X Factor 2010
Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
17 Oct 10
00:44
Joined:
Date Joined:
02 Oct 07
Watched it at work with one of my colleagues who doesn't like this sort of stuff and for most of it was actually quite embarrassed about how utterly awful most of it was tonight.
Anyway here is my musings on tonights performances.
Storm - I thought he was ok last week but tonight he was just dreadful, very king of Sid to give me 7/1 for next elimination after he sang but that was the only good thing to come from this abomintaion. The arrangement was also terrible.
Treyc - Another who went downhill from last week, Danyl and Ruth both sang the same song much better in previous series and although she sang ok it was very karaoke for me.
Paige - Sang the song quite well but very forgettable and in serious danger of leaving tomorrow, the worst thing you can be on these shows is forgettable especially from an early pitch.
Wand Erection - The emporors new clothes, the panel tells everyone that these are the hot new boyband and everyone screams and cheers. I thought they looked and sounded amateur and shambolic, how they can be the price they are is beyond me.
Cher - I just don't like her and struggle to get round that, I hated every minute of this, the things you see when you haven't got a gun.
John - Not a song I really like but I thought John was great tonight and gave one of the best performances of the night. Another couple of weeks like this and he becomes a real contender.
Diva Fever - Two more bullets I wish I had, this was truely awful and toe curlingly out of tune I nearly threw up. How the feck they can let the tone deaf one sing lead is beyond me and why the hell were the backing singers allowed to sing most of it for them. A real talent vaccuum of an act.
Rebecca - A far more suitable song than last week but she didnt actually sing as well as last week. She really needs to get some confidence as tonight she sang and acted like she didnt believe in herself. She is my biggest green and I was disappointed as it could have been brilliant and was only quite good.
Aiden - from hero to zero, he was all over the place and duly slipped down the betting, still massively too short though as he showed tonight he is just not up to winning this.
Wagner - Obviously not very good cos he isnt very good but still better than quite a few others which just shows how bad tonight really was.
Katie - A person I dont like singing a song I dont like and yet for me the best performance of the night, she sang really well and gave a very believable perfomance.
Bellamy - Utterly dire for the second week running, I dont think they will go this week because of the pimping of the judges but they dont even deserve to be here. How anyone could think these were worth voting for is beyond me.
Mary - Sang very well but not as stronger performance as last week but still easily one of the best of the night.
Matt - pimp slot and sang well but nowhere near as good as the reaction by the judges or the market but that is probably a reflection of how bad it was tonight. He is great when he lets rip but his control on the quieter bits is not quite there.
Anyway here is my musings on tonights performances.
Storm - I thought he was ok last week but tonight he was just dreadful, very king of Sid to give me 7/1 for next elimination after he sang but that was the only good thing to come from this abomintaion. The arrangement was also terrible.
Treyc - Another who went downhill from last week, Danyl and Ruth both sang the same song much better in previous series and although she sang ok it was very karaoke for me.
Paige - Sang the song quite well but very forgettable and in serious danger of leaving tomorrow, the worst thing you can be on these shows is forgettable especially from an early pitch.
Wand Erection - The emporors new clothes, the panel tells everyone that these are the hot new boyband and everyone screams and cheers. I thought they looked and sounded amateur and shambolic, how they can be the price they are is beyond me.
Cher - I just don't like her and struggle to get round that, I hated every minute of this, the things you see when you haven't got a gun.
John - Not a song I really like but I thought John was great tonight and gave one of the best performances of the night. Another couple of weeks like this and he becomes a real contender.
Diva Fever - Two more bullets I wish I had, this was truely awful and toe curlingly out of tune I nearly threw up. How the feck they can let the tone deaf one sing lead is beyond me and why the hell were the backing singers allowed to sing most of it for them. A real talent vaccuum of an act.
Rebecca - A far more suitable song than last week but she didnt actually sing as well as last week. She really needs to get some confidence as tonight she sang and acted like she didnt believe in herself. She is my biggest green and I was disappointed as it could have been brilliant and was only quite good.
Aiden - from hero to zero, he was all over the place and duly slipped down the betting, still massively too short though as he showed tonight he is just not up to winning this.
Wagner - Obviously not very good cos he isnt very good but still better than quite a few others which just shows how bad tonight really was.
Katie - A person I dont like singing a song I dont like and yet for me the best performance of the night, she sang really well and gave a very believable perfomance.
Bellamy - Utterly dire for the second week running, I dont think they will go this week because of the pimping of the judges but they dont even deserve to be here. How anyone could think these were worth voting for is beyond me.
Mary - Sang very well but not as stronger performance as last week but still easily one of the best of the night.
Matt - pimp slot and sang well but nowhere near as good as the reaction by the judges or the market but that is probably a reflection of how bad it was tonight. He is great when he lets rip but his control on the quieter bits is not quite there.
Show More
marks out of 10 please or you will be...........
REPORTED
REPORTED
I agree with nearly all of that HF.
Katie good but not that good.
Mary was sensational and I rather enjoyed the tarts without violins.
