Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Horse Antepost

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 225 comments are related to the topic:
The Eclipse - Sandown July 6th

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 4 of 6  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 225
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 16:30
Brigust, I'm not going to go into why Frankel was so much better than anything else seen for years once again, as it requires criteria that you just don't recognise.

Back To Enable, she beat all those horses when she was a 3yo with the allowances. Why is this so hard to grasp? I thought she was an outstanding 3yo filly. I said this at the time. I said she gave the fastest Oaks winning performance I'd seen and rated, which goes all the way back to Oh So Sharp and includes my own favourite money spinner Ouija Board. The WFA allowance is a scale devised to try to even up the lack of maturity 3yos have against their elders. It is supposedly based on averages, although those averages have been called into question and the scale has been tinkered with a few times.

If a WFA system has to be used then using averages is the best that can be done. However if anyone is trying to tell me that all horses improve with age, that some horses don't reach their full potential at 3, that all horses improve each month by a set number of pounds then the conversation ends there. As I can't accept that any intelligent person could believe such rubbish.
By:
woodmanchester
When: 07 Jul 19 16:54
Frankel was a freak

Best of all time
By:
Andrew.in.Sweden
When: 07 Jul 19 17:03
Hi Laurie,

Welcome back, a long time since you posted, are you back in UK ? I know what you mean about living in 2 countries i'm doig exactly that at the moment. Still working as a consultant to Saab aerospace, but i'm also doing some secondment work west of Munich. I'm commuting once a month, in fact i returned home (Sweden) on Friday and now i'm at Arlanda waiting for a return flight. It's only a temporary situation and i actually don't mind it, Bavaria is a nice place to live.

Hope life is good with you.

I also thought Enable would win yesterday, it appears there are some at least that can see she is an exceptional middle distance filly/mare. It's going to take an equally exceptional performance from whoever for her to get beaten at Ascot. The Yorkshire Oaks in August will be a formality and then on to the Arc, and again, she will be very hard to beat, given her relaxed, switched off style of running and turn of foot. I plan to go to Ascot, not York and i go to the Arc every year anyway.

Exciting times.
By:
brigust1
When: 07 Jul 19 17:11
I missed that one Figgis. You guys are using a 'criteria' we mere mortals don't understand. Laugh And the reason you don't want to explain it I suppose is because we won't understand it? That makes it look as silly as it sounds. Suddenly the Willoughby's of this world have the golden grail. You make me laugh.

Hi Andrew. Yes I'm over for a few weeks with the grandchildren. Lots to do and places to go.

It was good to watch. And I think she had a bit in hand. Sadly everything Frankie wins on is a 'great' horse but hype is the order of the day nowadays so it has to be expected. Do you not think she will go for the Juddmonte? Then the Arc?
By:
Andrew.in.Sweden
When: 07 Jul 19 17:13
I guess you will be returning to France at some point ? Let me know if you're going to Longchamp in October. Bring dark glasses if you do, the new grandstand is tacky and gaudy Wink
By:
Andrew.in.Sweden
When: 07 Jul 19 17:14
Laurie, JG favours another Yorkshire and i think it's wise decision, albeit not set in stone yet.

More later, flight being called.
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 17:14
Andrew, getting you to separate what she did as a 3yo is proving difficult, so imagine if any other horse had won last year's Arc and this year's Eclipse by exactly the same distances against the exact same opposition, how would you rate those performances? Forget scales, putting them into an historical context would you say they were well above average, average, or below average?
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 17:26
You guys are using a 'criteria' we mere mortals don't understand

Well I could go into times but I would be wasting mine. No, I mean simple criteria such as the obvious knowledge that horses can and do improve at the age of 4 and even older, rather than holding them down by what they did in previous years or trying to average their entire career performances. Recognising that there's a massive difference between simply saying this horse beat that compared to one horse that absolutely pulverised the opposition. Recognising that 3lbs over a mile is so obviously not 2lbs it is 3lbs minimum. Recognising that a horse who doesn't just win a Thirsk Hunt Cup but who wins it effortlessly by 6 lengths while being hammered in the betting by those in the know could indeed go on to be a Gp1 performer. Basic stuff really but only for the unblinkered Wink
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 17:27
* 1 length over a mile
By:
brigust1
When: 07 Jul 19 17:59
That is exactly my point Figgis. The only horse Frankel met of any note was Canford Cliffs. He always had classic intentions and ran in the 2000 guineas finishing 3rd. Horses like Farhh, Excelebration, Cirrus des Aigles, Zoffany, Dubawi Gold, Klammer etc etc never had classic potential. The reason they succeeded was that there was a mass shortage of class horses at that time. In Frankel's 2000 Guineas the next 5 home never won a Group 1 race throughout their careers. The best older horse came from Australia, the Arc winner was German, the Derby winner retired straight away having only won a Group 3. It happens a bit like this year. Can you see a three year old winning the Arc this year? At least the likely protagonists will have always been thought of a top class horses. The only difference is that Frankel arrived and couldn't believe his luck.

