We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
salmon spray • April 26, 2016 10:26 PM BST
It was hardly something I had ANY expertise in but I had noticed years before there was a potential problem with the Leppings Lane end. For those who didn't know it in those days you entered the grounds through a fairly wide entrance then as you approached the turnstiles the corridor narrowed a fair bit. The ground was built before WW1 and was not the only one that had those sort of design problems. Oddly Wednesday used to pack bigger crowds in for local derbies without any problems for decades. The difficulties started with semi-finals in the 80s. Football fans,not just Liverpool,became more and more unruly from the late 60s and it came to a peak in the 80s. Anybody who knew anything about football and lived through that period can hardly dispute that.......spot on thats how i remember it. |
|
By:
question is how did football fans go from been well behaved in the early 60s to unruly bunch in 20 years.
|
|
By:
It is right Ch Supt David Duckenfield takes the blame
He made the mistake of opening the exit gate and had the overall responsible for keeping fans safe which he failed in. But there is another reality here, I assume the caged area for Liverpool fans was large enough for all those who paid for their ticket. So the excess which caused this tragedy must have been caused by Liverpool fans who did not buy a ticket. Which makes them partly morally responsible for this tragedy surely????????? I don't think David Duckenfield intended to murder Liverpool fans, he made a mistake under extreme pressure from Liverpool fans who had not bought a tickets There were other failings here, not enough turn styles for instance. Lessons have been learned painfully, after 30 years we need closure. In My Opinion. |
|
By:
let it rest, ffs
|
|
By:
Lots of young girls went to football matches on their own with friends in the 70s and 80s WTF are you talking about Denman ?
I went to football matches on my own when I was 12 onwards in the 70s .. The opened exit gate led to a tunnel marked "Standing", which led directly to the two already overcrowded enclosures. In previous years the tunnel had been closed off by police when the two central pens were full; however, on this occasion the tunnel was unmanned>>>>That is why the deaths and carnage occurred ,it was the down to the police ,had they put a some officers at each Full terrace entrance pointing to either end terrace the fans would have followed their directions .. As for your Comments regarding The Bog Side massacre ,I cannot even be bothered to Reply ,but will say the word Pathetic Comes to Mind ![]() |
|
By:
I've never stood on the leppings lane end (why would I?) but regularly stood on the kop when terraces were there and i can barely recall seeing young females (whether accompanied or not). It wasn't the place for them.
Surges were common and no quarter could have been given even had they wanted to. Ebul makes a good point that I'd never dwelled on that much. Surely pre ticket sales are known? I remember the Liverpool fans decrying the fact that forest got the kop that day saying how could Liverpool be given the away end? Well the number of pre sold tickets to matches might be the reason then, I don't know how big a problem it was for Liverpool fans arriving at matches without tickets was but it's been admitted to have been common. Forest were also a big side then and pretty local, it's just arrogance of the Liverpool support that has been seen numerous times. There were 73,000 at that ground for a cup game one year without incident, and the Boxing Day massacre had 49,000 all Sheffield rivalry. |
|
By:
ebul there was plenty of room in stand behind the goal but the space was at the sides
and nobody to direct folk to the space, and natural way to proceed at stadium was forward and into the middle, there are numerous books including "fever pitch" where people give their own experiences of this ground |
|
By:
It is widely reported that Duckenfield's mistake was opening the gate and he should face criminal charges for that.
This was not a mistake at all and a very simplified response by the media - in hindsight Duckenfield ordered the gate to be opened, people died, therefore that was a mistake. If he decided to not open the gate and people were crushed outside and died, then people today would blame him for NOT opening the gate and say that it was a mistake. The mistake was not making sure people went to the side pens. It seems like the police and Duckenfield himself were completely disorganised, but possibly Duckenfield may have just assumed that there would be police on hand to ensure people were directed to outside pens once in the ground, or at least that fans would work it out themselves (though obviously people would have no choice and just get carried forward in the wave to the central pens). The same match at the same ground was played the year before in 1988. Why did the same tragedy not occur that year? (Amongst a few changes) I believe there were police on hand inside the ground to direct fans then, and ultimately whoever changed that could be considered "responsible". |
|
By:
if you just read the verdict and the analysis these questions are answered, here is video summary
. http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/video/2016/apr/26/hillsborough-inquiry-anatomy-of-a-disaster-video It was Dukenfields first match, the guy previously was moved off for some scandal. Even with previous guy in charge there were near misses and dangerous situations in previous years. It was Dunkenfields responsabilty to oversea policing, the duty of care to people attending, he can assume anything its his job to get police in right place and give orders. Who know if as many people woulld have died outside the gate, but him ordering it to be opened, certainly caused the crush at the pens. If people would have died outside its still his responability and failings for not setting up cordon down the road |
|
By:
I expect if you look at the policing for matches throughout the 1980's you would find endless situations where this kind of tragedy would have occured and for the grace of God just didn't happen.
