Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Cheltenham Festival

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 1360 comments are related to the topic:
champion hurdle 2017

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 25 of 35  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | ... | 35 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 1,360
By:
duffy
When: 26 Feb 17 23:21
They need to strap Wylie to a chair in a dark room, shove a tele in front of him and play on a continuous loop last year's Neptune pointing out how the horse is absolutely pulling Walsh's arms out into the home bend!!!, not over the first couple hurdles!! but after 2 miles +, then point out the acceleration to win the race in a few seconds and then explain to him that that is what a proper champion looks like.Grin
By:
geoff m
When: 26 Feb 17 23:22
DuffyLaughLaughLaughLaugh
Stevie Wonder text me after Neptune and said get on for the CHampion
By:
firstimevisor
When: 26 Feb 17 23:23
Yorkhill will run in the JLT. Mullins will have very decent chances of winning the race with Limini and Footpad and possibly one or 2 others.They will go there with proper chances in a race that any one of about twelve can win. Its easy to see how Tombstone is now going there as well - there's nothing between any of them and this will be reflected in the betting on the day. I could see Yanworth going off around 4-1 fav with about 10 others at 12-1 or less.
By:
geoff m
When: 26 Feb 17 23:41
the above 1st time makes all the more reason why they should switch to the CHampion. In view of Mullins comments(and the way things of panned out) why would they then wait to look to switch to hurdles /champion route next year.
Hes hardly thinking lets take the JLT bag that then come back to the champion next year. If bouvoiur Dair(switch back) can do it whom Yorkhill would have been fav to beat in the JLT and the 2nd fav Yanworth for champion Yorkhill travelled over him pulling Rubys arms out aint going to get a better oppourtunity.
If Yorkhill is a died in the wool chaser why did Mullins even bother mentioning the prospect of Champion Hurdle for him 5 or 6 weeks back?
By:
duffy
When: 26 Feb 17 23:52
Limini running in the CH and Yorkhill running in the JLT is a bit like a football manager playing Andy Sinton in the Champion's League Final and keeping Cristiano Ronaldo back for the Checkatrade TrophyCrazy
By:
firstimevisor
When: 27 Feb 17 00:04
Mullins just mentioned that he always thought the horse was champion hurdle material,as in he's good enough to win one (he's often said the same about Douvan) and people lost the run of themselves.

I don't think we'll see Buveur D'air over fences again. If Yorkhill were to struggle with his fencing over the Spring then he could go back hurdling with him next year but, for now, its all about chasing and getting experience and a JLT would be a great pointer to a Gold Cup next year.
By:
geoff m
When: 27 Feb 17 00:06
Willies left his foot in the door knowing what was apertaining with his existing champion hurdlers the door aint fully closed yet.
By:
sageform
When: 27 Feb 17 07:43
With at least one of the Henderson runners in the CH to ride following a leading contender in the Supreme and then Altior and Must Bite, I have just had a speculative bet on Nico de Boinville to be top jockey at the meeting. Fingers crossed he at least gets there. He may also get some of the other Henderson rides owned by JP.
By:
buddeliea
When: 27 Feb 17 07:56
Absolutely no chance of Yorkhill in the CH......not now that I have joined the bandwagon and invested in Yorkhill on here(32)was 80 I believe since then! such a shrewdie I amLaugh

Much more realistic I think is that we would know by now,as I believe he would have had a spin over hurdles before Cheltenham.
The face that aint happened tells me they are determined to stay chasing, and get as much experience at it for Gold Cup aspirations.
By:
impossible123
When: 27 Feb 17 09:03
Yorkhill has not had a race over fences either - boy, he needs it more in this discipline - since his none-too-convincing display in his last victory; he could have a racecourse gallop on top of the many schooling/spins at home prior to this race (if supplemented).

I believe his Gold Cup aspiration will not be inconvenienced one iota if he goes chasing post Cheltenham on evidence seen so far.
By:
buddeliea
When: 27 Feb 17 12:11
He has had races over fences this season though.

His GC chances will be inconvenienced if he does not get enough experience, and does seem he needs it.

This, as said before(a few times now),is down to Wylie wanting a GC horse, must be.
Otherwise he would have already reverted to hurdles imo.
By:
Jb23
When: 27 Feb 17 12:21
Sounds like Limini will be supplemented for the CH judging from various comments emerging from Mullins media day. I can't believe her jumping hasnt been bought into question on here. If Yanworth is crabbed for the way he hurdles, then I think its perfectly reasonable to hold the same standard to Limini and question her hurdling ability.  Didn't Ricci mention that they were planning to run her on the flat because of her jumping? Pretty sure she was a long time antepost favourite for the Ascot Stakes at Royal Ascot.

