Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Cheltenham Festival

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 994 comments are related to the topic:
PRESENTING PERCY

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 20 of 25  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | ... | 25 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 994
By:
Catch Me ifyoucan
When: 17 Mar 19 12:34
Roll on AINTREE & PUNCHESTOWN - Phillip needs some doe to pay the bills Devil
By:
FOYLESWAR
When: 17 Mar 19 14:06
i think and alluded to it at the start of the season ........last seasons gruelling gold cup may well have  left a mark on the front 2 ........havent seen nothing this season to change my mind .
By:
FOYLESWAR
When: 17 Mar 19 14:07
have seen nothing^^^^^
By:
Autocue
When: 17 Mar 19 16:55
Pat Kelly's horse looks a world beater at Cheltenham two years running and your mystery man's called a genius, then we hear he's been fined for another horse testing positive for cobalt, then his horse looks ordinary. Interesting to see what Presenting Percy does next. At least he got back to his box, unlike Invitation Only whose death was horrible. He tried to get up but his back end wouldn't work then he went down like a log.
By:
Hibore
When: 17 Mar 19 17:50
Rancid trainer. Bonkers how you can call him a genius unless Lance Armstrong is your role model.

Totally agree with you Auto regarding Invitation Only and also Sir Eric RIP.
By:
impossible123
When: 17 Mar 19 17:54
Presenting Percy is 16/1 for the Gold Cup if anyone is interested. But, my £64k question would be will he even turn up given his consistency in missing planned race engagement? If so, will he even be good enough? Notwithstanding one can be 100% certain his prep will be nothing like this season's ie non-existent.
By:
irishone
When: 17 Mar 19 18:04
Hibore exposes himself again ….

Hibore 21 Jun 18 09:21  Kelly is very astute and Presenting Percy is a very exciting Novice
Hibore 17 Mar 19 16:50  Rancid trainer. Bonkers how you can call him a genius unless Lance Armstrong is your role model.
By:
Hibore
When: 17 Mar 19 18:16
IRISH THAT LOOKS LIKE YOU ARE DEFENDING KELLY OVER DRUGGING HORSES. IS THAT CORRECT ?


Pat Kelly fined after winner returned a positive test for cobalt
Galway native trained Warendorf to win a point to point at Belclare last March

Tue, Sep 25, 2018, 17:50 Updated: Tue, Sep 25, 2018, 18:01


Drugging horses can make you look astute. Lucky Matt Chapman pointed this out as the Irish don’t mention it.
By:
Hibore
When: 17 Mar 19 18:19
Cobalt is a naturally occurring substance in horses but when administered in large quantities it is believed to increase red blood cells and improve metabolic efficiency similar to the blood doping agent EPO.
Evidence was heard at Tuesday’s Referrals Committee hearing from Dr Lynn Hillyer, the chief veterinary officer and head of anti-doping at the Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board, as well as Professor Stuart Paine from the University of Nottingham.
By:
Hibore
When: 17 Mar 19 18:39
I’m glad you have made your position on doping clear.

I’ll let the rest of the posters rip you to pieces.
By:
irishone
When: 17 Mar 19 18:41
If you check back in the thread Hibore you will see that I was the first to mention "Cobalt" on  30th August 2018. Why would anyone defend that ?

Firstimevisor
27 Aug 18 17:45
Pat Kelly has a Turf Club hearing coming up,with potentially serious consequences hanging over him.

irishone
30 Aug 18 12:13

Hes got the 2019 gold cup winner and the 2019 grand national winner and they are going to do him for cobalt ? 

So again, get yer facts right before ye go to war !
By:
irishone
When: 17 Mar 19 18:46
This all happened last SEPTEMBER by the way Hibore not last week as your post pretends .....


Pat Kelly fined after winner returned a positive test for cobalt
Galway native trained Warendorf to win a point to point at Belclare last March
Tue, Sep 25, 2018, 17:50 Updated: Tue, Sep 25, 2018, 18:01
Brian O'Connor