Should we go through the records now and see which matches were incompetently policed and criminally charge all those involved. It was different times and different standards adhered to. The one thing to be grateful from the Hillsborough tragedy is that lessons were learnt and things are far far safer these days. |
|
By:
Respect to all the people who continued to fight for the truth. What has angered me are the revelations concerning the massive cover up exercise which took place after the event.
|
|
By:
Aye but football lost part of its soul when all sweaters came about as a result.
Appealing to families with hampers or whatever sterilised the atmosphere in many respects. I guess until a tragedy occurs why would you change anything? Except it had occurred already at Bolton where I think 29 died with far greater numbers than were present at leppings lane that day from recollection. This is a case of the squeaky wheel getting the oil. So the families have got what they wanted or what they said they wanted that's the end of it.....right? |
|
By:
its only different times now, police covered up their failings at the time, they knew there would be **** storm if people knew 96 people were unlawfully kiled then and if the truth was known, instead of lies, who knows who would have prosecuted.
|
|
By:
All sweaters pmsl
This iPad ffs All seaters |
|
By:
Correct. And as an outcome prosecutions need to follow on those now shown to be accountable.
|
|
By:
^ to cooperman
|
|
By:
Agreed Facts. Saville and the Rotherham grooming case are amongst others overseen by the same force which, in my opinion, need a more thorough examination.
|
|
By:
The families have been given what they have fought for I thought confirmation that the fans were not to be blame for the deaths.
The police behaved badly in covering up which has been revealed, and any charge should be against those involved in this rather than the unlawful killing. Duckenfield did not mean to kill anyone, and while he was underprepared (but no different from how general policing was for football matches in those days) and "froze" is that a reason to convict someone? If so, you would need to convict a huge number of people from the 1980's involved in policing. What incentive is there to join the police if you are going to be at risk of being convicted in such circumstances. |
|
By:
For contemporary disaster, the Herald of Free Enterprise sank in march 1987, by October the same year coroner had given unlawful kiling verdicts. Not 27 years later because of cover up and lies by police and media.
No one was convicted then although it went to court |
|
By:
It's pretty nailed on the cps will argue there is a case to try duckenfield, I think he will now have a very difficult time in such a trial when the evidence to temper the outcome has been taken away.
That will probs occur with or without vocal support of the families. What I'll be interested to see is if they then want compensation, taken from other innocent people's pockets? |
|
By:
The difficulty was that Duckenfield may well have made the right decision to open the gate if he didn't know that fans would inevitably,as pointed out above,have made for the central pen(s).
As I said there WAS a potential problem at Leppings Lane and it would only have needed the sort of behaviour which was common amongst fotball fans in the 80s to have triggered that.I stopped going to matches a few years earlier because in my mid-30s I had started to realise that matches generally had become an unpleasant and possibly dangerous place to be.I never went to a game in which Liverpool were playing but I was knocked over at Walsall where in a ground about 25% full the fans thought it would be funny to surge out from where they were gathered in the middle of the terraces. That was the climate in which the authorities were working and they quite possibly responsible for making the situation worse by treating fans as scum when 90% were not. Of course he should not have lied about opening the gate but he did it as he realised the extent of the disaster. If he had said he opened the gate because he genuinely believed there was about to be a disaster OUTSIDE the ground proper would there still be a call to throw him in jail ? |
|
By:
'.....The justice for Hillsborough campaigners have been rightly praised for their dignity and resilience.
These qualities were again on display when they reacted to yesterday’s damning verdicts. But their patience could be tested if there is a failure to hold those responsible for the disaster to account. Theresa May will give a statement to MPs at 12.30 today setting out the government's response. It should be said the Home Secretary has been no friend of the police and has been a consistent critic of their failings. But she will also know that 27 years of grief and injustice could turn to anger and grievance if those responsible for 96 deaths are not brought to book. Writing in the Mirror today Andy Burnham, who did so much to establish the Hillsborough panel, calls for a "root-and-branch" reform of South Yorks police. "The culture at this force has not changed," he notes......' |
|
By:
If he had said he opened the gate because he genuinely believed there was about to be a disaster OUTSIDE the ground proper would there still be a call to throw him in jail ?
who knows, those through the gate first ran, they were not being crushed to death. Outside were open roads so people could disperse. I think from his previous lies and still not saying where he was for 2 hours prior to ko, what he 'genuinely believed' should not be relevant |
|
By:
I don't know whether you knew the ground brendan but those of us who did can imagine it was very easy to foresee a POSSIBLE problem there. You couldn't have gone back if there were still people coming in. I think it is fair to say that Duckenfield's competence and his behaviour get about 1 out of 100 but whether it was criminal,by the standards of the time,is debatable.
|
|
By:
Earlier, Mr Duckenfield also told the jury he could not account for his movements for a period of more than two hours before he took up his position in the police control box on the afternoon of the semi-final.