Oh and I enjoyed Aiden, but hard to see him winning.
Katie good but not that good.
Mary was sensational and I rather enjoyed the tarts without violins.
Oh and I enjoyed Aiden, but hard to see him winning.
I thought Treyc was screechy and forgettab;e and I think she may be the shock in the bottom 3 tomorrow.
seeing as I dont want to be reported...
Storm - 1/10
Treyc - 5/10
Paige - 5/10
Wand Erection - 3/10
Cher - 2/10
John - 7/10
Diva Fever - 1/10
Rebecca - 6/10
Aiden - 4/10
Wagner - 4/10.
Katie - 8/10
Bellamy - 0/10
Mary - 7/10
Matt - 6.5/10
Storm - 1/10
Treyc - 5/10
Paige - 5/10
Wand Erection - 3/10
Cher - 2/10
John - 7/10
Diva Fever - 1/10
Rebecca - 6/10
Aiden - 4/10
Wagner - 4/10.
Katie - 8/10
Bellamy - 0/10
Mary - 7/10
Matt - 6.5/10
Storm - 0/10 (missed it, but Pamela got 10/10 on SCD)
Treyc - 5/10 (not a patch on Ruth)
Paige - 3/10
Wand Erection - 5/10 (a decent effort with a sh1te song)
Cher - 5/10 (Ok when you could hear her)
John - 8/10 ( I love this guy)
Diva Fever - 2/10
Rebecca - 5/10 (patchy again)
Aiden - 6/10 (better than most, but obviously not a patch on last week)
Wagner - 6/10.
Katie - 6/10
Bellamy - 6/10 ( I enjoyed it)
Mary - 9/10 (I thought she was better last week)
Matt - 5/10 (meh)
Treyc - 5/10 (not a patch on Ruth)
Paige - 3/10
Wand Erection - 5/10 (a decent effort with a sh1te song)
Cher - 5/10 (Ok when you could hear her)
John - 8/10 ( I love this guy)
Diva Fever - 2/10
Rebecca - 5/10 (patchy again)
Aiden - 6/10 (better than most, but obviously not a patch on last week)
Wagner - 6/10.
Katie - 6/10
Bellamy - 6/10 ( I enjoyed it)
Mary - 9/10 (I thought she was better last week)
Matt - 5/10 (meh)
Mary should be -
I thought she was better than last week
I thought she was better than last week
not seen it yet butmy dads said matrt was fantastic. aiden must have been horrendous going by betting
I maintain that the only one with any real talent is Rebecca.
Hel
I agree with a lot of that again. Didn't think Katie was THAT good but a big improvement. Wagner awful for me.
I agree with a lot of that again. Didn't think Katie was THAT good but a big improvement. Wagner awful for me.
the trick with wagner is he knows he cant sing but plays it in such a way as to try to make it oddly enjoyable a lot of the others cant sing either but dont realise this and therefore come across as hopelessly out of their depth
Aiden has to be careful that he's actually too good for this competition if that makes sense. His voice and musical taste would be better suited to Jools Holland than Cowell's empire.
His voice is superb but it is no way an X-Factor voice, the ridicule of his performance last night was a complete joke. It wasn't perfect but was in no way "rubbish" and I don't know why he said that.
I'm sure with strong guidance he'd be able to get through this competition and still win it, but I doubt he'll get this from Danni and although I've backed at 10s I'd be hopeful rather than confident.
His voice is superb but it is no way an X-Factor voice, the ridicule of his performance last night was a complete joke. It wasn't perfect but was in no way "rubbish" and I don't know why he said that.
I'm sure with strong guidance he'd be able to get through this competition and still win it, but I doubt he'll get this from Danni and although I've backed at 10s I'd be hopeful rather than confident.
Aiden's sulking seemed a bigger negative than his singing to me. Don't think Cowell will want to work that closely with such a stroppy kid who isn't all that great to compensate (forget the rubbish about being potentially a great star, blah blah we hear it every year about people who end up flipping burgers and singing in a local bar). 100s of kids could sing as well as he does, literally. I also think he is a little too close to last years winner for comfort.
Came across as a genuine emotional response to his disappointment to me stu
He'd just been slagged by the judges
He'd just been slagged by the judges
Storm - bottom
Paige and Treyc - Paige gets booted on the basis of his wardrobe
Paige and Treyc - Paige gets booted on the basis of his wardrobe
Yes - but there are different ways to respond and I don't think his way looked good.
Not sure I agree with that Stu, Aiden acknowledged he knew it wasn't that good and then genuinely looked like he was holding back tears.
Genuine eomitional responses tend to go down well in these shows, I think his off key warbling was more vote damaging than his attitude.
Genuine eomitional responses tend to go down well in these shows, I think his off key warbling was more vote damaging than his attitude.
I'm sure he could bounce back, but generally I don't really remember many winners down the years reacting in that way.
Off key warbling and attitude combine to make it a worrying week for Aidan backers (myself included).
I think he's safe and will go on to finish in the top half (not saying much with 16 acts this year), but doesn't look like a typical winner anymore.
