Forums

Cheltenham Festival

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 149 comments are related to the topic:
Is the Gold Cup between Kauto Star and Long Run

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 2 of 4  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 149
By:
booster
When: 04 Jan 12 22:39
Thanks, just found the same on Racing Post website. It's impossible to compare the 2 horses but I think he's up to winning off that mark and it's definitely more common for a top class horse to win big handicaps off a high weight than used to be the case when they would trot round in races like The Mandarin Chase at Newbury (before it changed to a handicap) and the races at Sandown and Wincanton in February which were always the recognised Gold Cup trials.
By:
strontium
When: 04 Jan 12 23:09
See your point, but who was the last horse to win the RP Chase off a mark as high as 159? I think 152 is the highest in the last 15 years?
By:
tomdeane
When: 05 Jan 12 00:19
It would certainly depend how good the field is but I suspect they think he is a fair chunk better than 159.

Nacarat was a half-length second in the race off 158 fairly recently, so doesn't seem insurmountable.
By:
booster
When: 05 Jan 12 17:28
Strontium, I've not checked but believe you're probably right about handicap marks of recent winners but who'd want to take him on off 159? I could see it being an unusually small field and some of the similarly rated horses going for conditions races instead. He gave Big Buck's a good race in The World Hurdle and he's well over 20lbs ahead of 159.Even in a big field his cruising speed and fast jumping would be great assets. The horse I think could give him a race who's rated mid 150s is Jessie's Dream if Elliott decides to come over for that race.
By:
strontium
When: 05 Jan 12 17:50
Sure he's well in, but I doubt by 20 lbs at this stage - Maybe 7-10. And it doesn't matter that he's well handicapped if there's something better handicapped lower in the weights, which is always a chance in a race like this.

I think he's unlikely to go for the RP chase anyway, not because of any handicap issue but because it's only 3 weeks before the Festival and they probably want to run him in the Argento to see how he stacks up against Grade 1 or 2 quality horses.

Incidentally, I've read that Jessies is likley to come over the Aon on Feb 11th - if so I guess he's unlikley for the RP chase.
By:
R Carver
When: 05 Jan 12 18:18
159 sounds good but I think it would be foolish to run off (probably) top weight in that and potentially throw away a tilt at the festival or a race at the festival. I recall it took the edge off Rooster Booster and Baracouda a few yrs back (they did have more miles on the clock, of course). Why tilt at a rich handicap now when they could have yrs of fun at the top level with this horse? I also think Gloria was 6 when he won the RP Chase off top weight, whereas I think Grands Crus is 7.

Btw, are people saying 159 is an under-assessment based on known chase form, or are people factoring potential in?
By:
R Carver
When: 05 Jan 12 18:26
My point about Gloria Victis' age being only to highlight the merit of that run off 11st 10 and winning by 10l and giving 15lbs to Marlborough - who 6 weeks later was a stylish winner of the William Hill, later won a handicap off 150, a Charlie Hall, a RP Chase aged 12 off 150 giving 18lbs and a beating to track lover Gunther McBride and was placed in a King George and Gold Cup and won a Gold Cup replacement!! Solid form!!
By:
strontium
When: 05 Jan 12 18:44
RC - short term potential in my case. He may end up being way better than 159 after another season.

I actually think it's very hard to rate his form accuratley. His beating of Champion Court in his first chase now looks very good. His narrow beating of Sonofvic does not! And in the Feltham he won in impressive looking style, but in the end he's beaten the mighty Silvianco Conti 2 l (which ties him in closely with Cue Card  and Michael Flips on one reading of the form). In fact, I'm not persuaded he has the best form of the 3 m novice chasers - that could be Join Together (who is also only 2 lb lower on OR).
By:
R Carver
When: 05 Jan 12 19:13
I agree Strontium that at the end of next yr, all being well, he'll be rated much higher. I think this yr I would go for the Newbury novice on AON day, then head for a novice race at the Festival with a view to ensuring next yr they have a horse to throw against Long Run and (rising 13!) Kauto.

