Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Horse Antepost

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 225 comments are related to the topic:
The Eclipse - Sandown July 6th

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 3 of 6  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 225
By:
A_T
When: 06 Jul 19 16:00
exercise gallop. can't see many taking her on at Ascot
By:
Charlton2005
When: 06 Jul 19 16:00
dante winner a hard ridden last - as expected
By:
Figgis
When: 06 Jul 19 16:08
Well done Andrew and anyone who took the short price. She always looked the winner and visually I was very impressed. Telecaster never showed up again and Magical was beaten fair and square. Whether that one ran up to her Ascot form today, however, I'm not so sure. She was sweating beforehand and Moore never really looked comfortable on her. Maybe that was deceiving though and possibly she did run right up to form. I admit that my stance that Enable will get beaten in the King George has taken a knock but I think she may have to do a lot more there and will take a proper view after the whole card has been run. I might even become an Enable backer Wink
By:
Figgis
When: 06 Jul 19 16:11
you're the one who is having trouble fella

A bit like you having trouble explaining any of your comments. When you said you were a writer, was it the text message comments in the Sun? Wink
By:
Andrew.in.Sweden
When: 06 Jul 19 16:23
Figgis,

Thank you.

To be honest i don't think i've seen a better filly/mare and i go back to Dahlia days. She's always going to be difficult to beat whatever the distance; almost Frankel-like in the way she switches off and travels well in her races. She knows she's good and will always pull out more if necessary. A very genuine, exceptional mare.

In my opinion she had it won the moment Frankie pressed the button and my neighbours are probably wondering what all the shouting was for.

The KG will be harder but she wll be race fit and who is there to beat her.

Good luck.
By:
FELTFAIR
When: 06 Jul 19 16:31
Just three weeks away. I would be waiting to know she is a definite runner before getting involved.
By:
woodmanchester
When: 06 Jul 19 16:32
I'm no expert but sure the television team said she's a filly?
By:
Andrew.in.Sweden
When: 06 Jul 19 16:34
Woodmanchester,

Correct, so did AOB during the interview
By:
FELTFAIR
When: 06 Jul 19 16:47
Four years and above becomes a mare.
By:
Jack Bauer '24'
When: 06 Jul 19 17:55
Five years and above.
By:
Figgis
When: 06 Jul 19 18:00
Confidence slightly shaken temporarily, but not stirred. I still believe Enable is highly likely to be beaten in the King George Silly
By:
Andrew.in.Sweden
When: 06 Jul 19 18:05
Jack,

4 years and above for thoroughbreds Wink
By:
harry callaghan
When: 06 Jul 19 18:19
another good performance from enable and a good piece of placement by john gosden, who found her a cracking opportunity to get started, against basically second rate grade 1 horses...her trainer has trained her impeccably her whole career in all fairness

i didn't have an interest today as i wanted her to win (so the hype can start again) and tbh i have tried so hard to get her previously and she hasn't been easy for me as i don't think she is that good, magical in the breeders cup was another harsh lesson for me and haggis's filly the other in the arc, obviously she carries a price tag every time she runs and as a horse bettor you are always trying to beat a horse like her

anyway i just wanted a clear head to move forward with with her, so nothing today as i couldn't find a decent type and have learnt my lesson with her, as she has been extremely well placed by her trainer, obviously she is good the form doesn't lie but i suppose she is that grinding same pace type horse who i just struggle with class wise and actually finding high class horses these days, is not easy as there isn't many good horses around


once again like in the arc imo she copped a speed friendly track today and at kempton she met a runner who did no running...dettori is riding very well again and is alive to spotting speed friendly tracks, when he rode her in the breeders cup he bought her wider than magical and it was a top class piece of riding considering how the track was that day, although the filly was still much the best that day anyway

enable's grinding same pace style is well suited to prominent racing and speed favouring tracks and she is very uncomplicated, so a horse ridden for speed is always going to be hostage against her in a tactical race on a speed favouring track when the speed holds up, not that there is many class middle distance horses running at the moment to take her on with, so it isn't going to be easy to get her again this year

we will see
By:
Jack Bauer '24'
When: 06 Jul 19 18:48
They are still referred to as fillies in UK racecards at the age of four and that is generally accepted amongst punters. You would have to ask a vet or an equine scientist when they biologically become mares, I wouldn't know about that.
By:
Figgis
When: 06 Jul 19 19:41
Don't give up Harry, the best chance is next.
By:
unclepuncle
When: 06 Jul 19 19:43
Agree with all that Harry.

