Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 183 comments are related to the topic:
Hillsborough decisions 11:00am tomorrow..

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 2 of 5  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 183
By:
Howdi
When: 26 Apr 16 17:56
football was lucky it wasn't closed down for a stint in the 80s. (Legacy of Hillsborough is of course all seater stadium).
By:
Howdi
When: 26 Apr 16 17:56
makes you wonder how police used to handle even bigger crowds in the 50-60s
By:
FredRescue
When: 26 Apr 16 17:57
Govt's reaction to the hooligans was to dictate contain and control.

What could they have feasibly suggested instead?
By:
Howdi
When: 26 Apr 16 17:58
^^^ good question but police upped their game in the 90s and got it under control a lot better.
By:
FredRescue
When: 26 Apr 16 18:03
So really the cause of Hillsborough was not the government, police, FA, but the 80's hooligans
By:
Howdi
When: 26 Apr 16 18:11
I don't think anyone has said that but it probably played a part in the way football matches were policed at that particular time in history.
By:
dustybin
When: 26 Apr 16 18:13
which is why I cant understand how an inquiry can come to such a verdict without bringing those elements into perspective.
Everyone was blamed even the ambulancemen there to assist, for not getting to the fans.

But no mention as far as I can see as to the knock on effect of the culture within football matches.
Totally bizarre, its like they just want it to go now.
By:
blackbarn
When: 26 Apr 16 18:28
dustybin - Why do you keep spouting stuff that has no basis in fact. You seem to have an agenda. 

The Ambulancemen were NOT blamed, The Ambulance SERVICE was criticised for a number of things but primarily for the delay in recognising and treating this as a major incident.  Hardly the same thing.
By:
dustybin
When: 26 Apr 16 18:33
The ambulance service then mr perdantic.

The point was that they found blame in everyone....except the fans.
Correct or not?
By:
dustybin
When: 26 Apr 16 18:35
pedantic
By:
Injera
When: 26 Apr 16 18:37
Hooliganism in the 80s is overplayed.

Police feared it to such an extent they were in no position to care for the public when there was a problem.

As I said earlier I was in more danger because of Plod and crushing.

As for Hillsborough, of course the fans' actions played a part. Their exoneration of all blame is predictable but not right.

Too many turned up late and put Duckenfield in a terrible position. 5700 were outside the turnstiles near kick off. Claims of ticketless fans have been denied but 'jibbing' by LFC fans was very common back then..

Once in they poured thru to the centre terrace which couldn't cope.

Appalling from the FA and Sheff Wed but the fans added to the chaos.
By:
blackbarn
When: 26 Apr 16 18:38
Dustybin, Yes, having heard all the evidence that was the conclusion. In fact that the fans did not contribute is specifically mentioned. Mind you these people heard all the evidence.  You seem better informedCrazy
By:
dustybin
When: 26 Apr 16 18:43
I just feel that by eliminating the wider picture of how and why things were done in such a way the verdict looks like a pendulum swing based simply on an over reaction to the lies made after the event.
We are all wise after the event, this is starting to look like a public hanging case on a number of individuals and the actions of fans totally dismissed as cause and effect.
By:
Howdi
When: 26 Apr 16 19:03
Injera spot on. Thats my memory of the 80s.
By:
Howdi
When: 26 Apr 16 19:04
out of interest why do the families want the current boss of West Yorksgire police to resign, whats he done? (I missed the reasoning)......
By:
ebulGery
When: 26 Apr 16 19:40
That seems baffling to me as well Howdi

I would see it more as a failure of care

I see insufficient preparation and foresight, it put the police under tremendous pressure, they made a decision on the day.

Sadly not the right one

Verdicts in trials now tend to be like reality shows as much as justice.

I suspect the truth is somewhere between the original Sun verdict and todays verdict.

But everything must be totally clear and simple now we cannot allow people to think for themselves that would never do.

