Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Cheltenham Festival

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 994 comments are related to the topic:
PRESENTING PERCY

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 18 of 25  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | ... | 25 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 994
By:
foxy
When: 24 Feb 19 13:52
Is this thread getting a little bit silly
By:
irishone
When: 24 Feb 19 15:31
British officials drug-tested Irish horses before Cheltenham
Willie Mullins confirmed that BHA officials had travelled to Ireland before the festival
Sun, Mar 18, 2018, 16:29

Brian O'Connor




A view of racing at the Cheltenham Festival last week. Photo: James Crombie/Inpho



British racing’s ruling body insists it has total faith in Ireland’s anti-doping system although British Horseracing Authority personnel carried out their own testing at two major Irish stables the week before Cheltenham.
Champion trainer Willie Mullins confirmed on Sunday that the BHA carried out testing at his yard. It is understood Gordon Elliott was the other trainer. Mullins and Elliott between them saddled 15 of the 17 Irish winners at last week’s festival. All samples taken were negative.
“Trainers regularly get out of competition testing. It’s never a surprise when they come in and we just let them get on with it. It’s part and parcel of racing. To me it’s just normal,” Mullins said.
Confirmation that the BHA visited Ireland on the run up to jump racing’s biggest meeting of the year comes on the back Irish dominance at Cheltenham but also a cross-channel media report which suggested there is unhappiness at the BHA about out of competition testing levels here.
That Guardian report also claimed that there could be an impact on Irish access to British racing in the months ahead if the BHA isn’t satisfied with the response of the Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board – formerly the Turf Club – in relation to their concerns.
News that British officials tested Irish trained horses comes in the context of 2017’s record haul of 19 festival winners for Ireland.
It appears to leave the British authorities open to a suspicion of sour grapes about Irish success at Cheltenham and claims of potential protectionism if access to cross-channel racing is curtailed in future.
Top flat trainer Ger Lyons tweeted: “Implies that Irish horses are cheating & that our authorities are turning a blind eye to it! Good to see they are as gracious in defeat as they are in victory.”



Hope you don't think any of my posts were tongue in cheek foxy …...















On Sunday the BHA said testing carried out by their officials in Ireland on the eve of Cheltenham was no reflection on the IHRB’s anti-doping system. It also rejected claims of sour grapes.
Asked if such testing in a different jurisdiction implied a lack of faith in the IHRB, the BHA spokesman, Robin Mounsey, was adamant it didn’t.
“I cannot strongly enough say that is not the intention. There is no lack of faith in the Irish anti-doping system. This is all about our own anti-doping strategy,” he said.
Mounsey outlined that new BHA strategy for out of competition testing on horses trained outside Britain on the run up to British racing’s major festivals, both on the flat and over jumps. He said this applied to all international runners.
“There is a new strategy focussing on the major festival here. This is about our festivals, about out of competition testing towards those festivals, and testing a spread of competitors at those festivals.
“With Cheltenham it wouldn’t make a lot of sense to encourage out of competition testing and not apply that strategy to half the population of horses at that festival,” he said.
The IHRB chief executive Denis Egan confirmed the BHA communicated with Irish racing’s regulatory body before visiting two yards in Ireland the week before Cheltenham.
“We went with them and there was no problem. This is bog-standard stuff. Under their rules the BHA have the power to come over here which is fine. We can go to the UK as well,” he said.
Egan said he wasn’t sure if Irish officials had ever themselves tested a horse in the UK ahead of it racing in Ireland. However he said that was a matter of logistics and that the BHA usually carry out testing in Britain for them.
“It’s not a problem if they want to come over here or if they want us to do it for them. There is no issue whatsoever,” he said.
Egan added that he had extensive communication with BHA officials at Cheltenham and said on Sunday: “They never inferred anything to us. There’s been no hint of unease at any stage . We’ve had nothing at all times but total cooperation with the BHA and vice versa.
“Irish horses run all over the world, in the US, France, Hong Kong, Australia and the UK, and they don’t come back positive.”
Willie Mullins said the BHA visited him under the auspicious of the IHRB and in his view such inspections are normal.
“If we have horses going to race in Melbourne or Hong Kong , blood and urine samples are taken before we go. And their Turf Club takes it. We think it’s routine,” he said. “It’s the way forward. Everyone should be tested.”
In 2014 the BHA carried out their own pre-festival testing on Cheltenham entries trained by Philip Fenton who was embroiled in a steroids scandal at that time.
Later that year Fenton was convicted of possessing banned animal medicines, including anabolic steroids, and fine E10,200. He was disqualified for three years by the Turf Club.
Mounsey said reports of potential barriers to Irish runners in Britain, and measures to try and boost home fortunes at Cheltenham in the face of recent Irish dominance, were misleading.
“Two issues were conflated. We’ve got to look at British racing and make sure it’s as competitive as possible. We will look at the race programme, investments in the sport, primzemoney and so on. That’s a problem for us.
“But the testing of Irish runners was conflated to that issue and that was not what was intended for that briefing. There is absolutely no suggestion of sour grapes at all. It’s about what we have to do in Britain to make ourselves more competitive,” he said.
By:
impossible123
When: 03 Mar 19 18:01
This is the opinion of Henrietta Knight trainer of 3x Gold Cup champion Best Mate on PP when asked if she thought PP could win the Gold Cup? Knight: "In my opinion, I can't see how a horse can win a Gold Cup without having a run in a steeplechase for the season esp one stepping out of novice company."