I think the pick of his form is very good and the impression he has made so far is second to none. His hurdles is top draw. For me his beating of Sonofvic is pretty good, under a penalty, because I think that horse will turn out to be very good (i'd disregard his latest run, and have no problems following him over fences all things being equal in the future. The Dipper was only his 4th run (I think) under rules)). He looked much the best in the Feltham under an unnecesarilly aggressive ride (did the horse take him to the front or did Scu elect to take it up that early?) - I think Siviniaco is a very nice horse who had a perfect prep at Wincanton (simialrish tracks for me) and whilst Bobs Worth would now need a stiffer track than Kempton (he was IMO flat to the boards the whole way) he is clearly a really decent horse. I think at this stage the horse has rock solid form and looks to have bags and bags of scope. I'd not swap him for any novice at this stage. As a purist it would be great to see him bolt up at Kempton but with an eye to the future, I'd probably elect to take the softest option at this stage.
By:
booster
When: 05 Jan 12 22:17
Just a couple of replies, I'd say the 159 rating is potentially good based on what he's likely to do given how good he was over hurdles and the future improvement with maturity and his ability to jump fences at speed although I think he may be better over shorter. The 20lbs I mentioned was in relation to Big Buck's hurdle rating and I fully accept that he's a superior hurdler.

The Pipe's do like The Racing Post Chase and The RSA Chase can be as tough a race as The Gold Cup, it's full of horses who looked top class but didn't go on and often requires an out and out stayer. Cooldine the last one I can recall immediately but we all know the record of winners isn't generally good in relation to the Gold Cup. Denman may have been an exception but he was an exception to most things.
By:
strontium
When: 05 Jan 12 22:19
Sorry Booster, I had misunderstood your comment about 20 lbs.
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 06 Jan 12 15:10
Meanwhile back to the title of this thread i have just topped up on LR and KS again today, intend to do this every week till the prices get chopped to too short! 11/4 LR (3.6 on here) and 4/1 KS is still good imo especially as their bigger than on here and theres more than 5k wanting to back KS even with still 10 weeks to go!
By:
R Carver
When: 07 Jan 12 15:49
I think we saw a possibly player today in Ireland too.
By:
brandyontherocks
When: 07 Jan 12 16:46
lets hope so carver

even tho last seasons novices (who i like to look at for the gold cup) have been poor so far this term quel esprit is still unexposed
he was still travelling well in the RSA when coming down, and was running away with the novice race at punchestown before being bought down
i like the way mullins has campaigned him this term.  not bottoming him out in slogs. running him over shorter trips, at a quicker pace to iron out any jumping issues. 
he won as he liked today and we will see next time out if he is a genuine gold cup contender
By:
R Carver
When: 07 Jan 12 16:51
Totally agre with all of that Brandy. The RSA was dreadful, but he was not IMO finished with (far from it) when coming to grief. I still think Time For Rupert can rebuild his reputation, and thnk he proobably ran very well at Cheltenham given he was not right in March. I'd also forgive Wetherby and Haydock too, given those tracks would be about as far from ideal as possible for this giant of a horse!
By:
brandyontherocks
When: 07 Jan 12 17:04
funny enough quel esprit and time for rupert were the 2 horses i backed at the start of the season
took a risk with rupert considering the trainer/jockey combination but half of that has been sorted out. i agree those 2 tracks would not play to his strengths but am concerned that the problem he had at the end of last term are behind him yet
By:
buddeliea
When: 07 Jan 12 17:27
QE could end up in Ryanair the way hes being campaigned,have taken some big odds in case.
His jumping this season has been very good,if that continues hes a player in his chosen race i feel.
By:
strontium
When: 07 Jan 12 17:46
Next run will be the Irish Hennessey I think, which should sort out the trip question. But it's certainly yet to be proven that he stays. Clearly his jumping is getting better, but he still has to prove he can jump when put under pressure. He's a very short pric for the Gold Cup imo with so much doubt around him.
By:
shockster
When: 07 Jan 12 18:16
There are too many questions to answer before backing Quel Esprit.  He could even go for a festival handicap, Ryanair or Gold cup. Possible he will be competitive in all, but which one.  Appreciate if he runs in Irish Hennessy and goes close then his handicap mark will be blown, but on todays jog round it can't go up much.
By:
denman85
When: 07 Jan 12 18:19
whatever race he goes for, one thing is for certain he'll end up on the floor, this horse cant jump
By:
brandyontherocks
When: 07 Jan 12 18:21
couldn't disagree more ^^^
By:
harry callaghan
When: 07 Jan 12 18:42
Denman 85 and Strontium..I totally agree he is not a fluent fencer and can't have him jumping well in decent grade...2 odds on wins against poor opponents and on bad ground still haven't convinced me about his jumping at speed on good ground...(he is not fluent) If he goes to the Irish Hennessy he wouldn't be without a chance however with the Irish staying chasers looking so moderate...in regards to cheltenham it is going to be heart in the mouth stuff for his followers...that is guaranteed.
By:
brandyontherocks
When: 07 Jan 12 23:26
very surprised you say that harry, as i know you watch a lot of video form