It will also allow compensation claims to be made which is always popular.
By:
ebulGery
When: 26 Apr 16 19:42
I am very cynical of justice nowadays  and have always been cynical of a sun verdict.
By:
Howdi
When: 26 Apr 16 20:01
^^^ another good post ebulgery
By:
ebulGery
When: 26 Apr 16 20:16
Happy I like that HowdiLaugh

I think the police chief should have stepped down at the time and admitted he made a bad miscalculation, which in fact he had.

He was under tremendous pressure when he did it, nobody expected thousands of Liverpool supporters to turn up on the day expecting to buy

tickets.

There was a near riot developing around the turn styles so he made the decision, without appreciating he was letting too many people

into too small a space in which they were caged in, there was no escape. It was the worst decision he could have made...in hindsight.
By:
Tommy Toes
When: 26 Apr 16 20:25
Well done to all the relatives of the Hillsborough tragedy.

It gives a little bit of faith to those of us who believe that truth - and tenacity in pursuing it - will always be the winner.

Let's not forget that the most evil bitch who ever governed this country:
The destroyer of lives (in more ways than one) Margaret Thatcher
was instrumental in allowing the South Yorkshire police to get away with murder for all those years, such was her allegiance to them in destroying the miners.

By Christ, that woman has SO much to answer for.
By:
Howdi
When: 26 Apr 16 20:28
one wonders why we hear so little of Heysel (tradegy)
By:
Howdi
When: 26 Apr 16 20:29
I wouldn't when someone would blame Maggie Mischief
By:
mad mad moon
When: 26 Apr 16 20:36
Injera and Ebulgery are pretty much spot on.
It needs to have closure, even if some of the verdicts are a bit skewed.
By:
dustybin
When: 26 Apr 16 20:41
ShockedShockedShocked
Howdi mentioned the 'H' word !!!!

The scouse stasi will be here shortly.
By:
ebulGery
When: 26 Apr 16 21:04
The 1990 official inquiry into the disaster, the Taylor Report, concluded that "the main reason for the disaster was the failure of police control."[1] Entry was possible only via one of seven decrepit turnstiles, a restriction that led to dangerous overcrowding outside the ground before kick-off. In an attempt to ease pressure outside the ground, Police Chief Superintendent David Duckenfield, the senior police officer responsible for the match, ordered an exit gate to be opened. The opened exit gate led to a tunnel marked "Standing", which led directly to the two already overcrowded enclosures. In previous years the tunnel had been closed off by police when the two central pens were full; however, on this occasion the tunnel was unmanned.
By:
DancingDenman
When: 26 Apr 16 21:31
What a full circle white wash. Every scouser had a ticket, stood in a orderly queue had nt had a sniff of alchol n all went to church on way to the game.
Was a big football supporter/ attender in the 80s  n the truth was nowt like were being told their a embarassment.
By:
DancingDenman
When: 26 Apr 16 21:35
Like the Bloody Sunday enquriy 'you did nothing wrong it was all the estashbliments fault'.
In other words how much do you want to fu ck off.
By:
blackbarn
When: 26 Apr 16 22:03
DancingDenman - I bet the families of the 10 year old, the two  14 year olds, the other 8 under 16 year olds, the six girls/ladies and the several old codgers, (of roughly my age) are thrilled with your informed, balanced and detailed assessment of what actually occurred.
By:
lmfao
When: 26 Apr 16 22:10
Start the suing ....
By:
lmfao
When: 26 Apr 16 22:19
In Mecca - at the Haj- time and again people are sadly crushed to death- its inevitable with crowds - and the point is to learn from past mistakes

This is a terrible accident- possibly a failure to care - no way is it unlawful killing

As a boy at Highbury i was caught up in a police horse penned in crowd and we/ I was being crushed - it was very frightening for 5 minutes- nothing my dad or i could do - but it was just a result of masses being crammed together- it happened at football ln those days-just part of life / living.
By:
ReaseHeath
When: 26 Apr 16 22:24
footage on the BBC news shows three fans and a policeman sprinting across the pitch with a stretcher and about 30 police officers standing on the pitch appearing not to be doing anything - a snapshot,yes, but the footage shows very little in the way of proactive policing.