Looks like she shares the same opinion as some here.
By:
irishone
When: 03 Mar 19 19:07
Bobsworth and NR both had one run before the GC , FACT
By:
irishone
When: 03 Mar 19 19:09
If you know the horse can jump why not go the hurdle route , keeping them lower and quicker
By:
irishone
When: 03 Mar 19 19:10
What does hen do now for a living .....writes books and teaches horses how to jump ...there's a shock
By:
irishone
When: 03 Mar 19 19:13
All Patrick has done is wrap him up in cooton wool ? ......best mate was accused of that ....who trained that one ?
By:
buddeliea
When: 03 Mar 19 19:29
Best Mate ran twice over fences each year before he won the Gold Cup if i remember correctly,one of which was the King George.
Rather different to PP.
It worked and so his trainer cannot be knocked.
Lets see how PP gets on,then we can judge after the event,which is the only time we can judge properly.
Now its just opinion, and if Hen Knight is asked hers,then she is entitled to give hers,and as a trainer of a horse that has won the Gold Cup three times,an opinion that should be respected imo.
By:
irishone
When: 03 Mar 19 19:35
Hen couldn't tie Patrick's boots up , the old fellah biddles was different gravy
By:
irishone
When: 03 Mar 19 19:36
Jenny pitman used to wrap them up in cotton wool as well
By:
irishone
When: 03 Mar 19 19:39
She did a blinding job with that somersby LaughLaugh
By:
buddeliea
When: 03 Mar 19 19:42
And she won Grand Nationals and Gold Cups.....another proven trainer of big chase winners that cannot be knocked.

We await what Patrick can do.
By:
buddeliea
When: 03 Mar 19 19:44
End of thread for me.
Another one i was stupid enough to think would be a sensible one.!!
By:
buddeliea
When: 03 Mar 19 19:45
Although i will revisit after the Gold Cup.......whatever the result.
By:
johnslad
When: 03 Mar 19 20:11
your memory is about 2 1/2 hrs if you read RP.COM report and as HEN said they were accused af cotton wool wrapping which you didn't add and for sensible its only that if its what you want to hear,just saying like as its just so repetitive listening and I don't know if he can win to be honest I can make a case for plenty and up in the air what to bet but a 2 time festival winner will have every chance if not more than that in what is not a vintage race maybe in no's but not in class imo.
By:
impossible123
When: 03 Mar 19 20:20
Not a follower of Tom Segal, but this was what he said about PP when asked in a Q & A session. Segal: "...the only time he stepped out of novice company he got beaten by Our Duke receiving weight."