I know from American racing the quickest way to the poor house is following times. But my point is that Frankel never showed those times. Racing is over the distance not in sections. Had Frankel been a fast horse Henry would not have started him over a mile on soft ground. Sea the Stars beat average times on three occasions from his 6 runs and broke the course record once. So it is not impossible or improbable in the current climate. Dancing Brave beat average times and broke course records, so did Nijinsky, Mill Reef and Brigadier Gerard. And so did Secretariat.
By:
elisjohn
When: 07 Jul 19 18:05
like i said class horses have been in decline for years.DANCING BRAVE  broke  course records in a canter, by far the best racehorse ive seen.
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 18:06
That is exactly my point Figgis

Yes, your point being that if horses don't win classics or go close to winning them, they can't be much good after. So if a horse isn't close to a champion early on in its 3yo season then it should never be upgraded later. Which is the point I'm saying is utter garbage.
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 18:13
Look at the ground when those horses ran in the seventies and early eighties. Christ, the clerks would be passing enough urine to drench the course themselves if they saw that ground on a race day.
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 18:13
On a race day nowadays I mean.
By:
elisjohn
When: 07 Jul 19 18:16
nashwan time on heavy was out of this world in the eclipse, 4 secs off sea the stars on firm.
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 18:22
Anyway, back to Enable. For me, the winning performance level in last year's Arc and this year's Eclipse were under average for the race. Whereas her 3yo performances were well above average for her sex and age. Give her back the allowances and she wins as easily as she did as a 3yo. So all I'm saying is she has basically stayed the same level. If she had improved with wfa she would be beating these horses more easily. This has proved good enough so far. There are those who will say she's only done what has been required and will up her game when/if needed. That is where I disagree.
By:
brigust1
When: 07 Jul 19 18:24
Not horses Figgis, all horses. The majority of classic horses I have seen this year do not look great. You may disagree. So what about the stables other horses not capable of being up to classic potential? How good will they be?
Take Frankel out of the classics and you have Dubawi Gold, Native Khan, Slim Shadey, Fury, Happy Today, Pour Moi, Treasure Beach, Carlton House, Memphis Tennessee, Recital, Dancing Rain, Wonder of Wonders, Izzi Top, Misty For Me, Beatrice Aurora, Blue Bunting, Together, Maquasid, Nova Heat, Barefoot Lass and Havant. These were a cross-section of the best horses around from the top yards. What Frankel met was the best of the rest so imagine how good that was.

Your comment about the ground is rubbish Figgis they watered when Brigadier Gerard was racing. The only difference is that they let the grass grow to provide a safe covering. And they never were able to move the rails or save strips of perfect ground for the best races.
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 18:29
Enough of the pointless my era was better than yours debates. Back to the discussion on future betting, which is what it's all about. Do people see Enable as a value bet for the King George?
By:
china castle
When: 07 Jul 19 18:42
Hi Figgis,

I think if Crystal Ocean could repeat last year's King George performance he could beat Enable. This will be his big target of the year and has the exact same prep as last year. Can't really see anything else being good enough.
By:
elisjohn
When: 07 Jul 19 18:44
not at 1/1. yesterday 4/6 against nothing, now i reckon this japan might be the real deal, about time coolmore produced something .
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 18:45
The majority of classic horses I have seen this year do not look great. You may disagree

I don't disagree on that at all. I think I might have said at the time Hermosa was a below average winner of the 1000. In hindsight that was wrong and I was probably hoping to see a really good filly. I'd say she was bang on average and there's nothing wrong with that, they can't all be superstars. For me, Magna Grecia was the worst Guineas winner for years, although it has to be said he didn't even run anywhere his previous level at the Curragh. He's slow but not that slow.

