Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Cheltenham Festival

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 994 comments are related to the topic:
PRESENTING PERCY

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 16 of 25  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | ... | 25 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 994
By:
pa lapsy
When: 21 Feb 19 14:03
Hey lads,any one know where i can get a "Presenting Percy" scarf?
By:
duffy
When: 21 Feb 19 14:18
Here's the thing though, Percy's trainer does not talk to anyone as we all know, irishone is right, connections do not talk him up, this combination of factors should be serving to turn the public off him but it's actually the exact opposite and he has a huge following, he must have done something right because people are backing him, said before he's got that bit of star quality that shines through even to be seen on the few times he's raced, you don't need to look at the pounds and ounces to see that for me, him and CDO to fight it out IMO.
By:
pa lapsy
When: 21 Feb 19 14:44
I think it is the best Gold Cup in years, Percy if he does it will be a true champion.
Simply an awesome performance from CDO last time. One right good horse.
Last years 1st and 2nd though personally don't fancy either.
Mullins 3 main ones only need to improve just a few lb.
Road to Respect would run well though jumping could be an issue.
Don't think you can discount Thistlecrack or Anibale fly either.

Brave man to have a lot of confidence in this field, i would quite happily watch.
By:
foxy
When: 21 Feb 19 15:36
Absolutely pa lapsy very very open indeed hopefully they will all get there but experience tells me they won’t.
By:
foxy
When: 21 Feb 19 15:42
You say the three Mullins horses invitation only won the thyestes of 152 djakadam won the race of 145 before running 2 nd behind Coneygree in the gold cup I don’t think you can put a line through him with great confidence.
By:
pa lapsy
When: 21 Feb 19 15:50
Hello Foxy, i took Willies word in his interview yesterday at face value that "he'll have to step up a bit". He was positive enough with the other 3,that reason only, i know i shouldn't but i did.
By:
foxy
When: 21 Feb 19 16:08
Yes I read that pa lapsy it surprised me the horse seems to always have been well regarded.there seems a little bit of doom and gloom about this years festival as we stand I find it a fascinating one as well as well as a very good one.
By:
pa lapsy
When: 21 Feb 19 16:19
Totally agree Foxy,think it is in part due to what seems a slight decline with WPM's horses,Rich Ricchi in particular the last few years seemed to have maybe 4 good things,not there this time. In the main quite an open look.

Altior,Paisley Park,Tiger Roll,Percy,Apples Jade a few for different reasons make it that way for me also,then there is the rest!
By:
foxy
When: 21 Feb 19 16:44
The biggest boost the meeting has got this winter is apples jade putting up 3 high class performances which makes the champion hurdle been just that.
By:
buddeliea
When: 21 Feb 19 17:12
Duffy

So connections dont talk PP up,and no form to speak of that is deserving of being Gold Cup fav.so therefore it must be Irish hype thats got him as fav for the Gold Cup.Like you say they are backing him.
As for star quality shining through...is that the RSA or the hurdle race this season?

I guess its gut feelings on your part,and no problem with that,i get those as well mate, and maybe he will turn out to be star quality and the next great champion,fair enough if he is,but he aint yet,and has no form to justify that sort of accolade imo.
!
By:
johnslad
When: 21 Feb 19 18:10
Well just lay it tiĺl the cows come home
By:
foxy
When: 21 Feb 19 18:44
What a magnificent contribution to this thread
By:
buddeliea
When: 21 Feb 19 18:58
Laugh

Well if i were a layer of horses i would certainly do that.
I am purely a backer of horses i think have a fair chance of winning at prices that appeal to me.

I do enjoy the discussion and debate on here though,and have for a few years now, hence the crazy amount of posts to my name!!
By:
Hibore
When: 21 Feb 19 20:07
Got to love this Percy love in.

Cons
Over a stone to find on form.
Not run over fences for a year which gives him little chance
Never won an Open grade 1 Chase
Beaten in only grade 2 open Chase by horse thrashed in Gold Cup (and was receiving 7lbs)
Claim to fame is beating Monalee by 7 lengths and Barney Duan by 3 lengths over hurdles off 146
Why not run in world Hurdle if so good ? Maybe  because Thistlecrack rated 174 Yes 2 STONE higher.
5 horses would give it weight in a handicap Chase.

Pros
It’s trained by Pat Kelly and ridden by Davy.
People in Ireland love a bridle horse.

Currently I make Bellshill and Anibale Fly as equal chance. When PP gets beat this thread will become very quiet.
By:
Hibore
When: 21 Feb 19 20:57
Forgot to add.

Percy’s RSA on “soft” ground was 6 mins 32sec. 35 secs slow against standard.

Native Rivers Gold Cup on “Heavy” apparently was 7mins 3 secs. 25 secs slow against standard.

Please explain that ? Native ran a higher speed figure Than Percy by miles.
By:
buddeliea
When: 22 Feb 19 07:53
Bringing some sense into the thread? is that allowed??Laugh
By:
ReaseHeath
When: 22 Feb 19 10:15
I'll have a go at explaining the speed figures...Happy

One was on the Old Course and one was on the New Course

Native River ran 1f 210y further and jumped 2 more fences (22 vs 20)

The Going Stick Readings (and the going allowances for the Raceform speed figures) suggest that Percy ran on worse ground (comparison is questionable though given they ran on different courses). Percy's performance actually compares more favourably using median times as the comparison point - 15.8 secs faster as opposed to 10.2 secs.

