Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 183 comments are related to the topic:
Hillsborough decisions 11:00am tomorrow..

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 5 of 5  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 183
By:
dustybin
When: 28 Apr 16 14:24
duckenfield over egged the flan with what now looks like deciet and got found out, perhaps for that alone he deserves what he will potentially get....but to think that forever more everyone gets force a verdict that the fans were innocent angels sticks in the craw a little.
By:
breadnbutter
When: 28 Apr 16 14:53
Taylor report highlighted the cause as "Police failings " in 1990 ,that was a long time ago.

This should have been dealt with and be over ,to me i think the police are not happy taking the blame and its went round the houses for a long time including a long term  labour goverment.

The FA seem to have been allowed to engineer a  distance from events ,appear bombproof imo .
By:
jamesdean
When: 28 Apr 16 15:13
Hindsight is a wonderful thing but the police had a care of duty on the day and they knew this before the accident.

Here's a question. If the police themselves never thought they were to blame, why lie afterwards?

Lies usually follow trying to hide guilt not innocence. They knew it was their fault

To blame the fans when it was the police' own negligence and them who had the care of duty was disgraceful
By:
dustybin
When: 28 Apr 16 15:55
Its very difficult to be both nanny and punisher of wrong at the same time, especially when the police couldnt know which ones might be the ones causing the trouble.

I think the police exaggerated established knowledge just to bring it to a swift conclusion, but it simply inflamed it and dragged it out.

A question that crosses my mind is to what extent can they say the turnstyles were the blame of the congestion.
There were 10100 tickets sold. Were those turnstyles deemed adequate for that number sold?
If a greater number of people than 10100 turn up.....who is to blame, and what could be done about it?
By:
Wesdag
When: 28 Apr 16 16:04
The inadequate response of the police to the crush and their subsequent covering up of those failings have served to deflect attention away from events leading up to the crush itself.

If the ground was virtually full at kick off, why were there thousands of fans still outside?

To say the events outside the ground had nothing at all to do with the decision to open the gates is nonsensical, imo.
By:
dustybin
When: 28 Apr 16 16:06
I suppose stop letting people pay in, would be the answer to my own question, but that itself becomes a disaster, how do you turn away people without tickets while accepting ticketed fans when the whole area is contested due to the fans pushing against the turnstyles.
By:
dustybin
When: 28 Apr 16 16:06
congested
By:
dustybin
When: 28 Apr 16 16:10
thats right wesdag
Its not even a case of being anti fans or their families, its about the verdict that is questionable.
Had they said, as the taylor report did, that there were areas, for eg. 'groups of tickless fans' attempting to get in for free, or that some were drunk and pushing etc, then I think everyone would accept the findings.
To say no blame at all is on the fans is absurd.
By:
ebulGery
When: 28 Apr 16 16:25
scandanavian_haven  • April 27, 2016 10:29 PM BST 


Tragically no one thought what would happen if these became overcrowded.

Pretty strange you're trolling this kind of topic ebul, you said this earlier and then backtracked and now saying again, and I told you earlier, thousands of fans who had been in that end in many previous games for years prior said it was a deathtrap!


I have not backtracked..where?

I am joining in a discussion....I give my opinion that is all, rather too often I admitBlush, but I live a sad life...I do not troll anyone.

Somebody asked why the fences...answer HOOLIGANISM which is true.
There should have been police posted to monitor the pens for overcrowding but sadly they called away to deal with the near riot at the front gate.

When David Duckenfield made his decision to let in all fans regardless whether they ha a ticket or not, he was under extreme pressure, due
to the near riot going at the turn styles. Not everybody makes the right decision under pressure.

As the officer in charge at the time he should have accepted responsibility for his failure to protect fans at the time and resigned.
Regretfully he did not, and it was put all on Liverpool fans..wrongly.

I think we have the right verdict now but things are never black and white in reality.
So of course ticketless Liverpool fans contributed to this. When Duckenfild made his fateful decision to open the exit gate he was trying to stop a riot at the front gate.