The Cheltenham festival winning trainer Pat Kelly has expressed disappointment with the outcome of a Referrals Committee hearing which saw him fined €1,000 after a point to point winner returned a positive test for cobalt.
Craughwell, Co. Galway based Kelly - who trains the current favourite for next year’s Cheltenham Gold Cup, Presenting Percy - trained Warendorf to win a point to point at Belclare last March.
On Tuesday a Referrals Committee hearing panel chaired by Justice Tony Hunt concluded that Warendorf’s sample contained cobalt above the international threshold and disqualified the horse.
Warendorf is the 13th winner, either on the track or in point to points, to be disqualified in Ireland this year following a testing positive for a prohibited substance.
Last week five winners were disqualified after testing positive for a variety of substances.
They included Camlann who tested positive for cobalt after winning at the Galway festival. His trainer, John ‘Shark’ Hanlon received an 18 month suspended sentence.
Cobalt is a naturally occurring substance in horses but when administered in large quantities it is believed to increase red blood cells and improve metabolic efficiency similar to the blood doping agent EPO.
Evidence was heard at Tuesday’s Referrals Committee hearing from Dr Lynn Hillyer, the chief veterinary officer and head of anti-doping at the Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board, as well as Professor Stuart Paine from the University of Nottingham.
Kelly gave evidence as did a Dr Vivian Gath from University College Dublin who gave evidence on his behalf.
The panel concluded Kelly was in breach of Rule 96(a) and noted that “two competing hypotheses had been presented by the parties.” They were satisfied though that the IHRB evidence was “sufficiently strong and scientifically based to be relied on.”
A statement added they accepted that the most probable explanation was the that horse was exposed to cobalt “proximate to race.”

The panel said the trainer was generally responsible under Rule 148 for all matters relating to the welfare, training and running of horses.
But “given certain unusual and specific aspects of the case they accepted Mr Kelly’s assurance that he had not administered anything to the horse.”
They nevertheless fined Kelly €1,000 as reasonable precautions had not been taken by him to ensure the breach didn’t occur. €3,000 costs were awarded to the IHRB.
Afterwards Kelly said: “I’m not very happy with the outcome and the process. I thought the whole case from start to finish would be held and it wasn’t. It was only really about the cobalt that the horse had in his system. How it got there I don’t know.”
He added: “Being truthfully honest about the case all the way, I didn’t think I was treated very fair. There’s a lot of things I’m not happy about. It has cost me a lot of money to fight a €100 win in a point to point, paying solicitors and barristers and experts and everything.”
Cobalt is a prohibited substance when present in concentrations above the international threshold for plasma of 25ng/ml.
Warendorf’s ‘A’ sample which was tested at the LGC laboratory in England returned a concentration of 38.8ng/ml. At Kelly’s request the ‘B’ sample was also tested and a laboratory in France returned a concentration of 38.3ng/ml.
By:
Hibore
When: 17 Mar 19 18:51
Is that meant to be your anti-doping post ?

Why are you defending him so staunchly. Facts are facts and some people hate trainers who try to cheat.
By:
irishone
When: 17 Mar 19 19:01
One question for you hibore ……..

Do you think a trainer you yourself previously labelled  "VERY ASTUTE"  would give a horse cobalt to win a point to point value one hundred pounds ?
By:
irishone
When: 17 Mar 19 19:19
And lastly just to make sure you can tell I am defending him 100%

PG KELLY HAS NEVER BEEN DONE FOR DOPING HORSES


“Given sure uncommon and particular facets of the case, they [the committee] accepted Mr Kelly’s assurance that he had not administered something to the horse. They didn’t discover adequate proof to droop the allow within the submissions earlier than them.” The €1,000 positive was essential, in line with the decision, as a result of “affordable precautions had not been taken by the handler to make sure that a breach didn’t happen”


EVERY HORSE IN THE YARD HAD LOW LEVELS OF COBALT
By:
Hibore
When: 17 Mar 19 19:24
Anti-doping chief insists Kelly was not absolved of blame over cobalt finding.

Just didn’t have a smoking gun....
By:
irishone
When: 17 Mar 19 20:16
Laugh

yeah ...probably because in your words he was "VERY ASTUTE"
By:
impossible123
When: 17 Mar 19 20:16
So the "considered" rumour about his missing planned engagement "could be" due to well-being by Geraghty on a Harvey's programme, and the comment by his owner ie let's hope he'd stay sound in the next fortnight post a gallop/work with Mall Dini and picked up by Lydia Hislop was pretty accurate as the horse was found to be lame in his right-hind post the Gold Cup.

Nevertheless, 16/1 could still tempt the naive and die-hard PP supporters next season; a double with Laurina (25/1 for the Champion Hurdle) could be life-changing if materialising.
By:
irishone
When: 17 Mar 19 20:24
The horse galloped around galway three times in the period leading up to the GC , he took several fences and came back sound. The owner was very well informed of everything. The booster was the reason for no show in the red mills , horse didnt take it well. Not an excuse ...FACT
By:
lapsy pa
When: 17 Mar 19 22:58
I "think" i know from your posts Irishone you are genuine and even still most certainly know enough about racing.