Apologies if it reads like I'm trying to be smart - the points I make are merely to highlight the pitfalls in trying to compare times on (essentially) different courses on different days.

I agree with your overall premise though, Hibore - I actually think Presenting Percy ran a very good speed figure - but Native River's was exceptional.

I also think there is an argument that Native River's overall preparation has actually been better this year - albeit tenuous - last year they had to hurry to get the prep race at Newbury in because he got jarred up in the previous year's Gold Cup and came in late - he ran a perfectly sound race at Haydock (they all get beaten - except Altior it seems) and I'd just put a line through the Kempton run - the track is not for him.

Swerving the race at Ascot was surely a great call - very little true evidence that he is regressing and every reason to believe that he'll run his race which takes us back to his 3rd to Sizing John 2 years ago i.e. to beat Native River one of the second season chasers/improvers will need to be as good as Sizing John was in the 2017 renewal (and even then might need a bit of help from the ground).

He'd still be favourite on m tissue (though I favour form in the book over potential, which could be lacking in imagination!)
By:
listonfp
When: 22 Feb 19 10:49
No PP tomorrow as expected. Cheltenham here we come!
By:
buddeliea
When: 22 Feb 19 12:19
Yep, non runner again.
By:
irishone
When: 22 Feb 19 12:27
People in Ireland love a bridle horse.
By:
irishone
When: 22 Feb 19 12:28
You don't see horses  coming up the hill on heavy at galway, winning on the bridle pal
By:
irishone
When: 22 Feb 19 12:30
Percy’s RSA on “soft” ground was 6 mins 32sec. 35 secs slow against standard.

Native Rivers Gold Cup on “Heavy” apparently was 7mins 3 secs. 25 secs slow against standard.

Please explain that
By:
irishone
When: 22 Feb 19 12:31
NO PROBLEM …. Johnson had diarrhoea two nights before and was understrength
By:
Hibore
When: 22 Feb 19 13:10
irishone
irishone 22 Feb 19 12:28 Joined: 22 Sep 06 | Topic/replies: 40,591
You don't see horses  coming up the hill on heavy at galway, winning on the bridle pal

Probably needs heavy ground, your right. Who did he beat ? Killutagh Vic ? That’s great form Wink
By:
impossible123
When: 22 Feb 19 15:31
As expected PP is missing this weekend (again); wish picking the Lottery numbers was as easy as predicting successive no-shows for PP over chases. Yet his price is shorter than NR despite much inferior chase form. Absolutely mind-boggling, and no doubt blarney money!
By:
foxy
When: 22 Feb 19 15:43
Killutagh vid didn’t run in the Galway race
By:
foxy
When: 22 Feb 19 15:44
Vic
By:
Hibore
When: 22 Feb 19 16:00
Was the horse that ran third an impostor then ?
By:
foxy
When: 22 Feb 19 16:03
That was gowran
By:
sixtwosix
When: 22 Feb 19 16:03
Favourite for the Gold Cup with no chasing since last festival  , not a chance this horse will win now imo.

Do we even think he will be a runner ?
By:
impossible123
When: 22 Feb 19 16:10
Stayers? He's had a better prep for that though.
By:
Hibore
When: 22 Feb 19 16:13
Sorry Foxy I thought Idiotish was going on about the last hurdle race. Don’t remember him winning on the bridle in that race so just checked.

He didn’t !
By:
foxy
When: 22 Feb 19 16:16
No worries hibore
By:
buddeliea
When: 22 Feb 19 16:18
Blimey,we are going back to October 17!! That the last time he ranLaugh.....sorry could not resist.
You right Hibore,according to Racing Post,he was ridden on the run in.
As usual Irish making things up to suit.
By:
duffy
When: 22 Feb 19 16:22
I think what we may have here is that theory about risking a horse on ground quicker than ideal and the thinking that they'll go on it once but will not if facing it again, therefore with the likelihood that the festival is going to be quicker than ideal they are keeping that experience on quicker ground for the festival itself, there's a trade off against not getting a run into him, but if that theory is a valid one then getting a run into him wouldn't matter anyway.
By:
buddeliea
When: 22 Feb 19 16:23
Do we even think he will be a runner ?

Thats a fair question Six.

I hope he does, but it would be hilarious reading this thread if he dont!
By:
foxy
When: 22 Feb 19 16:24
By the way from what I have seen of kiltutugh vic this season your right he is an imposter
By:
foxy
When: 22 Feb 19 16:26
I would discribe the Galway win as pushed out as opposed to ridden out
By:
buddeliea
When: 22 Feb 19 16:28
Well to be honest i dont recall the race, so just went on RP comments.
By:
buddeliea
When: 22 Feb 19 16:32
Duffy
That would certainly be a reason for the constant no shows,and i think you may be right.
Whatever though,its hardly an ideal prep hes had.

As a backer,how do you feel about it all?
Page 16 of 25  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | ... | 25 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com