Duckenfield should surely face a criminal prosecution for manslaughter on the basis of gross negligence but he may well be able to avoid that by claiming that the outcome of the inquests is prejudicial to his chances of getting a fair trial (not a lawyer so others may know better).

However, personally I'm not particularly comfortable with a process that takes 2 years and results in an outcome of answers to 14 closed questions with a few paragraphs of comments to qualify the answers to some of them.

Nobody should die just because they went to watch a football match and if it happened to someone in my family I'd do everything I could to find out exactly what happened to them.
By:
salmon spray
When: 26 Apr 16 22:26
It was hardly something I had ANY expertise in but I had noticed years before there was a potential problem with the Leppings Lane end. For those who didn't know it in those days you entered the grounds through a fairly wide entrance then as you approached the turnstiles the corridor narrowed a fair bit. The ground was built before WW1 and was not the only one that had those sort of design problems. Oddly Wednesday used to pack bigger crowds in for local derbies without any problems for decades. The difficulties started with semi-finals in the 80s. Football fans,not just Liverpool,became more and more unruly from the late 60s and it came to a peak in the 80s. Anybody who knew anything about football and lived through that period can hardly dispute that.
By:
ebulGery
When: 26 Apr 16 22:31
Duckenfield should surely face a criminal prosecution for manslaughter on the basis of gross negligence but he may well be able to avoid that by claiming that the outcome of the inquests is prejudicial to his chances of getting a fair trial (not a lawyer so others may know better).

I totally disagree with that. Yes he made wrong decision under pressure, that is all.
He must take responsibility for that I feel but Liverpool fans are responsible for their behaviour at the turn styles.

As MadMoon said earlier we need closure, pay the compensation claims and end it now.

Not all tragedies are for seen or prevented.

We are growing into a very vindictive society now.
By:
RLKingPunter
When: 26 Apr 16 22:41
At last someone has said the dreaded word....compensation
By:
salmon spray
When: 26 Apr 16 22:44
I agree with that ebulgery. Duckinfield and others behaved disgracefully in trying to cover-up some of their actions,but at the time the disaster happened he and others did their best ( and got a lot wrong ). Some of the rhetoric today has inferred they set out to kill Liverpool fans.
By:
blackbarn
When: 26 Apr 16 22:46
ebulgery - need to be careful here, but given the "unlawful killing" decision, the CPS will now decide whether there is sufficient evidence for individual (or group) prosecutions for a range of offences - criminal negligence, manslaughter etc.  Making a "wrong decision under pressure" may or may not be an explanation or defence to whatever charge is made against an individual.
By:
blackbarn
When: 26 Apr 16 22:51
Salmon - setting out to kill if carried out would be (attempted?) murder of course.  "Doing your best" matters not, if criminal negligence or manslaughter were proven.
By:
ReaseHeath
When: 26 Apr 16 22:53
I'm not sure you do need to be careful, BBC report as follows:

'The jury found match commander Ch Supt David Duckenfield was " responsible for manslaughter by gross negligence" due to a breach of his duty of care'

So how exactly can he be tried fairly for manslaughter with such a statement in the public domain?
By:
DancingDenman
When: 26 Apr 16 22:55
Blackbarm im a father of two teenage daughters if i allowed them to go into a male dominated unruly crowd,i was a attending football fan in the 80s n the behaviour of fans was outrageous & animal like, i would be as, if not more responsible than any copper, ambulance man or anyone else you'd like to blame.
By:
donny osmond
When: 26 Apr 16 23:10
we went to games in the 80s ( and 70s) we had our own transport as coaches were cattle to
the authorities.

hillsboro was one of the most likely accident spots because of the entry system which was awful

then entering a cage to watch a game of football  when everybody wanted to be central !

we always got to the side and with a crush barrier at our back, and got in early .....


police knew the score at all grounds but perhaps the chief hadnt done his homework

perhaps he made an honest mistake, but to cover up was unacceptable


why would so many policemen alter their statements at request of senior officer ?

was it routine for this to happen or did this huge well drilled cover up only happen once ?
Page 2 of 5  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com