She is very professional but based on todays run, where things really couldn't have panned out any better for her, she does look a 125 type, rather than a real superstar. It's not her fault she has very little to beat, bit like Altior.
Maybe she needs soft ground to produce a really striking 'ratings' performance where she can put some proper daylight between herself and her rivals late on, bit like Cracksman.
By:
A_T
When: 06 Jul 19 21:05
too much overanalysing going on here. enable's just a brilliant horse - give her a strong pace she'll win even easier

"she has been extremely well placed by her trainer"

she's run in 2 arcs, a king george, eclipse, breeders cup. what other races would you expect her to be running in?
By:
Figgis
When: 06 Jul 19 21:35
It all depends on what you class as brilliant though. For a long time now she's beat everything she's raced against and she's been remarkably consistent. As Harry said, she travels so well and makes everything easy for her jockey. She does it so easily that this helps her retain her form I think. Although it has to be said that it helps her that she hasn't met anything capable of running really fast against her on the day yet. I've seen many faster horses but it's been hard work for them and they've been spent after a couple of races. So she has some great qualities, she has those big races in the bag and nobody is saying she doesn't deserve them.

It's just that for me she hasn't yet met a proper Gp1 horse at the peak of its powers primed to run a big race. I know some fools tried to say the same about Frankel but he met better horses than she has and, importantly, he thrashed them pointless. He did so by also putting up some tremendous times. Enable hasn't done either yet as an older filly. For some people what she's done already will make her an all time great, which is fair enough. Personally I like a horse to be able to beat another fast horse or at least run very fast while beating inferiors before I consider it an all time great. Otherwise we'd have horses being considered greats who have just picked up big races in weak years. Let's see how Enable fares next time.
By:
harry callaghan
When: 06 Jul 19 21:43
i haven't given up figgis but i'll be picking my fights with her this time around, basically i can't find a decent 3 year old to go to war with, although i think the french derby winner is at least ok but only ok, i liked dyck for the derby but still have him regressing from last year something he did after the national stakes, i had him to win by 3 lengths at epsom and he didn't, maybe i just need to tear up my ratings as things aren't running to what i'm hoping for 

the older horses for me are so average it isn't funny, i'm continually picking at straws trying to find angles that aren't there, it is no wonder half these average older horses are still running because the young horses are so poor
By:
A_T
When: 06 Jul 19 22:07
which are these "speed friendly tracks"? Ascot, Epsom, Longchamps, Curragh, York, Chantilly, Sandown, Churchill Downs - have I missed any?
By:
harry callaghan
When: 06 Jul 19 23:06
A.T do you understand the term speed friendly? you clearly do hence trying to pull me up? you clearly thought i meant every race she has run in that she copped a bias? hence reeling off all the tracks she has run at

every track has biases at certain times on certain days, look at sandowns results today and tell me the track wasn't running biased to horses racing prominently which it has in the past by the way and tell me it wasn't speed friendly

when she won the arc she got to race close to just a moderately run affair and basically got first run, nelson ffs was still in there pitching a furlong out

at churchill you did not want to be on the swamp inside she raced widest

chantilly is a massive track for speed bias hence the results that day she won the arc

it is all well and good you coming on here to pull me up and good luck with you're race reading in the future
By:
Andrew.in.Sweden
When: 07 Jul 19 07:17
Figgis,

You appear to be making too much effort trying to devaluate Enable. Wink

He did so by also putting up some tremendous times. Enable hasn't done either yet as an older filly.

He (Frankel) never put up a fast time, only fast sectionals occasionally, it's one of the reasons many don't rate him, and i'm his biggest fan.

With reference to 'older' filly, i assume you mean as a 4/5 year old, well let's review times at the respective meetings in 3 of her last 4 races (i can't find standard times for Churchill Downs yet).

At Kempton on a standard to slow track, her race was only one of two that went under 2 seconds slower than standard (she was slow by 1.27 secs).

At Longchamp on good to soft, she was by far the fastest race winning time by standard on the card (fast by 1.26 secs). All others races times (group class) were slower than standard. She was also conceding 7 lb to a dual Group 1 race winner who had won 4 of her previous (and only) 5 starts. Please don't drag up the SOC 'unlucky' stance, she wasn't.