I am saying all this because I believe it, other people make their own choices.

I agree Dusty, the ticketless fans were a contributory factor, but I am afraid Duckenfield was in charge, he is paid to take the blame.
He made wrong decision under pressure, pity he did not order the turn styles to be locked, would have been a riot but saved lives.
Life is easy in hindsight
By:
Wesdag
When: 28 Apr 16 16:27
All that has been conveniently glossed over in the wave of rightful emotion and outrage of the police's handling of the aftermath of this tragedy.
By:
jamesdean
When: 28 Apr 16 16:27
I was going to highlight some key points below but can't be arsed. It's worth a read and puts an end to any doubt who was to blame imo


Hillsborough verdict: The final reckoning for David Duckenfield – the match commander who tried to blame the fans
The Independent
The Independent
Ian Herbert
2 days ago
SHARE
TWEET
SHARE
EMAIL
Notorious criminal given an Asbo at just 12-years-old jailed for machete raid…
Brits facing death by firing squad could be executed 'within weeks'

© Provided by Independent Print Limited There were moments across the course of the inquests when the crux of the matter for the families of those Liverpool fans who died – the horrific ineptitude of match commander David Duckenfield – descended into farce.

One of the witnesses whose testimony supported the view that the officer had failed catastrophically was retired chief inspector Frank Brayford who claimed Duckenfield had not even attended a pre-match briefing meeting on March 22, 1989. Brayford played the clown in court and stood up at one moment, leading the coroner to tell him he did not need to.

“I’m just going to give my bum a rest,” he said, to widespread mirth.

The black humour belonged to those who have been watching Duckenfield being questioned about this for years. When a civil prosecution was brought against him in 2000, the jury was hung. But it became clear midway through this two-year process that the past was catching up with him.

But Duckenfield’s week of testimony, from March 9 last year, was the most intense period of the entire inquest though and it narrowed down to an extraordinary 90 minutes of cross examination from Paul Greaney QC who, producing the documents that no one else had found.

He thus cornered Duckenfield, reducing to shreds both him and his claim that what he had done on day in question – allowing the exit gate C to be opened without consideration of how hundreds would funnel through it into a crush – were based on his inexperience and ignorance of the geography of the ground, for which there could be a shared responsibility.

Two pieces of evidence suggested that Duckenfield had the knowledge to foretell precisely how disastrous his actions might be. The first was an obscure item from Lord Justice Taylor’s 1990 Hillsborough report, at which Duckenfield declared he had attended a match when Millwall visited the ground which had produce the same cramming in the central pens where Liverpool’s fans died.

The second turned up the fine detail of a Duckenfield letter to his own Chief Constable, suggesting he had also experienced the same crush in 1979.
image © Provided by Independent Print Limited image

He knew, Greaney put it to him. There could be no sanctity or shared responsibility in the idea that he ought to have been helped to be better prepared for that day. There could only be an acceptance that he had been in a complete state of panic and had frozen. Duckenfield’s world diminished during the extraordinary 90-minute exchange.

“Freezing is a physical action, is it not, or am I mistaken?” Duckenfield said, attempting to rally.

“What I am describing, just so you are in no doubt, is this:” the barrister said. “To use a 19th century expression, although one that is rather evocative, you bottled it, you panicked, and you failed to take the action that you knew needed to be taken to avoid consequences that you had foreseen. Now, does that describe your state at the time?”

“I disagree with you, sir,” said Duckenfield

“Why?” Greaney asked.

hillsborough-disaster-5.jpg © Provided by Independent Print Limited hillsborough-disaster-5.jpg “Because that's my view,” Duckenfield replied.

“Why is it your view?” asked Greaney.

“Because it is my view, and there can be no other view than mine,” Duckenfield said.

“That's your position, is it?” Greaney asked.

“It is, sir,” the former officer replied.

A mere five minutes had elapsed before Greaney came at the subject again, with a different conclusion this time.
hillsborough-disaster-2.jpg © Provided by Independent Print Limited hillsborough-disaster-2.jpg

“Mr Duckenfield, you know what was in your mind, and I will ask you just one last time: will you accept that, in fact, you froze?” asked Greaney.

