Cricket
**The Ashes 2013 3rd Test 01-05 August Old Trafford**
|
By:
Nothing on hotspot = not out
Simple as that. |
|
By:
Nothing on snicko or hotspot , dear oh dear
|
|
By:
Can the umpires use the TV audio as part of a decision? If not, then yeah I suppose that is not out
|
|
By:
DREADFUL
|
|
By:
No snicko. Bat hit pad. Ball looked to miss by 3 inches.
How in fcuk these gooses get away with this rort that they have for 3 test matches now is woeful. |
|
By:
India's stand now is vinidicated..have seen enough of this DRS non sense..this is ridiculous decision
|
|
By:
Swann is going to be lethal on this pitch this afto!
|
|
By:
Who is the idiotic 3rd umpire this match?
|
|
By:
STILL FANCY A DRAW GUYS??
|
|
By:
Dharmasena's either bent, blind or just a stupid dumb feck.
Take your pick. |
|
By:
I vote for
"just a stupid dumb feck." |
|
By:
|
|
By:
wot is wrong with these umpires ? cant keep happening
|
|
By:
are these ****g umpires stupid or what
|
|
By:
|
|
By:
not out, but the message is swann is going to take wickets on this
|
|
By:
They can use audio, not snicko. He needs compelling evidence to overturn it. When he heard a noise as the ball passes the bat, then he's right to stick with the on-field umpire's decision. Pundits getting their knickers in a twist over nothing. Great to hear Warne bleating.
|
|
By:
watson will be sitting in the hutch absolutely furious that he didn't get to waste that appeal.
|
|
By:
Just a shocking decision. Wasn't even close, no noise - just unbelievable and he should be stood down for being unfit for purpose.
|
|
By:
did sky show the snicko? I missed it
|
|
By:
May be the same result Songs, but there would be less of an outcry over a dodgy decision. Human error can be forgiven easier.
|
|
By:
why out ?
  |
|
By:
I think that there was a faint mark on hotspot, but more to the point, there were two clear noises. Shane Warne is deaf, as is Botham.
I think that the 3rd Ump arrived at the correct decision. |
|
By:
Yes , nothing . Bat hit pad before the ball .
He has clearly missed it |
|
By:
why out ?
|
|
By:
|
|
By:
Well whats the point for DRS then you ass...if the DRS decision is a howler..dumbffs
|
|
By:
If you involve snicko, most of these bad decisions go away.
|
|
By:
"he should be stood down for being unfit for purpose"
Agreed |
|
By:
Snicko showed NOTHING for a second noise!
|
|
By:
NOTHING ON SNICKO .
|
|
By:
yet again, england with umpires on there side.... quite embarrassing really
|
|
By:
Aussies getting the rub of the green again with the umpires it will be argued.
|
|
By:
pathetic decision
|
|
By:
P1ss poor umpiring all round
|
|
By:
|
|
By:
|
|
By:
This is embarrassing as an English fan you see all such ridiculous decisions which take the sheen away from the win
|
|
By:
There were 2 noises. Warne & Beefy have managed to ignore the 2nd one as the ball passed the bat.
|