Yesterday, the Eclipse was only one of two races to finish in faster than standard time (fast by 0.73 secs)

As for :

Incorrect if you're referring to BHA that i suspect you are, the rating is what it implies.

Andrew, here is the BHA handicapper's blog after her first Arc win

https://www.britishhorseracing.com/handicappers-blog-5-october-2017/

Looks to me like they have not deducted anything for the wfa allowance, only the fillies allowance. They have rated her on the assumption that as a 4yo she would improve the 7lbs allowed for wfa.


You are using the introdution to support your case. In receipt of both the weight-for-age and weight-for-sex allowance, Enable looked the standout performer at the weights prior to this year’s Arc but she still improved both her form and standing with a commanding success.

BHA OR (official ratings) are based on a handicap system decided by a team of 12 headed by Dominic Gardiner-Hill and should not be confused with performance ratings they also produce. Nor are they calculated in the same way as Timeform or RPR. The OR is what is says on the tin, her BHA rating of 125 is a handicap rating irrespective of colt or filly, 3 or 4 year old, blah x 3, simple as.

RP quote, After a three-quarter-length defeat of old rival Magical that was more authoritative than the margin suggested, Dettori declared Enable the best horse he has ridden.

I'm sure if she won the boat race, you would say the other one was threading water WinkLaugh
By:
A_T
When: 07 Jul 19 08:51
Some real pearls of wisdom here from our gurus determined to rationalise why they keep getting it wrong on Enable. My 2 favourites so far:

the only reason Enable keeps winning is that she hasn't faced a horse faster than her

Gosden has been able to maintain her winning run by carefully placing her in uncompetitive races like the Arc, Eclipse, King George and Breeders Cup

Keep 'em coming Laugh
By:
elisjohn
When: 07 Jul 19 09:42
another one for you hereA T, she keeps on winning  coz the bloody standard of horses these days is atrocious, and has been for years, even coolomore really top  class milers/ 12 furlong horses go back 15 plus years.
By:
Charlton2005
When: 07 Jul 19 10:07
BHA OR (official ratings) are based on a handicap system decided by a team of 12 headed by Dominic Gardiner-Hill and should not be confused with performance ratings they also produce. Nor are they calculated in the same way as Timeform or RPR. The OR is what is says on the tin, her BHA rating of 125 is a handicap rating irrespective of colt or filly, 3 or 4 year old, blah x 3, simple as.

I haven't got the patience to explain this, but this is what you time boys are missing
By:
Charlton2005
When: 07 Jul 19 10:08
Gosden has been able to maintain her winning run by carefully placing her in uncompetitive races like the Arc, Eclipse, King George and Breeders Cup

Keep 'em coming


Grin
By:
brigust1
When: 07 Jul 19 10:43
Hi Andrew, I hope you are well and thriving. I do follow your threads when I am in the country and they are both entertaining and successful. Keep them up. The forum is struggling compared with a few years ago. I thought Enable was a good thing on Saturday and she is an admirable filly, no doubt about that but I do think she has suffered from lack of decent opposition, I agree with Figgis in this regard. It is not her fault but there it is.

I have to admit, Andrew, that I am one of the fools Figgis refers to about Frankel. I could not agree less with him about Frankel beating better horses like Cirrus des Aigles, Farrh, St Nicholas Abbey, Excelebration and Canford Cliffs. And his comment with regard to times and faster horses is laughable, frankly.
Frankel ran 14 times and, although he was a keen going, front running, pacemaker led racehorse he only managed to beat average time twice in 14 runs. And the so-called 'fast horses' he beat like Farrh, Canford Cliffs, Excelebration, Zoffany, Dubawi Gold and Roderic O'Connor BETWEEN THEM in all their wins managed to beat average times once. ONCE.
By:
FELTFAIR
When: 07 Jul 19 11:04
Brigust you old sod, where have you been?
By:
brigust1
When: 07 Jul 19 11:12
Hi Felt. How the devil are you? I've been around but really haven't had the time to do much more than just scan the forum on occasion. Sad to hear about John Mcririck. Not my cup of tea but sometimes it is good to have some you can shout at the TV about. I di write to him about his lack of support for the Sporting Life before it fell. He sent a nice letter back.
By:
A_T
When: 07 Jul 19 11:18
Times are almost an irrelevance in UK horse racing. It's simply not scientific.
By:
FELTFAIR
When: 07 Jul 19 11:38
I am well Brig thankyou and still enjoying the challenge of picking the occasional winner.
By:
brigust1
When: 07 Jul 19 11:42
Good luck to you Felt. The one good thing with living in two countries, one with Betfair and the other without Betfair, does concentrate your mind on the better races and help to avoid the dross. I did miss all of Royal Ascot this year, the first time in decades, but I can watch the recordings and imagine how much I would have won. Wink
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 13:05
He (Frankel) never put up a fast time