I think he's safe and will go on to finish in the top half (not saying much with 16 acts this year), but doesn't look like a typical winner anymore.
he is good when he gets it right, terrible when he gets it wrong like with Man in the Mirror.
Agree with most HF, though I thought Katie was good but not great.
Storm - 3/10
Treyc 6
Paige 5
5 directions 4
cher 3
John 7
Dive Fever 4
Rebecca 6.5
Aiden 3.5
Wagner 5
Weasel 6
Bellamy 4
Mary 6.5
Matt 7
Agree with most HF, though I thought Katie was good but not great.
Storm - 3/10
Treyc 6
Paige 5
5 directions 4
cher 3
John 7
Dive Fever 4
Rebecca 6.5
Aiden 3.5
Wagner 5
Weasel 6
Bellamy 4
Mary 6.5
Matt 7
Allez
I think a lot of his performance was good and he'd have been right up there still but you can't just conveniently forget that about four high notes (all the same word/same part of the song) were just terrible. We'd forgive someone once I'm sure but 4 times?
I actually thought his response was very sulky too so didn't acquit himself too well there but I think he was so disappointed at completely ruining all of his good work of last week so i can understand his frustration.
Still around for a good while yet though with I'm sure lots of good stuff to come if in not too high a key.
I think a lot of his performance was good and he'd have been right up there still but you can't just conveniently forget that about four high notes (all the same word/same part of the song) were just terrible. We'd forgive someone once I'm sure but 4 times?
I actually thought his response was very sulky too so didn't acquit himself too well there but I think he was so disappointed at completely ruining all of his good work of last week so i can understand his frustration.
Still around for a good while yet though with I'm sure lots of good stuff to come if in not too high a key.
marks refer to my own enjoyment of the performances, NOT how good or talented i think they are:
storm - 2/10 - awful, spoiled a classic song, pure cheese, early slot, lukewarm comments, f00ked!
treyc - 5/10 - sang it well in fairness, people with poor music taste will lap this up, boring.
paije - can't really remember it so can't give it a mark, seems a nice lad though.
one direction - 6/10 - rubbish song of course, but it was actually good fun, quite enjoyed it, couldn't help tapping my feet, mums and daughters love these lads, should at least make final.
cher - 0/10 - i hate this girl with a real passion, rude, obnoxious, and SHE CANNOT RAP!! that said, will probably stick around for a few more weeks.
john - 5/10 - likeable and sang it very well from what i heard of the bits we didn't talk over, a bit boring.
diva fever - 5/10 - dreadful, just DREADFUL, but absolutely HILARIOUS!
rebecca - 7/10 - i love the tone of her voice, thought she was great but could have been so much better - that song needs to build and her "shyness" didn't really allow it. too good for this shambles of a competition.
aiden - 3/10 - made me feel really uncomfortable, very poor. facial expressions when he sings are so irritating - looks like he has tourette's. he's actually not bad though.
wagner - 7/10 - brilliant, an absolute LEGEND!
katie - 5/10 - actually quite good, but there's no escaping the fact that she's a t!t.
belle amie - 3/10 - dire, no chemistry, another classic ruined this week. will not make it to week 4.
mary - 6/10 - yes it was good, yes she can sing, but she can't do old covers every week, will get boring very quickly. massively overrated of course, but she's actually not bad.
matt - 5/10 - sang it well, but a very boring, forgettable performance.
storm - 2/10 - awful, spoiled a classic song, pure cheese, early slot, lukewarm comments, f00ked!
treyc - 5/10 - sang it well in fairness, people with poor music taste will lap this up, boring.
paije - can't really remember it so can't give it a mark, seems a nice lad though.
one direction - 6/10 - rubbish song of course, but it was actually good fun, quite enjoyed it, couldn't help tapping my feet, mums and daughters love these lads, should at least make final.
cher - 0/10 - i hate this girl with a real passion, rude, obnoxious, and SHE CANNOT RAP!! that said, will probably stick around for a few more weeks.
john - 5/10 - likeable and sang it very well from what i heard of the bits we didn't talk over, a bit boring.
diva fever - 5/10 - dreadful, just DREADFUL, but absolutely HILARIOUS!
rebecca - 7/10 - i love the tone of her voice, thought she was great but could have been so much better - that song needs to build and her "shyness" didn't really allow it. too good for this shambles of a competition.
aiden - 3/10 - made me feel really uncomfortable, very poor. facial expressions when he sings are so irritating - looks like he has tourette's. he's actually not bad though.
wagner - 7/10 - brilliant, an absolute LEGEND!
katie - 5/10 - actually quite good, but there's no escaping the fact that she's a t!t.
belle amie - 3/10 - dire, no chemistry, another classic ruined this week. will not make it to week 4.
mary - 6/10 - yes it was good, yes she can sing, but she can't do old covers every week, will get boring very quickly. massively overrated of course, but she's actually not bad.
matt - 5/10 - sang it well, but a very boring, forgettable performance.
Post Your Reply
Please login to post a reply.
Wonder
Instance ID: 13539