Think people are trying to score points with the average run of PP,the odds were always in their favour,excuses were there re not quite fluent and slipped saddle,it wasn't a disgrace and surely deserves at least one go at benefit of doubt imo. A way above average GC.
By:
impossible123
When: 17 Mar 19 23:58
The thing is if PP had been having niggling issues about his well-being as was with Faugheen and Penhill to name two then, I believe, the racing community esp punters need to know; there had been "rumours" for his missing planned engagements other than ground which were subsequently hinted and subtly corroborated by his owner - he did finished lame in the Gold Cup. It might not be related but it sure gave credence though.

And today, it's been reported he could even miss the remainder of the season,...aggravation of an old recurring injury perhaps.
By:
irishone
When: 18 Mar 19 02:10
Impossible you are one dopey tw4t. You need to live with a thoughbred for a week . First thing you will notice isv
By:
irishone
When: 18 Mar 19 02:15
They are nervous wrecks. Second thing is every other day they wake up with a niggle. Getting them to a race course on a certain time on a certain date without a niggle is pure genius. You have no clue about thoroughbreds , if you started reporting niggles you would soon get over whelmed and bored. These guys are touch and go, younever know where you stand.
By:
Hibore
When: 22 Mar 19 22:50
Percy 16/1 for next year’s GC must be a mistake ? Surely the best horse ever ....trained by the best trainer....and best syringe in Ireland is a steal.

Irish and Johns must be all over this looking to get another £300k bet on to lay off at 14/1 for a massive “green” again.
By:
irishone
When: 22 Mar 19 23:14
Laugh
By:
Hibore
When: 28 Dec 19 20:06
Hi Irish, what’s the lowdown after today’s race. Are we all systems go for the Gold Cup ?
By:
irishone
When: 28 Dec 19 22:05
Not about
By:
irishone
When: 28 Dec 19 22:07
Thought he done well today , certainly appears to have recovered from the injury, not around for the next few weeks so will update you before gowran.
By:
impossible123
When: 29 Dec 19 15:06
His best run yesterday ever. Will he be good enough to win the Blue Riband at Cheltenham? I'd rather think not.
By:
irishone
When: 29 Dec 19 18:00
Best run ever ? Dope !  His galway win was better....
By:
penzance
When: 29 Dec 19 19:09
what that race where he beat De Plotting Shed?
Don't you mean the Fairyhouse win?
By:
irishone
When: 29 Dec 19 23:04
No i mean the gakway ones. The maiden hurdle was pure class. The day he beat de ploting shed and maldini he was also pure class, mainly because he took over in an absolute bog and stayed on up the hill. Clueless idiocy saying saville was his best run ever after either of those runs let alone the rsa ..... No doubt fueled by some defunct weight rating system
By:
miltons sophie
When: 30 Dec 19 07:16
Or put another way winning despite and not because of conditions/circumstances is one way of evaluating performance and much as I think this is significant I can’t help thinking strength of opposition is also pretty blooming important.but in essence I agree taking a black and white view of ratings is the quickest way to the poor house. They are however useful and directional.
By:
Hibore
When: 30 Dec 19 08:43
Morning Line on Saturday.

Oil Bell - “Is the enigma of PP outweigh the substance of his form at top level”
Chapman “I’m not sure he quite as good as we all want him to be”

That about sums him up.
By:
impossible123
When: 30 Dec 19 10:32
An acquired taste for the uninitiated and diehard supporters. Everyone is vulnerable to the odd emotive imperfection, I guess. Each to his/her won.
By:
irishone
When: 30 Dec 19 12:20
Would help if yer cud spell pwoperly
By:
impossible123
When: 04 Jan 20 14:25
Could he side-step the Gold Cup as connections were a touch underwhelmed with his performance in the Savills Chase? He was fit and well still not good enough spoke volume, I firmly believe.

Where could he go if ducking the Gold Cup? Ryanair is very unlikely, 4m Chase?
By:
Hibore
When: 10 Jan 20 16:36
Going over hurdles as prep again. Galmoy hurdle as last year where he can beat the likes of Killutagh Vic again.
I’m not sure which is hyped up more...the horse or the trainer. Kelly has had 88 runners without a winner since Percy winning that race last year.
Why would you have a horse with him ?
By:
foxy
When: 10 Jan 20 17:36
Great news for the paying public who are going to Gowran that day regardless of what anybody thinks about his ability he is a horse the crowd like to see.
By:
foxy
When: 10 Jan 20 17:52
22 winners in 5 years surprisingly joint top course is Cheltenham.
Page 20 of 25  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | ... | 25 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com