“Yes, sir,” replied Duckenfield.

From that moment on, the prospect of the match commander being found to have unlawfully killed the 96 – the hugely anticipated 6th question of the 14 the jury was asked to consider and the only one on which they were not unanimous - was suddenly a possibility. The jury had to be satisfied that Duckenfield knew there was a risk of death when he fatefully opened exit gate C. Greaney established that.

It was a deeply unattractive picture of Duckenfield that the jury was presented with. He began his testimony as an upright, broad-backed, proud Yorkshireman, sipping water at first and then orange juice; defining the scope of his answers and admitting he had cynically blamed supporters for forcing open the gate. (“The lie,” as the Hillsborough Independent Panel report’s author Professor Phil Scraton describes it went all around the world. It was immediately reported by BBC match commentator John Motson and evening news reader Moira Stuart.)

hillsborough-disaster-2.jpg © Provided by Independent Print Limited hillsborough-disaster-2.jpg Supporters are crushed against the barrier as disaster strikes before the FA Cup semi-final match between Liverpool and Nottingham Forest played at the Hillsborough Stadium in Sheffield, 1989

But a more pernicious characterisation of Duckenfield surfaced in the testimony of others. He was in charge of the game because of the side-lining of the late Brian Mole, an ex-Chief Superintendent who paid the price for a prank in which a young officer was set upon by fellow officers. The balance of evidence suggested that Duckenfield did attend the March 22 meeting.

But the past two years have also revealed that having been asked to command the match Duckenfield asked Mole, who had always been hands-on, to give him time and advice, only to find the officer, affronted by his own demotion, unwilling.

Rather than tackle this problem by attending the stadium and developing an understanding, Duckenfield merely retreated to his office, sulking and smarting. The late Mr Mole’s ex-wife, Margaret Topley, said that Mr Mole had indicated through intermediaries that he would work for Duckenfield at the semi-final but that he had turned the offer down.

Duckenfield’s performance on the day was subsequently disastrous. Martin ‘Mac’ McLoughlin was present at the 12.30pm pre-match briefing which Duckenfield addressed – garrulously as McLoughlin recalls. “We’ve catered for every eventuality,” Duckenfield told them. Eyes rolled. “The gaffer liked the sound of his own voice,” McLoughlin remembers. His whereabouts immediately after that are a mystery. He was seemingly missing between 11am and 1pm, the inquest has heard. No-one can account for what he did between that time.

His admission that he had deceitfully blamed supporters pre-empted what he might have known was coming anyway. Retired ciircuit judge and former Liverpool FC solicitor Tony Ensor described meeting Duckenfield and representatives of Nottingham Forest, Sheffield Wednesday at 3.30pm on the day of the disaster and remembered Duckenfield saying fans had forced the gate into the ground. Duckenfield had told them "an untruth," he said.

Under the rules governing inquests, Duckenfield could not be named today when the jury found that the 96 had been unlawfully killed. But the evidence of the past two years has rendered it indisputable that only one individual would carry the responsibility for such a finding. It was taken 27 years and the longest inquest in British criminal history but one word from the jury forewoman was enough.

Sir John Goldring asked her: “Are you satisfied, so that you are sure, that those who died in the Disaster were unlawfully killed?” She said: “Yes.”
By:
ebulGery
When: 28 Apr 16 16:27
true
By:
Wesdag
When: 28 Apr 16 16:28
^ that was to dusty
By:
ebulGery
When: 28 Apr 16 16:33
and mine was to you Wesdag.

It that is true jamesdean, Duckenfieled is not coming well outof this at all.

I have some understanding for Duckenfield's mistake, but he should never have tried to deny it.

I have said I agree with verdict.
By:
annie.
When: 28 Apr 16 21:26
I was working in a head office racing room at the time taking credit bets, I was also secretary to the racing manager, so I saw it as it happened, I will never forget it.
By:
annie.
When: 28 Apr 16 21:30
I must come to ebulGery's defence. 