if you watch his 2 novice championship races at chelt and punch his jumping was very fluent and neat

especially at chelt he winged most jumps and the couple he got in close to he corrected himself quickly. the reason he pulled himself to the front so early in the race was because of his brilliant jumping

i think people are saying/guessing he is a dodgy jumper is because he has got a couple of F's next to his name.watch him again and see what you think.   an excellent 95-1 shot me thinks
By:
buddeliea
When: 08 Jan 12 08:31
Correct,

He jumped well in the RSA,yes he fell near the finish,but even the best jumpers can fall.His 2 runs this season he has hardly put a foot wrong and no way would i dismiss him cos of his jumping.
For me its a case of which race,but then hes been a big price for the GC and Ryanair,so ive backed him for both on here.
This horse i feel has got some real class,and i am quiet glad to have him on my side,especially at the prices that have been available.
Personally feel the Ryanair is more suited to him this season,think he would appreciate the shorter distance at this stage of his career before maybe stepping up next season.
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 08 Jan 12 10:30
The thing i would be worried about with backing him for both is that not one bookie in the country has him priced up for the Ryanair but he is available at 40s (hills and sj) for the GC and is priced up by all firms for that. Being as he is 40 on here for the GC and 40/1 at books i would imagine at this stage it is the GC he is being aimed for! Though admittedly he is only 36 for the Ryanair which baffles me as to why no books have him priced up for that race, could it just be that people are taking the small amounts getting offered by layers whom have big smiles on their faces as respect to this, i do tend to always go with the exchanges/books when trying to second guess where one will run at the festival as regards to antepost bets and it is not often wrong!
By:
buddeliea
When: 08 Jan 12 10:41
well i have 80 for the Gold Cup,and 54 for the Ryanair,so yes i have lost out on one,but at those prices i wont have lost a lot as my stake can be lower.
I only backed him for the Ryanair when i saw the distance of races he was running in,made sense to me,although where he ends up is anyones guess,and with Mullins its likely we wont know for a while yet.
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 08 Jan 12 10:47
I am about to nip out and have a little tickle on Quel and Burton Port for the GC both at 40s. Wont be backing Quel for the ryanair at all and if it is that race he goes for, well ive lost a point and i can justify it, he would be good enough to sneak a place in the GC imo. But then so is most of the field and is the reason why i like to sweep up all of these big prices at this stage as you always end up with most of the field backed at well under 100% making a nice profit in the mean time, god i love cheltenham in march! Crazy
By:
harry callaghan
When: 08 Jan 12 14:13
Well Brandy you said it, he is a 95-1 shot...I do watch a lot of video form and have watched him closely this season and he still is not fluent...That isn't to say he hasn't got ability but I would say he is going to hit one at some point during a race and still don't believe he has the ability to become a 175+ horse which he would have to run to, to get in the money at cheltenham...Just my opinion and he maybe able to win in decent grade in Ireland as the Chasers there are very moderate over staying distances...We will know more about him after he contests the Hennessy...ability wise that is...but if the ground is soft/heavy they won't go as quick and his jumping won't be put under the maximum scrutiny, like it will be in the Gold Cup...

If he were mine however he would be campaigned to run in the William Hill Trophy...Off of about 150 he would be of interest...just an opinion but that would be for me...
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 08 Jan 12 15:39
Erm QE is only 40 on here to lay with plenty wanting to back at 50 now, so how is he a 95 shot? Or are you referring to the ryanair where he is only 36 currently where no one is willing to ask for a price?
By:
harry callaghan
When: 08 Jan 12 16:53
Apologies I hadn't looked...brandy had said he was 95 which I thought was fair...umm 40's well wish you all the best...he obviously has the better price so apologies for that.
By:
R66
When: 08 Jan 12 21:37
TFR fantastic value @ 20/1.
By:
denman85
When: 08 Jan 12 21:46
r66- trr great value? hes only got a make up 30l with the top 2?
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 08 Jan 12 22:24
I have backed TFR at the start of the season and believe his run against the top two is not to be taken literally. He has good cheltenham form and the trainer i think is deliberately keeping this horse away from the track and alike tracks until we see him at the festival, i believe he will come on bundles for every run this season and for that reason, (and my speculation about the track) i intend to go in again at 20s. (backed at 14s at the beginning of the season) He is just the type to run well without troubling the top two and could easily run a place.