I shall cease to post on this thread until the race; will accolade PP if he wins similarly, his trainer if he does not.
By:
irishone
When: 03 Mar 19 20:52
Glad to see you lads disappearing.

You turned a thread about a trade into a continual slagging of Pp's preparation, price, value, form , trainer and jockey.

It was never about that ! It was about a free bet in the gold cup ten months before the race.

As soon as you read a slagging of the honourable queen of Cheltenham, bit too close to home,  the dummmies get spat out the pram and you are not playing anymore .

Apologies to Henrietta Knight .
By:
duffy
When: 04 Mar 19 02:01
Criticism of his prep is based solely on what we perceive to be "normal", it does not make it wrong or by default automatically detract from his chance of winning the race if he doesn't race when people on the outside think he should run.

His absence displays a sign of huge faith and confidence in the horse as they obviously feel no need to run him if everything isn't right, there's no thought of offsetting this against the up side of getting a run into him.

The trainer has campaigned him in a less than usual way in the past and it has worked.

What accentuates the feeling against the way that the horse is campaigned is the fact that the trainer won't give the time of day to the media and won't sit down and explain all his decisions which would help us understand more what goes on, this aloofness can become tiresome of course and serves to put people off and criticise more.
By:
impossible123
When: 04 Mar 19 11:23
From experience and past data "normal" would be running at least 2x in chases (preps); against fellow competitors. Has PP done any of these? If PP was not heading the market eg 10/1 plus his prep (or lack of it) would not be a contentious issue to most.

Maybe a novice chaser would be required to qualify to run in any future Gold Cup ie trials prior to participation for the safety of the horse and integrity of the sport.
By:
foxy
When: 04 Mar 19 11:27
How did he go on and who won the raceWink
By:
GAZO
When: 04 Mar 19 12:27
there is no normal,it depends on the horse but they did keep declaring the horse to run which suggests to me they wanted to give him a run
By:
foxy
When: 04 Mar 19 13:43
Was Nicky pleased with santini after yesterday’s Newbury workout
By:
The Sawyer
When: 04 Mar 19 17:38
If he turns up next Friday and wins given his prep, perhaps we can argue that he may as well have run in it last year instead of the RSA.

He'd be going for the hat trick in 2020 wouldn't he?
By:
impossible123
When: 04 Mar 19 17:53
^^
In your dream...after being beaten by Our Duke receiving weight in the only non-novice chase contest he'd run in last season.
By:
The Sawyer
When: 04 Mar 19 18:36
imp123

It was said tongue in cheek - but if he does win, and on the basis that there is no racecourse evidence to suggest he has improved this year, why couldn't you argue that he would have won last year.

After all it's the same oppo.
By:
impossible123
When: 04 Mar 19 18:52
I believe race data told a different story plus the pace set by NR (and MB) could/would have caused concerns for PP as it did for many seasoned chasers in the field.

If PP was 8/1 plus, and not heading the market he'd have come under-the-radar of most (like Sizing John) except his connections and fervent supporters. Nevertheless, the lack of a prep race over fences is a significant no-no with me and most here, I believe. And, his defeat by Our Duke receiving weight in the only non-novice chase contest last season was telling for me.
By:
irishone
When: 04 Mar 19 19:40
"I believe race data told a different story"
What race data ? Have you got all the splits ? Put them up

As for the Red Mills  it wasnt his ground, heavy has never been his ground, Davy saved him, he improves massively on good ground , this has all been said before on here, and anyways I thought you were leaving ? 

impossible123
03 Mar 19 20:20

I shall cease to post on this thread until the race; will accolade PP if he wins similarly, his trainer if he does not


Another FOUND scenario.....LaughLaughLaughLaugh
By:
The Sawyer
When: 04 Mar 19 21:10
And after all, Our Duke did go off 2nd fav for last years Gold Cup - ahead of NR (Native River) in the market.
By:
jedi sophie
When: 04 Mar 19 21:14
Percy bashers seem to have forgot Our Duke was a top class horse.
He really was.
By:
impossible123
When: 04 Mar 19 22:05
I'm not PP bashing, and neither are those not endeared to PP. But we are just being realistic about his chances and his unjustified position at the head of the market despite a defeat in a non-novice chase by OD receiving 7lbs plus a bizarre prep for the Gold Cup.

