Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 340 comments are related to the topic:
Oscar Pistorious - Last day of freedom for some time

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 3 of 9  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 9 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 340
By:
Try My Best
When: 11 Sep 14 12:05
Prosecutor put in a worse display than the accused imo.
By:
maleuk01.
When: 11 Sep 14 12:06
she is saying that you carnt see by firing a gun you can kill someone, is she serious?

this case stinks.
By:
layingdoesntwork
When: 11 Sep 14 12:09
Fame and Money always wins in this world, go **** anyone who isn't
By:
doantwin2easy
When: 11 Sep 14 12:11

Sep 11, 2014 -- 6:02AM, Ted Brogan wrote:


Sep 11, 2014 -- 11:56AM, doantwin2easy wrote:judge is trashing Pistorius as a witness under cross examination. contradicting himself. Yet he still gets off murder.Because it is up to the prosecution to prove guilt, not him to prove innocence


Judge, "how could the accused reasonably have foreseen that the shots he fired would have killed the deceased". She bought OP's version of events over the prosecutions - despite the fact that he couldn't get his story straight. Perhaps Nel didn't do his job properly. Perhaps.

By:
GRANTCKING
When: 11 Sep 14 12:14

Sep 11, 2014 -- 6:09AM, layingdoesntwork wrote:


Fame and Money always wins in this world, go **** anyone who isn't


yep got to agree with this, if your somewhat rich or famous you can do anything you want and not face any consequences

By:
call me a taxi
When: 11 Sep 14 12:27
GRANTCKING
11 Sep 14 11:35   
congrats OP u f ucking c unt


It took me a good 20 seconds to twig that OP is Oscar Pistorius, not Wesdag, the Opening Poster.

Laugh
By:
layingdoesntwork
When: 11 Sep 14 12:27
ExcitedExcited
By:
FlowerMyth
When: 11 Sep 14 12:27
I didn’t post anything before because I was listening and I thought I hadn’t heard it right, but it seems I didn’t mishear, the judge reckons it’s not foreseeable that shooting bullets through a door into a room might kill someone you think is inside it? That seems truly a bizarre conclusion to me.
By:
DonNo1
When: 11 Sep 14 12:28
"How could the accused reasonably have foreseen that the shot he fired would kill the deceased?"

4 shots into a small toilet cubicle, I think it's pretty unreasonable to foresee a situation where someone wouldn't die
By:
layingdoesntwork
When: 11 Sep 14 12:29
Judge payed off - NAP
By:
johnizere
When: 11 Sep 14 12:30
Only two possible outcomes...
Culpable homicide, or aquittal!
evens the pair?
By:
Crisp77
When: 11 Sep 14 12:31
£2 on culpable homicide.
By:
call me a taxi
When: 11 Sep 14 12:32
4/5 acquittal
11/10 culpable homicide
By:
GRANTCKING
When: 11 Sep 14 12:32
4/9 acquittal 13/8 homicide
By:
GRANTCKING
When: 11 Sep 14 12:33
if there was any justice in life his brother wouldve lost both his legs in that car accident, cant stand the whole family, bas tards
By:
dlarssonf
When: 11 Sep 14 12:34
Disgraceful decision
By:
HH Sultan Vinegar
When: 11 Sep 14 12:34
Crisp you'll have to top up your account first remember.
By:
brigust1
When: 11 Sep 14 12:36
All we need now is Israel to be charged with war crimes.
By:
doantwin2easy
When: 11 Sep 14 12:38

Sep 11, 2014 -- 6:28AM, DonNo1 wrote:


"How could the accused reasonably have foreseen that the shot he fired would kill the deceased?" 4 shots into a small toilet cubicle, I think it's pretty unreasonable to foresee a situation where someone wouldn't die


I guess the judges point is that he couldn't reasonably have known it was "the deceased" that would die from the shots being fired, not that there was a good chance someone would die. Although I am not clear on that.

Personally I would have checked the location of my loved one before starting to fire bullets.

By:
DonNo1
When: 11 Sep 14 12:43
Ah fair point, i'd still argue that one could still reasonably foresee that it was her in toilet and thus kill her
By:
layingdoesntwork
When: 11 Sep 14 12:44
She will probably now say he acted like a reasonable person would then go to aquitt him of all charges.
By:
GRANTCKING
When: 11 Sep 14 12:47
how much longer till they come back, anyone know? been gone a while
By:
Crisp77
When: 11 Sep 14 12:51

Sep 11, 2014 -- 6:34AM, HH Sultan Vinegar wrote:


Crisp you'll have to top up your account first remember.


Total available: £0.00

Shocked...I think I have found the iCloud hacker

By:
GRANTCKING
When: 11 Sep 14 12:54
Andrew Harding Africa correspondent tweets: No sign of Judge returning... an unexpected, unexplained delay in proceedings. #OscarPistorius
By:
GRANTCKING
When: 11 Sep 14 12:54
hahahah the judge has maybe realised pistorius hasnt deposited the cash into her account yet?
By:
layingdoesntwork
When: 11 Sep 14 12:55
GrinGrinGrinGrin
By:
Crisp77
When: 11 Sep 14 12:56
Floella Benjamin can step in. All she needs to know is if he shot her through the round window or the square window.
By:
call me a taxi
When: 11 Sep 14 12:57
Laugh
By:
GRANTCKING
When: 11 Sep 14 13:03
the judge has worn out the F5 button on her laptop waiting for the pistorius money to hit her offsigre account Laugh
By:
bigted.
When: 11 Sep 14 13:04
Joey Barton..

I mean who locks the toilet door when they go for a p1ss in the middle of the night in their own house?



more fkn brains than milady..

imo
By:
FlowerMyth
When: 11 Sep 14 13:05
I guess the judges point is that he couldn't reasonably have known it was "the deceased" that would die from the shots being fired, not that there was a good chance someone would die. Although I am not clear on that.

The identity wasn't important. There was a distinction only in that either he did or didn't intend to kill an intruder or her. She's saying he didn't intend to kill (not guilty of murder) and couldn't have foreseen that 'somebody' would die as a consequence of his actions. Basically she's saying he wasn't reckless. (WALOFS)

(Is the way I see it)
By:
GRANTCKING
When: 11 Sep 14 13:08
I agree with you flowermyth, when you fire 4 shots into a small confined space the intention is without a doubt to kill anyone inside
By:
Crisp77
When: 11 Sep 14 13:09
Lucy Thornton from the UK's Daily Mirror newspaper tweets: Carl turns round and winks at his brother Oscar as court waits for the Judge to return. #Pistorius
By:
layingdoesntwork
When: 11 Sep 14 13:09
Carl turns round and winks at his brother Oscar as court waits for the Judge to return. #Pistorius
By:
layingdoesntwork
When: 11 Sep 14 13:09
lol same time
By:
Crisp77
When: 11 Sep 14 13:09
Laugh
By:
layingdoesntwork
When: 11 Sep 14 13:09
bunch of bastarts this family
By:
layingdoesntwork
When: 11 Sep 14 13:12
something is happening though long delay
By:
maleuk01.
When: 11 Sep 14 13:14
feel sorry for reeva and her family.

How the judge cannot see its murder like the rest of the world can beggars belief.
By:
GRANTCKING
When: 11 Sep 14 13:14
oh here we go
Page 3 of 9  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 9 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com