Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Cheltenham Festival

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 1360 comments are related to the topic:
champion hurdle 2017

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 24 of 35  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | ... | 35 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 1,360
By:
shockster
When: 26 Feb 17 11:54
Limini is long odds on IMO to be supplemented.  Ricci/Mullins will want a runner (Why wouldn't they) and pretty sure they know VVM ain't quick enough and she's got the Mares covered in their book, so it seems a no brainer to me.

However, still happy myself with Brain Power and Buveur D'air.  All ground conditions covered with those 2.
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 26 Feb 17 12:13
And why wouldn't Yorkhill be supplemented if Limini was? I don't understand they are different owners and don't give me this carp about pecking orders please i can't be bothered
By:
wellchief
When: 26 Feb 17 13:30
Limini is a good hurdler going for a much higher quality hurdle race and I assume Limini's career will be kept over hurdles, so it makes sense.

I still don't like horses getting supplemented last minute but its the rules of the game.

Yorkhill is a future Gold Cup runner so if they have confidence that he will make it to that level over that trip then why deviate? Same goes with Altior and Douvan; if there futures are over fences then that's where they should be kept and not going back to hurdles.

Jack of all trades springs to mind if constant switching between codes.
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 26 Feb 17 13:35
Spot on chief.

There is absolutely no chance they switch Yorkhill now.
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 26 Feb 17 13:49
Understand all that and thanks for answering the question with a rational and educated explanation. Not that i would expect anything less from two of the most trusted and respected forumites on this forum.

Just can't get out of my head why anyone would think that just because one horse was supplemented another from a different owner wouldn't, it's just ridiculous and stupid assumption to make. I can only put my finger on anyones reasoning for thinking this via pocket talking. Just ridiculous.

Kinda the same as saying this race has lost all of it's class because we don't have a horse at a stupidly short price in it.

I am a huge believer that horses are only as good as their last race and rarely come back from injury with the same level of ability. I rarely back horses that do this in championship races, unless the price is right and it is rarely right i.e Sprinter Sacre 25/1 last season e.g had Faugheen been a similar price in Sept/Oct, i would have played.
By:
ReaseHeath
When: 26 Feb 17 13:57

Feb 26, 2017 -- 3:19AM, wellchief wrote:


Re Petit and Nichols Canyon.Just a couple of months ago, Nichols beat Jers Girl (146) by a very easy 12 lengths giving 10 pounds. That's a solid mid to low 160's performance right there.Jers I admit has been a bit disappointing this year and is better over a bit further, but in no way did Nichols look like he'd regressed, he ran well to form, if not better.He is then well and truly stuffed by Petit twice, and the assumption is that he's all of a sudden regressed and the form isn't worth anything? Based on what? Could it not be that he was simply beaten by a better horse but is still a very good 2miler in his own right? He was third in the CH last year.I like that people are ignoring Petit, hopefully he'll go out another few points for a tasty ew price.


This post deserves another outing, every word makes great sense...

By:
geoff m
When: 26 Feb 17 14:41
Tombstone to be supplemented. A waste of supplementary fee imo but its oleary who whinges @ a £5 a week training increase @ MullinsLaughLaugh
By:
Jb23
When: 26 Feb 17 14:58
My speculative fiver at 120s on Tombstone after beating Jezki looks a little better now! Swings and roundabouts of antepost punting eh
By:
buddeliea
When: 26 Feb 17 15:14
Nice one jb,wish you luck
By:
tomdeane
When: 26 Feb 17 15:16
Re Petit and Nichols Canyon.Just a couple of months ago, Nichols beat Jers Girl (146) by a very easy 12 lengths giving 10 pounds. That's a solid mid to low 160's performance right there.Jers I admit has been a bit disappointing this year and is better over a bit further, but in no way did Nichols look like he'd regressed, he ran well to form, if not better.He is then well and truly stuffed by Petit twice, and the assumption is that he's all of a sudden regressed and the form isn't worth anything? Based on what? Could it not be that he was simply beaten by a better horse but is still a very good 2miler in his own right? He was third in the CH last year.I like that people are ignoring Petit, hopefully he'll go out another few points for a tasty ew price.

This is of course totally possible but my concern would be Nichols Canyon at Leopardstown. He hasn't looked happy at that venue for some time to me.

That said, I like Petit Mouchoir and think he is the one approaching a value price at the front of the market. He looks pretty uncomplicated, has a gear, and seems very honest. I suppose you'd be ever so slightly concerned that Gigginstown have supplemented Tombstone though...
By:
ReaseHeath
When: 26 Feb 17 15:31
that crossed my mind about Tombstone but it could just be that they want two in the race and Apple's Jade clearly is n't going to make the cut. King, Henderson, Mullins will all have 2 runners or more as will Munir & Suede and JPM from an ownership perspective. It can't do any harm tactically.

Petit Mouchoir will want a strong gallop in all probability but not sure you would want to be trying to make all in a Champion Hurdle, I've no idea about the tactics at this stage in truth but it gives them more flexibility.
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 26 Feb 17 16:35
I thought the same about the supplementing of Tombstone ref PM, but there is a lot of prize money up for grabs in an open year. The fact it's so open must have been a factor as well.
By:
wellchief
When: 26 Feb 17 18:25
Surprised at the Tombstone decision. He only went up a pound for his Jezki win, so not as if that blew his handicap mark.