MB was 4/1 fav, OD 9/2 2nd fav and NR 5/1 3rd fav, and assuming MB and NR ran up to their rating of between 168/170 (173 and 178 in the Gold Cup respectively) similarly OD (Irish National 170) PP is still at least 7lbs behind these 3 horses.
By:
Trueblue82
When: 05 Mar 19 01:17
I have enjoyed reading this thread and the fact that people are so divided with their opinions of PP and the gold cup. I can't wait for the race to see what happens.
Personally I will not be backing PP, he may well be good enough and hats off if he is but too many negatives for me.
I have read alot of people saying his RSA win was outstanding, but those same people say Monalee doesn't stay 3 miles so I think it could be looked at from both angles.
I think the race has so many questions to be answered by nearly every horse that predicting the winner for this race is as hard as any race at this year's festival.
Can't wait to see which horse answers with aplomb
By:
nineteen points
When: 05 Mar 19 07:51
surely native river is being overlooked massively.to be, fair mite bite also.if either one gets their preffered going they will be there at the death.
By:
impossible123
When: 05 Mar 19 08:56
Personally, the only positive with PP at he head of the betting market is there are some stonking values to be held for the others eg CDO, NR, MB, Thistlecrack and Kemboy to name a few.
By:
irishone
When: 05 Mar 19 20:09
Losing all credibility
5 posts
Since he stated "I shall cease to post on this thread until the race"
By:
mrtopnotch
When: 06 Mar 19 10:47
The novices from last year are strong this year - Elegant escape, Monalee etc.
So we can assume they are a good crop entering this years equation.
Presenting Percy's performance in hammering the two above, in last years RSA, was electric.
But there is the doubt of preparation!
CDO imo is not a Cheltenham horse

NR has to be the bet on course form  - Kemboy, Al Boum Photo, Bellshill would all be dangers.

Intriguing race and one to savour
By:
impossible123
When: 08 Mar 19 17:51
Monalee is not a 3-miler; Elegant Escape is an out-and-out stayer thus the Welsh National.

Interesting titbit from a programme hosted by Harvey with Geragthy about Presenting Percy picked-up by Hislop.

Harvey: "There must have been something amiss with Presenting Percy for him only to have raced once to date this season."
Geraghty; "Well, you'd imagine he's had some...it might be only minor...issues."

Reynolds (owner) post Galway schooling; "Pat (trainer) is happy with him and he worked with Mall Dini this morning. We're delighted with him. Fingers crossed he'll be ok in the morning and for the next fortnight. Trying to keep him right is the challenge."

Missing his numerous planned engagements was not wholly ground induced then?
By:
irishone
When: 08 Mar 19 18:00
HDB knows monalee a bit better than you.

PP missed the durkan because he wasnt fit

All reported on here

You might ignore me but people on here see you post things
That you lie about
The found incident was one
.....and you said you were not going to post anymore on here

Treating the forum with disdain
By:
penzance
When: 08 Mar 19 18:44
whatever anyone says Presenting Percy's preperation
hasn't been ideal.He may win but connections must have
wanted more chase runs before the GC,no way this was
the plan.
By:
irishone
When: 08 Mar 19 19:17
It was very close to the plan
How can you question the preparation?
Kellys won two races at the festival with him
By:
Hibore
When: 08 Mar 19 19:22
Irish doesn’t think he’ll win. The purpose of this thread was to to back at 6/1 and lay off just before the race for a small profit.

Only thing Irish laid off just after his hurdle win at 7/2 before he drifted when missed his two chase runs.

That’s correct isn’t it ?
Page 18 of 25  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | ... | 25 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com