He has, even though he is a self confessed misogynist, always been kind to me.  To call him a troll and to liken him to vermin is beyond the pale.
By:
ebulGery
When: 28 Apr 16 21:58
ta annie, you a very nice personHappy

These are the things I have to put with up in life it is so unfairCry

Laugh
By:
dustybin
When: 29 Apr 16 10:13
I read yesterday that I think it was either family members or people associated with the families are now barking down comments made on some retired police websites which said retired policemen and women can be proud of the work they had done in their careers.
I find it even more difficult to believe that  people are in a position to say the retired police didn't do anything they can be proud of.

I have had a number of friends tell me similar experiences of what they saw outside the ground that day.
Some were in high rise flats near the ground and others on the hills overlooking it and they all said the same, that all you could hear was the sound of sirens rushing to and from the ground (and that it almost looked biblical from a distance the way the sun rays looked to be focusing on hillsborough on a hot day)

People have long forgotten the good work that was done through all the accusations.

Socrates said not to avenge injustice for damnation of ones soul.
Makes you wonder.....
By:
ebulGery
When: 29 Apr 16 14:10
Everything has to be black and white now dusty

The public want a clear arrow pointing at who is the good guy and who is the bad guy

anything more complicated than that they don't want to know

No retired policeman or policewomen has to be ashamed of anything, unless they did something bad themselves.


On the police side there is only one man at fault here David Duckenfield. Who should have admitted his mistake at the time.'

The police should have given him up at the time and not tried to shield him...but people do shield their own out of mistaken loyalty.

I have severe doubts Liverpool supporters were behaving like a Sunday School outing so the words entirely blameless would not be my description.

But it is right David Duckenfield carries the can, that is what he was paid for.
By:
dustybin
When: 29 Apr 16 14:27
I dont think Ive seen anyone defend duckenfield other than say he made mistakes, but on covering up for it nobody defends him.

If you take away all malevolent intent and just look at the numbers I cant see how they can arrive at a verdict of saying fans didnt have an impact.
Ive looked through the taylor report again, and what I had forgotten was that the 10100 figure of tickets sold was actually the maximum capacity for the standing region for away fans (which was debatable even before the disaster)
That meant the game was sold out. There is not ambivalence to that fact. The fact people without tickets were admitted into the ground can be blamed at a number of people, but the very fact anyone without a ticket therefore contributed to the extent of the disaster whether well meaning or not.
Look at the pictures around kick off.
The north west quarter had a capacity of 2900, there are way more than that just in that section. All pens were packed, not just those behind the goal, and thats discounting anyone still not in the ground by 10 minutes to kick off.
This all adds up to a figure well and above 10100. I wouldnt like to guess by how many more, perhaps somebody knows, but that figure is the number of fans who didnt have tickets.
That has to be a factor, it maybe that fewer people died had fewer ticketless fans turned up.
That doesnt mean those fans were acting in a detriment manner, but it still contributed.
By:
Wesdag
When: 29 Apr 16 15:08
If you take away all malevolent intent and just look at the numbers I cant see how they can arrive at a verdict of saying fans didnt have an impact.

Spot on.
Defies all logic to suggest otherwise.
If there was nobody left outside at 3pm, would the gates have been opened?
Of course not.
By:
dustybin
When: 29 Apr 16 15:32
Some of the stuff in the taylor report is obviously now seen as inaccurate for one reason or another.
But does anyone know whether its still true that horses were found to have cigarette burn marks on their arse out of interest?
By:
dustybin
When: 29 Apr 16 16:24
*pen 1 wasnt as rammed as it first looked on images I saw, theres still plenty over 10100 in the standing sections though
By:
Jack Hacksaw
When: 16 May 16 18:43
But does anyone know whether its still true that horses were found to have cigarette burn marks on their arse out of interest?

If they didn't at the time, they would have had shortly afterwards.
Page 5 of 5  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com