I think the Oaks was bang average, even though Pink Dogwood disappointed last time and it remains to be seen how the winner comes out of it. The Derby, frankly, was terrible. I backed AVD thinking he was capable of more on his best form last year. A lot of that was based on the run against Quorto, who hasn't been seen since, so I may have overrated him that day. Take that out and I would still have backed AVD and I still believe he was the worthy winner on the day, but I wouldn't have had as much on, I got lucky. Despite not running very fast a lot of the runners still appeared to have a hard race that day and on the evidence of the Curragh have gone even further backwards. Couldn't back any of them in future unless improvement is shown.
By:
brigust1
When: 07 Jul 19 18:46
You think Enable isn't that great because of the horses that are around. And I agree with that. But it was worse with Frankel.

Would you think Enable's classics group of Wings of Eagles, Cliffs of Moher, Cracksman, Eminent. Benbatl, Capri, Churchill, Barney Roy, Al Wukair, Lancaster Bomber, Dream Castle, Rhodedendron, Alluringly, Horseplay, Coronet, Isabel de Urbina, Winter, Daban, Talaayeb, Fair Eca and Unforgatable Filly were a better group than Frankel's group?  I certainly do but I also think they were not a great bunch.

This isn't about my era this is your era, today's era. The quality of horses Frankel ran against were, in my opinion, of a lower quality than Enable's group.

Yet you will be looking at Enable's chance of winning the King George or whether or not there is a three year old good enough to benefit from the allowances.   

There wasn't anything from the 3 year old division capable of benefitting from the allowances last year and if it is the same this year do you upgrade Enable or say she didn't beat much. Just like I am saying about Frankel.
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 18:50
China castle, you know it makes sense Wink
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 19:00
Look, if we were ONLY going to judge horses on who they'd beat then it would be a piss poor state of affairs in the 21st century. It would mean a brilliant horse could come along facing below average opponents but no, he's no good because he beat nobodies. Maybe that applies in other sports but, even for those who don't want to recognise time PERFORMANCES, we can measure how good a horse is by how far they beat the rated opposition. Maybe we might get that wrong on one performance. There is still debate about how good Hawkwing's Locking win was. With Frankel he did it time and again season after season, with the allowances and without them. It's bewildering how anyone can fail to recognise just what an absolutely brilliant racehorse he was when there is just so much evidence to prove it.
By:
A_T
When: 07 Jul 19 19:12
Frankel's generation was outstanding. His 3yo peers won nearly all the WFA races worth winning that year - Nathaniel, Danedream. Then they came back the following year and as 4yos beat the 3yos in all the WFA races. Farrh even came back the year after aged 5 to be the champion miler.

Brigust must have an alert set up here to notify him when someone says something positive about Frankel as it's the only time he ever posts - too busy travelling to Brigadier Gerard's grave to lay flowers every day and writing letters of protest to Timeform.


Enable looks like she might do something no horse has ever done - be the best middle distance horse 3 years running. That would be some achievement.
By:
china castle
When: 07 Jul 19 19:26
I can only assume the big difference in price between Enable and Crystal Ocean is partly due to that joke race at Kempton last September. Enable set a very slow pace , for the grade of race , which meant Crystal Ocean had little chance of beating her.
By:
brigust1
When: 07 Jul 19 19:37
Flipping heck Figgis that is exactly the same criteria you are using for Enable. She didn't beat very much by very far.

In my opinion, 'time' performances are as useless as a chocolate teapot. You don't even know where the best ground is for a starter or the proper race distance.
In the Queen Anne apparently, Frankel ran the 5th furlong in a good time and faster than the 5-furlong horses in the Kings Stand. What is overlooked is that Frankel would have been 15 lengths behind the Kings Stand winner at the 5-furlong marker, after running 5 furlongs on the easirt part of the track so how can you possibly compare the two? In America they have fast quarter horses to run 2 furlongs but they are hopeless at 5 furlongs. 

And A_T how unusual for the 3 year olds to win with the allowances. Figgis will answer that one for you. The fact is the 3 year old classic contenders in Frankel's year won 14 Group 1 races whereas in Enable's year they won 25 Group 1 races. And I am not saying that was a great year.

The clues are all there you just have to cut through the hype. In the last 50 years one horse shared Frankel's record for the worst 2000 Guineas and that was Roland Gardens.