Found this quote from Willie from between Cheltenham & Aintree: "Every time we work her at home, she shows us she's a good mare....Her jumping has improved all the time and I thought she was slick enough today on only her third run....She's plenty of stamina and lots of speed. The only thing I was worried about was her jumping but she did it easily enough."

For me, upon rewatching the Aintree race, she didn't seem to jump massively well their either. Obviously last weeks performance seemed to be considerably better however I think for all Yanworth is rightly or wrongly criticised for his jumping, the same could easily be said for Limini
By:
firstimevisor
When: 27 Feb 17 13:01
There's nothing much wrong with Yorkhill's jumping, other than he tends to jump out left. He did this over hurdles as well. He has only run twice over fences. He's entitled to make a few novicey mistakes.They all do and this is why there is a novice season...they are learning. Surely you don't believe Graham Wylie would make decisions as whether to go chasing or stay hurdling? These decisions are made only by the man who knows best and Wylie is quite happy with that.
By:
Goretski
When: 27 Feb 17 13:07
Surely you don't believe Graham Wylie would make decisions as whether to go chasing or stay hurdling? These decisions are made only by the man who knows best and Wylie is quite happy with that.

Surely you don't think Willie decides 1st time???
By:
firstimevisor
When: 27 Feb 17 13:14
Of course he does
By:
Graeme83
When: 27 Feb 17 13:16
Nichols Canyon will probably miss festival for punchestown.
By:
impossible123
When: 27 Feb 17 13:21
The 2018 Gold Cup could include Douvan - a baptism of fire! I just cannot see that happening.

As a matter of interest does JP McManus have any horses with Mullins? If so, his best present inmate at Closutton, please - I cannot recall if he has or not.
By:
Goretski
When: 27 Feb 17 13:23
Not a hope in hell does he! Theres no chance Wylie signs a cheque for a €100K+ lets say, pays the weekly fees and says to Willie best of luck with that one! hope he wins a decent prize for ya!
By:
FOYLESWAR
When: 27 Feb 17 13:26
he has got blu et rouge ,cant think of any more off hand
By:
impossible123
When: 27 Feb 17 13:33
Cheers 'Foyleswar', only one noteworthy - I wonder why. Even O'Brien junior has more than one,...a better trainer than Mullins or put-off by Mullins' exorbitant training fee...maybe pecking order - politics and nepotism, even in horse racing.
By:
firstimevisor
When: 27 Feb 17 13:36
Holy sh1t Goretski do you really think Graham Wylie makes the decisions? He's a businessman living in Yorkshire. He knows nothing about horses.But he's a good and gracious owner who doesn't interfere which is exactly as it should be and he gets fantastic results.
By:
Goretski
When: 27 Feb 17 13:49
Im not saying he makes the decisions solely but theres no chance Willie makes them solely either regarding his horses....If he did Yorkhill would be favourite and running in CH and not the JLT. He doesn't need to know anything about horses thats what he invests in and pays Mullins for!
By:
firstimevisor
When: 27 Feb 17 13:58
Your last sentence is 100% correct Goretski. The one in the middle appears to suggest that WPM is opposed to running Yorkhill in the JLT which makes no sense at all. Don't know where you are getting this from but if there's any truth to it then he won't run in it, guaranteed.
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 27 Feb 17 13:59
Goretski. Willie makes all the decisions. I actually had a chat with Graham Wylie a few years ago and he says he does exactly what Willie tells him. He has very minimal input to targets / plans.

Its like this at most of the biggest yards.
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 27 Feb 17 14:00
Impossible. JP doesnt have more with Willie because he likes to be more involved in plans and what the horses do. And Willie wont entertain this. He decides what his horses do.
By:
firstimevisor
When: 27 Feb 17 14:02
Spot on CCM
By:
Goretski
When: 27 Feb 17 14:17
My point was on numerous occasions Mullins has said he could see Yorkhill as a CH horse. So if he calls the shots well then why wasn't he even given a speculative entry
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 27 Feb 17 14:25
Just because he could see the horse as a potential CH horse, it doesn't mean he thinks thats the best route for the horse. The horse is a class act and could possibly win a CH or go to the top of the Chasing game. Remember Willie hasnt won a GC yet.. its the big gap in his CV, so Im sure hes keen to have as many potential bullets for it as possible.