He told the inquests his mind was "a complete blank" and he could only remember being taken "taken out" in a police car by a colleague and "we drove around". Ms Lambert put it to Mr Duckenfield that this was a "significant period of time" and would have been a "golden opportunity" to get to know the ground better, on what was to be his first match as commander. Mr Duckenfield agreed that it was, but said he could not recall convenient, almost like he was pished |
|
By:
yes ive lived in sheffield and know the end.
I think its only right that instead of being tried by forum, he gets chance to defend hinself in court. Its very difficult to get one of these corporate manslaughter changes or death by gross negligence to stick |
|
By:
A criminal trial against Duckenfield is fraught.
Someone mentioned the Herald of Free Enterprise disaster, in that trial it was not the guy who was asleep on the job and failed to close the doors that was blamed the most. The failings of one person should not cause a disaster the size of Hillsborough. The Popplewell report after the Bradford Fire Stadium disaster basically said the Police should ensure safety outside the ground and the club responsible inside. At Hillsbrough there was apparently some kind of "informal" arrangement between police and Sheff Wed that the police would look after Lepping's Lane, general away end and Sheff Wed the rest of the ground. Again further confusion contributing to the disaster. Throw the book at Duckenfield for lying and trying to cover himself but he can't be the only one responsible. |
|
By:
wen i say more open roads, i mean in comparison to the pens, the place to get people to move back was outside the ground not within site of the pitch, of course with announcement that everyone with tickets will get in and matched delayed untill they were
|
|
By:
That sounds fine in theory brendan. Might have worked IF they had a tannoy system that could be heard properly outside the ground and IF everybody HAD tickets. I don't know the answer to either of those questions.
|
|
By:
the police should check and do this with swfc, Duckenfield/police should have safety measures in place, every route leads back to police failings, some by swfc and their safety engineers like verdict found
|
|
By:
Yep. Poor communications,bad ground design etc. Wouldn't be allowed today. Having said that the Alton Towers people have accepted responsiblity for the crash there last year. I realise nobody died but at least two people suffered life-changing injuries. You won't see any individuals in the dock there.
|
|
By:
This is the founder mental question of how much of what happened outside is down to the actions of the police, and frankly why I find it hard to believe that all blame is exonerated from the crowd as a whole.
Leppings lane end is right on a bend which creates a bottleneck and has a river right by the entrance which can't help. People got crushed at the front trying to get in the ground.....but the police weren't pushing them in. There have been references to the deaths at the haj, which do consistently occur, but the numbers are in the millions not several tens of thousand. Loads were learned after this event, much of it naturally occurring due to collections of people, but are we saying the actions of people in large numbers resolves them of any responsibility? I say no. |
|
By:
i think it could have been foreseen that 10,000 people would try and get through those 7 turnstiles in the hour or so before the match, I dont think its the fans duty to arrive staggered or 3 hours before kick off. so i would say yes, they were blameless
you won't see any individuals in the dock there. No one has so far been in the dock over this, even if it went to court at the time, very unlikely a policeman would be in court or convicted. |
|
By:
It's not about that though is it?
What's happened here is that the people who had been blamed were totally exonerated while pretty much everyone else who could be blamed, were. They could have said the conduct of the fans played a part, but instead are saying they had no impact. How is that simply not fawning for the families in court after the momentum pre inquiry was a general movement in that direction? It looks to me like they wouldn't be the ones to say, 'sorry, no actually the fans did have a role in this' |
|
By:
Everything today seems to have to be black and white.
|
|
By:
dusty,
I think you're wasting your time here trying to be rational about those events. Scapegoats have been found and if you fight long enough, you'll get the truth you want. |
|
By:
The scapegoats have been exonerated and the truly guilty have been exposed. It's clearly difficult for you and dustybin to accept for your own reasons.
Many people would have given up trying to establish the truth in the face of a massive cover up so the families deserve every credit for their belief and perseverance which was at great cost to their health and personal lives. Thankfully they are getting that credit from most quarters and you are clearly in the minority. |
|
By:
Were the jury unanimous in their verdict?
|
|
By:
And your point is
|
|
By:
As a Sheffielder I don't really appreciate people from Liverpool telling us that S Yorks police should be disbanded. I rather think that should be a decision for us.
|