As could so many others, at biggish double fig prices, and at 1/4 the odds for a place, why not, at this early stage one can afford to back many in the race. Just have to be good at second guessing trainers etc, i use betfair/bookies/news/rp website/attheraces websites etc as a guide!

I have

Long Run 11/4 - going in big cannot have him out of the front 2
Kauto Star 11/2, 5/1, 4/1 - going in bigger cannot have him not in the first 3
Captain Chris 16/1 - price wise pick, yes i no lol dont take pish hehe, but he does get a winner or two every year don't he? Is also a saver
The rest are also savers bets
Grand Crus 8/1 nrnb
Burton Port 40/1
TFR 14/1 (soon to again at 20s)
Quel Esprit 40/1

backed so far Crazy it is a back book i am not a layer lol though by the time the day comes round i will have the top 2 winning me money and the others losing me slightly but if i have a place backed also it will become profit Crazy
By:
thedemps
When: 08 Jan 12 22:29
I thought he was great EW value last March at 20s not so sure now

Would you lay him EW at that price den?  I wouldn't as he is one of the few that has the class and he jumps economically but I was really disappointed with him at Haydock
By:
R66
When: 08 Jan 12 22:34
seathe - he can win it.

Holes galore in the front 2 - he absolutely loves Chelters - simply ignore his RSA run as something was badly amiss from the 'Get Go' - and his new alliance with O'Regan could be a match made in heaven.
An absolute barrel of a horse - you wont see a horse with a bigger chest cavity.;he's getting better with each run this season.
He'll sit in front 2 or 3, take it up going out on the 2nd circuit and grind them downy- LR will probably either Unseat or Fall and KS probablt Pull Up.
By:
strontium
When: 08 Jan 12 22:39
In his last 4 races Long Run has won the two most presitigious Grade 1 chases of the year and come second in two more, only beaten by one of the greatest steeple chasers of all time. He's run in 12 chases, won 7 and never unplaced. Holes galore?
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 08 Jan 12 22:40
Haha you beat me to that one strontium Crazy
By:
R66
When: 08 Jan 12 22:53
Regressing - his jumping is shocking atm and not good enough to win Grade 1 chases - he's fallen back into the habit of running into the bottom of them and snatching his head up as he takes off - something may be hurting him.
His massive engine is getting him close, but he may just be starting to sour like a lot of precocious French geldings do.
Wouldn't be entirely surprised to see blinkers on him soon.
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 08 Jan 12 23:05
I am no great fan of Long Run but i do not agree he is regressing as his jumping is spot on at his normal cruising speed but as soon as you put pace to the race it goes to pot. He is an out and out stayer with a big engine which loves to go his own pace. Much like Denman but with a lower cruising speed but will and can outstay anything over the gold cup trip and still be able to quicken up the hill. Look at his paddy power run, his jumping went to pot as soon as the pace quickened, he won the KG that year, he made it look effortlessly but he was niggled down the back straight and got in close to a couple then too, KS was having an off season then and Riverside theatre is just short of his class. Now look at that years gold cup, he could not go with the front two, (denman and Kauto) until almost 2 out where he then oustayed them up the hill. SWC obviously wise to the fact he cannot jump at pace, to which Paul Nichols and Ruby have now obviously come wise to and this is how they have beaten him twice this season already.

So it is quite ludicrous to say LR is past imvho!
By:
booster
When: 09 Jan 12 04:24
I've never backed Long Run but it's difficult to say he's regressing. He was 17 lengths clear of the third, Arkle winner, Caotain Chris, in The King George, running virtually to the pound on official marks and he and Kauto Star have finished first and second in the only two Grade 1 3 mile chases to be run this season in England. I'd agree his jumping's not been great but it wasn't the best last year. He fiddles a few, hits a few and jumps a few OK but his biggest asset is his engine and he's edging towards a backable price. I'd take 3-1 on the day, which I can see him being.

To say there are holes in the front two is surely a wind up, they're both miles clear of the rest and repeatedly show a similar level of form and are past winners of the race. I'm not really sure what is expected of them.

I know as punters we're always trying to find one to beat the favourites but think there'll be better chances at the prices than this race at the festival.

As for Time For Rupert, the only form I can see which would put him within hailing distance is his World Hurdle form of two seasons ago which probably sums up his chance and I see only Grands Crus as the horse who could challenge the top two.
Page 2 of 4  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com