Im pretty sure Douvan could win the CH stood on his head this year, but he will stay chasing.

They made the decision to go chasing at the start of the season, and are sticking with it. I think its a case of trying to balance what is best for each individual horse, and the stable overall.
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 27 Feb 17 14:31
And Im absolutely convinced that if Willie Mullins wants Yorkhill in the CH, he will put him there.

Wylie isnt going to argue with having the fav for that race is he? Wylie will agree with whatever Willie wants.
By:
geoff m
When: 27 Feb 17 14:46
if Wylie was saying he thinks Yorkhills a Champion Hurdle horse and Mullins saying hes a chaser going for the JLt yhen 1.001 its going JlT
Its the other way round and i reckon its 50/50  whether he does get supplemented not to difficult to give it a  few spins over hurdles @ home and to all intent and purposes thats all Buveur Dair did @ Sandown.
If?? hes is supplemented hes 3/1  /7/2 fav
By:
delsie777
When: 27 Feb 17 14:50
JP has several with WPM - Great Field. Blazer. Bon Papa. Castella Sforza. Blu Et Rouge to name a few
By:
Sankara
When: 27 Feb 17 15:10
Mullins didn't choose where his Gigginstown horses ran.
By:
buddeliea
When: 27 Feb 17 16:58
Well it all makes sense now if Wylie is not the one pushing for a Gold Cup horse.
If it is Mullins doing what it seems he normally does...... whats best for the stable and his jockey,then I can see the JLT angle.
Pretty sure the horse would rather go for the CH,as he does not seem to be natural at the fences as yet,and I imagine his owner would love a CH winner.

Oh well,its not like we have not seen this before!!!
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 27 Feb 17 17:17
Full Limini quote:

I went to Punchestown questioning whether I was mad to run her there, as it was hard to see her not having a hard race with Apple’s Jade in there. With just three weeks to Cheltenham that would be far from ideal, so I debated whether I should take her out of the race or not. I just hoped it wouldn’t turn into a slog and everything fell into place for her. I was very happy with how well she settled and jumped. While I thought she had improved based on homework, I wasn’t sure she had improved that much and that leads you to question whether Apple’s Jade ran up to her form. However, more important is that Limini didn’t have a hard race and has come out of it well. We haven’t made a decision on her Cheltenham target yet, but I’d say it’s 50/50 between the Champion Hurdle and the Mares’ Hurdle. I had a quick chat with Rich and we both said we wouldn’t chat much more about it until the morning when she would have to be supplemented for the Champion Hurdle. A lot depends on how Vroum Vroum Mag is between now and then too, but the more I think about, if Vroum Vroum is fine and sparkling, we might take a punt with Limini and run in the Champion Hurdle.
By:
buddeliea
When: 27 Feb 17 17:23
So basically he thinks VVM will win the Mares if fit.
Well they obviously aint interested in 1st and 2nd in the mares,so that sorts out Limini for the CH.
VVM not fine and sparkling,then Limini in the Mares.
All will be revealed supplement day.

Not that I will be that bothered re my CH bets.
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 27 Feb 17 17:26
I'm comfortable with that. Can see some greed kicking in though with a small stakes double on Limini/VVM if they go that route now Excited
By:
sageform
When: 27 Feb 17 18:26
Yanworth now clear favourite.
By:
trigger3
When: 27 Feb 17 21:35
I don't have an issue with Mullins sending either of Limini or VVM to the CH, in fact I welcome it even though I believe neither are good enough.

However, Id also ask the question as to why a far superior animal like Yorkhill appears not to be considered for a top championship race in favour of a novice race at an intermediate distance. To my mind Yorkhill would have a favourites chance of winning the race, whereas I don't see any way either of the 2 Ricci mares can win it.
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 27 Feb 17 21:37
Limini has got a right chance in the champ, rated 145 before her run with Apples at the weekend, she put her away with ease, distance was 2 lengths but there was room for a lot more. Apples is 153, this puts Limini at 155+, given mares get a 7ib allowance in it, this puts her to 162, Yanworth is 164 so she only really has a couple pounds to find with the race fav
I'm quite happy with my 20/1 thank you
By:
trigger3
When: 27 Feb 17 21:41
I'd be happy enough being on at 20/1 myself, it depends on whether you consider AJ to have ran up to her rating last time out. To my mind it would take a huge leap of faith to consider Limini has improved that much after a long lay off.
Page 25 of 35  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | ... | 35 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com