It is called 'class'. Some horses have it and some don't. Some have a 'touch of class' and very few are 'top class'. Class horses will always pulverise the rest that is why the likes of Arkle and Desert Orchid could defy the handicapper, class. If Frankel was beating class horses easily that would be different but as Phil Smith, Head of the BHA said in the press and in a letter to me and I quote' It is difficult splitting Frankel and Dancing Brave because one beat lesser horses easily while the other beat better horses narrowly'. You only have to ask any sportsman or woman, or football manager whether it is a better achievement to beat lesser opponents easily or better opponents narrowly and I know what they will say, every time.
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 19:44
She didn't beat very much by very far.

Jesus effing Christ. Are you seriously trying to compare beating Magical and Sea Of Class by less than a length to what Frankel did as a 4yo. I feel sorry for you man Laugh
By:
brigust1
When: 07 Jul 19 19:50
Figgis it was you comparing Enable with Frankel, if you remember.

Your comment was 'Look, if we are only going to judge horses on who they'd beat then it would be a piss poor state of affairs in the 21st Century yet you are still going on about Magical and Sea of Class.

You don't know what rubbish you are churning out from one minute to the next. Must be the new secret criteria.
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 19:50
In my opinion, 'time' performances are as useless as a chocolate teapot

Brig, is that your opinion as a successful punter, or as house refurbisher **** book writer? And by the way, I'm not trying to play Billy Big Bollocks here, a successful punter can be a success on a small level.
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 19:51
Ffs, **** was the censored word.
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 19:53
Ffs, scum without the s, no slur intended Laugh
By:
brigust1
When: 07 Jul 19 19:54
No need to get insulting Figgis.The lowest form of conversation. If you cannot have a sensible, rational conversation then shut up.
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 19:56
Your comment was 'Look, if we are only going to judge horses on who they'd beat then it would be a piss poor state of affairs in the 21st Century yet you are still going on about Magical and Sea of Class.

Yes, and it was followed by

we can measure how good a horse is by how far they beat the rated opposition

Do you also skip sentences when book writing? Wink
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 19:57
No need to get insulting Figgis

Which bit did you find insulting?
By:
unclepuncle
When: 07 Jul 19 20:34
A_T
07 Jul 19 19:12

Brigust must have an alert set up here to notify him when someone says something positive about Frankel as it's the only time he ever posts - too busy travelling to Brigadier Gerard's grave to lay flowers every day and writing letters of protest to Timeform.


PMSL.Laugh
By:
brigust1
When: 07 Jul 19 20:40
When you start talking about me personally. It doesn't matter what I do or have done for a living we are discussing horseracing.

Let me take you back to 9.35pm yesterday when you said Enable hasn't yet met a proper Group 1 horse at the peak of its powers primed to run a big race. I know some fools tried to say the same about Frankel but he met better horses (ABSOLUTELY NOT TRUE) than she has and, importantly, he thrashed them pointless (ABSOLUTELY NOT TRUE). He did so by putting up some tremendous times (ABSOLUTELY NOT TRUE). All of these points we have covered this afternoon.

Then you continued with

'Personally, I like a horse to be able to beat another fast horse or at least run very fast while beating inferiors before I consider it an all time great. (ABSOLUTELY UNTRUE).

The conclusion of this conversation is that the evidence proves Frankel has NEVER put up a fast time in his career, his opponents he beat easily have NEVER put up a fast time throughout their careers. He has never met a FAST horse and the evidence of his race times is that he is not a FAST horse himself so your criteria for selecting an all time simply great does not apply to Frankel.
By:
Howellsy
When: 07 Jul 19 20:41
Brigust, your comments about Frankel ultimately undermine anything you say about the game in my view. Excelebration, Farrh, St Nicholas Abbey, Canford Cliffs, Cirrus des Aigles. Stuffed out of sight (bar Cirrus on very soft ground - Nathaniel stuffed though). That'll do me - and there were plenty of others.
By:
brigust1
When: 07 Jul 19 20:48
Howellsy you are fully entitled to your opinion and I hope I am too. I am simply stating the facts and the form. Don't you find it surprising that Frankel only beat average time on two occasions in his 14 race career? Do you not find it surprising that only two horses on your list beat average time on only one occasion throughout their careers? The total classic form between them all was a third and a 6th to Makfi, a 25/1 shot, in the 2000 Guineas.
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 20:52
Brigust, ok you're right, we've all been rumbled. The time fans were wrong, the form ratings people were wrong and punters everywhere, many of them who never even made a penny on the horse, who still said he was the best they'd seen. I don't know why we did it, we have no connection to the horse. Now maybe it would make more sense if some of us had been, say, his groom or something Wink
Page 4 of 6  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com