an impact on the funding and especially on exchange players.
Both issues are referred to as loopholes. The first, and perhaps simplest to argue against, is the notion that bets on overseas horseracing should be leviable.If there is any justification for a levy it is the premise that the British horseracing industry needs "protecting" because of its economic importance, and that it deserves a cut of the take made by betting concerns. Now, it surely is stretching things to argue that a race that takes place in say Australia, the Melbourne Cup say, has any bearing on the UK racing industry and therefore any British citizen betting on that race through a British bookmaker should have 10% of their losses (the gross win )leviable.If any tax or levy is due it surely would be to the Australian Government and Australian racing, not to British racing. That line of argument is surely clear cut. The second issue, I am not so sure about. This is the argument that layers on exchanges should be levied on their winnings. I think the mistake that the racing industry is making is to use the term "layers" which only illustrates their ignorance of how betting on exchanges works. I know how they have got to this; they are looking at licenced bookmakers hedging (laying & backing) onto exchanges and making the leap that as a result leviable income is being siphoned off. Obviously, a licenced bookmaker has to record these transactions as part his book and then those profits (or those losses) would be part and parcel of his return on the race. His gross win is not affected. There is no seepage, in truth. But, now take the aspect that could affect many on here, and that is that regular net winners are making a living out of bets on horseracing and not making any contribution to the levy on those winnings (even though they pay commission and PC to BF who in turn pay the levy on their gross take). Shouldn't these "players" be treated as de facto businesses? The precedent that everyone refers to when the issue of punters not being taxed on their winnings is raised, is the 1920's judgement that gamblers are most likely to lose and the costs of raising revenue on the losers would exceed the revenue gained. This judgement is now out-dated. It was made at a time when the bookmakers, with the help of the mathematics of over-round, and a high one at that, were bound to win overall and the punters were bound to lose. Generally speaking, that is still the case. The reason that bookmakers continue to make huge profits (£3-4 billion in total take , £1 billion on horseracing)is mathematics. 2% over round per runner gives you them an unsurmountable edge over the punter. Whilst the overound is around 101-102% on exchange markets, and clearly at a level that makes it impossible to make a profit from making a book in the traditional sense, it is clear from practice that it is sufficient for traders with high-power computers and automatic trading, to consistently rack up profits. These robots find the inefficiencies in the market, take advantage of them in milli-seconds, and are off and away . They are making money because there is a huge amount of bets placed manually still, and the fastest compters can easily beat any manual player on fast trading. The amounts of profit that many on the forum claim to be making is evidence that regular profits are being made, especially in the IR markets where the speed of the programmes and technological advantages provides an edge that,albeit on large "churn", creates large profits. The data relating to these individuals is available to both the levy and to the revenue authorities. Betfair have opened the door to this argument through the introduction of the PC which more or less endorses the claim that these people exist. I can foresee that this might be the first time that BF loses an argument. |
|
By:
This thread continues to amaze me and I do feel like either I'm missing the point entirely, or the Levy guys are utterly clueless. Maybe there's an element of both.
Why would racing, which it seems everyone agrees is in decline (unless asked in public, in which case it's booming of course), want to charge any of their remaining customers even more money? Surely the result of this isn't a bigger income, it's just fewer customers. I'd imagine that anyone who is not an insider that is smart enough to make a consistent profit "laying" horses (God these people are dumb if they don't realise that backing and laying is the same thing) is smart enough to move to any one of a zillion other markets where they don't have to give a bunch of overpaid snooty gits a chunk of their winnings for the privelege of watching a generally turgid sport. (This is not wishing to insult racing fans, I get the impression that even many racing fans would rather not watch races with completely random hopeless horses in them... other than for betting purposes of course.) Am I entirely missing the point, or are the Levy Board so arrogant and out of touch that they can't realise that they're in a highly competetive marketplace and have been for 10-20 years now. Not only that, but they're attacking that marketplace with a sub-par product and ridiculous rules that serve only to put new customers off ... and incredibly seemingly put off existing customers as well. That's a hard double to land! |
|
By:
Lori
Racing is run by traditionalists on behalf of traditionalists. The reasoning is thus: Owners fund the sport, their motivation is to enjoy the thrills of ownership and to win races. They do not own for the sake of entertaining the public and certainly not for the purposes of betting by others although many do like to bet themselves and some do so to help fund their horses costs. Owners pay the bills and trainers responsibilty is towards their owners. It isn' that long ago that the prevailing view was that the public doesn't pay the bills and is therefore not entitled to know anything or be told anything about the horses or their condition. That is for the owners to know and for the others to find out. Many in racing still hold to this view. The role of the public is to help defray the costs of ownership through a levy which helps to boost prizemoney. That's it - there is no concern for the views of the public although because courses must attract racegoers, they show some interest in what the public wants. The modern view that racing is part of the entertainment business and is reliant on the gambling market and consequently should understand the needs and wants of the racegoer/punter is paid lip-service to really. Perhaps some journalists can see the bigger picture but there aren't many of them. I don''t suppose for one moment that if you asked trainers, administrators etc if they see that increasing the take from punters is counter-productive and tantamount to shooting themselves in the foot, that they would ever agree or even recognise the argument. I can't agree with your point that racing is "turgid" - everyone to their own taste - and the levy Board is constrained by the its legal status to act as mediator between racing and bookmakingso I don'tt think its them being arrogant that is the problem. if the day arrives when no-ore trilbies are seen may be the day that the racing world might see outside its current myopic view. |