A long way short imo and not one that I could back between 8 and 16/1 anyway.
By:
buddeliea
When: 26 Feb 17 18:38
So who will ride BD and Yanworth now??
By:
Goretski
When: 26 Feb 17 18:40
Chief...i'd say Tombstone's handicap mark would have been mid 150's by the time Mr. Smith had his say. Horse is obviously fit and well and nowhere else for him to go really.. I know Elliot really rates the beast and in an open year when he wasn't that far behind the current fav in last years supreme i can see why connections are having a go, that said i can't see them throwing him in and the supplementry fee away for the craic!!
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 26 Feb 17 18:47
Budd. Guess Fehily will ride BD a squad he has ridden the horse several times before. As he has UKWIMH.
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 26 Feb 17 18:47
* as he has
By:
buddeliea
When: 26 Feb 17 19:35
Well Hendo does like Fehily. and like you say hes ridden him plenty of times.
Mark Walsh on Yanworth?
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 26 Feb 17 20:19
Yeah maybe mate. Can't think of anyone else who would be ahead of him.
By:
ReaseHeath
When: 26 Feb 17 20:23
which leaves MTOY. Happy

Nico? Coleman? Richard Johnson?
By:
jedi sophie
When: 26 Feb 17 20:25
Prefer Johnson on Yanworth me!
By:
unclepuncle
When: 26 Feb 17 20:29
McCoy to come out of retirement.Devil
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 26 Feb 17 20:49
Suppose Johnson will ride Defi Du Seuil.
By:
buddeliea
When: 26 Feb 17 20:50
Yeh,I would like Johnson on Yanworth too.
By:
wellchief
When: 26 Feb 17 21:40
Cheers Goretski, saw on the RP he is now 148 after that run but didn't realise they are reevaluated before the festival.

Makes sense then if he has gone/will go too high up the handicap
By:
impossible123
When: 26 Feb 17 21:41
I hope JP will allow his trainers the choice of jockeys instead of Mark Walsh taking over Geraghty's rides at Cheltenham - he lacks the experience here to assume the role of Geraghty solely.
By:
jedi sophie
When: 26 Feb 17 21:43
I agree 123!
By:
tomdeane
When: 26 Feb 17 21:57
Experience is important at Cheltenham, I admit, but Mark Walsh is one of the best jockeys in the game, and he's riding out of his skin at present.
By:
ReaseHeath
When: 26 Feb 17 22:04
I would think they'd be pragmatic. Mark Walsh will surely partner most of the ones based in Ireland because he's probably ridden many of them before. Equally some of the available jockeys based in UK will have ridden some of the JPM horses based here when Barry was n't available or there were two in a race.

Perhaps Mark Walsh does n't quite have Barry's seniority to have first pick every time there is more than one runner? McCoy is on the JP team these days so surely he'll have an input on jockey bookings.

You might find Aidan Coleman on a lot of the Jonjo trained JP horses.
By:
geoff m
When: 26 Feb 17 22:05
Johnson would be ideal for Yanworth. Obvious choice

Will WIllie supplement Renneti cruised all over tombstone @  Navan after giving lengths away early doors ran a stormeragainst Sutton Place despite giving huge amount of ground away. Serious horse if he could get away with them
By:
geoff m
When: 26 Feb 17 22:19
I think a few more twists and turns to come before the curtain goes up
Out of the 25 currently in the Betfair market can only see about 10 that are definite runners barring injury etc
Which will surely be tempting for some others even tho they are currently  huge prices due to doubt about participation to throw their hat back into the ring
Jezki a prime example on better ground
By:
impossible123
When: 26 Feb 17 22:28
Mark Walsh is without doubt a good up-and-coming jockey however, he is inexperienced over here and not ridden most if not all of the supposed goodies for Cheltenham.
By:
duffy
When: 26 Feb 17 22:28
Why would Yorkhill being supplemented for the CH preclude him from realizing GC pretensions in the future? In any case, doesn't he also realize that the CH is probably an easier option than the JLT for a horse that certainly hasn't set the world alight in the jumping stakes as of yet.
By:
geoff m
When: 26 Feb 17 22:33
Wonder if Wylie will follow the Ricci route of Yorkhill goes for JLT or stays @ home @ Cheltenham PreviewsLaughLaughLaughLaughLaugh
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 26 Feb 17 22:41
I'm not sure Mark Walsh would be described as 'up and coming'.
By:
impossible123
When: 26 Feb 17 22:45
Absolutely, taking in this race has no bearing on Yorkhill's 2018 Gold Cup aspiration if connections so wish. Also, Mullins knows Yorkhill is the only horse in his yard that can serve it up to the present probable runners here; the JLT pales into insignificance in comparison to this race. I think he'll be supplemented (eventually).
By:
duffy
When: 26 Feb 17 22:55
Basically speaking, if Mullins wants a runner, run Limini, if he wants a contender, convince Wylie to run Yorkhill.
By:
geoff m
When: 26 Feb 17 22:55
That would turn the market on its head.
He would be fav imo.
Which then begs the question why would they go elsewhere.
Why he hasnt been campaigned down the champion hurdle route no doubt down to the fact Willie thought he would get Annie and or Faugheen back. Mullins initial reaction  after last years Neptune was Yorkhill was a potential champion hurdler and reiterated that @ the time when he said he wouldnt be afraid of Annie meeting Faugheen a few weeks back when probably knowing damn well that wasnt going to happen. Mullins has opened the door for the oppourtunity i cant recall anywhere whe has closed it Wylie can bail out and let Willie and Ruby get him off the hook as i type this i think 55s is massive im going in with some non runner field money. Heres hoping
By:
duffy
When: 26 Feb 17 22:58
Said earlier that Yorkhill's price has lengthened (from the 20/30's that it had been hovering around for the past few weeks) since Limini's win the other day, since it's looking like that that would be the stable runner.
By:
geoff m
When: 26 Feb 17 23:15
Hes the only horse other than Douvan that Mullins could honestly say i think hed have a right chance in the Champion. Limini may have a chance of grabbing a place (as so many have in this race)but canna see her winning
Page 24 of 35  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | ... | 35 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com