Andrew, once again you are confusing times with "time performances". If times aren't your thing that's fair enough but if you're going to keep commenting on them then I suggest you do a little reading on the subject first Wink
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 13:20
Some real pearls of wisdom here from our gurus determined to rationalise why they keep getting it wrong on Enable

It seems impossible to explain to some people that when some punters take on a 4/6 fav they don't all think "this cannot win".

the only reason Enable keeps winning is that she hasn't faced a horse faster than her

I said she hasn't faced a fast horse without the allowance, at least one that was primed to run right up to form on the day. Maybe you put Cloth Of Stars up there? I don't. She beat Magical in America fair and square but the improved Magical this year obviously ran below her very best yesterday. Incidentally I only felt Enable was vulnerable in last year's Arc (which she only just won) and this year's Eclipse but I've never gone big against her up to now because there has never been anything really decent to take her on with. I backed her during her 3yo career and took the short odds on her first start last year, as it was hard to lose on those terms.
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 13:48
BHA OR (official ratings) are based on a handicap system decided by a team of 12 headed by Dominic Gardiner-Hill and should not be confused with performance ratings they also produce. Nor are they calculated in the same way as Timeform or RPR. The OR is what is says on the tin, her BHA rating of 125 is a handicap rating irrespective of colt or filly, 3 or 4 year old, blah x 3, simple as.

My initial comment that you picked up on was referring to a 134 rating. As I have explained that was Timeform, as it was obviously they who rated her 134 after the Arc, not the BHA.

But as you prefer to use BHA figures as benchmarks, yet curiously seem unwilling to accept the quite low 125, I wonder if you could clear this up?

https://www.britishhorseracing.com/regulation/translating-performance-figures-initial-handicap-rating/

Here is an explanation of how the BHA translate their performance figures into handicap figures. So in effect they are saying a performance figure can be higher than the handicap rating, as the one big performance may not be a true reflection of the horse's overall ability. That's all fair enough to me. However they do say that if a horse was given a performance figure of 70 three times then the handicap figure would probably match. This suggests that apart from one rating being judged on a one race basis and the other being an overall figure the ratings are indeed calculated to the same scale. Are you saying otherwise?
By:
Figgis
When: 07 Jul 19 13:56
It is not her fault but there it is

Brigust is quite right. Of course it isn't her fault, only a cheerleading fanboy would take what has been said as blaming the filly/mare. The point is (unlike Frankel) she hasn't beat them by enough of a margin to prove she's vastly superior. Yes she's been very easy on the eye and won with some authority. Some people will take this as meaning she could've won by 3 or 4, etc, I don't.
By:
woodmanchester
When: 07 Jul 19 14:00
Enable beats whatever is put in front of her and over 1m 4f will be even more commanding
By:
brigust1
When: 07 Jul 19 16:17
I'm not so sure about that Figgis. The horses Frankel beat decisively were Canford Cliffs, Farhh, Excelebration, Klammer, Rainbow Springs and Dubawi Gold. Enable easily beat Rhodedendron, Ulysees, Sea of Class, Cloth of Stars and Coronet among many others. All Group 1 horses.
On the other hand Frankel beat Farhh who won the Thirsk Hunt Cup and his 2 Group 1's as a 4 year old, Excelebration who won three Group 1's beating Cityscape and Rio de la Plata (not Group 1 horses), Canford Cliffs who certainly ran below form and suffered an injury and Dubawi Gold who never won a Group 1. Klammer who won a Group 3 and Rainbow Springs who won a maiden.

The jury is out. There is just too much hype and little substance
By:
brigust1
When: 07 Jul 19 16:18
*Cloth of Gold
By:
brigust1
When: 07 Jul 19 16:27
And of course Crystal Ocean.
Page 3 of 6  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com